sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan-run-d94d4516b9d898793318805e.md

3 KiB

Independent integrated verification plan — run-d94d4516b9d898793318805e

Scope classification before execution: independent static reproduction and archived-state inspection of the integrated evidence package. This is not original-assisted runtime, a partial or full live comparison, an independent replacement, or integrated replay.

Acceptance falsifiers

  1. Reject if the assigned worktree HEAD/common-directory identities differ from the contract, if the canonical integrated source binding differs from either evidence record, or if any declared binary/input/outcome hash is stale. The paired RE tree is expected to differ from canonical only because campaign and verify/results are excluded from RE source identity; its computed binding must still match the prior paired identity, not be silently treated as the integrated identity.
  2. Reject zero execution, any nonzero subprocess, empty expected output, stderr, parse resync, best-effort recovery, hint failure, missing branch window, or truncated wide terminal instruction.
  3. Falsify the ABI boundary claims if direct PE bytes disagree with ret 4 at the five one-argument helpers, ret 8 at string allocation or dedup, plain ret at the constructor, or if the byte immediately before that plain return is also c3 (negative control).
  4. Falsify record/container interpretation if the captured instructions do not expose distinct ObservedTech 0x2c and PlayerEvent 0x74 strides, three guarded PlayerEvent long-string destructions, deep-copy calls, description inequality, or unordered-coordinate comparison.
  5. Falsify archived-state claims if independent parsing does not find EvNxID 4, a turn-3 bucket count 2, event ID 3 with all reported fields/default position words, byte-exact full rebuild, or the independently inspected RNG leaf (2503 bytes and reported digest).
  6. Do not convert matching static bytes into live allocator safety, runtime branch execution, original-game differential, replacement acceptance, or replay acceptance. Empty/full capacity, short/long strings, duplicate/nonduplicate and unwind/failure remain distinct unexecuted states.

Required exposure and challenge

Execute all 22 windows: seven narrow/wide terminal-boundary pairs plus constructor, copy, destructor, import-thunk, string comparison, byte comparison and PlayerEvent-constructor controls. Require strict save parsing and checksum coverage, then inspect actual event and RNG state rather than trusting counters. Challenge the integrated handoff with an independently generated held-out PE boundary ablation: read one byte before and one byte after each claimed return start and verify that shifting the start does not itself satisfy the complete expected encoding.

Decision rule: only a source-bound, non-skipping reproduction with every listed static/state check passing can support a scoped integrated PASS. Any contradictory provenance, unexpected boundary, or source identity mismatch is a surprise and pauses the affected verdict.