14 lines
4.9 KiB
JSON
14 lines
4.9 KiB
JSON
{
|
|
"actor": "research ABI surprise resolver",
|
|
"contract": "research-completion-abi",
|
|
"explanation": "Astra resolution-only decision, session run-daefd1b77558f324ae730b27; apply jointly with d-fd5aff1eaf78a8c15d96723c. OBSERVATION: inspected verify/results/research-completion-abi-correction-verifier/reproduce_run_ee78b8773688ca09f8046e21.py. Lines 7 and 72 hard-code prior output directory and session; lines 26/36/84 allow overwriting prior outputs. Actual-session report-run-5bd0e537bb0c4c4f43987ac1.md records current invocation and exit 1; generated run-ee78b8773688ca09f8046e21/manifest.json claims prior session with fresh timestamp. Current checkpoint 070383fd013a0e4b1a2ef5e0 rehashed that manifest/report to the inherited checkpoint hashes. Binary/tool/source and positive static execution qualifications are recorded in d-fd5aff1eaf78a8c15d96723c; no fresh binary execution or runtime neutrality measurement here. No basis to infer a different game build or game mechanism from stale provenance.\nOVERTURNED in exact current-session domain: manifest is truthful evidence of run-5bd0e537bb0c4c4f43987ac1, inherited helper is safely reusable unchanged across fresh sessions, and fresh timestamp/identical stdout repairs stale session identity. QUALIFIED: raw outputs and report survive as archived static measurements with documented provenance defect, not independent current-session or integrated acceptance. SURVIVES: failed boundary challenge is a failure, eight positive objdump subprocess records support static capture rather than zero-execution, and unaffected decoded ownership rows retain only the partial static domain in companion decision. A later report cannot retroactively turn overwritten prior-session output into an immutable original-run bundle.\nINVALIDATE current-session/full-compare acceptance use of the entire verifier run-ee78b8773688ca09f8046e21/manifest.json package, its hard-coded helper as a fresh-run recipe, and any checkpoint/verdict depending on that attribution. Preserve original files and failure report; no in-place relabeling, rehashing old measurements under new source, or overwriting again. Evidence array already empty; earlier invalidated integrated evidence/verdict remains invalid. No claim that all historical instruction bytes are false. Revised dependencies: a fresh uniquely named analyst package and a separately executed independent verifier package, each with explicit immutable session/actor/role/model, invocation/time, source-content bindings, original input and dereferenced tool identity, argv/cwd/streams/results and artifact hashes. Harness/interpreter identity must be bound as consumed tooling, not inferred from Git HEAD. Full instruction/dataflow review must accompany marker checks; helper regex matches only mov DWORD PTR [ebp-0x20] and alone is not exhaustive def/use proof. Both existing acceptance criteria, archived-record checking and integrated independent reproduction remain mandatory.\nVALID NEXT ACTION: lead schedules the existing analyst for static capture repair under normal lifecycle controls, using companion boundary probe and a new session-specific output directory with fail-if-exists semantics. Direct commands with a contemporaneous immutable manifest are sufficient; no general framework changes needed. Independent verifier follows in a separate execution after fresh analyst handoff. Closing these surprises permits needs-revision only, not ready/accepted; live-record-bridge and research-replacement remain dependency-gated, no implementation/lab authorization, and no projection publication until integration. This resolver makes no source edits or nested launches.",
|
|
"id": "d-0bb927e63b915c87a58d4257",
|
|
"invalidated_checkpoint": null,
|
|
"invalidated_evidence": [],
|
|
"model": "openai/gpt-6-astra",
|
|
"probe": "Cheapest provenance discriminator before capture: supply the actual new campaign run session explicitly to a fresh minimal capture recipe/direct manifest; verify it equals the launch record and output directory and that the directory does not already exist. Predeclare negative checks rejecting missing session, stale prior-session ID and reused output location before running objdump. Archive the recipe and interpreter/tool/source/input identities before capture; run all four exact/repaired complete-boundary windows plus companion negative boundary control into the new directory and record actual commands, timestamps, return codes and stream hashes. Fail closed on identity drift and any required failure; expected bad-boundary control must remain explicitly classified negative, never counted as a passing full stream. Independent verifier must reproduce with its own real session and fresh directory, not execute the inherited hard-coded helper or relabel this manifest. No probe was executed by resolver.",
|
|
"role": "resolver",
|
|
"schema": "sots-decision/1",
|
|
"surprise": "s-d44b9f9e62272794d88bbed6",
|
|
"timestamp": "2026-09-10T04:51:08.364275+00:00"
|
|
}
|