14 lines
6.4 KiB
JSON
14 lines
6.4 KiB
JSON
{
|
|
"actor": "research-problem-resolver",
|
|
"contract": "research-completion-abi",
|
|
"explanation": "Astra resolution, session run-7cc79c9a0461bcbeac0abf28. OBSERVATION/PROVENANCE: directly inspected objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt lines 8-11,102,118,138 and independent run-eba7860308317f839eb35392 observed-alloc/player-append/player-copy.stdout.txt: archive prints c2 04 00 at 0x57e5e3/0x86c62d/0x7694bf, independent exact-stop outputs print c2 only (while decoder still labels ret 4). Archive explicitly calls itself SELECTED windows, so whole-file unfiltered completeness was never warranted; selection alone cannot explain adding bytes beyond declared stops. Production history remains unknown. IDENTITY/EXECUTION: manifest and reproducer bind executable SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and objdump SHA256 1eaaef2e7f57c4c7f69115c495e2466f5a8c8e5f3bc42221d092382f30f9d4cd (reported GNU 2.38); subprocess PIPE bytes are persisted without filtering, argv/cwd/return codes/nonempty stdout/empty stderr recorded. Hashes are historical measurements, not fresh binary rehashes by this resolver. Fresh paired git HEAD/common-dir checks match engine 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 at /home/alex/sots-engine/.git and RE 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 at /home/alex/sots-re/.git; dirty source manifests are in runner source_before. No candidate build or game process executed: no stale-build diagnosis and no runtime instrument-neutrality claim. Absolute versus relative input paths legitimately alter stdout headers. Stop-boundary-dependent byte display, including mnemonic decoding beyond printed bytes, prevents using ret text as a complete-byte observation. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS: (1) OVERTURNED: the three selected terminal byte rows being reproducible from the declared narrow commands under the bound instrument; invalidate their command-to-byte provenance. (2) QUALIFIED: ret-4 ABI for allocator 0x57e590, append 0x86c580 and copy 0x7693f0 remains a static hypothesis supported by decoded text, pending complete-byte recapture and independent check, not callable/live safety. (3) SURVIVES in directly inspected static interiors only: count*0x2c and call 0x924fb6 at observed allocation; PlayerEvent stride/end increment 0x74, growth call 0x869500 and copy call 0x7693f0; three string assignments via 0x425430 at offsets 0x08/0x24/0x50 and EAX destination return. (4) QUALIFIED: remaining constructor/copy/destructor, allocator-family, nested-vector, short/long and exceptional-cleanup handoff claims are not semantically falsified by these terminal boundaries, but complete ownership branch/ABI cross-check is unfinished; selected excerpts cannot prove completeness. (5) SURVIVES as independent static interpretation/archived-state evidence, not runtime measurement: repaired description equality, unordered-coordinate mismatch and parsed turn3 event values in verifier result. This resolution does not independently reproduce them. (6) OVERTURNED: instruction_lines as instruction coverage/count; reproducer includes address-bearing function labels. Process execution survives, branch execution does not follow from disassembly counts. (7) QUALIFIED/NOT ESTABLISHED: ownership-recovered and independent-cross-check acceptance; no acceptance waiver. Live allocator compatibility/failure, runtime strings/events, RNG and replacement/integrated replay remain untested. INVALIDATION: supersede ownership archive as command-reproducible raw evidence for affected three sections, and any completeness/ready implications in recovered-static.md, reva-2026-09-09-index.md and campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md relying on it; preserve all files as historical evidence. Verifier manifest remains raw execution evidence except invalid coverage interpretation; blocked result remains valid. No contract evidence entries exist to remove. Existing dedup boundary-repair decision/package is not invalidated. REVISED SCOPE/DEPENDENCIES: authorize only analyst-owned static provenance repair and handoff update within existing ABI scope, followed by a fresh independent verifier. Keep original executable and exact objdump identity as explicit inputs; capture source bindings at production, never retro-bind old measurements. Audit all declared ownership stops and retain full per-command streams rather than selected excerpts. No engine/framework/lab changes or new live fixture work authorized. research-replacement remains proposed with readiness/helper/fixture dependencies unresolved; this is not permission to implement. Campaign needs-revision means repair-only eligibility, not resumed affected acceptance. Integrator must link this actual decision and regenerate projections after integration; no separate board history.",
|
|
"id": "d-d4c494ba02ada278030ef473",
|
|
"invalidated_checkpoint": "campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-0097da20f564f89191a49da6.json",
|
|
"invalidated_evidence": [],
|
|
"model": "openai/gpt-6-astra",
|
|
"probe": "Cheapest discriminating experiment: authorized ABI analyst, fresh owned output directory, no lab access, checkpoint first. Pin and hash input, objdump/version and paired source binding before and after capture. Run /usr/bin/objdump -D -Mintel on the same executable for start/stop pairs 0x0057e590:(0x0057e5e4,0x0057e5e6), 0x0086c580:(0x0086c62e,0x0086c630), 0x007693f0:(0x007694c0,0x007694c2). Preserve literal stdout/stderr, exact argv/cwd, exit status and SHA256 for all six runs. Prediction: narrow prints c2 only, widened prints c2 04 00, all preceding instruction bytes agree after accounting only for documented header path differences. Also retain raw byte dumps spanning each terminal instruction to cross-check decoding. Any changed interior byte/input/tool identity or different terminal immediate stops repair and requires another surprise, not normalization. Audit remaining ownership terminal boundaries; recapture any truncated window with minimal full-instruction widening and retain all full streams. Then update owned provenance index/handoff to cite this decision and superseding artifacts without rewriting history. Fresh independent verifier must reproduce complete repaired windows and meaningful boundary challenge, finish ownership branch/archived-state checks, and explicitly retain live-safety limitations before either acceptance criterion can pass.",
|
|
"role": "resolver",
|
|
"schema": "sots-decision/1",
|
|
"surprise": "s-4f71bf4a5df4e5fc992bb6b2",
|
|
"timestamp": "2026-09-10T00:49:57.462505+00:00"
|
|
}
|