14 lines
6.2 KiB
JSON
14 lines
6.2 KiB
JSON
{
|
|
"actor": "research-problem-resolver",
|
|
"contract": "research-completion-abi",
|
|
"explanation": "Astra resolution-only, session run-ec31ee938e1f509cd7130c03. OBSERVATION/PROVENANCE: verifier plan verify/results/research-completion-abi-correction-verifier/verification-plan-run-d6c4dc15e9f4d15155fee856.md item 5 requires complete ret 4 at 0x00779912 with stop 0x00779913. Analyst run-9daf5c3b75547271d5c3b4ed/nested-copy-authority.stdout.txt line 79 shows c2 04 00 through 0x00779914; checkpoint 1d04a2672a212e8b1fb37297 rehashed plan to 78e1ee70e73cf4be34884fc2073cd650ada4a20322c1ad50cb2deeb339021fbc and authority to 973c87ccab76a8454a4e43c83b59cdeace1e4f8c124c5aa9630cb956e3156bb8, matching prior plan hash and analyst manifest. Analyst a20/a28 raw streams show terminal 74 versus 74 10 at 0x00779a1f; section-byte control contains 74 10 8b cf e8 28 6a ff ff. Instrument output is boundary-sensitive even when its mnemonic/target looks complete. This falsifies a verifier expectation before execution, not analyst authority or game behavior.\nIDENTITY/EXECUTION: assigned Git HEAD/common roots match engine 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7. Historical analyst manifest binds binary 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, objdump 1eaaef2e7f57c4c7f69115c495e2466f5a8c8e5f3bc42221d092382f30f9d4cd GNU 2.38, and twelve explicit commands with zero exits, nonempty stdout and empty stderr. These are positive archived static executions, not fresh resolver executions. Binary/tool not freshly rehashed here. Current runner engine digest matches ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd; RE runner digest e97ad0ed5708a38d40294fb6cb4ba3cb49d4938710e3c01983fa055cbf22c0b9 differs from historical 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Separate open surprise s-210e489610197533e4f4cce1 blocks source-identical reproduction. No stale-build/game-mechanism diagnosis. No runtime instrument neutrality, allocator, RNG or game execution measured.\nCLAIMS: OVERTURNED: plan item 5 complete-stop prediction for 0x00779913, and inference that failure at this verifier-chosen boundary falsifies the analyst 0x00779930 authority window. SURVIVES: archived ret encoding c2 04 00 at 0x00779912 in the hash-bound authority; the failure remains a failed predeclared prediction. QUALIFIED: minimum complete stop 0x00779915 is byte-length reasoning and an unexecuted new control, not a measurement or genuinely blinded holdout after this inspection. It covers normal return only, excludes cleanup beginning at 0x00779915, and cannot replace authority through exclusive stop 0x00779930. SURVIVES within their existing static domain only: analyst copy/allocation/cleanup instruction observations and other plan falsifiers; no new ABI semantic endorsement. QUALIFIED: independent-cross-check remains unsatisfied, ownership-recovered remains analyst static evidence awaiting reproduction. OVERTURNED for current launch: source-identical RE assumption, tracked separately. SURVIVES: runtime safety and replacement remain unaccepted; archived saves validate serialized values only, not capacity, string ownership, transient stack values or RNG draws.\nINVALIDATION: preserve the failed plan and checkpoint 4555678e34291015554e7e88 as history, but invalidate item 5 as executable acceptance requirement and its next action to run the unchanged plan. No run-d6c4dc15e9f4d15155fee856 reproduction result exists to rehabilitate. No analyst raw bytes are invalidated by this boundary mistake; prior d-fd5aff1eaf78a8c15d96723c and d-0bb927e63b915c87a58d4257 invalidations remain. CLI clears current evidence/checkpoint and invalidates any verdict; empty evidence array is not acceptance. No acceptance waiver.\nREVISED SCOPE/DEPENDENCIES: retain contract criteria and static/save-only scope; no implementation, architecture edits or lab use. After source-drift resolution and lead lifecycle authorization, independent verifier may create a fresh actual-session fail-if-exists reproduction, preserving old prediction failure and adding both new boundary controls. Required full authority/ABI windows and archived record accounting remain. research-live-record-bridge stays needs-revision with unaccepted ABI dependency; research-replacement stays proposed, its accepted-dependency narrative is not current status and cannot authorize wiring. No downstream promotion. Integrator must link this decision rather than write another board history, and regenerate projections only after valid integration.",
|
|
"id": "d-6e30d172051af0385f5979eb",
|
|
"invalidated_checkpoint": "campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-1d04a2672a212e8b1fb37297.json",
|
|
"invalidated_evidence": [],
|
|
"model": "openai/gpt-6-astra",
|
|
"probe": "Cheapest boundary discriminator, NOT run here: after s-210e489610197533e4f4cce1 source reconciliation and lead authorization, checkpoint a fresh independent verifier session and new fail-if-exists directory. Rehash binary, objdump/interpreter, recipe, paired source and archived-save inputs before/after. Run /usr/bin/objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00779850 against dumps/sots.exe twice, stops 0x00779913 and 0x00779915, plus full authority stop 0x00779930. Independently map PE VA 0x00779912..0x00779914 to file offsets and read bytes directly (not only a second disassembly). Predict c2-only truncated byte row at bad stop and c2 04 00 ret 4 at aligned stop, no changed preceding complete rows; preserve mnemonic/bytes separately. Normal-return stop must not be counted as unwind coverage. Keep a20 negative and aligned a21/a23/a28 controls, all other ABI/save falsifiers and explicit unexercised runtime states. Record actual commands, timestamps, exits, raw stdout/stderr hashes, positive executions and all missing/skipped states; reject drift, unexpected stderr, zero execution or contradiction. Mark original prediction failed, repaired control unblinded/new, never retroactive success. Immediate next action is lead scheduling a read-only manifest-delta review for source surprise, not this blocked reproduction.",
|
|
"role": "resolver",
|
|
"schema": "sots-decision/1",
|
|
"surprise": "s-81ffc3041e1f07b87928e6f2",
|
|
"timestamp": "2026-09-10T13:06:19.620541+00:00"
|
|
}
|