sots-re/campaign/runtime/runs/run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f.jsonl

{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999214146,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088a9a43d0011CJ875OZ3QGYCL","messageID":"msg_088a99708001SOIjPTsiFPTkoZ","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"b237afdbd4b863388f24849b1a3257db5fc8ffeb","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999218474,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"todowrite","callID":"call_3iyb1cb87OKIcTCfmRiUyOme","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"todos":[{"content":"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities","status":"in_progress","priority":"high"},{"content":"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states","status":"pending","priority":"high"},{"content":"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption","status":"pending","priority":"high"},{"content":"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint","status":"pending","priority":"high"}]},"output":"[\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities\",\n    \"status\": \"in_progress\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states\",\n    \"status\": \"pending\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption\",\n    \"status\": \"pending\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint\",\n    \"status\": \"pending\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  }\n]","metadata":{"todos":[{"content":"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities","status":"in_progress","priority":"high"},{"content":"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states","status":"pending","priority":"high"},{"content":"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption","status":"pending","priority":"high"},{"content":"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint","status":"pending","priority":"high"}],"truncated":false},"title":"4 todos","time":{"start":1788999218468,"end":1788999218472}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_09c45416f80d2b5e016aa1f62f7bb087d18b66c698a0016cc6"}},"id":"prt_088a9a9b20016DT86n8d2Jadq3","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a99708001SOIjPTsiFPTkoZ"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999218534,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088a9b562001tO2kwD6ZWX8Ezi","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"463beb19f25a5c033be11b6c8cde81b9192eeca4","messageID":"msg_088a99708001SOIjPTsiFPTkoZ","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":5957,"input":5813,"output":111,"reasoning":33,"cache":{"write":0,"read":0}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999227841,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088a9d9bc0016TkNdyNBHQZRvA","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"792e8389646fc1b51b4eddeb50b69d4d0fee37e5","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999227924,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_uBk6V8nakTjEU7jNMeUW3zqa","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/README.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/README.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Canonical campaign controls\n2: \n3: `sots-re/campaign/` is the state authority. Start with your contract, its checkpoint, open\n4: surprises, and [current policy](../guides/multi-agent-workflow.md). Board/dashboard are generated\n5: projections. Historical evidence is not current acceptance. No automatic commits or lab operations.\n6: \n7: Framework development is complete. The `controls-bootstrap` contract reached scoped acceptance;\n8: see [rollout result](rollout/RESULT.md) and its current contract/verdict for source-bound evidence.\n9: Active work is reverse engineering. Change tooling only to unblock a named RE experiment.\n10: \n11: ## Contract format\n12: \n13: `contract.schema.json` is strict JSON Schema (unknown fields and duplicate JSON keys fail).\n14: The standard-library validator implements the schema's used subset. A populated example is\n15: [contracts/controls-bootstrap.json](contracts/controls-bootstrap.json); its lifecycle is in the record.\n16: \n17: Required fields:\n18: \n19: | Field | Structure |\n20: |---|---|\n21: | `id`, `title`, `status` | Slug, short title, lifecycle state |\n22: | `owner` | `{ \"name\": \"worker-identity\", \"role\": \"implementer\" }` |\n23: | `baseline` | `{ \"engine\": {\"path\":\"/absolute/canonical/engine\",\"commit\":\"full-commit-id\"}, \"re\": {\"path\":\"/absolute/canonical/re\",\"commit\":\"full-commit-id\"} }` |\n24: | `scope`, `inputs`, `effects` | Arrays of explicit nonempty strings; include full write set and runtime inputs |\n25: | `original_dependencies` | String array, including original-assisted portions and unavailable inputs |\n26: | `dependencies` | Array of other contract IDs; all must be accepted before ready/implementing |\n27: | `acceptance` | Array of `{ \"id\": \"unique-criterion\", \"axis\": \"validation-scope\", \"criterion\": \"executable requirement\" }` |\n28: | `predictions`, `stop_conditions` | String arrays of predictions and conditions that halt work |\n29: | `checkpoint` | `null` or `campaign/runtime/checkpoints/<id>.json` |\n30: \n31: Optional `evidence` is an array of\n32: `{id,axis,path,sha256,source,integrated,source_binding,binaries,inputs,outcomes}`.\n33: `path` is an existing canonical RE-relative artifact; `sha256` hashes its actual bytes; `source`\n34: equals the contract's complete baseline object. Store understanding,\n35: implementation, original dependencies, and validation scope as separate acceptance/evidence axes.\n36: There is no generic `verified` scalar. Baseline commit IDs describe starting repositories;\n37: dirty source identity is machine-bound by `source_binding`, never inferred from those commits.\n38: Criteria need distinct states, branch exposure, positive execution, complete writes/elements,\n39: allocations/IDs/events/RNG/runtime inputs, synthetic and original-game differentials as applicable.\n40: The CLI checks package identity and declared axes; the independent reviewer evaluates the actual\n41: criteria, gate outcomes, full manifests and integrated reproduction. A passing measurement alone\n42: does not establish acceptance.\n43: \n44: ### Source-bound evidence interface (R4)\n45: \n46: `source_binding` is `{engine:{path,commit,sha256},re:{path,commit,sha256}}`. Generate it with:\n47: \n48: ```sh\n49: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re source-binding research-replacement --engine-worktree /absolute/candidate-engine --re-worktree /absolute/candidate-re\n50: ```\n51: \n52: Omit both worktree arguments to bind the canonical integrated trees. Paths must be Git worktree\n53: roots in the respective baseline repositories. `commit` is the actual current HEAD; `sha256`\n54: is the deterministic digest of the actual file manifest, including dirty/untracked nonignored\n55: files, deleted tracked paths (`null`), file bytes and Unix modes. Symlinks/submodules fail closed.\n56: The fixed manifest policy uses `git ls-files --cached --others --exclude-standard`; ignored\n57: untracked build/output files are not source. Python cache directories are excluded. In RE only,\n58: `verify/results/` and `campaign/` are excluded **except** `campaign/models.json`,\n59: `campaign/contract.schema.json`, and `campaign/agents/**`. These exclusions prevent mutable\n60: contracts/checkpoints/evidence/projections from hashing themselves. Relevant RE tools, tests,\n61: generated facts and guides remain bound. Any consumed item outside that source inventory must\n62: appear among immutable input/binary artifacts. The independent reviewer checks inventory adequacy.\n63: \n64: `binaries` and `inputs` are nonempty arrays of `{path,sha256}` artifact references; for tooling\n65: contracts, bind the executable scripts/interpreter identity package and fixture input package.\n66: `outcomes` exactly covers the acceptance criterion IDs for that evidence axis, with entries\n67: `{criterion,status,artifact:{path,sha256}}`; promotion requires `status: \"pass\"`. Outcome artifacts\n68: contain positive execution, branch/state exposures, reproduction recipe and required effect/input\n69: accounting. The CLI checks identities, hashes and declared outcomes, **not arbitrary criterion\n70: semantics**. The independent verifier must reproduce and challenge those claims.\n71: \n72: For example, an outcome for the bootstrap contract is:\n73: \n74: ```json\n75: {\"criterion\":\"controls-negative-paths\",\"status\":\"pass\",\"artifact\":{\"path\":\"verify/results/controls/result.json\",\"sha256\":\"<actual 64-hex artifact hash>\"}}\n76: ```\n77: \n78: Capture bindings when producing evidence; do not attach a fresh source hash to old measurements.\n79: Every evidence/verdict/promotion check rehashes referenced sources and artifacts. Same-HEAD byte\n80: changes reject old evidence and verdicts. Integrated records require canonical paths, lead in\n81: integration state, and one identical binding across **all** final integrated evidence. A lead's\n82: `integrated` boolean cannot substitute for this check. Verdicts bind the full evidence array and\n83: the source-binding array; old verdicts lacking these identities must be reproduced.\n84: \n85: This contract wrapper is separate from gate measurement schema **`sots-gate/1`**, whose `source`\n86: still has `engine`/`re`. Reference its immutable manifest/binary/input package; do not rename its\n87: fields to match contract `source`. Reporter output is measured evidence, with `--require-match`\n88: for required equality, and gains acceptance only through independent contract/integration gates.\n89: \n90: ## State and transactions\n91: \n92: Every command requires `--state-root /absolute/canonical/sots-re` (the repository, not `campaign/`).\n93: No sibling inference. Control records stay below canonical `campaign/runtime/`; contracts remain\n94: in `campaign/contracts/`. Immutable hashed artifacts may be referenced anywhere inside canonical\n95: RE, including existing `verify/` corpora, without copying them. Absolute/traversing artifact paths,\n96: outside symlinks, Git internals and named secret/private-key locations are rejected; aliases are\n97: checked after resolution too. Never reference secrets or commit owner-supplied binaries/assets.\n98: JSON writes are atomic and fsynced; a canonical `flock` serializes\n99: CLI mutations, WIP decisions, and resource acquisition. Do not hand-edit active state concurrently\n100: with commands. Interrupted multi-file operations retain blocking records and require inspection.\n101: \n102: Runtime APIs (JSON files; no server):\n103: \n104: - `runtime/checkpoints/*.json`: `sots-checkpoint/1`, contract, actor/role/model/session, timestamp,\n105:   contract `basis` digest, bounded summary (6000 characters), up to 32 `{path,sha256}` artifacts,\n106:   and one `next_action` (2000 characters). Include observations versus decisions, source identities,\n107:   tests, blockers, resources/access/cleanup, exact next action in the summary/artifacts.\n108:   Do not attach the checkpoint's own contract as an artifact: saving the pointer changes that\n109:   file. Its task metadata is already covered by `basis`; the CLI rejects this self-reference.\n110: - `runtime/surprises/*.json`: `sots-surprise/1`, id, contract, `status: open|resolved`, summary,\n111:   discriminating probe, actor/model/session provenance where applicable, optional decision ID.\n112: - `runtime/decisions/*.json`: `sots-decision/1`, Astra resolution, explanation/probe, invalidated\n113:   evidence and checkpoint; prior verdict is marked invalidated. Resolution returns needs-revision\n114:   only when all surprises are closed. Re-probe and rebuild evidence; resolution is not acceptance.\n115: - `runtime/verdicts/<contract>.json`: independent verifier actor/session/model, pass/fail,\n116:   explanation, contract basis, complete evidence digest and source-bindings digest.\n117: - `runtime/transitions/*.json`: actor/model, previous/next lifecycle state, timestamp.\n118: - `runtime/leases/<resource>.json`: owner, random token, held/released, acquisition/release provenance.\n119: - `runtime/runs/run-*.json`, `.jsonl`, `.stderr.log`: requested model/config, command, worktree\n120:   manifests before/after, expanded prompt hash, effective configuration hashes, canonical config\n121:   file hashes, actual events/session/model when emitted, completion/checkpoint status. Effective\n122:   provider config is hashed rather than persisted because it can contain credentials.\n123:   `active-<contract>.json` reserves the contract. Interrupted running reservations never auto-expire.\n124: \n125: Lifecycle: `proposed -> ready -> implementing -> verification -> integration -> accepted`.\n126: Blocked and needs-revision edges support repairs; no skipping stages. Ready requires scope,\n127: inputs, acceptance, stop conditions, valid pinned baseline and accepted dependencies. Implementing\n128: is atomically capped at two concurrent contracts; lead schedules only one pilot before enabling\n129: two independent slices. Verification requires fresh checkpoint/artifacts after implementation start.\n130: Integration requires lead plus independent passing verifier bound to current source/evidence.\n131: Accepted requires every declared axis in integrated evidence, passing independent verdict over\n132: that final package, and no open surprises. Adding integrated evidence changes the evidence digest:\n133: the verifier must attest the integrated package again. Handoff/promotion/end checkpoints must be\n134: within 15 minutes; recovery start has no age limit.\n135: \n136: Role/model registry: lead/architecture-review/analyst/implementer/verifier/lab =\n137: `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`; resolver = `openai/gpt-6-astra`.\n138: CLI identity fields are **claims, not authenticated model authority**. The runner requests the\n139: registry model explicitly and records emitted provenance. Editable JSON, agent permissions and\n140: shell-accessible tooling are not a security boundary. No silent routing fallback.\n141: \n142: ## Commands\n143: \n144: Run from either repository using the canonical tool path when necessary. Examples:\n145: \n146: ```sh\n147: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate\n148: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re list\n149: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-replacement\n150: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint controls-bootstrap --actor controls-architect --role architecture-review --model openai/gpt-6-astra --session rollout-controls --summary 'Source identities, observations, decisions, tests and blockers are in the attached checkpoint.' --artifact campaign/rollout/controls-worker-state.md --next-action 'Run the independent controls review.'\n151: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re transition controls-bootstrap ready --actor controls-architect --role architecture-review --model openai/gpt-6-astra\n152: ```\n153: \n154: `surprise CONTRACT --summary TEXT --probe TEXT` blocks immediately. `resolve SURPRISE_ID\n155: --explanation TEXT --probe TEXT` requires claimed Astra lead/resolver. Both also require\n156: `--actor NAME --role ROLE --model MODEL`. `evidence CONTRACT --record campaign/path.json`\n157: uses the same identity flags; record format is the evidence object above. Integrated records\n158: require lead and integration state. `verdict CONTRACT --session SESSION --verdict pass|fail\n159: --explanation TEXT` requires verifier identity flags and independent actor/session.\n160: \n161: ```sh\n162: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease acquire windows-vm --actor lab-one --role lab --model openai/gpt-5.5\n163: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease show windows-vm\n164: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease release windows-vm --actor lab-one --role lab --model openai/gpt-5.5 --token TOKEN_FROM_ACQUIRE\n165: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease release windows-vm --actor lead --role lead --model openai/gpt-6-astra --lead-release --reason 'Confirmed prior operator stopped; access and cleanup checked.'\n166: ```\n167: \n168: No stale lease stealing. Explicit lead release requires an explanation and lab preconditions,\n169: side effects, cleanup, and access verification in the operator checkpoint. Treat lease tokens\n170: as local owner capabilities, not secrets to put in a board/dashboard.\n171: \n172: ## Fresh bounded launches\n173: \n174: Prepare **two actual linked worktrees**, each distinct from its canonical source repository,\n175: at the contract's full baseline commit. No auto commits/worktree creation. Launch uses explicit\n176: canonical `OPENCODE_CONFIG`, checks matching repo-local agent/model/40 steps, and sets the final\n177: environment overlay to bind requested role/model/steps. Other inherited config overrides are\n178: cleared. `opencode models` must list the exact requested model even for dry runs.\n179: \n180: ```sh\n181: python3 tools/run_agent.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re --role implementer --actor worker-one --contract slice-one --engine-worktree /home/alex/worktrees/slice-one-engine --re-worktree /home/alex/worktrees/slice-one-re --cwd engine --dry-run\n182: ```\n183: \n184: Remove `--dry-run` to execute. Normal worker launch requires a valid durable checkpoint, matching\n185: owner/role/status, no open surprises, baseline HEADs and canonical Git common-directory identity.\n186: Recovery checks checkpoint identity/basis and artifact hashes regardless of age, rechecks any\n187: source-bound evidence, and validates paired Git worktree/baseline identity. Missing ordinary-worker\n188: state still blocks. Bootstrap lead/architecture-review can start without a checkpoint; they still\n189: need paired worktrees. Astra lead/resolver may launch a blocked contract with open surprises and\n190: without a worker checkpoint in **resolution-only** scope: read evidence and write decisions/state,\n191: no implementation. Its prompt and permission overlay carry that limit, and worktree source changes\n192: fail completion. Ordinary affected workers stay blocked. Other Astra architecture actors receive\n193: explicit architecture authority within their owned scope. Each run is a fresh\n194: `opencode run --format json --model ... --agent ...`; no resume/continue option is used. The prompt\n195: supplies the run ID to use as checkpoint `--session`; actual OpenCode session IDs are captured\n196: separately when emitted. On exit, a checkpoint after start matching actor/role/model/run ID is\n197: mandatory or the run is marked incomplete. Completion additionally requires a zero exit, no\n198: `type:error`, a successful `step_finish` with `part.reason: \"stop\"`, one nonempty actual session ID,\n199: and consistent explicitly emitted model IDs. Text/tool-call/length events alone cannot complete a\n200: run. Missing model emission is recorded `observed_model_status: \"unavailable\"`, never invented.\n201: \n202: The runner checks the exact Git baseline again under reservation lock, rejects intervening contract\n203: changes, and checks canonical model/prompt/config files and effective configuration for drift at\n204: completion. Expanded role prompt/model/steps are frozen in the last-layer environment overlay.\n205: `opencode debug config` runs in the actual launch cwd with the actual environment before execution\n206: and again at completion. Permissions explicitly allow read/search, ordinary worker shell commands,\n207: and external-directory access to the assigned paired trees plus canonical RE; role-specific edit\n208: denies survive. Task delegation and interactive questions are denied. No `--auto` is required.\n209: Noninteractive command/environment tests and a live loader check cover this overlay; an actual\n210: normal worker launch smoke is a separate lead integration check. Permissions and before/after\n211: checks are operational guards, not a sandbox or continuous filesystem audit.\n212: Compaction is a backstop; no token threshold or machine-enforced 20-tool-call claim.\n213: \n214: ## Local verification\n215: \n216: ```sh\n217: python3 -m unittest discover -s verify/campaign -p 'test_*.py' -v\n218: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate\n219: ```\n220: \n221: Tests create commits only in disposable fixture repositories, linked worktrees and fake OpenCode processes; they do\n222: not launch agents or touch the lab. Historical rollout artifacts retain the scope and source identity\n223: of their runs; consult the accepted contract and current evidence, not an old handoff's status prose.\n\n(End of file - total 223 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Canonical campaign controls\n\n`sots-re/campaign/` is the state authority. Start with your contract, its checkpoint, open\nsurprises, and [current policy](../guides/multi-agent-workflow.md). Board/dashboard are generated\nprojections. Historical evidence is not current acceptance. No automatic commits or lab operations.\n\nFramework development is complete. The `controls-bootstrap` contract reached scoped acceptance;\nsee [rollout result](rollout/RESULT.md) and its current contract/verdict for source-bound evidence.\nActive work is reverse engineering. Change tooling only to unblock a named RE experiment.\n\n## Contract format\n\n`contract.schema.json` is strict JSON Schema (unknown fields and duplicate JSON keys fail).\nThe standard-library validator implements the schema's used subset. A populated example is\n[contracts/controls-bootstrap.json](contracts/controls-bootstrap.json); its lifecycle is in the record.\n\nRequired fields:\n\n| Field | Structure |\n|---|---|","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/README.md","text":"# Canonical campaign controls\n\n`sots-re/campaign/` is the state authority. Start with your contract, its checkpoint, open\nsurprises, and [current policy](../guides/multi-agent-workflow.md). Board/dashboard are generated\nprojections. Historical evidence is not current acceptance. No automatic commits or lab operations.\n\nFramework development is complete. The `controls-bootstrap` contract reached scoped acceptance;\nsee [rollout result](rollout/RESULT.md) and its current contract/verdict for source-bound evidence.\nActive work is reverse engineering. Change tooling only to unblock a named RE experiment.\n\n## Contract format\n\n`contract.schema.json` is strict JSON Schema (unknown fields and duplicate JSON keys fail).\nThe standard-library validator implements the schema's used subset. A populated example is\n[contracts/controls-bootstrap.json](contracts/controls-bootstrap.json); its lifecycle is in the record.\n\nRequired fields:\n\n| Field | Structure |\n|---|---|\n| `id`, `title`, `status` | Slug, short title, lifecycle state |\n| `owner` | `{ \"name\": \"worker-identity\", \"role\": \"implementer\" }` |\n| `baseline` | `{ \"engine\": {\"path\":\"/absolute/canonical/engine\",\"commit\":\"full-commit-id\"}, \"re\": {\"path\":\"/absolute/canonical/re\",\"commit\":\"full-commit-id\"} }` |\n| `scope`, `inputs`, `effects` | Arrays of explicit nonempty strings; include full write set and runtime inputs |\n| `original_dependencies` | String array, including original-assisted portions and unavailable inputs |\n| `dependencies` | Array of other contract IDs; all must be accepted before ready/implementing |\n| `acceptance` | Array of `{ \"id\": \"unique-criterion\", \"axis\": \"validation-scope\", \"criterion\": \"executable requirement\" }` |\n| `predictions`, `stop_conditions` | String arrays of predictions and conditions that halt work |\n| `checkpoint` | `null` or `campaign/runtime/checkpoints/<id>.json` |\n\nOptional `evidence` is an array of\n`{id,axis,path,sha256,source,integrated,source_binding,binaries,inputs,outcomes}`.\n`path` is an existing canonical RE-relative artifact; `sha256` hashes its actual bytes; `source`\nequals the contract's complete baseline object. Store understanding,\nimplementation, original dependencies, and validation scope as separate acceptance/evidence axes.\nThere is no generic `verified` scalar. Baseline commit IDs describe starting repositories;\ndirty source identity is machine-bound by `source_binding`, never inferred from those commits.\nCriteria need distinct states, branch exposure, positive execution, complete writes/elements,\nallocations/IDs/events/RNG/runtime inputs, synthetic and original-game differentials as applicable.\nThe CLI checks package identity and declared axes; the independent reviewer evaluates the actual\ncriteria, gate outcomes, full manifests and integrated reproduction. A passing measurement alone\ndoes not establish acceptance.\n\n### Source-bound evidence interface (R4)\n\n`source_binding` is `{engine:{path,commit,sha256},re:{path,commit,sha256}}`. Generate it with:\n\n```sh\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re source-binding research-replacement --engine-worktree /absolute/candidate-engine --re-worktree /absolute/candidate-re\n```\n\nOmit both worktree arguments to bind the canonical integrated trees. Paths must be Git worktree\nroots in the respective baseline repositories. `commit` is the actual current HEAD; `sha256`\nis the deterministic digest of the actual file manifest, including dirty/untracked nonignored\nfiles, deleted tracked paths (`null`), file bytes and Unix modes. Symlinks/submodules fail closed.\nThe fixed manifest policy uses `git ls-files --cached --others --exclude-standard`; ignored\nuntracked build/output files are not source. Python cache directories are excluded. In RE only,\n`verify/results/` and `campaign/` are excluded **except** `campaign/models.json`,\n`campaign/contract.schema.json`, and `campaign/agents/**`. These exclusions prevent mutable\ncontracts/checkpoints/evidence/projections from hashing themselves. Relevant RE tools, tests,\ngenerated facts and guides remain bound. Any consumed item outside that source inventory must\nappear among immutable input/binary artifacts. The independent reviewer checks inventory adequacy.\n\n`binaries` and `inputs` are nonempty arrays of `{path,sha256}` artifact references; for tooling\ncontracts, bind the executable scripts/interpreter identity package and fixture input package.\n`outcomes` exactly covers the acceptance criterion IDs for that evidence axis, with entries\n`{criterion,status,artifact:{path,sha256}}`; promotion requires `status: \"pass\"`. Outcome artifacts\ncontain positive execution, branch/state exposures, reproduction recipe and required effect/input\naccounting. The CLI checks identities, hashes and declared outcomes, **not arbitrary criterion\nsemantics**. The independent verifier must reproduce and challenge those claims.\n\nFor example, an outcome for the bootstrap contract is:\n\n```json\n{\"criterion\":\"controls-negative-paths\",\"status\":\"pass\",\"artifact\":{\"path\":\"verify/results/controls/result.json\",\"sha256\":\"<actual 64-hex artifact hash>\"}}\n```\n\nCapture bindings when producing evidence; do not attach a fresh source hash to old measurements.\nEvery evidence/verdict/promotion check rehashes referenced sources and artifacts. Same-HEAD byte\nchanges reject old evidence and verdicts. Integrated records require canonical paths, lead in\nintegration state, and one identical binding across **all** final integrated evidence. A lead's\n`integrated` boolean cannot substitute for this check. Verdicts bind the full evidence array and\nthe source-binding array; old verdicts lacking these identities must be reproduced.\n\nThis contract wrapper is separate from gate measurement schema **`sots-gate/1`**, whose `source`\nstill has `engine`/`re`. Reference its immutable manifest/binary/input package; do not rename its\nfields to match contract `source`. Reporter output is measured evidence, with `--require-match`\nfor required equality, and gains acceptance only through independent contract/integration gates.\n\n## State and transactions\n\nEvery command requires `--state-root /absolute/canonical/sots-re` (the repository, not `campaign/`).\nNo sibling inference. Control records stay below canonical `campaign/runtime/`; contracts remain\nin `campaign/contracts/`. Immutable hashed artifacts may be referenced anywhere inside canonical\nRE, including existing `verify/` corpora, without copying them. Absolute/traversing artifact paths,\noutside symlinks, Git internals and named secret/private-key locations are rejected; aliases are\nchecked after resolution too. Never reference secrets or commit owner-supplied binaries/assets.\nJSON writes are atomic and fsynced; a canonical `flock` serializes\nCLI mutations, WIP decisions, and resource acquisition. Do not hand-edit active state concurrently\nwith commands. Interrupted multi-file operations retain blocking records and require inspection.\n\nRuntime APIs (JSON files; no server):\n\n- `runtime/checkpoints/*.json`: `sots-checkpoint/1`, contract, actor/role/model/session, timestamp,\n  contract `basis` digest, bounded summary (6000 characters), up to 32 `{path,sha256}` artifacts,\n  and one `next_action` (2000 characters). Include observations versus decisions, source identities,\n  tests, blockers, resources/access/cleanup, exact next action in the summary/artifacts.\n  Do not attach the checkpoint's own contract as an artifact: saving the pointer changes that\n  file. Its task metadata is already covered by `basis`; the CLI rejects this self-reference.\n- `runtime/surprises/*.json`: `sots-surprise/1`, id, contract, `status: open|resolved`, summary,\n  discriminating probe, actor/model/session provenance where applicable, optional decision ID.\n- `runtime/decisions/*.json`: `sots-decision/1`, Astra resolution, explanation/probe, invalidated\n  evidence and checkpoint; prior verdict is marked invalidated. Resolution returns needs-revision\n  only when all surprises are closed. Re-probe and rebuild evidence; resolution is not acceptance.\n- `runtime/verdicts/<contract>.json`: independent verifier actor/session/model, pass/fail,\n  explanation, contract basis, complete evidence digest and source-bindings digest.\n- `runtime/transitions/*.json`: actor/model, previous/next lifecycle state, timestamp.\n- `runtime/leases/<resource>.json`: owner, random token, held/released, acquisition/release provenance.\n- `runtime/runs/run-*.json`, `.jsonl`, `.stderr.log`: requested model/config, command, worktree\n  manifests before/after, expanded prompt hash, effective configuration hashes, canonical config\n  file hashes, actual events/session/model when emitted, completion/checkpoint status. Effective\n  provider config is hashed rather than persisted because it can contain credentials.\n  `active-<contract>.json` reserves the contract. Interrupted running reservations never auto-expire.\n\nLifecycle: `proposed -> ready -> implementing -> verification -> integration -> accepted`.\nBlocked and needs-revision edges support repairs; no skipping stages. Ready requires scope,\ninputs, acceptance, stop conditions, valid pinned baseline and accepted dependencies. Implementing\nis atomically capped at two concurrent contracts; lead schedules only one pilot before enabling\ntwo independent slices. Verification requires fresh checkpoint/artifacts after implementation start.\nIntegration requires lead plus independent passing verifier bound to current source/evidence.\nAccepted requires every declared axis in integrated evidence, passing independent verdict over\nthat final package, and no open surprises. Adding integrated evidence changes the evidence digest:\nthe verifier must attest the integrated package again. Handoff/promotion/end checkpoints must be\nwithin 15 minutes; recovery start has no age limit.\n\nRole/model registry: lead/architecture-review/analyst/implementer/verifier/lab =\n`openai/gpt-5.6-sol`; resolver = `openai/gpt-6-astra`.\nCLI identity fields are **claims, not authenticated model authority**. The runner requests the\nregistry model explicitly and records emitted provenance. Editable JSON, agent permissions and\nshell-accessible tooling are not a security boundary. No silent routing fallback.\n\n## Commands\n\nRun from either repository using the canonical tool path when necessary. Examples:\n\n```sh\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re list\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-replacement\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint controls-bootstrap --actor controls-architect --role architecture-review --model openai/gpt-6-astra --session rollout-controls --summary 'Source identities, observations, decisions, tests and blockers are in the attached checkpoint.' --artifact campaign/rollout/controls-worker-state.md --next-action 'Run the independent controls review.'\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re transition controls-bootstrap ready --actor controls-architect --role architecture-review --model openai/gpt-6-astra\n```\n\n`surprise CONTRACT --summary TEXT --probe TEXT` blocks immediately. `resolve SURPRISE_ID\n--explanation TEXT --probe TEXT` requires claimed Astra lead/resolver. Both also require\n`--actor NAME --role ROLE --model MODEL`. `evidence CONTRACT --record campaign/path.json`\nuses the same identity flags; record format is the evidence object above. Integrated records\nrequire lead and integration state. `verdict CONTRACT --session SESSION --verdict pass|fail\n--explanation TEXT` requires verifier identity flags and independent actor/session.\n\n```sh\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease acquire windows-vm --actor lab-one --role lab --model openai/gpt-5.5\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease show windows-vm\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease release windows-vm --actor lab-one --role lab --model openai/gpt-5.5 --token TOKEN_FROM_ACQUIRE\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease release windows-vm --actor lead --role lead --model openai/gpt-6-astra --lead-release --reason 'Confirmed prior operator stopped; access and cleanup checked.'\n```\n\nNo stale lease stealing. Explicit lead release requires an explanation and lab preconditions,\nside effects, cleanup, and access verification in the operator checkpoint. Treat lease tokens\nas local owner capabilities, not secrets to put in a board/dashboard.\n\n## Fresh bounded launches\n\nPrepare **two actual linked worktrees**, each distinct from its canonical source repository,\nat the contract's full baseline commit. No auto commits/worktree creation. Launch uses explicit\ncanonical `OPENCODE_CONFIG`, checks matching repo-local agent/model/40 steps, and sets the final\nenvironment overlay to bind requested role/model/steps. Other inherited config overrides are\ncleared. `opencode models` must list the exact requested model even for dry runs.\n\n```sh\npython3 tools/run_agent.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re --role implementer --actor worker-one --contract slice-one --engine-worktree /home/alex/worktrees/slice-one-engine --re-worktree /home/alex/worktrees/slice-one-re --cwd engine --dry-run\n```\n\nRemove `--dry-run` to execute. Normal worker launch requires a valid durable checkpoint, matching\nowner/role/status, no open surprises, baseline HEADs and canonical Git common-directory identity.\nRecovery checks checkpoint identity/basis and artifact hashes regardless of age, rechecks any\nsource-bound evidence, and validates paired Git worktree/baseline identity. Missing ordinary-worker\nstate still blocks. Bootstrap lead/architecture-review can start without a checkpoint; they still\nneed paired worktrees. Astra lead/resolver may launch a blocked contract with open surprises and\nwithout a worker checkpoint in **resolution-only** scope: read evidence and write decisions/state,\nno implementation. Its prompt and permission overlay carry that limit, and worktree source changes\nfail completion. Ordinary affected workers stay blocked. Other Astra architecture actors receive\nexplicit architecture authority within their owned scope. Each run is a fresh\n`opencode run --format json --model ... --agent ...`; no resume/continue option is used. The prompt\nsupplies the run ID to use as checkpoint `--session`; actual OpenCode session IDs are captured\nseparately when emitted. On exit, a checkpoint after start matching actor/role/model/run ID is\nmandatory or the run is marked incomplete. Completion additionally requires a zero exit, no\n`type:error`, a successful `step_finish` with `part.reason: \"stop\"`, one nonempty actual session ID,\nand consistent explicitly emitted model IDs. Text/tool-call/length events alone cannot complete a\nrun. Missing model emission is recorded `observed_model_status: \"unavailable\"`, never invented.\n\nThe runner checks the exact Git baseline again under reservation lock, rejects intervening contract\nchanges, and checks canonical model/prompt/config files and effective configuration for drift at\ncompletion. Expanded role prompt/model/steps are frozen in the last-layer environment overlay.\n`opencode debug config` runs in the actual launch cwd with the actual environment before execution\nand again at completion. Permissions explicitly allow read/search, ordinary worker shell commands,\nand external-directory access to the assigned paired trees plus canonical RE; role-specific edit\ndenies survive. Task delegation and interactive questions are denied. No `--auto` is required.\nNoninteractive command/environment tests and a live loader check cover this overlay; an actual\nnormal worker launch smoke is a separate lead integration check. Permissions and before/after\nchecks are operational guards, not a sandbox or continuous filesystem audit.\nCompaction is a backstop; no token threshold or machine-enforced 20-tool-call claim.\n\n## Local verification\n\n```sh\npython3 -m unittest discover -s verify/campaign -p 'test_*.py' -v\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate\n```\n\nTests create commits only in disposable fixture repositories, linked worktrees and fake OpenCode processes; they do\nnot launch agents or touch the lab. Historical rollout artifacts retain the scope and source identity\nof their runs; consult the accepted contract and current evidence, not an old handoff's status prose.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":223,"totalLines":223,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/README.md","time":{"start":1788999227895,"end":1788999227921}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_064f20d566fa046e016aa1f63bc4d887d1a0ce68aa4171811f"}},"id":"prt_088a9d9bf001lrtj36ed39C9OX","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999228001,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_mnPCjyHy2v40x5HWu7seRTim","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"acceptance\": [\n3:     {\n4:       \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n5:       \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n6:       \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n7:     },\n8:     {\n9:       \"axis\": \"validation\",\n10:       \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n11:       \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n12:     }\n13:   ],\n14:   \"baseline\": {\n15:     \"engine\": {\n16:       \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n17:       \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n18:     },\n19:     \"re\": {\n20:       \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n21:       \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n22:     }\n23:   },\n24:   \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241.json\",\n25:   \"dependencies\": [\n26:     \"controls-bootstrap\"\n27:   ],\n28:   \"effects\": [\n29:     \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n30:   ],\n31:   \"evidence\": [],\n32:   \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n33:   \"inputs\": [\n34:     \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n35:     \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n36:     \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n37:     \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n38:   ],\n39:   \"original_dependencies\": [\n40:     \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n41:   ],\n42:   \"owner\": {\n43:     \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n44:     \"role\": \"analyst\"\n45:   },\n46:   \"predictions\": [\n47:     \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n48:     \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n49:   ],\n50:   \"scope\": [\n51:     \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n52:     \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n53:     \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n54:     \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n55:     \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n56:   ],\n57:   \"status\": \"verification\",\n58:   \"stop_conditions\": [\n59:     \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n60:     \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n61:     \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n62:   ],\n63:   \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n64: }\n\n(End of file - total 64 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"acceptance\": [\n    {\n      \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n      \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n      \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"axis\": \"validation\",\n      \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n      \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"baseline\": {\n    \"engine\": {\n      \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n      \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n    },\n    \"re\": {\n      \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json","text":"{\n  \"acceptance\": [\n    {\n      \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n      \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n      \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"axis\": \"validation\",\n      \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n      \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"baseline\": {\n    \"engine\": {\n      \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n      \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n    },\n    \"re\": {\n      \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n      \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n    }\n  },\n  \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241.json\",\n  \"dependencies\": [\n    \"controls-bootstrap\"\n  ],\n  \"effects\": [\n    \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n  ],\n  \"evidence\": [],\n  \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"inputs\": [\n    \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n    \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n    \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n    \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n  ],\n  \"original_dependencies\": [\n    \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n  ],\n  \"owner\": {\n    \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n    \"role\": \"analyst\"\n  },\n  \"predictions\": [\n    \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n    \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n  ],\n  \"scope\": [\n    \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n    \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n    \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n    \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n    \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n  ],\n  \"status\": \"verification\",\n  \"stop_conditions\": [\n    \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n    \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n    \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n  ],\n  \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":64,"totalLines":64,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json","time":{"start":1788999227902,"end":1788999227926}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_064f20d566fa046e016aa1f63bc4e887d1a63b86618e026944"}},"id":"prt_088a9d9fa001x2Y3UpFO45tOi9","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999228001,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_mEkdO5gLBjQQ0242aDgr9XlG","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine/AGENTS.md"},"output":"<path>/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine/AGENTS.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # SOTS engine instructions\n2: \n3: Read `CONTRIBUTING.md` and `docs/architecture.md` before changing code.\n4: All task state, contracts, checkpoints, surprises, lab leases and acceptance evidence belong to\n5: the **canonical sots-re repository**, selected explicitly by the campaign runner's state root.\n6: The canonical local checkout is `/home/alex/sots-re`; paired worktrees must use the assigned\n7: state root, not assume their sibling directory is the RE repository.\n8: \n9: Read that repository's `AGENTS.md`, `campaign/README.md`, and your contract/checkpoint. Architecture\n10: and plan-changing surprises require GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`). No silent model fallback.\n11: Do not introduce another task board or agent fleet here. Checkpoint every 20 tool calls/15min and\n12: before compaction, experiments, handoffs and stops. Workers run bounded sessions and resume from\n13: repository state. No worker subdelegation, automatic commits, pushes or shared worktree edits.\n14: \n15: Keep engine logic independent of original-process memory; adapters marshal complete inputs and\n16: effects. Partial phases must report unknown dependencies. Missing dependencies are not zeros by\n17: default. Never claim independent replacement while original helpers perform the claimed work.\n18: Test both boundaries and original observations; report skipped tests honestly. Run a fresh gate\n19: from sots-re against explicit source/corpus paths for a source-bound result.\n\n(End of file - total 19 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# SOTS engine instructions\n\nRead `CONTRIBUTING.md` and `docs/architecture.md` before changing code.\nAll task state, contracts, checkpoints, surprises, lab leases and acceptance evidence belong to\nthe **canonical sots-re repository**, selected explicitly by the campaign runner's state root.\nThe canonical local checkout is `/home/alex/sots-re`; paired worktrees must use the assigned\nstate root, not assume their sibling directory is the RE repository.\n\nRead that repository's `AGENTS.md`, `campaign/README.md`, and your contract/checkpoint. Architecture\nand plan-changing surprises require GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`). No silent model fallback.\nDo not introduce another task board or agent fleet here. Checkpoint every 20 tool calls/15min and\nbefore compaction, experiments, handoffs and stops. Workers run bounded sessions and resume from\nrepository state. No worker subdelegation, automatic commits, pushes or shared worktree edits.\n\nKeep engine logic independent of original-process memory; adapters marshal complete inputs and\neffects. Partial phases must report unknown dependencies. Missing dependencies are not zeros by\ndefault. Never claim independent replacement while original helpers perform the claimed work.\nTest both boundaries and original observations; report skipped tests honestly. Run a fresh gate\nfrom sots-re against explicit source/corpus paths for a source-bound result.","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine/AGENTS.md","text":"# SOTS engine instructions\n\nRead `CONTRIBUTING.md` and `docs/architecture.md` before changing code.\nAll task state, contracts, checkpoints, surprises, lab leases and acceptance evidence belong to\nthe **canonical sots-re repository**, selected explicitly by the campaign runner's state root.\nThe canonical local checkout is `/home/alex/sots-re`; paired worktrees must use the assigned\nstate root, not assume their sibling directory is the RE repository.\n\nRead that repository's `AGENTS.md`, `campaign/README.md`, and your contract/checkpoint. Architecture\nand plan-changing surprises require GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`). No silent model fallback.\nDo not introduce another task board or agent fleet here. Checkpoint every 20 tool calls/15min and\nbefore compaction, experiments, handoffs and stops. Workers run bounded sessions and resume from\nrepository state. No worker subdelegation, automatic commits, pushes or shared worktree edits.\n\nKeep engine logic independent of original-process memory; adapters marshal complete inputs and\neffects. Partial phases must report unknown dependencies. Missing dependencies are not zeros by\ndefault. Never claim independent replacement while original helpers perform the claimed work.\nTest both boundaries and original observations; report skipped tests honestly. Run a fresh gate\nfrom sots-re against explicit source/corpus paths for a source-bound result.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":19,"totalLines":19,"truncated":false}},"title":"../../../tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine/AGENTS.md","time":{"start":1788999227948,"end":1788999227995}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_064f20d566fa046e016aa1f63bc51487d1b7d08f6388f3befe"}},"id":"prt_088a9da28001snOWMLGeQv6SaW","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999228001,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_8sa6E4G5NUcrxJtUgn2G2KMu","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re/AGENTS.md"},"output":"<path>/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re/AGENTS.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # SOTS campaign instructions\n2: \n3: This repository is the state authority for the SOTS reconstruction and its Windows lab.\n4: Start with `campaign/README.md`, your contract, its latest checkpoint, and open surprises.\n5: Current policy: `guides/multi-agent-workflow.md`. Engine architecture: `sots-engine/docs/architecture.md`.\n6: Historical findings are evidence, not current execution instructions or accepted status.\n7: \n8: ## Authority and models\n9: \n10: - Architecture, planning, acceptance-policy changes, and evidence that changes the plan belong\n11:   to **GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`)**. The user's final correction supersedes SOL/MYTHOS.\n12: - `campaign/models.json` is the role/model registry. Launch with `tools/run_agent.py` and an\n13:   explicit role, contract, state root, and paired worktrees. Never silently downgrade or fall back.\n14: - Ordinary implementation/test failures inside the contract may be fixed by its worker.\n15:   Falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope\n16:   require a recorded surprise and an Astra resolution before affected work continues.\n17: - No worker subdelegation. The lead assigns parallelism; max two implementation slices after\n18:   the pilot. Independent workload preparation is scheduled against explicit resource leases.\n19: \n20: ## Durable state and context\n21: \n22: Checkpoint in the canonical RE state root every **20 tool calls or 15 minutes**, whichever is\n23: earlier, and before an experiment, compaction, handoff, or stop. Include model/session, exact\n24: source identities, evidence paths, decisions versus observations, tests, blockers, and ONE exact\n25: next action. Do not store state only in a chat summary or `/tmp`.\n26: The runner uses bounded 40-step quanta. After checkpointing, stop and restart from the repository;\n27: automatic compaction is a backstop, not proof that a checkpoint was written. On recovery read the\n28: contract/checkpoint, verify worktree and resource identities, then continue. Missing state means\n29: blocked, not permission to reconstruct progress from memory.\n30: \n31: ## Ownership\n32: \n33: Use distinct engine and RE worktrees per lane, baseline-pinned. Canonical runtime state is shared\n34: only through the campaign tools. One integrator writes current evidence pointers and projections.\n35: Never stage someone else's changes. No automatic commit, push, pull, or reset. Commands requiring\n36: these actions need explicit user authorization. Source edits use apply_patch.\n37: VM, shared build-host, and Ghidra mutation require leases. A stale lease is not automatically free.\n38: Record preconditions, side effects, cleanup and access verification for any lab operation.\n39: Rollout bootstrap file-ownership exception: `campaign/rollout/architecture-decision.md` only.\n40: \n41: ## Evidence\n42: \n43: No generic `verified` promotion. Separate understanding, implementation, original dependencies,\n44: and validation scope. A count is insufficient without distinct states, branch exposures, and\n45: positive execution evidence. Include all writes, container elements, allocations, IDs, events,\n46: RNG draws, and runtime-only inputs. Original-assisted execution is not independent replacement.\n47: Synthetic boundary tests and original-game differential tests are complementary. Missing required\n48: inputs, zero execution, incomplete coverage, unexpected skips, stale binaries or unbound source\n49: identity fail acceptance. One independent verifier must reproduce the package; integrated-tree\n50: evidence is required for acceptance. Reports are measurements until those gates pass.\n51: \n52: Never commit owner-supplied binaries/assets or secrets. Engine facts cross only documented\n53: generated channels. Never paste disassembly/decompiler output into the engine repository.\n\n(End of file - total 53 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# SOTS campaign instructions\n\nThis repository is the state authority for the SOTS reconstruction and its Windows lab.\nStart with `campaign/README.md`, your contract, its latest checkpoint, and open surprises.\nCurrent policy: `guides/multi-agent-workflow.md`. Engine architecture: `sots-engine/docs/architecture.md`.\nHistorical findings are evidence, not current execution instructions or accepted status.\n\n## Authority and models\n\n- Architecture, planning, acceptance-policy changes, and evidence that changes the plan belong\n  to **GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`)**. The user's final correction supersedes SOL/MYTHOS.\n- `campaign/models.json` is the role/model registry. Launch with `tools/run_agent.py` and an\n  explicit role, contract, state root, and paired worktrees. Never silently downgrade or fall back.\n- Ordinary implementation/test failures inside the contract may be fixed by its worker.\n  Falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope\n  require a recorded surprise and an Astra resolution before affected work continues.\n- No worker subdelegation. The lead assigns parallelism; max two implementation slices after\n  the pilot. Independent workload preparation is scheduled against explicit resource leases.\n\n## Durable state and context","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re/AGENTS.md","text":"# SOTS campaign instructions\n\nThis repository is the state authority for the SOTS reconstruction and its Windows lab.\nStart with `campaign/README.md`, your contract, its latest checkpoint, and open surprises.\nCurrent policy: `guides/multi-agent-workflow.md`. Engine architecture: `sots-engine/docs/architecture.md`.\nHistorical findings are evidence, not current execution instructions or accepted status.\n\n## Authority and models\n\n- Architecture, planning, acceptance-policy changes, and evidence that changes the plan belong\n  to **GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`)**. The user's final correction supersedes SOL/MYTHOS.\n- `campaign/models.json` is the role/model registry. Launch with `tools/run_agent.py` and an\n  explicit role, contract, state root, and paired worktrees. Never silently downgrade or fall back.\n- Ordinary implementation/test failures inside the contract may be fixed by its worker.\n  Falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope\n  require a recorded surprise and an Astra resolution before affected work continues.\n- No worker subdelegation. The lead assigns parallelism; max two implementation slices after\n  the pilot. Independent workload preparation is scheduled against explicit resource leases.\n\n## Durable state and context\n\nCheckpoint in the canonical RE state root every **20 tool calls or 15 minutes**, whichever is\nearlier, and before an experiment, compaction, handoff, or stop. Include model/session, exact\nsource identities, evidence paths, decisions versus observations, tests, blockers, and ONE exact\nnext action. Do not store state only in a chat summary or `/tmp`.\nThe runner uses bounded 40-step quanta. After checkpointing, stop and restart from the repository;\nautomatic compaction is a backstop, not proof that a checkpoint was written. On recovery read the\ncontract/checkpoint, verify worktree and resource identities, then continue. Missing state means\nblocked, not permission to reconstruct progress from memory.\n\n## Ownership\n\nUse distinct engine and RE worktrees per lane, baseline-pinned. Canonical runtime state is shared\nonly through the campaign tools. One integrator writes current evidence pointers and projections.\nNever stage someone else's changes. No automatic commit, push, pull, or reset. Commands requiring\nthese actions need explicit user authorization. Source edits use apply_patch.\nVM, shared build-host, and Ghidra mutation require leases. A stale lease is not automatically free.\nRecord preconditions, side effects, cleanup and access verification for any lab operation.\nRollout bootstrap file-ownership exception: `campaign/rollout/architecture-decision.md` only.\n\n## Evidence\n\nNo generic `verified` promotion. Separate understanding, implementation, original dependencies,\nand validation scope. A count is insufficient without distinct states, branch exposures, and\npositive execution evidence. Include all writes, container elements, allocations, IDs, events,\nRNG draws, and runtime-only inputs. Original-assisted execution is not independent replacement.\nSynthetic boundary tests and original-game differential tests are complementary. Missing required\ninputs, zero execution, incomplete coverage, unexpected skips, stale binaries or unbound source\nidentity fail acceptance. One independent verifier must reproduce the package; integrated-tree\nevidence is required for acceptance. Reports are measurements until those gates pass.\n\nNever commit owner-supplied binaries/assets or secrets. Engine facts cross only documented\ngenerated channels. Never paste disassembly/decompiler output into the engine repository.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":53,"totalLines":53,"truncated":false}},"title":"../../../tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re/AGENTS.md","time":{"start":1788999227985,"end":1788999227998}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_064f20d566fa046e016aa1f63bc51c87d1b2d410490abfaf7c"}},"id":"prt_088a9da2e001xKOpfna4KCokAL","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999228017,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"glob","callID":"call_3F7bEBXNdCLya7AIEFszXzbJ","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign","pattern":"**/*surpris*"},"output":"No files found","metadata":{"count":0,"truncated":false},"title":"campaign","time":{"start":1788999227936,"end":1788999228003}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_064f20d566fa046e016aa1f63bc50087d18084eb624756ed7b"}},"id":"prt_088a9da1c001uHc0bDYKtlYAj1","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999228017,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_ZPsTsZcdISjZcA0CpVunNDpP","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/guides/multi-agent-workflow.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/guides/multi-agent-workflow.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Multi-agent operating architecture\n2: \n3: ## Product and milestone\n4: \n5: Reconstruct a behavior-equivalent engine consuming owner-supplied assets. The next product\n6: milestone is standalone replay given a captured command stream and complete declared runtime\n7: inputs. The first workflow pilot is the complete research write set. A passing host build is a\n8: component baseline, not a playable engine or independent replacement.\n9: \n10: ## Source of truth\n11: \n12: `campaign/contracts/` holds versioned tasks, `campaign/runtime/` holds checkpoints, sessions,\n13: leases and surprises, and evidence packages identify inputs, source and executable artifacts.\n14: `campaign/current.json` selects published evidence by path and digest. Board/dashboard are\n15: generated projections, never alternate writable authorities. Exact tool CLI/schema is documented\n16: in `campaign/README.md`. Historical findings retain their original experiment scope; they are\n17: not promoted by copying an old status into a new contract.\n18: \n19: ## Model authority\n20: \n21: | Responsibility | Model |\n22: |---|---|\n23: | Normal planning, architecture and integration loop | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n24: | Bounded RE analysis, implementation and independent verification | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n25: | Routine lab/workload operations | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n26: | Problem and surprise resolution | GPT-6 Astra |\n27: | Context compaction | GPT-5.5 |\n28: \n29: Exact provider IDs are in `campaign/models.json`. The lead escalates to Astra when a falsified\n30: assumption, conflict, instrument effect, or scope change blocks the loop. No fallback is automatic. Model names in editable JSON are\n31: provenance, not authentication: launcher events and independent review support the record.\n32: Permissions reduce accidental role drift; unrestricted local shell access is not a sandbox.\n33: \n34: ## Behavioral slice\n35: \n36: The lead specifies a bounded input domain, full observable write set, dependencies, acceptance\n37: workloads and stop conditions. The analyst recovers behavior; the verifier specifies discriminating\n38: tests before implementation; the implementer changes engine/adapters; the lab operator captures\n39: controls; the verifier reproduces; the integrator tests the combined source snapshot.\n40: \n41: Include transitive effects: allocations, IDs, container ELEMENTS, event text/records, RNG and\n42: nonserialized state. An address/function name is not a sufficient replacement boundary. If a\n43: neighbor function supplies required effects, extend the approved contract or expose it as an\n44: original dependency. Do not call the original and label the result independent.\n45: \n46: Lifecycle is `proposed → ready → implementing → verification → integration → accepted`, with\n47: blocked/revision states. Lifecycle is distinct from evidence strength. Acceptance is scoped to\n48: the manifest's exact procedure and workloads, never universal correctness.\n49: \n50: ## Independence\n51: \n52: Verifier and implementer are different executions. Verification starts with the contract, raw\n53: evidence and reproduction recipe, not just the author's conclusion. Require one meaningful\n54: challenge: held-out state, boundary, negative control, ablation, or independent state accounting.\n55: Both synthetic tests and original-game experiments matter. Repeat-call volume cannot replace\n56: branch and distinct-state coverage. Null effects and zero executions must be distinguishable.\n57: \n58: ## Sessions and recovery\n59: \n60: At most two implementation slices after a single-slice pilot. No nested worker delegation.\n61: Paired worktrees isolate source changes; unique build directories isolate artifacts. Canonical\n62: RE runtime state remains explicit even when a worker runs in `/tmp` worktrees.\n63: \n64: Checkpoint every 20 calls or 15min; also before experiments, compaction, handoff and stopping.\n65: Record source identities, exact changed paths, commands/results, artifacts and hashes, open\n66: surprises, held leases, requested/observed model, session identity and exact next action. Avoid\n67: large prose histories: raw logs belong in evidence; the checkpoint is a bounded resumption record.\n68: \n69: The launcher caps a quantum at 40 agent steps. A new quantum starts fresh using contract and\n70: checkpoint. Auto-compaction with an ample reserved window and four retained turns is enabled.\n71: This is a best-effort context backstop; regular durable checkpoints and fresh quanta provide the\n72: actual recovery discipline. Never claim a model compacted merely because a setting exists.\n73: \n74: ## Surprises\n75: \n76: On a falsified prediction, contradictory claim, unexplained regression, instrument interference,\n77: or newly necessary dependency: record the observation and evidence; block affected work. Astra\n78: first checks the instrument and source identity, then marks claims surviving/qualified/overturned,\n79: chooses a discriminating experiment, and records the revised plan. Unaffected contracted work\n80: may continue. Updating a paragraph without invalidating affected acceptance is insufficient.\n81: \n82: ## Lab ownership\n83: \n84: Acquire a canonical resource lease before VM, build-host or Ghidra mutation. An expired timestamp\n85: does not authorize stealing a lease. The lead reconciles stale ownership with actual processes.\n86: Use one guest at a time for maintenance, capture before/after inventory, preserve access and\n87: runtime dependencies, and verify unattended console login plus authenticated administration.\n88: Reboots require a free guest and a recorded recovery path. Runtime/Ghidra changes are experiments\n89: with provenance, not undocumented preparatory steps.\n90: \n91: ## Gate and publication\n92: \n93: Run the local gate with explicit engine, corpus, new output directory and profile. It snapshots\n94: source, uses fresh builds, records manifests and runs the expected test inventory once. Host\n95: profile allows a named list of unavailable asset/trace tests and publishes them as limitations.\n96: Full acceptance requires the full profile and the slice-specific original oracle; no blanket\n97: waiver converts a host pass to fidelity. Standalone measurement may diverge; acceptance may not.\n98: \n99: The integrator alone selects current results after verifying their hashes and source binding.\n100: No percentages of LOC, mapped rows or closed leaves purport to measure engine completeness.\n101: Run failure and missing evidence are visible states. Old results remain historical, not current.\n\n(End of file - total 101 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Multi-agent operating architecture\n\n## Product and milestone\n\nReconstruct a behavior-equivalent engine consuming owner-supplied assets. The next product\nmilestone is standalone replay given a captured command stream and complete declared runtime\ninputs. The first workflow pilot is the complete research write set. A passing host build is a\ncomponent baseline, not a playable engine or independent replacement.\n\n## Source of truth\n\n`campaign/contracts/` holds versioned tasks, `campaign/runtime/` holds checkpoints, sessions,\nleases and surprises, and evidence packages identify inputs, source and executable artifacts.\n`campaign/current.json` selects published evidence by path and digest. Board/dashboard are\ngenerated projections, never alternate writable authorities. Exact tool CLI/schema is documented\nin `campaign/README.md`. Historical findings retain their original experiment scope; they are\nnot promoted by copying an old status into a new contract.\n\n## Model authority\n","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/guides/multi-agent-workflow.md","text":"# Multi-agent operating architecture\n\n## Product and milestone\n\nReconstruct a behavior-equivalent engine consuming owner-supplied assets. The next product\nmilestone is standalone replay given a captured command stream and complete declared runtime\ninputs. The first workflow pilot is the complete research write set. A passing host build is a\ncomponent baseline, not a playable engine or independent replacement.\n\n## Source of truth\n\n`campaign/contracts/` holds versioned tasks, `campaign/runtime/` holds checkpoints, sessions,\nleases and surprises, and evidence packages identify inputs, source and executable artifacts.\n`campaign/current.json` selects published evidence by path and digest. Board/dashboard are\ngenerated projections, never alternate writable authorities. Exact tool CLI/schema is documented\nin `campaign/README.md`. Historical findings retain their original experiment scope; they are\nnot promoted by copying an old status into a new contract.\n\n## Model authority\n\n| Responsibility | Model |\n|---|---|\n| Normal planning, architecture and integration loop | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n| Bounded RE analysis, implementation and independent verification | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n| Routine lab/workload operations | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n| Problem and surprise resolution | GPT-6 Astra |\n| Context compaction | GPT-5.5 |\n\nExact provider IDs are in `campaign/models.json`. The lead escalates to Astra when a falsified\nassumption, conflict, instrument effect, or scope change blocks the loop. No fallback is automatic. Model names in editable JSON are\nprovenance, not authentication: launcher events and independent review support the record.\nPermissions reduce accidental role drift; unrestricted local shell access is not a sandbox.\n\n## Behavioral slice\n\nThe lead specifies a bounded input domain, full observable write set, dependencies, acceptance\nworkloads and stop conditions. The analyst recovers behavior; the verifier specifies discriminating\ntests before implementation; the implementer changes engine/adapters; the lab operator captures\ncontrols; the verifier reproduces; the integrator tests the combined source snapshot.\n\nInclude transitive effects: allocations, IDs, container ELEMENTS, event text/records, RNG and\nnonserialized state. An address/function name is not a sufficient replacement boundary. If a\nneighbor function supplies required effects, extend the approved contract or expose it as an\noriginal dependency. Do not call the original and label the result independent.\n\nLifecycle is `proposed → ready → implementing → verification → integration → accepted`, with\nblocked/revision states. Lifecycle is distinct from evidence strength. Acceptance is scoped to\nthe manifest's exact procedure and workloads, never universal correctness.\n\n## Independence\n\nVerifier and implementer are different executions. Verification starts with the contract, raw\nevidence and reproduction recipe, not just the author's conclusion. Require one meaningful\nchallenge: held-out state, boundary, negative control, ablation, or independent state accounting.\nBoth synthetic tests and original-game experiments matter. Repeat-call volume cannot replace\nbranch and distinct-state coverage. Null effects and zero executions must be distinguishable.\n\n## Sessions and recovery\n\nAt most two implementation slices after a single-slice pilot. No nested worker delegation.\nPaired worktrees isolate source changes; unique build directories isolate artifacts. Canonical\nRE runtime state remains explicit even when a worker runs in `/tmp` worktrees.\n\nCheckpoint every 20 calls or 15min; also before experiments, compaction, handoff and stopping.\nRecord source identities, exact changed paths, commands/results, artifacts and hashes, open\nsurprises, held leases, requested/observed model, session identity and exact next action. Avoid\nlarge prose histories: raw logs belong in evidence; the checkpoint is a bounded resumption record.\n\nThe launcher caps a quantum at 40 agent steps. A new quantum starts fresh using contract and\ncheckpoint. Auto-compaction with an ample reserved window and four retained turns is enabled.\nThis is a best-effort context backstop; regular durable checkpoints and fresh quanta provide the\nactual recovery discipline. Never claim a model compacted merely because a setting exists.\n\n## Surprises\n\nOn a falsified prediction, contradictory claim, unexplained regression, instrument interference,\nor newly necessary dependency: record the observation and evidence; block affected work. Astra\nfirst checks the instrument and source identity, then marks claims surviving/qualified/overturned,\nchooses a discriminating experiment, and records the revised plan. Unaffected contracted work\nmay continue. Updating a paragraph without invalidating affected acceptance is insufficient.\n\n## Lab ownership\n\nAcquire a canonical resource lease before VM, build-host or Ghidra mutation. An expired timestamp\ndoes not authorize stealing a lease. The lead reconciles stale ownership with actual processes.\nUse one guest at a time for maintenance, capture before/after inventory, preserve access and\nruntime dependencies, and verify unattended console login plus authenticated administration.\nReboots require a free guest and a recorded recovery path. Runtime/Ghidra changes are experiments\nwith provenance, not undocumented preparatory steps.\n\n## Gate and publication\n\nRun the local gate with explicit engine, corpus, new output directory and profile. It snapshots\nsource, uses fresh builds, records manifests and runs the expected test inventory once. Host\nprofile allows a named list of unavailable asset/trace tests and publishes them as limitations.\nFull acceptance requires the full profile and the slice-specific original oracle; no blanket\nwaiver converts a host pass to fidelity. Standalone measurement may diverge; acceptance may not.\n\nThe integrator alone selects current results after verifying their hashes and source binding.\nNo percentages of LOC, mapped rows or closed leaves purport to measure engine completeness.\nRun failure and missing evidence are visible states. Old results remain historical, not current.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":101,"totalLines":101,"truncated":false}},"title":"guides/multi-agent-workflow.md","time":{"start":1788999227942,"end":1788999228015}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_064f20d566fa046e016aa1f63bc50887d1ab3df5acdc2a6a6a"}},"id":"prt_088a9da22001Rh9cIrkJ5t2dJk","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999228021,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_sXe26eCvJNP168sMD4SPVLSB","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n3:   \"artifacts\": [\n4:     {\n5:       \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json\",\n6:       \"sha256\": \"c03d87ff4c7e2a23d43cb3c7d1c7bf19dfb3dfd868a9cbac2b8401fe3ee00fbd\"\n7:     },\n8:     {\n9:       \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\",\n10:       \"sha256\": \"3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06\"\n11:     },\n12:     {\n13:       \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md\",\n14:       \"sha256\": \"fd0337bf2135341843738adc831ea3bd94fa6b87f5c21e652df919a5d2bec9df\"\n15:     },\n16:     {\n17:       \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md\",\n18:       \"sha256\": \"ff6357a055021d9a3d13c10496f41dbdd7266807817affc1fdb32cde19221f66\"\n19:     },\n20:     {\n21:       \"path\": \"campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md\",\n22:       \"sha256\": \"613314318a89efa3ea51e0ee3f43bc2ecd67ff01950a4da77036c1d95c566e5d\"\n23:     }\n24:   ],\n25:   \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n26:   \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n27:   \"id\": \"5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241\",\n28:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n29:   \"next_action\": \"Lead launch an independent verifier on the same paired baseline and SHA256-matched dumps/sots.exe to reproduce all four objdump windows in objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt and challenge the equal-versus-description-only-different empty/short/long EvDsc branch predictions without using the analyst interpretation as authority.\",\n30:   \"role\": \"analyst\",\n31:   \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n32:   \"session\": \"run-c98b95381afc4933dad98898\",\n33:   \"summary\": \"Fresh recovery/stop checkpoint for bounded analyst quantum. Static observations versus decisions: no new ABI interpretation or measurement was produced; the prior static handoff and dedup/helper repair remain the current analyst record, and Astra decision d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924 remains resolved. All six canonical surprise records were read; campaign status reports no open surprises for this contract. The prior checkpoint exact next action is explicitly a lead action to launch an independent verifier, so this analyst did not delegate, self-verify, promote a claim, repeat completed analysis, or change architecture. Identity observations: requested/claimed model openai/gpt-5.6-sol matches campaign/models.json analyst registry. Engine worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine is HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 with common dir /home/alex/sots-engine/.git and source-binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd. RE worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re is HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 with common dir /home/alex/sots-re/.git and source-binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Both retain the pre-existing dirty inventories described by the prior checkpoint; this quantum edited neither worktree and owns no source change. Artifact/input observation: archived index continues to identify dumps/sots.exe as SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 / MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c and the complete objdump capture as SHA256 3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06; this quantum did not substitute a fresh runtime measurement. Tests/checks: campaign status succeeded and source-binding reproduced both prior digests. Blocker/handoff: acceptance criterion independent-cross-check remains outside analyst authority and requires a distinct verifier execution; live allocator safety, allocation-failure outcomes... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n34:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:12:25.600374+00:00\"\n35: }\n\n(End of file - total 35 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json\",\n      \"sha256\": \"c03d87ff4c7e2a23d43cb3c7d1c7bf19dfb3dfd868a9cbac2b8401fe3ee00fbd\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\",\n      \"sha256\": \"3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"fd0337bf2135341843738adc831ea3bd94fa6b87f5c21e652df919a5d2bec9df\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"ff6357a055021d9a3d13c10496f41dbdd7266807817affc1fdb32cde19221f66\"\n    },\n    {","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json\",\n      \"sha256\": \"c03d87ff4c7e2a23d43cb3c7d1c7bf19dfb3dfd868a9cbac2b8401fe3ee00fbd\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\",\n      \"sha256\": \"3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"fd0337bf2135341843738adc831ea3bd94fa6b87f5c21e652df919a5d2bec9df\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"ff6357a055021d9a3d13c10496f41dbdd7266807817affc1fdb32cde19221f66\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"613314318a89efa3ea51e0ee3f43bc2ecd67ff01950a4da77036c1d95c566e5d\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Lead launch an independent verifier on the same paired baseline and SHA256-matched dumps/sots.exe to reproduce all four objdump windows in objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt and challenge the equal-versus-description-only-different empty/short/long EvDsc branch predictions without using the analyst interpretation as authority.\",\n  \"role\": \"analyst\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-c98b95381afc4933dad98898\",\n  \"summary\": \"Fresh recovery/stop checkpoint for bounded analyst quantum. Static observations versus decisions: no new ABI interpretation or measurement was produced; the prior static handoff and dedup/helper repair remain the current analyst record, and Astra decision d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924 remains resolved. All six canonical surprise records were read; campaign status reports no open surprises for this contract. The prior checkpoint exact next action is explicitly a lead action to launch an independent verifier, so this analyst did not delegate, self-verify, promote a claim, repeat completed analysis, or change architecture. Identity observations: requested/claimed model openai/gpt-5.6-sol matches campaign/models.json analyst registry. Engine worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine is HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 with common dir /home/alex/sots-engine/.git and source-binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd. RE worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re is HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 with common dir /home/alex/sots-re/.git and source-binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Both retain the pre-existing dirty inventories described by the prior checkpoint; this quantum edited neither worktree and owns no source change. Artifact/input observation: archived index continues to identify dumps/sots.exe as SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 / MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c and the complete objdump capture as SHA256 3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06; this quantum did not substitute a fresh runtime measurement. Tests/checks: campaign status succeeded and source-binding reproduced both prior digests. Blocker/handoff: acceptance criterion independent-cross-check remains outside analyst authority and requires a distinct verifier execution; live allocator safety, allocation-failure outcomes... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:12:25.600374+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":35,"totalLines":35,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241.json","time":{"start":1788999227930,"end":1788999228019}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_064f20d566fa046e016aa1f63bc4f487d1abcb3cb261531c3a"}},"id":"prt_088a9da00001OuFQLEQDnkW3Zj","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999228101,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088a9dac0001Kc1qseQ2X2OvcH","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"01f52d92adbf7265c0f0bc6c9973b74a20137782","messageID":"msg_088a9b588001Df0DrxkuM1g8Re","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":6347,"input":481,"output":234,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":5632}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999230188,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088a9e2e80016d8lwg21Wi3ki0","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"598596f26851be845bb855c386b501f411ec0ed8","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999241155,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_xPPeMReMqVJrNz95F4aCMmWp","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/models.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/models.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"schema\": \"sots-models/1\",\n3:   \"roles\": {\n4:     \"lead\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n5:     \"resolver\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n6:     \"architecture-review\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n7:     \"analyst\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n8:     \"implementer\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n9:     \"verifier\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n10:     \"lab\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\"\n11:   },\n12:   \"agents\": {\n13:     \"lead\": \"sots-lead\",\n14:     \"resolver\": \"sots-resolver\",\n15:     \"architecture-review\": \"sots-lead\",\n16:     \"analyst\": \"sots-analyst\",\n17:     \"implementer\": \"sots-implementer\",\n18:     \"verifier\": \"sots-verifier\",\n19:     \"lab\": \"sots-lab\"\n20:   },\n21:   \"max_steps\": 40,\n22:   \"implementation_wip\": 2\n23: }\n\n(End of file - total 23 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"schema\": \"sots-models/1\",\n  \"roles\": {\n    \"lead\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"resolver\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n    \"architecture-review\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"analyst\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"implementer\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"verifier\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"lab\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\"\n  },\n  \"agents\": {\n    \"lead\": \"sots-lead\",\n    \"resolver\": \"sots-resolver\",\n    \"architecture-review\": \"sots-lead\",\n    \"analyst\": \"sots-analyst\",\n    \"implementer\": \"sots-implementer\",\n    \"verifier\": \"sots-verifier\",\n    \"lab\": \"sots-lab\"\n  },","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/models.json","text":"{\n  \"schema\": \"sots-models/1\",\n  \"roles\": {\n    \"lead\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"resolver\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n    \"architecture-review\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"analyst\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"implementer\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"verifier\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n    \"lab\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\"\n  },\n  \"agents\": {\n    \"lead\": \"sots-lead\",\n    \"resolver\": \"sots-resolver\",\n    \"architecture-review\": \"sots-lead\",\n    \"analyst\": \"sots-analyst\",\n    \"implementer\": \"sots-implementer\",\n    \"verifier\": \"sots-verifier\",\n    \"lab\": \"sots-lab\"\n  },\n  \"max_steps\": 40,\n  \"implementation_wip\": 2\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":23,"totalLines":23,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/models.json","time":{"start":1788999241095,"end":1788999241137}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b602079b1966e1a016aa1f648f3fc87d18f475aabb8f51ca5"}},"id":"prt_088aa0d7d001fJpgoeCSDeO2tT","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999241155,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_adCdQTDwHCdugrb3hDzyP2ld","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Completion record ABI recovery\n2: \n3: Static handoff only. The provenance index is\n4: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md`; the regenerated instruction\n5: capture and interpretation are respectively\n6: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` and\n7: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md`. The complete dedup/helper repair is\n8: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`. Input identity is `dumps/sots.exe`,\n9: SHA-256 `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n10: `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n11: \n12: ## Implementable machine boundaries recovered\n13: \n14: * `0x008562a0`: ObservedTech default constructor, ECX receiver, EAX return, plain `ret`.\n15: * `0x007b7320`: ObservedTech vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x2c`.\n16:   Its copy helper is `0x0079a150` (cdecl-style allocator/destination/source stack arguments), which copy-constructs the embedded string rather than copying a\n17:   vector element header. Capacity growth is `0x007b5820` -> `0x007b34e0` -> `0x0057e590`.\n18: * `0x0057e590` calls `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x2c`; reallocation destroys every old element via\n19:   virtual slot 0 with zero and frees the array through `0x00924faa`. These are MSVCR100 scalar-new\n20:   and scalar-delete import thunks, not clean-room allocator operations.\n21: * `0x0086c580`: PlayerEvent vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x74`.\n22:   It grows via `0x00869500` and copy-constructs through `0x007693f0` (ECX destination, stack source,\n23:   EAX destination return, ret 4), independently assigning all\n24:   three strings. `0x0061ae90` releases each long string via `0x00924faa` when capacity is `>= 0x10`.\n25: * `0x004249a0` (reached by `0x00425430` assignment) allocates through `0x00924fb6` and releases a\n26:   prior long destination buffer through `0x00924faa`. A temporary long string is therefore not\n27:   transferable by raw header copy.\n28: * `0x00885380`: get-or-create TurnEvents bucket, ECX EventStorage receiver plus stack turn, EAX\n29:   bucket return, `ret 4`. It returns the last existing matching turn. On absence it appends a deep\n30:   copy of a zero/empty stack bucket through `0x00884cb0`, then writes the stored turn.\n31: * `0x00884cb0`: outer TurnEvents vector append, ECX vector receiver plus stack source, `ret 4`,\n32:   stride `0x18`. Full-capacity growth is `0x008841a0` -> `0x00883a60`; allocation is\n33:   `0x006e8f50` -> `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x18`. Existing buckets are copy-constructed by\n34:   `0x0077fed0`, including an independently allocated/copied nested PlayerEvent vector via\n35:   `0x00779850` -> `0x0078af40` (`count * 0x74`) -> `0x007725a0` -> `0x007693f0`.\n36: * TurnEvents virtual slot zero resolves from vtable `0x00a0f07c` to `0x0062e120`. It destroys the\n37:   nested vector through `0x00629580`; that destroys every `0x74` PlayerEvent, frees the nested block,\n38:   and zeros its three pointers. Static unwind edges clean partial PlayerEvent and TurnEvents ranges\n39:   and free the new outer block, but no allocation failure was executed live.\n40: \n41: ## Ordering / visible effects\n42: \n43: RecordObservedTech's append predicate is name absence, not capacity. A matching existing record\n44: keeps first-turn/name and updates last-turn/with mask. `0x00825d40` scans a bucket's events in\n45: `0x74` steps, checking action, location, three floats, message and image before passing both\n46: description strings to `0x0046f8c0`. Fresh complete instructions establish that helper as\n47: caller-cleaned `bool string_not_equal(stored, candidate)`: it returns one for any byte/length\n48: difference and zero for equality, handling each operand's inline/heap representation at capacity\n49: `0x10`. FindDuplicate reaches the match return only on zero, so `EvDsc` equality is required and a\n50: description-only difference does not deduplicate. This statically contradicts the inherited\n51: description-omission claim; decision `d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` required the now-archived complete\n52: branch/helper repair. The wrapper returns the first element equal in all fields and writes nothing.\n53: `0x00879eb0` prunes only a leading\n54: stale run (`EvTurn < turn-50`), deep-shifts from the run's last stale element, and therefore removes\n55: `n-1`: one stale bucket survives, a single stale bucket causes no write, and stale buckets after a\n56: fresh bucket are not inspected. The no-duplicate EventStorage path remains distinct from event-vector\n57: capacity: it is the path that appends a `0x74` PlayerEvent and changes IDs/vector contents. Caller\n58: text/position/action/defaulting and the exact PostEvent write order remain required inputs/effects.\n59: No RNG draw occurs in the recovered bucket, duplicate, prune, copy, allocation, or destruction\n60: boundaries.\n61: \n62: ## Original/runtime dependencies and limits\n63: \n64: Any original-assisted allocation, string assignment or deletion must retain allocator-family\n65: compatibility: the recovered calls target the original MSVCR100 import thunks. A standalone\n66: replacement needs its own coherent allocation/destruction boundary; calling these original helpers\n67: is an original dependency, not independent replacement. Calling `0x0046f8c0` likewise retains an\n68: original string-layout/comparison dependency, though its equality behavior is implementable without\n69: allocation in a standalone boundary. Required unavailable proof inputs are a safe\n70: long-string/full-capacity pre/post fixture (or equivalent archived trace), same-bucket\n71: equal/description-only-different event fixtures covering short and long strings, exact exceptional\n72: cleanup outcomes under a live throw, and independent reproduction of the named static windows and\n73: falsifiers. This handoff makes no live\n74: allocator-safety, runtime event-construction, or replacement-acceptance claim.\n\n(End of file - total 74 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Completion record ABI recovery\n\nStatic handoff only. The provenance index is\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md`; the regenerated instruction\ncapture and interpretation are respectively\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` and\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md`. The complete dedup/helper repair is\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`. Input identity is `dumps/sots.exe`,\nSHA-256 `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n\n## Implementable machine boundaries recovered\n\n* `0x008562a0`: ObservedTech default constructor, ECX receiver, EAX return, plain `ret`.\n* `0x007b7320`: ObservedTech vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x2c`.\n  Its copy helper is `0x0079a150` (cdecl-style allocator/destination/source stack arguments), which copy-constructs the embedded string rather than copying a\n  vector element header. Capacity growth is `0x007b5820` -> `0x007b34e0` -> `0x0057e590`.\n* `0x0057e590` calls `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x2c`; reallocation destroys every old element via\n  virtual slot 0 with zero and frees the array through `0x00924faa`. These are MSVCR100 scalar-new\n  and scalar-delete import thunks, not clean-room allocator operations.","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md","text":"# Completion record ABI recovery\n\nStatic handoff only. The provenance index is\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md`; the regenerated instruction\ncapture and interpretation are respectively\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` and\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md`. The complete dedup/helper repair is\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`. Input identity is `dumps/sots.exe`,\nSHA-256 `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n\n## Implementable machine boundaries recovered\n\n* `0x008562a0`: ObservedTech default constructor, ECX receiver, EAX return, plain `ret`.\n* `0x007b7320`: ObservedTech vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x2c`.\n  Its copy helper is `0x0079a150` (cdecl-style allocator/destination/source stack arguments), which copy-constructs the embedded string rather than copying a\n  vector element header. Capacity growth is `0x007b5820` -> `0x007b34e0` -> `0x0057e590`.\n* `0x0057e590` calls `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x2c`; reallocation destroys every old element via\n  virtual slot 0 with zero and frees the array through `0x00924faa`. These are MSVCR100 scalar-new\n  and scalar-delete import thunks, not clean-room allocator operations.\n* `0x0086c580`: PlayerEvent vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x74`.\n  It grows via `0x00869500` and copy-constructs through `0x007693f0` (ECX destination, stack source,\n  EAX destination return, ret 4), independently assigning all\n  three strings. `0x0061ae90` releases each long string via `0x00924faa` when capacity is `>= 0x10`.\n* `0x004249a0` (reached by `0x00425430` assignment) allocates through `0x00924fb6` and releases a\n  prior long destination buffer through `0x00924faa`. A temporary long string is therefore not\n  transferable by raw header copy.\n* `0x00885380`: get-or-create TurnEvents bucket, ECX EventStorage receiver plus stack turn, EAX\n  bucket return, `ret 4`. It returns the last existing matching turn. On absence it appends a deep\n  copy of a zero/empty stack bucket through `0x00884cb0`, then writes the stored turn.\n* `0x00884cb0`: outer TurnEvents vector append, ECX vector receiver plus stack source, `ret 4`,\n  stride `0x18`. Full-capacity growth is `0x008841a0` -> `0x00883a60`; allocation is\n  `0x006e8f50` -> `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x18`. Existing buckets are copy-constructed by\n  `0x0077fed0`, including an independently allocated/copied nested PlayerEvent vector via\n  `0x00779850` -> `0x0078af40` (`count * 0x74`) -> `0x007725a0` -> `0x007693f0`.\n* TurnEvents virtual slot zero resolves from vtable `0x00a0f07c` to `0x0062e120`. It destroys the\n  nested vector through `0x00629580`; that destroys every `0x74` PlayerEvent, frees the nested block,\n  and zeros its three pointers. Static unwind edges clean partial PlayerEvent and TurnEvents ranges\n  and free the new outer block, but no allocation failure was executed live.\n\n## Ordering / visible effects\n\nRecordObservedTech's append predicate is name absence, not capacity. A matching existing record\nkeeps first-turn/name and updates last-turn/with mask. `0x00825d40` scans a bucket's events in\n`0x74` steps, checking action, location, three floats, message and image before passing both\ndescription strings to `0x0046f8c0`. Fresh complete instructions establish that helper as\ncaller-cleaned `bool string_not_equal(stored, candidate)`: it returns one for any byte/length\ndifference and zero for equality, handling each operand's inline/heap representation at capacity\n`0x10`. FindDuplicate reaches the match return only on zero, so `EvDsc` equality is required and a\ndescription-only difference does not deduplicate. This statically contradicts the inherited\ndescription-omission claim; decision `d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` required the now-archived complete\nbranch/helper repair. The wrapper returns the first element equal in all fields and writes nothing.\n`0x00879eb0` prunes only a leading\nstale run (`EvTurn < turn-50`), deep-shifts from the run's last stale element, and therefore removes\n`n-1`: one stale bucket survives, a single stale bucket causes no write, and stale buckets after a\nfresh bucket are not inspected. The no-duplicate EventStorage path remains distinct from event-vector\ncapacity: it is the path that appends a `0x74` PlayerEvent and changes IDs/vector contents. Caller\ntext/position/action/defaulting and the exact PostEvent write order remain required inputs/effects.\nNo RNG draw occurs in the recovered bucket, duplicate, prune, copy, allocation, or destruction\nboundaries.\n\n## Original/runtime dependencies and limits\n\nAny original-assisted allocation, string assignment or deletion must retain allocator-family\ncompatibility: the recovered calls target the original MSVCR100 import thunks. A standalone\nreplacement needs its own coherent allocation/destruction boundary; calling these original helpers\nis an original dependency, not independent replacement. Calling `0x0046f8c0` likewise retains an\noriginal string-layout/comparison dependency, though its equality behavior is implementable without\nallocation in a standalone boundary. Required unavailable proof inputs are a safe\nlong-string/full-capacity pre/post fixture (or equivalent archived trace), same-bucket\nequal/description-only-different event fixtures covering short and long strings, exact exceptional\ncleanup outcomes under a live throw, and independent reproduction of the named static windows and\nfalsifiers. This handoff makes no live\nallocator-safety, runtime event-construction, or replacement-acceptance claim.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":74,"totalLines":74,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md","time":{"start":1788999241099,"end":1788999241141}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b602079b1966e1a016aa1f648f40887d189412265d42d6e82"}},"id":"prt_088aa0d89001PWl5341Pkgsd7T","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999241155,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_19CglQXZCZFycjyfuB4xGruL","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n3: # Tool: GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38, Intel syntax.\n4: # Every command below exited 0. Output is unfiltered.\n5: #\n6: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe\n7: \n8: dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n9: \n10: \n11: Disassembly of section .text:\n12: \n13: 00825d40 <.text+0x424d40>:\n14:   825d40:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n15:   825d41:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n16:   825d43:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n17:   825d44:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n18:   825d45:\t8b 5d 08             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n19:   825d48:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n20:   825d49:\t33 f6                \txor    esi,esi\n21:   825d4b:\t3b de                \tcmp    ebx,esi\n22:   825d4d:\t75 0a                \tjne    0x825d59\n23:   825d4f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n24:   825d50:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n25:   825d52:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n26:   825d53:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n27:   825d55:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n28:   825d56:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n29:   825d59:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n30:   825d5c:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n31:   825d5f:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n32:   825d64:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n33:   825d66:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n34:   825d68:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n35:   825d6b:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n36:   825d6d:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n37:   825d70:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n38:   825d72:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n39:   825d73:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n40:   825d76:\t0f 84 d5 00 00 00    \tje     0x825e51\n41:   825d7c:\t8b 7d 0c             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n42:   825d7f:\t89 75 08             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],esi\n43:   825d82:\t8b 73 08             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n44:   825d85:\t03 75 08             \tadd    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n45:   825d88:\t8b 4e 6c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x6c]\n46:   825d8b:\t3b 4f 6c             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x6c]\n47:   825d8e:\t0f 85 91 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n48:   825d94:\t8b 56 40             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x40]\n49:   825d97:\t3b 57 40             \tcmp    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x40]\n50:   825d9a:\t0f 85 85 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n51:   825da0:\td9 46 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x44]\n52:   825da3:\td9 47 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x44]\n53:   825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n54:   825da8:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n55:   825daa:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n56:   825dad:\t7a 76                \tjp     0x825e25\n57:   825daf:\td9 46 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x48]\n58:   825db2:\td9 47 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x48]\n59:   825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n60:   825db7:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n61:   825db9:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n62:   825dbc:\t7a 67                \tjp     0x825e25\n63:   825dbe:\td9 46 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4c]\n64:   825dc1:\td9 47 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4c]\n65:   825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n66:   825dc6:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n67:   825dc8:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n68:   825dcb:\t7a 58                \tjp     0x825e25\n69:   825dcd:\t83 7f 38 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x38],0x10\n70:   825dd1:\t8b 57 34             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x34]\n71:   825dd4:\t8d 47 24             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x24]\n72:   825dd7:\t8d 4e 24             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x24]\n73:   825dda:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825dde\n74:   825ddc:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n75:   825dde:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n76:   825ddf:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n77:   825de0:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n78:   825de3:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n79:   825de4:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n80:   825de6:\te8 b5 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n81:   825deb:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n82:   825ded:\t75 36                \tjne    0x825e25\n83:   825def:\t83 7f 64 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x64],0x10\n84:   825df3:\t8b 57 60             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x60]\n85:   825df6:\t8d 47 50             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x50]\n86:   825df9:\t8d 4e 50             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x50]\n87:   825dfc:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825e00\n88:   825dfe:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n89:   825e00:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n90:   825e01:\t8b 51 10             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n91:   825e04:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n92:   825e05:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n93:   825e06:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n94:   825e08:\te8 93 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n95:   825e0d:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n96:   825e0f:\t75 14                \tjne    0x825e25\n97:   825e11:\t8d 47 08             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x8]\n98:   825e14:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n99:   825e15:\t8d 4e 08             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n100:   825e18:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n101:   825e19:\te8 a2 9a c4 ff       \tcall   0x46f8c0\n102:   825e1e:\t83 c4 08             \tadd    esp,0x8\n103:   825e21:\t84 c0                \ttest   al,al\n104:   825e23:\t74 37                \tje     0x825e5c\n105:   825e25:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n106:   825e28:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n107:   825e2b:\t8b 75 fc             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4]\n108:   825e2e:\t83 45 08 74          \tadd    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],0x74\n109:   825e32:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n110:   825e37:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n111:   825e39:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n112:   825e3b:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n113:   825e3e:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n114:   825e40:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n115:   825e43:\t46                   \tinc    esi\n116:   825e44:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n117:   825e46:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n118:   825e49:\t3b f0                \tcmp    esi,eax\n119:   825e4b:\t0f 82 31 ff ff ff    \tjb     0x825d82\n120:   825e51:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n121:   825e52:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n122:   825e53:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n123:   825e55:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n124:   825e56:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n125:   825e58:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n126:   825e59:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n127:   825e5c:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n128:   825e5d:\t8b c6                \tmov    eax,esi\n129:   825e5f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n130:   825e60:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n131:   825e61:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n132:   825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n133:   825e64:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n134: \n135: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe\n136: \n137: dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n138: \n139: \n140: Disassembly of section .text:\n141: \n142: 0046f8c0 <.text+0x6e8c0>:\n143:   46f8c0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n144:   46f8c1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n145:   46f8c3:\t8b 45 0c             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n146:   46f8c6:\t83 78 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [eax+0x14],0x10\n147:   46f8ca:\t8b 48 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [eax+0x10]\n148:   46f8cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x46f8d1\n149:   46f8cf:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n150:   46f8d1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n151:   46f8d2:\t8b 4d 08             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n152:   46f8d5:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n153:   46f8d6:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n154:   46f8d9:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n155:   46f8da:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n156:   46f8dc:\te8 bf 3d fb ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n157:   46f8e1:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n158:   46f8e3:\t1b c0                \tsbb    eax,eax\n159:   46f8e5:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n160:   46f8e7:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n161:   46f8e8:\tc3                   \tret\n162:   46f8e9:\tcc                   \tint3\n163:   46f8ea:\tcc                   \tint3\n164:   46f8eb:\tcc                   \tint3\n165:   46f8ec:\tcc                   \tint3\n166:   46f8ed:\tcc                   \tint3\n167:   46f8ee:\tcc                   \tint3\n168:   46f8ef:\tcc                   \tint3\n169: \n170: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe\n171: \n172: dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n173: \n174: \n175: Disassembly of section .text:\n176: \n177: 004236a0 <.text+0x226a0>:\n178:   4236a0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n179:   4236a1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n180:   4236a3:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n181:   4236a6:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n182:   4236a7:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n183:   4236a8:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n184:   4236a9:\t8b 7d 08             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n185:   4236ac:\t3b c7                \tcmp    eax,edi\n186:   4236ae:\t73 0b                \tjae    0x4236bb\n187:   4236b0:\t68 60 1f 9e 00       \tpush   0x9e1f60\n188:   4236b5:\tff 15 54 d1 9d 00    \tcall   DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd154\n189:   4236bb:\t8b 75 0c             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n190:   4236be:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n191:   4236c0:\t3b c6                \tcmp    eax,esi\n192:   4236c2:\t73 02                \tjae    0x4236c6\n193:   4236c4:\t8b f0                \tmov    esi,eax\n194:   4236c6:\t8b 5d 14             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x14]\n195:   4236c9:\t8b d6                \tmov    edx,esi\n196:   4236cb:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n197:   4236cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x4236d1\n198:   4236cf:\t8b d3                \tmov    edx,ebx\n199:   4236d1:\t83 79 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0x10\n200:   4236d5:\t72 04                \tjb     0x4236db\n201:   4236d7:\t8b 01                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n202:   4236d9:\teb 02                \tjmp    0x4236dd\n203:   4236db:\t8b c1                \tmov    eax,ecx\n204:   4236dd:\t8b 4d 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n205:   4236e0:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n206:   4236e1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n207:   4236e2:\t03 c7                \tadd    eax,edi\n208:   4236e4:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n209:   4236e5:\te8 36 f0 ff ff       \tcall   0x422720\n210:   4236ea:\t83 c4 0c             \tadd    esp,0xc\n211:   4236ed:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n212:   4236ef:\t75 15                \tjne    0x423706\n213:   4236f1:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n214:   4236f3:\t73 0a                \tjae    0x4236ff\n215:   4236f5:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n216:   4236f6:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n217:   4236f7:\t83 c8 ff             \tor     eax,0xffffffff\n218:   4236fa:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n219:   4236fb:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n220:   4236fc:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n221:   4236ff:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n222:   423701:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n223:   423703:\t0f 95 c0             \tsetne  al\n224:   423706:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n225:   423707:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n226:   423708:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n227:   423709:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n228:   42370a:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n229: \n230: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe\n231: \n232: dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n233: \n234: \n235: Disassembly of section .text:\n236: \n237: 00422720 <.text+0x21720>:\n238:   422720:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n239:   422721:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n240:   422723:\t8b 4d 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n241:   422726:\t8b 55 08             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n242:   422729:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n243:   42272a:\t8b 75 10             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n244:   42272d:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n245:   42272e:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n246:   422731:\t72 14                \tjb     0x422747\n247:   422733:\t8b 02                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n248:   422735:\t3b 01                \tcmp    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n249:   422737:\t75 12                \tjne    0x42274b\n250:   422739:\t83 ee 04             \tsub    esi,0x4\n251:   42273c:\t83 c1 04             \tadd    ecx,0x4\n252:   42273f:\t83 c2 04             \tadd    edx,0x4\n253:   422742:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n254:   422745:\t73 ec                \tjae    0x422733\n255:   422747:\t85 f6                \ttest   esi,esi\n256:   422749:\t74 45                \tje     0x422790\n257:   42274b:\t0f b6 02             \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx]\n258:   42274e:\t0f b6 39             \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx]\n259:   422751:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n260:   422753:\t75 31                \tjne    0x422786\n261:   422755:\t83 fe 01             \tcmp    esi,0x1\n262:   422758:\t76 36                \tjbe    0x422790\n263:   42275a:\t0f b6 42 01          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x1]\n264:   42275e:\t0f b6 79 01          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x1]\n265:   422762:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n266:   422764:\t75 20                \tjne    0x422786\n267:   422766:\t83 fe 02             \tcmp    esi,0x2\n268:   422769:\t76 25                \tjbe    0x422790\n269:   42276b:\t0f b6 42 02          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x2]\n270:   42276f:\t0f b6 79 02          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x2]\n271:   422773:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n272:   422775:\t75 0f                \tjne    0x422786\n273:   422777:\t83 fe 03             \tcmp    esi,0x3\n274:   42277a:\t76 14                \tjbe    0x422790\n275:   42277c:\t0f b6 42 03          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x3]\n276:   422780:\t0f b6 49 03          \tmovzx  ecx,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x3]\n277:   422784:\t2b c1                \tsub    eax,ecx\n278:   422786:\tc1 f8 1f             \tsar    eax,0x1f\n279:   422789:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n280:   42278a:\t83 c8 01             \tor     eax,0x1\n281:   42278d:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n282:   42278e:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n283:   42278f:\tc3                   \tret\n284:   422790:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n285:   422791:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n286:   422793:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n287:   422794:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n288:   422795:\tc3                   \tret\n\n(End of file - total 288 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n# SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n# Tool: GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38, Intel syntax.\n# Every command below exited 0. Output is unfiltered.\n#\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00825d40 <.text+0x424d40>:\n  825d40:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  825d41:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  825d43:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825d44:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  825d45:\t8b 5d 08             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d48:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  825d49:\t33 f6                \txor    esi,esi","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt","text":"# Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n# SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n# Tool: GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38, Intel syntax.\n# Every command below exited 0. Output is unfiltered.\n#\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00825d40 <.text+0x424d40>:\n  825d40:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  825d41:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  825d43:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825d44:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  825d45:\t8b 5d 08             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d48:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  825d49:\t33 f6                \txor    esi,esi\n  825d4b:\t3b de                \tcmp    ebx,esi\n  825d4d:\t75 0a                \tjne    0x825d59\n  825d4f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825d50:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  825d52:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825d53:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825d55:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825d56:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n  825d59:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n  825d5c:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825d5f:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n  825d64:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n  825d66:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n  825d68:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n  825d6b:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n  825d6d:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n  825d70:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n  825d72:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  825d73:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n  825d76:\t0f 84 d5 00 00 00    \tje     0x825e51\n  825d7c:\t8b 7d 0c             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  825d7f:\t89 75 08             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],esi\n  825d82:\t8b 73 08             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825d85:\t03 75 08             \tadd    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d88:\t8b 4e 6c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x6c]\n  825d8b:\t3b 4f 6c             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x6c]\n  825d8e:\t0f 85 91 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n  825d94:\t8b 56 40             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x40]\n  825d97:\t3b 57 40             \tcmp    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x40]\n  825d9a:\t0f 85 85 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n  825da0:\td9 46 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x44]\n  825da3:\td9 47 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x44]\n  825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n  825da8:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825daa:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dad:\t7a 76                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825daf:\td9 46 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x48]\n  825db2:\td9 47 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x48]\n  825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n  825db7:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825db9:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dbc:\t7a 67                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825dbe:\td9 46 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4c]\n  825dc1:\td9 47 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4c]\n  825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n  825dc6:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825dc8:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dcb:\t7a 58                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825dcd:\t83 7f 38 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x38],0x10\n  825dd1:\t8b 57 34             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x34]\n  825dd4:\t8d 47 24             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x24]\n  825dd7:\t8d 4e 24             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x24]\n  825dda:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825dde\n  825ddc:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  825dde:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825ddf:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825de0:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  825de3:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825de4:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  825de6:\te8 b5 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  825deb:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  825ded:\t75 36                \tjne    0x825e25\n  825def:\t83 7f 64 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x64],0x10\n  825df3:\t8b 57 60             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x60]\n  825df6:\t8d 47 50             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x50]\n  825df9:\t8d 4e 50             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x50]\n  825dfc:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825e00\n  825dfe:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  825e00:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825e01:\t8b 51 10             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  825e04:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825e05:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825e06:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  825e08:\te8 93 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  825e0d:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  825e0f:\t75 14                \tjne    0x825e25\n  825e11:\t8d 47 08             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x8]\n  825e14:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825e15:\t8d 4e 08             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n  825e18:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825e19:\te8 a2 9a c4 ff       \tcall   0x46f8c0\n  825e1e:\t83 c4 08             \tadd    esp,0x8\n  825e21:\t84 c0                \ttest   al,al\n  825e23:\t74 37                \tje     0x825e5c\n  825e25:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n  825e28:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825e2b:\t8b 75 fc             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4]\n  825e2e:\t83 45 08 74          \tadd    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],0x74\n  825e32:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n  825e37:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n  825e39:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n  825e3b:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n  825e3e:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n  825e40:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n  825e43:\t46                   \tinc    esi\n  825e44:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n  825e46:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n  825e49:\t3b f0                \tcmp    esi,eax\n  825e4b:\t0f 82 31 ff ff ff    \tjb     0x825d82\n  825e51:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  825e52:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825e53:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  825e55:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825e56:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825e58:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825e59:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n  825e5c:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  825e5d:\t8b c6                \tmov    eax,esi\n  825e5f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825e60:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825e61:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825e64:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n0046f8c0 <.text+0x6e8c0>:\n  46f8c0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  46f8c1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  46f8c3:\t8b 45 0c             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  46f8c6:\t83 78 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [eax+0x14],0x10\n  46f8ca:\t8b 48 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [eax+0x10]\n  46f8cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x46f8d1\n  46f8cf:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  46f8d1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  46f8d2:\t8b 4d 08             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  46f8d5:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  46f8d6:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  46f8d9:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  46f8da:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  46f8dc:\te8 bf 3d fb ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  46f8e1:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n  46f8e3:\t1b c0                \tsbb    eax,eax\n  46f8e5:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n  46f8e7:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  46f8e8:\tc3                   \tret\n  46f8e9:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ea:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8eb:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ec:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ed:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ee:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ef:\tcc                   \tint3\n\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n004236a0 <.text+0x226a0>:\n  4236a0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  4236a1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  4236a3:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  4236a6:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  4236a7:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  4236a8:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  4236a9:\t8b 7d 08             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  4236ac:\t3b c7                \tcmp    eax,edi\n  4236ae:\t73 0b                \tjae    0x4236bb\n  4236b0:\t68 60 1f 9e 00       \tpush   0x9e1f60\n  4236b5:\tff 15 54 d1 9d 00    \tcall   DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd154\n  4236bb:\t8b 75 0c             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  4236be:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  4236c0:\t3b c6                \tcmp    eax,esi\n  4236c2:\t73 02                \tjae    0x4236c6\n  4236c4:\t8b f0                \tmov    esi,eax\n  4236c6:\t8b 5d 14             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x14]\n  4236c9:\t8b d6                \tmov    edx,esi\n  4236cb:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  4236cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x4236d1\n  4236cf:\t8b d3                \tmov    edx,ebx\n  4236d1:\t83 79 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0x10\n  4236d5:\t72 04                \tjb     0x4236db\n  4236d7:\t8b 01                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n  4236d9:\teb 02                \tjmp    0x4236dd\n  4236db:\t8b c1                \tmov    eax,ecx\n  4236dd:\t8b 4d 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  4236e0:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  4236e1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  4236e2:\t03 c7                \tadd    eax,edi\n  4236e4:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  4236e5:\te8 36 f0 ff ff       \tcall   0x422720\n  4236ea:\t83 c4 0c             \tadd    esp,0xc\n  4236ed:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  4236ef:\t75 15                \tjne    0x423706\n  4236f1:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  4236f3:\t73 0a                \tjae    0x4236ff\n  4236f5:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  4236f6:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  4236f7:\t83 c8 ff             \tor     eax,0xffffffff\n  4236fa:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  4236fb:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  4236fc:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n  4236ff:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  423701:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  423703:\t0f 95 c0             \tsetne  al\n  423706:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  423707:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  423708:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  423709:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  42370a:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00422720 <.text+0x21720>:\n  422720:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  422721:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  422723:\t8b 4d 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  422726:\t8b 55 08             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  422729:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  42272a:\t8b 75 10             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  42272d:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  42272e:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n  422731:\t72 14                \tjb     0x422747\n  422733:\t8b 02                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n  422735:\t3b 01                \tcmp    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n  422737:\t75 12                \tjne    0x42274b\n  422739:\t83 ee 04             \tsub    esi,0x4\n  42273c:\t83 c1 04             \tadd    ecx,0x4\n  42273f:\t83 c2 04             \tadd    edx,0x4\n  422742:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n  422745:\t73 ec                \tjae    0x422733\n  422747:\t85 f6                \ttest   esi,esi\n  422749:\t74 45                \tje     0x422790\n  42274b:\t0f b6 02             \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx]\n  42274e:\t0f b6 39             \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx]\n  422751:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422753:\t75 31                \tjne    0x422786\n  422755:\t83 fe 01             \tcmp    esi,0x1\n  422758:\t76 36                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42275a:\t0f b6 42 01          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x1]\n  42275e:\t0f b6 79 01          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x1]\n  422762:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422764:\t75 20                \tjne    0x422786\n  422766:\t83 fe 02             \tcmp    esi,0x2\n  422769:\t76 25                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42276b:\t0f b6 42 02          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x2]\n  42276f:\t0f b6 79 02          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x2]\n  422773:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422775:\t75 0f                \tjne    0x422786\n  422777:\t83 fe 03             \tcmp    esi,0x3\n  42277a:\t76 14                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42277c:\t0f b6 42 03          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x3]\n  422780:\t0f b6 49 03          \tmovzx  ecx,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x3]\n  422784:\t2b c1                \tsub    eax,ecx\n  422786:\tc1 f8 1f             \tsar    eax,0x1f\n  422789:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  42278a:\t83 c8 01             \tor     eax,0x1\n  42278d:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  42278e:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  42278f:\tc3                   \tret\n  422790:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  422791:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  422793:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  422794:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  422795:\tc3                   \tret","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":288,"totalLines":288,"truncated":false}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt","time":{"start":1788999241116,"end":1788999241145}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b602079b1966e1a016aa1f648f42887d1a55be5b2c1d1b0ba"}},"id":"prt_088aa0d98001TcSrrOMhi0lMzr","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999241156,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_5YMOyxT13IEMAvj3HWMQKNN2","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Fresh static observations\n2: \n3: Static evidence only. It does not establish live allocator safety, a compatible replacement\n4: allocator, or replacement acceptance. Raw local evidence and exact regeneration commands are in\n5: `objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt`; the owner-supplied input is `dumps/sots.exe`, SHA-256\n6: `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n7: `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n8: \n9: ## Recorded instruction facts\n10: \n11: * `ObservedTech::ObservedTech` at `0x008562a0` is an ECX receiver, returns that receiver in EAX,\n12:   and uses plain `ret`. It installs vtable `0x00a2439c`; initializes the string rooted at `+0x0c`\n13:   to `_Myres=15`, `_Mysize=0`, empty first byte; zeros `+4` (therefore both 16-bit turns), `+8`, and\n14:   `+0x28`; and calls `0x00425550` for the empty-string setup.\n15: * `vector<ObservedTech>::push_back` at `0x007b7320` is ECX receiver plus one stack word (`ret 4`).\n16:   It grows only when `_Mylast == _Myend`, through `0x007b5820(this, 1)`, then invokes the\n17:   `0x0079a150` element-copy helper and advances `_Mylast` by exactly `0x2c`. The source-inside-vector\n18:   and source-outside-vector branches both lead to this copy helper; the former recomputes the source\n19:   from its pre-growth index. Thus append copies the temporary rather than adopting its string header.\n20: * The `0x0079a150` helper constructs a destination `ObservedTech`: vptr, words `+4/+6`, byte `+8`,\n21:   string copy via `0x00425430`, and word `+0x28`. It is a copy construction operation, not a raw\n22:    44-byte memcpy. Independent Astra cross-check pins a **cdecl-style three-stack-argument** ABI:\n23:    unused allocator argument, destination at `[ebp+0xc]`, source at `[ebp+0x10]`; plain `ret` and\n24:    caller cleanup of 12 bytes. Incoming ECX is not a receiver (its initial push only allocates a\n25:    local slot that is overwritten). Exact C++ template name is unnecessary for this machine boundary.\n26: * `0x007b5820` computes required capacity as old size plus its one stack-word count and uses the\n27:   1.5x growth rule when sufficient. It calls `0x007b34e0`; that reallocator calls `0x0057e590` with\n28:   new element count. `0x0057e590` multiplies by `0x2c` and calls `0x00924fb6` (scalar `operator new`\n29:   import thunk). Reallocation copy-constructs old elements through `0x0085e650`, calls each old\n30:   element's virtual destructor slot 0 with pushed zero, then frees the old array through\n31:   `0x00924faa` (scalar `operator delete` import thunk), and updates all three vector pointers.\n32: * `PlayerEvent` vector append at `0x0086c580` is ECX receiver plus one stack word (`ret 4`), grows\n33:   through `0x00869500` if full, copy-constructs the element through `0x007693f0`, then advances\n34:   `_Mylast` by `0x74`. The copy helper copies scalar fields and independently assigns all three\n35:   strings at `+8`, `+0x24`, `+0x50` through `0x00425430`; it is not a 116-byte header copy.\n36: * `PlayerEvent` destructor body at `0x0061ae90` tests each string capacity (`+0x1c`, `+0x38`,\n37:   `+0x64`) against `0x10`; for long strings it frees the buffer at `+8`, `+0x24`, `+0x50` through\n38:   `0x00924faa`, then restores empty/SSO values. This establishes three independent owned-string\n39:   cleanup paths in a copied event.\n40: * `0x004249a0`, called from the string assignment `0x00425430`, allocates new character storage via\n41:   `0x00924fb6` and frees an existing long destination buffer through `0x00924faa` before installing\n42:   the replacement pointer/size/capacity. The branch condition for long ownership is capacity\n43:   `>= 0x10`; short strings stay inline. Per the independently captured PE imports, these thunks map\n44:   to MSVCR100 scalar `operator delete` and scalar `operator new` respectively.\n45: \n46: ### Nested TurnEvents machine boundary\n47: \n48: * `0x00885380` is an ECX-receiver operation over the outer vector at receiver `+4`, takes one\n49:   stack `int turn`, returns a `TurnEvents*` in EAX, and uses `ret 4`. It divides the outer byte span\n50:   by `0x18`, scans every element, and overwrites its candidate on every `EvTurn` match. Therefore a\n51:   hit returns the **last** matching bucket and performs no construction, allocation, ID update, or\n52:   RNG draw.\n53: * On a miss it initializes a stack `TurnEvents` with vptr `0x00a0f07c` and zero nested-vector\n54:   pointers, then calls outer `vector<TurnEvents>::push_back` at `0x00884cb0`. Only after append does\n55:   it write the requested turn to the stored element at `_Mylast[-1]+4`. It destroys the temporary's\n56:   nested vector through `0x00629580` and returns the new element. The temporary itself starts with\n57:   turn zero; append deep-copies that zero before the stored turn is patched.\n58: * `0x00884cb0` is ECX receiver plus one source pointer and `ret 4`; stride is `0x18`. It handles a\n59:   source pointer inside its own vector separately so growth cannot invalidate the source. Both\n60:   branches install the TurnEvents vptr, copy `EvTurn`, and copy-construct the nested PlayerEvent\n61:   vector through `0x00779850`; this is not a 24-byte header copy. It advances outer `_Mylast` only\n62:   after the nested copy call returns.\n63: * Outer full-capacity growth is `0x008841a0` -> `0x00883a60`. Capacity selection is old capacity\n64:   plus half where sufficient, otherwise required size. `0x006e8f50` allocates `count * 0x18` through\n65:   `0x00924fb6`. `0x0077fed0` copy-constructs every old TurnEvents, including an independent nested\n66:   vector via `0x00779850`; then `0x00883a60` invokes each old TurnEvents virtual destructor with\n67:   deleting flag zero, frees the old outer allocation through `0x00924faa`, and writes all three\n68:   outer vector pointers.\n69: * The vtable bytes at `0x00a0f07c` identify slot zero as `0x0062e120`. That scalar-deleting\n70:   destructor calls `0x00629580` on the nested vector at `+8`; with flag bit zero it does not free the\n71:   inline TurnEvents object. `0x00629580` invokes every nested PlayerEvent virtual destructor in\n72:   `0x74` steps, frees the nested allocation through `0x00924faa`, and zeros all three nested vector\n73:   pointers.\n74: * `0x00779850` is ECX destination nested vector plus one source-vector pointer and `ret 4`. An empty\n75:   source leaves three zero pointers. A nonempty source allocates `count * 0x74` through\n76:   `0x0078af40` -> `0x00924fb6`, then `0x007725a0` copy-constructs each PlayerEvent through\n77:   `0x007693f0`. Its unwind destroys already completed PlayerEvents; `0x00779850` then calls\n78:   `0x00629580`, and outer range-copy unwind at `0x0077fed0` destroys already completed TurnEvents.\n79:   Outer reallocation's landing path frees the newly allocated outer block before continuing the\n80:   exception through `0x00924fbc`. These are observed cleanup edges, not a claim that allocation\n81:   failure has been executed live.\n82: \n83: ### Duplicate and prune branches\n84: \n85: * `0x00825d40` receives bucket and candidate pointers as two stack words, ignores incoming ECX,\n86:   and uses `ret 8`. A null bucket or empty nested vector returns zero. It scans in `0x74` steps and\n87:   checks, in order: `EvAct`, `EvLoc`, all three `EvPos` floats, `EvMsg`, `EvImg`, then calls\n88:   `0x0046f8c0` with the strings rooted at `EvDsc +8`. Complete fresh capture establishes that\n89:   `0x0046f8c0` is a two-stack-argument, caller-cleaned string-inequality operation: first argument is\n90:   the stored string, second is the candidate string, EAX/AL is one iff the strings differ, and it\n91:   uses plain `ret`. `0x00825e21` therefore reaches the matched-element return only when AL is zero,\n92:   i.e. when descriptions are equal. A description-only difference continues the scan. This\n93:   contradicts the inherited claim that `EvDsc` was excluded; decision\n94:   `d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` required this evidence repair after resolving surprise\n95:   `s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f`. The first element equal in every listed field returns its pointer;\n96:   exhaustion returns zero. The wrapper performs no writes, allocation, destruction, ID change,\n97:   event append, or RNG draw.\n98: * `0x0046f8c0` selects the candidate's inline bytes when capacity is `<0x10`, otherwise its heap\n99:   pointer, and passes candidate length/data plus stored length and offset zero to `0x004236a0`.\n100:   `0x004236a0` independently selects the stored string's inline/heap bytes, compares the minimum\n101:   byte count through `0x00422720`, then orders unequal lengths. Equal bytes and equal lengths return\n102:   zero; any byte or length difference returns nonzero, which `0x0046f8c0` normalizes to one. Thus\n103:   empty/short/long combinations are covered statically without allocation or copying. The\n104:   imported failure helper at IAT slot `0x009dd154` is called only when offset exceeds stored length;\n105:   it is unreachable for this offset-zero call, and no failure path was executed live. Its exact\n106:   imported symbol remains unresolved in this package.\n107: * `0x00879eb0` is ECX receiver plus one stack `turn` and `ret 4`. It computes cutoff `turn-50` and\n108:   inspects only the leading run with `EvTurn < cutoff`. Its selected pointer is the **last** stale\n109:   member. No stale member, exactly one leading stale member, or an initially empty vector returns\n110:   without writes. For two or more leading stale buckets, it copies from the last stale bucket\n111:   through the old end into the old beginning: each destination gets source `EvTurn`, then its nested\n112:   vector is deep-assigned by `0x0077a6b0`. It destroys the trailing shifted-from TurnEvents through\n113:   virtual slot zero and sets outer `_Mylast` to the end of the retained prefix. Thus it removes\n114:   `stale_count-1`, deliberately retaining one stale bucket; a stale bucket after the first fresh\n115:   bucket is never inspected. No outer allocation is visible in this wrapper, but nested assignment\n116:   may allocate/free/copy/destroy PlayerEvents according to destination capacity.\n117: \n118: ## Ordering and boundary\n119: \n120: `RecordObservedTech` first tests for an existing matching name; name absence, not vector fullness,\n121: reaches the constructor/append sequence. The wrapper later destroys its temporary long string, so\n122: the stored element must already own an independent string allocation where applicable. Existing\n123: records retain first turn/name and update last turn/with mask; this wrapper itself does not expose a\n124: live allocation failure outcome. `EventStorage::PostEvent` constructs a temporary PlayerEvent,\n125: prunes/selects/deduplicates, and only its no-duplicate branch appends; IDs and event vector pointers\n126: remain part of the caller-level behavior documented in `findings/subsystems/events.md`.\n127: \n128: ## Remaining blockers / minimum probes\n129: \n130: 1. `0x0084ee30` remains covered only by the initial ReVa capture in this package; its full local\n131:    instruction window should still be added by the independent verifier when checking default-field\n132:    values. The nested construction/growth, duplicate, and prune helpers now have local raw captures.\n133: 2. Exact C++ template declarations and the runtime outcome of allocation failure remain unresolved.\n134:    Static unwind edges are captured, but no live throw was induced and no allocator-safety claim is\n135:    made.\n136: 3. A read-only synthetic long-string/full-capacity fixture (or a safe existing archived trace with\n137:    pre/post memory) is required to falsify the static ownership interpretation. It cannot prove\n138:    allocator compatibility by coherent parsing alone.\n139: 4. `EvDsc` equality participation is now statically pinned, but has not been exercised in a live\n140:    same-bucket description-only fixture. Independent review must reproduce the complete helper and\n141:    branch windows before this becomes accepted ABI evidence.\n142: \n143: Independent cross-check captures: `verify/results/research-callback/observed-copy-helper-objdump.txt`\n144: and `event-copy-helper-objdump.txt`. The PlayerEvent copy operation is different: ECX is the\n145: destination, one stack argument is source, EAX returns destination and `ret 4` cleans the argument.\n146: Do not reuse the ObservedTech copy-helper calling convention for PlayerEvent.\n147: \n148: Nested raw capture: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt`.\n149: Complete dedup/helper/callee capture:\n150: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`.\n151: Verifier falsifiers should include: otherwise-identical records with equal versus description-only\n152: different `EvDsc`, separately using empty/short and long descriptions (static prediction: only equal\n153: descriptions deduplicate); one versus two\n154: leading stale buckets; a stale bucket after a fresh one; existing duplicate turn buckets (last-match\n155: selection); and outer spare/full capacity with nested empty/nonempty PlayerEvent vectors.\n\n(End of file - total 155 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Fresh static observations\n\nStatic evidence only. It does not establish live allocator safety, a compatible replacement\nallocator, or replacement acceptance. Raw local evidence and exact regeneration commands are in\n`objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt`; the owner-supplied input is `dumps/sots.exe`, SHA-256\n`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n\n## Recorded instruction facts\n\n* `ObservedTech::ObservedTech` at `0x008562a0` is an ECX receiver, returns that receiver in EAX,\n  and uses plain `ret`. It installs vtable `0x00a2439c`; initializes the string rooted at `+0x0c`\n  to `_Myres=15`, `_Mysize=0`, empty first byte; zeros `+4` (therefore both 16-bit turns), `+8`, and\n  `+0x28`; and calls `0x00425550` for the empty-string setup.\n* `vector<ObservedTech>::push_back` at `0x007b7320` is ECX receiver plus one stack word (`ret 4`).\n  It grows only when `_Mylast == _Myend`, through `0x007b5820(this, 1)`, then invokes the\n  `0x0079a150` element-copy helper and advances `_Mylast` by exactly `0x2c`. The source-inside-vector\n  and source-outside-vector branches both lead to this copy helper; the former recomputes the source\n  from its pre-growth index. Thus append copies the temporary rather than adopting its string header.\n* The `0x0079a150` helper constructs a destination `ObservedTech`: vptr, words `+4/+6`, byte `+8`,","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md","text":"# Fresh static observations\n\nStatic evidence only. It does not establish live allocator safety, a compatible replacement\nallocator, or replacement acceptance. Raw local evidence and exact regeneration commands are in\n`objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt`; the owner-supplied input is `dumps/sots.exe`, SHA-256\n`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n\n## Recorded instruction facts\n\n* `ObservedTech::ObservedTech` at `0x008562a0` is an ECX receiver, returns that receiver in EAX,\n  and uses plain `ret`. It installs vtable `0x00a2439c`; initializes the string rooted at `+0x0c`\n  to `_Myres=15`, `_Mysize=0`, empty first byte; zeros `+4` (therefore both 16-bit turns), `+8`, and\n  `+0x28`; and calls `0x00425550` for the empty-string setup.\n* `vector<ObservedTech>::push_back` at `0x007b7320` is ECX receiver plus one stack word (`ret 4`).\n  It grows only when `_Mylast == _Myend`, through `0x007b5820(this, 1)`, then invokes the\n  `0x0079a150` element-copy helper and advances `_Mylast` by exactly `0x2c`. The source-inside-vector\n  and source-outside-vector branches both lead to this copy helper; the former recomputes the source\n  from its pre-growth index. Thus append copies the temporary rather than adopting its string header.\n* The `0x0079a150` helper constructs a destination `ObservedTech`: vptr, words `+4/+6`, byte `+8`,\n  string copy via `0x00425430`, and word `+0x28`. It is a copy construction operation, not a raw\n   44-byte memcpy. Independent Astra cross-check pins a **cdecl-style three-stack-argument** ABI:\n   unused allocator argument, destination at `[ebp+0xc]`, source at `[ebp+0x10]`; plain `ret` and\n   caller cleanup of 12 bytes. Incoming ECX is not a receiver (its initial push only allocates a\n   local slot that is overwritten). Exact C++ template name is unnecessary for this machine boundary.\n* `0x007b5820` computes required capacity as old size plus its one stack-word count and uses the\n  1.5x growth rule when sufficient. It calls `0x007b34e0`; that reallocator calls `0x0057e590` with\n  new element count. `0x0057e590` multiplies by `0x2c` and calls `0x00924fb6` (scalar `operator new`\n  import thunk). Reallocation copy-constructs old elements through `0x0085e650`, calls each old\n  element's virtual destructor slot 0 with pushed zero, then frees the old array through\n  `0x00924faa` (scalar `operator delete` import thunk), and updates all three vector pointers.\n* `PlayerEvent` vector append at `0x0086c580` is ECX receiver plus one stack word (`ret 4`), grows\n  through `0x00869500` if full, copy-constructs the element through `0x007693f0`, then advances\n  `_Mylast` by `0x74`. The copy helper copies scalar fields and independently assigns all three\n  strings at `+8`, `+0x24`, `+0x50` through `0x00425430`; it is not a 116-byte header copy.\n* `PlayerEvent` destructor body at `0x0061ae90` tests each string capacity (`+0x1c`, `+0x38`,\n  `+0x64`) against `0x10`; for long strings it frees the buffer at `+8`, `+0x24`, `+0x50` through\n  `0x00924faa`, then restores empty/SSO values. This establishes three independent owned-string\n  cleanup paths in a copied event.\n* `0x004249a0`, called from the string assignment `0x00425430`, allocates new character storage via\n  `0x00924fb6` and frees an existing long destination buffer through `0x00924faa` before installing\n  the replacement pointer/size/capacity. The branch condition for long ownership is capacity\n  `>= 0x10`; short strings stay inline. Per the independently captured PE imports, these thunks map\n  to MSVCR100 scalar `operator delete` and scalar `operator new` respectively.\n\n### Nested TurnEvents machine boundary\n\n* `0x00885380` is an ECX-receiver operation over the outer vector at receiver `+4`, takes one\n  stack `int turn`, returns a `TurnEvents*` in EAX, and uses `ret 4`. It divides the outer byte span\n  by `0x18`, scans every element, and overwrites its candidate on every `EvTurn` match. Therefore a\n  hit returns the **last** matching bucket and performs no construction, allocation, ID update, or\n  RNG draw.\n* On a miss it initializes a stack `TurnEvents` with vptr `0x00a0f07c` and zero nested-vector\n  pointers, then calls outer `vector<TurnEvents>::push_back` at `0x00884cb0`. Only after append does\n  it write the requested turn to the stored element at `_Mylast[-1]+4`. It destroys the temporary's\n  nested vector through `0x00629580` and returns the new element. The temporary itself starts with\n  turn zero; append deep-copies that zero before the stored turn is patched.\n* `0x00884cb0` is ECX receiver plus one source pointer and `ret 4`; stride is `0x18`. It handles a\n  source pointer inside its own vector separately so growth cannot invalidate the source. Both\n  branches install the TurnEvents vptr, copy `EvTurn`, and copy-construct the nested PlayerEvent\n  vector through `0x00779850`; this is not a 24-byte header copy. It advances outer `_Mylast` only\n  after the nested copy call returns.\n* Outer full-capacity growth is `0x008841a0` -> `0x00883a60`. Capacity selection is old capacity\n  plus half where sufficient, otherwise required size. `0x006e8f50` allocates `count * 0x18` through\n  `0x00924fb6`. `0x0077fed0` copy-constructs every old TurnEvents, including an independent nested\n  vector via `0x00779850`; then `0x00883a60` invokes each old TurnEvents virtual destructor with\n  deleting flag zero, frees the old outer allocation through `0x00924faa`, and writes all three\n  outer vector pointers.\n* The vtable bytes at `0x00a0f07c` identify slot zero as `0x0062e120`. That scalar-deleting\n  destructor calls `0x00629580` on the nested vector at `+8`; with flag bit zero it does not free the\n  inline TurnEvents object. `0x00629580` invokes every nested PlayerEvent virtual destructor in\n  `0x74` steps, frees the nested allocation through `0x00924faa`, and zeros all three nested vector\n  pointers.\n* `0x00779850` is ECX destination nested vector plus one source-vector pointer and `ret 4`. An empty\n  source leaves three zero pointers. A nonempty source allocates `count * 0x74` through\n  `0x0078af40` -> `0x00924fb6`, then `0x007725a0` copy-constructs each PlayerEvent through\n  `0x007693f0`. Its unwind destroys already completed PlayerEvents; `0x00779850` then calls\n  `0x00629580`, and outer range-copy unwind at `0x0077fed0` destroys already completed TurnEvents.\n  Outer reallocation's landing path frees the newly allocated outer block before continuing the\n  exception through `0x00924fbc`. These are observed cleanup edges, not a claim that allocation\n  failure has been executed live.\n\n### Duplicate and prune branches\n\n* `0x00825d40` receives bucket and candidate pointers as two stack words, ignores incoming ECX,\n  and uses `ret 8`. A null bucket or empty nested vector returns zero. It scans in `0x74` steps and\n  checks, in order: `EvAct`, `EvLoc`, all three `EvPos` floats, `EvMsg`, `EvImg`, then calls\n  `0x0046f8c0` with the strings rooted at `EvDsc +8`. Complete fresh capture establishes that\n  `0x0046f8c0` is a two-stack-argument, caller-cleaned string-inequality operation: first argument is\n  the stored string, second is the candidate string, EAX/AL is one iff the strings differ, and it\n  uses plain `ret`. `0x00825e21` therefore reaches the matched-element return only when AL is zero,\n  i.e. when descriptions are equal. A description-only difference continues the scan. This\n  contradicts the inherited claim that `EvDsc` was excluded; decision\n  `d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` required this evidence repair after resolving surprise\n  `s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f`. The first element equal in every listed field returns its pointer;\n  exhaustion returns zero. The wrapper performs no writes, allocation, destruction, ID change,\n  event append, or RNG draw.\n* `0x0046f8c0` selects the candidate's inline bytes when capacity is `<0x10`, otherwise its heap\n  pointer, and passes candidate length/data plus stored length and offset zero to `0x004236a0`.\n  `0x004236a0` independently selects the stored string's inline/heap bytes, compares the minimum\n  byte count through `0x00422720`, then orders unequal lengths. Equal bytes and equal lengths return\n  zero; any byte or length difference returns nonzero, which `0x0046f8c0` normalizes to one. Thus\n  empty/short/long combinations are covered statically without allocation or copying. The\n  imported failure helper at IAT slot `0x009dd154` is called only when offset exceeds stored length;\n  it is unreachable for this offset-zero call, and no failure path was executed live. Its exact\n  imported symbol remains unresolved in this package.\n* `0x00879eb0` is ECX receiver plus one stack `turn` and `ret 4`. It computes cutoff `turn-50` and\n  inspects only the leading run with `EvTurn < cutoff`. Its selected pointer is the **last** stale\n  member. No stale member, exactly one leading stale member, or an initially empty vector returns\n  without writes. For two or more leading stale buckets, it copies from the last stale bucket\n  through the old end into the old beginning: each destination gets source `EvTurn`, then its nested\n  vector is deep-assigned by `0x0077a6b0`. It destroys the trailing shifted-from TurnEvents through\n  virtual slot zero and sets outer `_Mylast` to the end of the retained prefix. Thus it removes\n  `stale_count-1`, deliberately retaining one stale bucket; a stale bucket after the first fresh\n  bucket is never inspected. No outer allocation is visible in this wrapper, but nested assignment\n  may allocate/free/copy/destroy PlayerEvents according to destination capacity.\n\n## Ordering and boundary\n\n`RecordObservedTech` first tests for an existing matching name; name absence, not vector fullness,\nreaches the constructor/append sequence. The wrapper later destroys its temporary long string, so\nthe stored element must already own an independent string allocation where applicable. Existing\nrecords retain first turn/name and update last turn/with mask; this wrapper itself does not expose a\nlive allocation failure outcome. `EventStorage::PostEvent` constructs a temporary PlayerEvent,\nprunes/selects/deduplicates, and only its no-duplicate branch appends; IDs and event vector pointers\nremain part of the caller-level behavior documented in `findings/subsystems/events.md`.\n\n## Remaining blockers / minimum probes\n\n1. `0x0084ee30` remains covered only by the initial ReVa capture in this package; its full local\n   instruction window should still be added by the independent verifier when checking default-field\n   values. The nested construction/growth, duplicate, and prune helpers now have local raw captures.\n2. Exact C++ template declarations and the runtime outcome of allocation failure remain unresolved.\n   Static unwind edges are captured, but no live throw was induced and no allocator-safety claim is\n   made.\n3. A read-only synthetic long-string/full-capacity fixture (or a safe existing archived trace with\n   pre/post memory) is required to falsify the static ownership interpretation. It cannot prove\n   allocator compatibility by coherent parsing alone.\n4. `EvDsc` equality participation is now statically pinned, but has not been exercised in a live\n   same-bucket description-only fixture. Independent review must reproduce the complete helper and\n   branch windows before this becomes accepted ABI evidence.\n\nIndependent cross-check captures: `verify/results/research-callback/observed-copy-helper-objdump.txt`\nand `event-copy-helper-objdump.txt`. The PlayerEvent copy operation is different: ECX is the\ndestination, one stack argument is source, EAX returns destination and `ret 4` cleans the argument.\nDo not reuse the ObservedTech copy-helper calling convention for PlayerEvent.\n\nNested raw capture: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt`.\nComplete dedup/helper/callee capture:\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`.\nVerifier falsifiers should include: otherwise-identical records with equal versus description-only\ndifferent `EvDsc`, separately using empty/short and long descriptions (static prediction: only equal\ndescriptions deduplicate); one versus two\nleading stale buckets; a stale bucket after a fresh one; existing duplicate turn buckets (last-match\nselection); and outer spare/full capacity with nested empty/nonempty PlayerEvent vectors.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":155,"totalLines":155,"truncated":false}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md","time":{"start":1788999241105,"end":1788999241147}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b602079b1966e1a016aa1f648f41087d183a3351467f30bcb"}},"id":"prt_088aa0d8d001ID7voBarof9fQG","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999241156,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_7XJYeSy4V1526G5rNNu3Jker","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Read-only capture / provenance index\n2: \n3: Initial ReVa session: `run-1b88df9d169e9517a5e1b0f0`.\n4: \n5: ReVa selected program: `/Sword of the Stars.exe`; reported MD5:\n6: `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`. The initial ReVa service did not expose a local path or\n7: SHA-256. This limitation is now resolved for the static analysis input only: local\n8: `dumps/sots.exe` has the same MD5 and SHA-256\n9: `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, as independently recorded\n10: in `campaign/research/record-observation-crosscheck.md`. This binds the local objdump captures to\n11: the ReVa-selected binary fingerprint; it does not bind any live runtime, allocator, asset, or shim.\n12: \n13: | Anchor | Fresh static observation |\n14: |---|---|\n15: | `0x007ba1a0` | `read-memory` returned 256 bytes; decompilation reports 395 bytes, four callers including `OnTechResearched` at `0x008917dc`. |\n16: | `0x008862b0` | `read-memory` returned 435 bytes; decompilation reports 435 bytes and 161 incoming references. |\n17: | `0x0084ee30` | `read-memory` returned 196 bytes; decompilation reports a 196-byte `__fastcall` constructor and six incoming references. |\n18: \n19: Requests used the live schema: `programPath=/Sword of the Stars.exe`,\n20: `addressOrSymbol` for memory, and `functionNameOrAddress` for decompilation. All calls were\n21: read-only; no Ghidra, VM, or source mutation occurred.\n22: \n23: ## Local instruction capture added in this quantum\n24: \n25: `objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` contains selected raw instruction windows plus exact GNU\n26: objdump 2.38 commands. It covers the ObservedTech constructor, append/copy/reallocation/allocation\n27: and destruction path, plus PlayerEvent vector copy and three-string destruction path. The\n28: interpretation is in `recovered-static.md`; raw instructions are the authority where the old\n29: decompiler's false non-return annotation could truncate cleanup.\n30: \n31: `objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt` adds exact local commands and selected raw instructions for\n32: `0x00885380`, `0x00825d40`, `0x00879eb0`, outer TurnEvents append/growth/copy/destruction, nested\n33: PlayerEvent vector construction/copy/destruction, both allocation strides, and static unwind edges.\n34: Its selected excerpt omitted the test/branch at `0x00825e1e`--`0x00825e2d`, so Astra decision\n35: `d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` overturned that excerpt's sufficiency for branch polarity.\n36: \n37: `objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt` repairs that gap with unfiltered, exit-zero GNU objdump 2.38\n38: output for complete `0x00825d40`--`0x00825e64`, helper `0x0046f8c0` through its return, and direct\n39: comparison callees `0x004236a0` and `0x00422720` through every return. After `EvImg`, FindDuplicate\n40: passes both `EvDsc` strings to `0x0046f8c0`; that helper returns one for unequal strings and zero for\n41: equal strings. `0x00825e23` jumps to the matched-element return only on zero. Therefore description\n42: equality is required for dedup. Candidate and stored strings each independently select inline versus\n43: heap bytes at capacity `0x10`; byte equality plus length equality is required, including empty and\n44: mixed short/long cases. This is static instruction evidence, not a live same-bucket fixture.\n45: The raw capture SHA-256 is `3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06`.\n46: \n47: ## Independent-review falsifiers\n48: \n49: The independent verifier should reproduce the local commands against the recorded SHA-256 input\n50: and challenge these distinct-state claims:\n51: \n52: 1. Empty ObservedTech vector and full vector: verify that `0x007b7320` reaches growth only on\n53:    `_Mylast == _Myend`, and that its `0x0079a150` path copy-constructs rather than header-copies.\n54: 2. Long versus short strings: verify `>= 0x10` cleanup and that the temporary cleanup after\n55:    `RecordObservedTech` cannot be interpreted as ownership transfer.\n56: 3. New versus existing observed-tech name and duplicate versus no-duplicate event: verify branch\n57:    ordering before inferring any allocation or ID effect.\n58: 4. Event vector full capacity: verify the `0x74` copy/growth path independently from the `0x2c`\n59:    ObservedTech path; a matching vector header alone is not a falsifier-resistant semantic test.\n60: 5. Duplicate comparator: hold action/location/finite position/message/image fixed; compare equal\n61:    versus description-only-different EvDsc for empty/short and long strings. Raw instructions predict\n62:    dedup only for equal descriptions. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence and full\n63:    pre/post records/IDs in any later live test; static parsing alone does not prove runtime safety.\n64: 6. Prune boundaries: distinguish zero, one, and two leading stale buckets, plus stale-after-fresh;\n65:    only the two-leading-stale case should shorten the outer vector, by one bucket.\n66: 7. Turn buckets: with duplicate `EvTurn` buckets, get-or-create should return the last match; on a\n67:    miss compare spare versus full outer capacity and empty versus nonempty nested vectors.\n68: \n69: No live allocator-safety or replacement claim is offered for independent approval.\n\n(End of file - total 69 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Read-only capture / provenance index\n\nInitial ReVa session: `run-1b88df9d169e9517a5e1b0f0`.\n\nReVa selected program: `/Sword of the Stars.exe`; reported MD5:\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`. The initial ReVa service did not expose a local path or\nSHA-256. This limitation is now resolved for the static analysis input only: local\n`dumps/sots.exe` has the same MD5 and SHA-256\n`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, as independently recorded\nin `campaign/research/record-observation-crosscheck.md`. This binds the local objdump captures to\nthe ReVa-selected binary fingerprint; it does not bind any live runtime, allocator, asset, or shim.\n\n| Anchor | Fresh static observation |\n|---|---|\n| `0x007ba1a0` | `read-memory` returned 256 bytes; decompilation reports 395 bytes, four callers including `OnTechResearched` at `0x008917dc`. |\n| `0x008862b0` | `read-memory` returned 435 bytes; decompilation reports 435 bytes and 161 incoming references. |\n| `0x0084ee30` | `read-memory` returned 196 bytes; decompilation reports a 196-byte `__fastcall` constructor and six incoming references. |\n\nRequests used the live schema: `programPath=/Sword of the Stars.exe`,\n`addressOrSymbol` for memory, and `functionNameOrAddress` for decompilation. All calls were","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md","text":"# Read-only capture / provenance index\n\nInitial ReVa session: `run-1b88df9d169e9517a5e1b0f0`.\n\nReVa selected program: `/Sword of the Stars.exe`; reported MD5:\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`. The initial ReVa service did not expose a local path or\nSHA-256. This limitation is now resolved for the static analysis input only: local\n`dumps/sots.exe` has the same MD5 and SHA-256\n`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, as independently recorded\nin `campaign/research/record-observation-crosscheck.md`. This binds the local objdump captures to\nthe ReVa-selected binary fingerprint; it does not bind any live runtime, allocator, asset, or shim.\n\n| Anchor | Fresh static observation |\n|---|---|\n| `0x007ba1a0` | `read-memory` returned 256 bytes; decompilation reports 395 bytes, four callers including `OnTechResearched` at `0x008917dc`. |\n| `0x008862b0` | `read-memory` returned 435 bytes; decompilation reports 435 bytes and 161 incoming references. |\n| `0x0084ee30` | `read-memory` returned 196 bytes; decompilation reports a 196-byte `__fastcall` constructor and six incoming references. |\n\nRequests used the live schema: `programPath=/Sword of the Stars.exe`,\n`addressOrSymbol` for memory, and `functionNameOrAddress` for decompilation. All calls were\nread-only; no Ghidra, VM, or source mutation occurred.\n\n## Local instruction capture added in this quantum\n\n`objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` contains selected raw instruction windows plus exact GNU\nobjdump 2.38 commands. It covers the ObservedTech constructor, append/copy/reallocation/allocation\nand destruction path, plus PlayerEvent vector copy and three-string destruction path. The\ninterpretation is in `recovered-static.md`; raw instructions are the authority where the old\ndecompiler's false non-return annotation could truncate cleanup.\n\n`objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt` adds exact local commands and selected raw instructions for\n`0x00885380`, `0x00825d40`, `0x00879eb0`, outer TurnEvents append/growth/copy/destruction, nested\nPlayerEvent vector construction/copy/destruction, both allocation strides, and static unwind edges.\nIts selected excerpt omitted the test/branch at `0x00825e1e`--`0x00825e2d`, so Astra decision\n`d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` overturned that excerpt's sufficiency for branch polarity.\n\n`objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt` repairs that gap with unfiltered, exit-zero GNU objdump 2.38\noutput for complete `0x00825d40`--`0x00825e64`, helper `0x0046f8c0` through its return, and direct\ncomparison callees `0x004236a0` and `0x00422720` through every return. After `EvImg`, FindDuplicate\npasses both `EvDsc` strings to `0x0046f8c0`; that helper returns one for unequal strings and zero for\nequal strings. `0x00825e23` jumps to the matched-element return only on zero. Therefore description\nequality is required for dedup. Candidate and stored strings each independently select inline versus\nheap bytes at capacity `0x10`; byte equality plus length equality is required, including empty and\nmixed short/long cases. This is static instruction evidence, not a live same-bucket fixture.\nThe raw capture SHA-256 is `3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06`.\n\n## Independent-review falsifiers\n\nThe independent verifier should reproduce the local commands against the recorded SHA-256 input\nand challenge these distinct-state claims:\n\n1. Empty ObservedTech vector and full vector: verify that `0x007b7320` reaches growth only on\n   `_Mylast == _Myend`, and that its `0x0079a150` path copy-constructs rather than header-copies.\n2. Long versus short strings: verify `>= 0x10` cleanup and that the temporary cleanup after\n   `RecordObservedTech` cannot be interpreted as ownership transfer.\n3. New versus existing observed-tech name and duplicate versus no-duplicate event: verify branch\n   ordering before inferring any allocation or ID effect.\n4. Event vector full capacity: verify the `0x74` copy/growth path independently from the `0x2c`\n   ObservedTech path; a matching vector header alone is not a falsifier-resistant semantic test.\n5. Duplicate comparator: hold action/location/finite position/message/image fixed; compare equal\n   versus description-only-different EvDsc for empty/short and long strings. Raw instructions predict\n   dedup only for equal descriptions. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence and full\n   pre/post records/IDs in any later live test; static parsing alone does not prove runtime safety.\n6. Prune boundaries: distinguish zero, one, and two leading stale buckets, plus stale-after-fresh;\n   only the two-leading-stale case should shorten the outer vector, by one bucket.\n7. Turn buckets: with duplicate `EvTurn` buckets, get-or-create should return the last match; on a\n   miss compare spare versus full outer capacity and empty versus nonempty nested vectors.\n\nNo live allocator-safety or replacement claim is offered for independent approval.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":69,"totalLines":69,"truncated":false}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md","time":{"start":1788999241110,"end":1788999241150}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b602079b1966e1a016aa1f648f41c87d18a4fd84ccc01ccaa"}},"id":"prt_088aa0d93001umg5BgoksrKzR2","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999241156,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_a9XUHyBXWXFwngLIImjDFRtR","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n4:   \"explanation\": \"Astra resolution-only decision, session run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5. Observation/provenance: archived verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt SHA256 f95bbd2674aaa074feb70ebb13ec4877b3ceef3d2aafe5810b8b0ec337cfbb8b lines 211-213 contains lea candidate+8, lea stored+8 and call 0x0046f8c0. It jumps directly from 0x00825e19 to 0x00825e2e in the selected excerpt: the disputed test/branch is NOT archived there. No helper body exists in the four-file ABI results package. Surprise says true AL matches; checkpoint 26d1c4fa6bd58b6a442e0241 and handoff say false. Neither polarity is independently established by this archive. This is an evidence-completeness/conflicting-interpretation problem, not measured game behavior or a stale-build mechanism. Identity: assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common dirs independently checked; both dirty inventories observed. Source-before manifests are in runtime/runs/run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5.json; no fresh content binding substituted for old measurements. Input SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and matching ReVa MD5 are recorded provenance only, not freshly rehashed here. Campaign checkpoint rehashed the raw excerpt and index successfully. No live positive execution, runtime binary/input binding, or hooks-off neutrality measurement exists in this review. Read-only archive inspection has no game-side instrument effect; runtime neutrality remains unproved. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS, exact domains: (1) SURVIVES: the archived x86 excerpt loads two +8 addresses and calls the named helper, and shows stride 0x74 and a matched-element return; static excerpt domain only. (2) QUALIFIED: events.md:182-185 claim that EvDsc is not compared; suspended as an implementable dedup rule, not conclusively falsified without helper semantics. (3) QUALIFIED: new handoff/index prediction t... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n5:   \"id\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n6:   \"invalidated_checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-fd414ea958fd39c18cee1964.json\",\n7:   \"invalidated_evidence\": [],\n8:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n9:   \"probe\": \"Cheapest discriminating action: lead schedule the ABI analyst to rehash dumps/sots.exe against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, bind paired source manifests, checkpoint, then archive UNFILTERED objdump output for 0x00825d40..0x00825e65 and helper 0x0046f8c0 through all returns (follow any callees), with raw bytes, exact command, tool identity and exit status. Recover push/ECX conventions, test/branch polarity and short/long string semantics; mismatch or missing bytes stops interpretation. This is read-only local static work, not permission to mutate VM/Ghidra. Independent verifier reproduces the complete windows. Only after semantics and ownership are pinned should an explicitly assigned leased lab experiment compare same-bucket events equal in action/location/finite position/message/image, first identical descriptions then description-only difference, including short/long strings. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence, full pre/post records and IDs, exact binary/input/source identities and neutral controls; helper/branch analysis predicts outcomes but is not runtime measurement.\",\n10:   \"role\": \"resolver\",\n11:   \"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\",\n12:   \"surprise\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n13:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:52:51.024636+00:00\"\n14: }\n\n(End of file - total 14 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"explanation\": \"Astra resolution-only decision, session run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5. Observation/provenance: archived verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt SHA256 f95bbd2674aaa074feb70ebb13ec4877b3ceef3d2aafe5810b8b0ec337cfbb8b lines 211-213 contains lea candidate+8, lea stored+8 and call 0x0046f8c0. It jumps directly from 0x00825e19 to 0x00825e2e in the selected excerpt: the disputed test/branch is NOT archived there. No helper body exists in the four-file ABI results package. Surprise says true AL matches; checkpoint 26d1c4fa6bd58b6a442e0241 and handoff say false. Neither polarity is independently established by this archive. This is an evidence-completeness/conflicting-interpretation problem, not measured game behavior or a stale-build mechanism. Identity: assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common dirs independently checked; both dirty inventories observed. Source-before manifests are in runtime/runs/run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5.json; no fresh content binding substituted for old measurements. Input SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and matching ReVa MD5 are recorded provenance only, not freshly rehashed here. Campaign checkpoint rehashed the raw excerpt and index successfully. No live positive execution, runtime binary/input binding, or hooks-off neutrality measurement exists in this review. Read-only archive inspection has no game-side instrument effect; runtime neutrality remains unproved. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS, exact domains: (1) SURVIVES: the archived x86 excerpt loads two +8 addresses and calls the named helper, and shows stride 0x74 and a matched-element return; static excerpt domain only. (2) QUALIFIED: events.md:182-185 claim that EvDsc is not compared; suspended as an implementable dedup rule, not conclusively falsified without helper semantics. (3) QUALIFIED: new handoff/index prediction t... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n  \"id\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n  \"invalidated_checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-fd414ea958fd39c18cee1964.json\",\n  \"invalidated_evidence\": [],\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Cheapest discriminating action: lead schedule the ABI analyst to rehash dumps/sots.exe against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, bind paired source manifests, checkpoint, then archive UNFILTERED objdump output for 0x00825d40..0x00825e65 and helper 0x0046f8c0 through all returns (follow any callees), with raw bytes, exact command, tool identity and exit status. Recover push/ECX conventions, test/branch polarity and short/long string semantics; mismatch or missing bytes stops interpretation. This is read-only local static work, not permission to mutate VM/Ghidra. Independent verifier reproduces the complete windows. Only after semantics and ownership are pinned should an explicitly assigned leased lab experiment compare same-bucket events equal in action/location/finite position/message/image, first identical descriptions then description-only difference, including short/long strings. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence, full pre/post records and IDs, exact binary/input/source identities and neutral controls; helper/branch analysis predicts outcomes but is not runtime measurement.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\",\n  \"surprise\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:52:51.024636+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"explanation\": \"Astra resolution-only decision, session run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5. Observation/provenance: archived verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt SHA256 f95bbd2674aaa074feb70ebb13ec4877b3ceef3d2aafe5810b8b0ec337cfbb8b lines 211-213 contains lea candidate+8, lea stored+8 and call 0x0046f8c0. It jumps directly from 0x00825e19 to 0x00825e2e in the selected excerpt: the disputed test/branch is NOT archived there. No helper body exists in the four-file ABI results package. Surprise says true AL matches; checkpoint 26d1c4fa6bd58b6a442e0241 and handoff say false. Neither polarity is independently established by this archive. This is an evidence-completeness/conflicting-interpretation problem, not measured game behavior or a stale-build mechanism. Identity: assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common dirs independently checked; both dirty inventories observed. Source-before manifests are in runtime/runs/run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5.json; no fresh content binding substituted for old measurements. Input SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and matching ReVa MD5 are recorded provenance only, not freshly rehashed here. Campaign checkpoint rehashed the raw excerpt and index successfully. No live positive execution, runtime binary/input binding, or hooks-off neutrality measurement exists in this review. Read-only archive inspection has no game-side instrument effect; runtime neutrality remains unproved. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS, exact domains: (1) SURVIVES: the archived x86 excerpt loads two +8 addresses and calls the named helper, and shows stride 0x74 and a matched-element return; static excerpt domain only. (2) QUALIFIED: events.md:182-185 claim that EvDsc is not compared; suspended as an implementable dedup rule, not conclusively falsified without helper semantics. (3) QUALIFIED: new handoff/index prediction t... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n  \"id\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n  \"invalidated_checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-fd414ea958fd39c18cee1964.json\",\n  \"invalidated_evidence\": [],\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Cheapest discriminating action: lead schedule the ABI analyst to rehash dumps/sots.exe against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, bind paired source manifests, checkpoint, then archive UNFILTERED objdump output for 0x00825d40..0x00825e65 and helper 0x0046f8c0 through all returns (follow any callees), with raw bytes, exact command, tool identity and exit status. Recover push/ECX conventions, test/branch polarity and short/long string semantics; mismatch or missing bytes stops interpretation. This is read-only local static work, not permission to mutate VM/Ghidra. Independent verifier reproduces the complete windows. Only after semantics and ownership are pinned should an explicitly assigned leased lab experiment compare same-bucket events equal in action/location/finite position/message/image, first identical descriptions then description-only difference, including short/long strings. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence, full pre/post records and IDs, exact binary/input/source identities and neutral controls; helper/branch analysis predicts outcomes but is not runtime measurement.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\",\n  \"surprise\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:52:51.024636+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":14,"totalLines":14,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json","time":{"start":1788999241120,"end":1788999241153}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b602079b1966e1a016aa1f648f43087d18ac003d7c1c458d7"}},"id":"prt_088aa0d9d001mzTIDj5ddE6aIp","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999241168,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"glob","callID":"call_qBkQgjwJTTBG7VPHlOTmOewa","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises","pattern":"*.json"},"output":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902.json","metadata":{"count":6,"truncated":false},"title":"campaign/runtime/surprises","time":{"start":1788999241083,"end":1788999241159}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b602079b1966e1a016aa1f648f3e887d1a6c0aa72dacb189f"}},"id":"prt_088aa0d76001ly3kvE5EemtII7","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999241233,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aa0dfb0014098hDaqy5FC5M","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"212e07a5ae87c4eb7755e3d373865f2cc2ecd70b","messageID":"msg_088a9daea0018uyRppg0dtdx8E","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":15681,"input":9326,"output":265,"reasoning":74,"cache":{"write":0,"read":6016}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999243387,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aa1678001p76MvQFE0XCyfv","messageID":"msg_088aa0e3d001JCan4WZGflnesT","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"627d8d5dc489b6d7d4bf17e6297223d1921ce269","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999256767,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_0U76fKyofSFmzwAt22obVttN","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"controls-architect\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n4:   \"decision\": \"d-42c6d0b4ee5114e6f2e07c99\",\n5:   \"id\": \"s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649\",\n6:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n7:   \"probe\": \"Introduce an immutable typed acceptance package binding candidate/integrated source manifests, built binary, inputs and per-criterion results; change source bytes at unchanged HEAD and require integration/acceptance rejection.\",\n8:   \"role\": \"architecture-review\",\n9:   \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n10:   \"status\": \"resolved\",\n11:   \"summary\": \"Independent review R4: lifecycle source binding checks baseline path/commit and artifact hashes, but not the actual candidate/integrated source manifest. Implementation bytes can change at the same HEAD without invalidating the current evidence/verdict. This requires a cross-cutting evidence package/interface decision with publishing and gate owners.\",\n12:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T21:34:52.829937+00:00\"\n13: }\n\n(End of file - total 13 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"controls-architect\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-42c6d0b4ee5114e6f2e07c99\",\n  \"id\": \"s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Introduce an immutable typed acceptance package binding candidate/integrated source manifests, built binary, inputs and per-criterion results; change source bytes at unchanged HEAD and require integration/acceptance rejection.\",\n  \"role\": \"architecture-review\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent review R4: lifecycle source binding checks baseline path/commit and artifact hashes, but not the actual candidate/integrated source manifest. Implementation bytes can change at the same HEAD without invalidating the current evidence/verdict. This requires a cross-cutting evidence package/interface decision with publishing and gate owners.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T21:34:52.829937+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"controls-architect\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-42c6d0b4ee5114e6f2e07c99\",\n  \"id\": \"s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Introduce an immutable typed acceptance package binding candidate/integrated source manifests, built binary, inputs and per-criterion results; change source bytes at unchanged HEAD and require integration/acceptance rejection.\",\n  \"role\": \"architecture-review\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent review R4: lifecycle source binding checks baseline path/commit and artifact hashes, but not the actual candidate/integrated source manifest. Implementation bytes can change at the same HEAD without invalidating the current evidence/verdict. This requires a cross-cutting evidence package/interface decision with publishing and gate owners.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T21:34:52.829937+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":13,"totalLines":13,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649.json","time":{"start":1788999256751,"end":1788999256765}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c6468df5f1aff39016aa1f658823487d190e4443f23379f44"}},"id":"prt_088aa4a85001qBuul1fAnVZp41","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa0e3d001JCan4WZGflnesT"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999256799,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_ZQS8kXdbLsxNdCBlzQx5PwEz","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"controls-independent-verifier\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n4:   \"decision\": \"d-2570bf9c76ae66711bdac461\",\n5:   \"id\": \"s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d\",\n6:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-terra\",\n7:   \"probe\": \"Parse every nonblank JSONL line of campaign/runtime/runs/run-cb15199f9272fe496bd10a8a.jsonl; compare count, error events, stop events, sessions, source_before/source_after and run record fields. Determine whether the false 24-event assertion invalidates only narrative verifier artifacts or the integrated controls evidence/verdict package.\",\n8:   \"role\": \"verifier\",\n9:   \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n10:   \"status\": \"resolved\",\n11:   \"summary\": \"Contradictory prior verification claim: verdict controls-bootstrap.json and checkpoint b467c2d772260f1f03637133 report 24 parsed events for run-cb15199f9272fe496bd10a8a, but independent JSONL parsing finds 67 valid events. The run record itself reports event_count 67. The zero-error, one-session, one-stop, return-0 and unchanged-source facts agree; the count claim is false. Existing source-bound evidence does not document this raw-run count, so its acceptance impact needs Astra resolution before a new verdict.\",\n12:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:17:38.435822+00:00\"\n13: }\n\n(End of file - total 13 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"controls-independent-verifier\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-2570bf9c76ae66711bdac461\",\n  \"id\": \"s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-terra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Parse every nonblank JSONL line of campaign/runtime/runs/run-cb15199f9272fe496bd10a8a.jsonl; compare count, error events, stop events, sessions, source_before/source_after and run record fields. Determine whether the false 24-event assertion invalidates only narrative verifier artifacts or the integrated controls evidence/verdict package.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Contradictory prior verification claim: verdict controls-bootstrap.json and checkpoint b467c2d772260f1f03637133 report 24 parsed events for run-cb15199f9272fe496bd10a8a, but independent JSONL parsing finds 67 valid events. The run record itself reports event_count 67. The zero-error, one-session, one-stop, return-0 and unchanged-source facts agree; the count claim is false. Existing source-bound evidence does not document this raw-run count, so its acceptance impact needs Astra resolution before a new verdict.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:17:38.435822+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"controls-independent-verifier\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-2570bf9c76ae66711bdac461\",\n  \"id\": \"s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-terra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Parse every nonblank JSONL line of campaign/runtime/runs/run-cb15199f9272fe496bd10a8a.jsonl; compare count, error events, stop events, sessions, source_before/source_after and run record fields. Determine whether the false 24-event assertion invalidates only narrative verifier artifacts or the integrated controls evidence/verdict package.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Contradictory prior verification claim: verdict controls-bootstrap.json and checkpoint b467c2d772260f1f03637133 report 24 parsed events for run-cb15199f9272fe496bd10a8a, but independent JSONL parsing finds 67 valid events. The run record itself reports event_count 67. The zero-error, one-session, one-stop, return-0 and unchanged-source facts agree; the count claim is false. Existing source-bound evidence does not document this raw-run count, so its acceptance impact needs Astra resolution before a new verdict.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:17:38.435822+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":13,"totalLines":13,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d.json","time":{"start":1788999256792,"end":1788999256797}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c6468df5f1aff39016aa1f658824887d19ff67e8d686b196e"}},"id":"prt_088aa4ab80015DrmaBzYZxdZ2g","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa0e3d001JCan4WZGflnesT"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999256850,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_U39ofdLXM25xKgSMsWUjyhx8","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"final-controls-verifier\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n4:   \"decision\": \"d-d2aeed91781c4da6057f00a7\",\n5:   \"id\": \"s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5\",\n6:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-terra\",\n7:   \"probe\": \"From canonical RE, run source-binding once with no worktree arguments and once with the assigned paired paths; confirm the differing RE digest and absence of paired tools/campaign.py plus verify/campaign/test_controls.py. Astra must decide whether independent integrated reproduction may use only dirty canonical trees or provide source-identical linked worktrees and repeat/attest verification.\",\n8:   \"role\": \"verifier\",\n9:   \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n10:   \"status\": \"resolved\",\n11:   \"summary\": \"Falsified paired-worktree reproducibility assumption. The assigned /tmp/opencode/sots-launch-re is clean at the pinned RE HEAD but lacks tools/campaign.py and verify/campaign/test_controls.py; its source binding is 67b7b60509fe43c8d23382003fed069fb32549094eea0c039b75475e32a7a9eb, not the evidence binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Engine paired binding likewise differs (949dfb46... versus ccd8e020...). Canonical integrated trees do rehash exactly to the claimed binding and declared binary/input/outcome hashes match, but the supplied isolated paired source cannot reproduce the package from handoff alone. This blocks the final independent integrated verdict under the required linked-worktree/reproduction guard.\",\n12:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:25:50.265100+00:00\"\n13: }\n\n(End of file - total 13 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"final-controls-verifier\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-d2aeed91781c4da6057f00a7\",\n  \"id\": \"s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-terra\",\n  \"probe\": \"From canonical RE, run source-binding once with no worktree arguments and once with the assigned paired paths; confirm the differing RE digest and absence of paired tools/campaign.py plus verify/campaign/test_controls.py. Astra must decide whether independent integrated reproduction may use only dirty canonical trees or provide source-identical linked worktrees and repeat/attest verification.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Falsified paired-worktree reproducibility assumption. The assigned /tmp/opencode/sots-launch-re is clean at the pinned RE HEAD but lacks tools/campaign.py and verify/campaign/test_controls.py; its source binding is 67b7b60509fe43c8d23382003fed069fb32549094eea0c039b75475e32a7a9eb, not the evidence binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Engine paired binding likewise differs (949dfb46... versus ccd8e020...). Canonical integrated trees do rehash exactly to the claimed binding and declared binary/input/outcome hashes match, but the supplied isolated paired source cannot reproduce the package from handoff alone. This blocks the final independent integrated verdict under the required linked-worktree/reproduction guard.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:25:50.265100+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"final-controls-verifier\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-d2aeed91781c4da6057f00a7\",\n  \"id\": \"s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-terra\",\n  \"probe\": \"From canonical RE, run source-binding once with no worktree arguments and once with the assigned paired paths; confirm the differing RE digest and absence of paired tools/campaign.py plus verify/campaign/test_controls.py. Astra must decide whether independent integrated reproduction may use only dirty canonical trees or provide source-identical linked worktrees and repeat/attest verification.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Falsified paired-worktree reproducibility assumption. The assigned /tmp/opencode/sots-launch-re is clean at the pinned RE HEAD but lacks tools/campaign.py and verify/campaign/test_controls.py; its source binding is 67b7b60509fe43c8d23382003fed069fb32549094eea0c039b75475e32a7a9eb, not the evidence binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Engine paired binding likewise differs (949dfb46... versus ccd8e020...). Canonical integrated trees do rehash exactly to the claimed binding and declared binary/input/outcome hashes match, but the supplied isolated paired source cannot reproduce the package from handoff alone. This blocks the final independent integrated verdict under the required linked-worktree/reproduction guard.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:25:50.265100+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":13,"totalLines":13,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5.json","time":{"start":1788999256837,"end":1788999256848}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c6468df5f1aff39016aa1f658825087d1b79b27ca43a98570"}},"id":"prt_088aa4af2001bpF4WIIuRoCSCq","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa0e3d001JCan4WZGflnesT"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999256924,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_Fq0xzc5MNFeXUj4Wn5yIn91Q","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"rollout-lead\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n4:   \"decision\": \"d-6239404c8f40351310c8abf0\",\n5:   \"id\": \"s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc\",\n6:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n7:   \"probe\": \"Allow verifier launch in verification and integration; reject owner overlap, source drift and open surprises in both.\",\n8:   \"role\": \"lead\",\n9:   \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n10:   \"status\": \"resolved\",\n11:   \"summary\": \"Independent Astra R8: verifier launch permits verification only, but final integrated evidence requires a fresh verifier execution in integration.\",\n12:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:09:56.316247+00:00\"\n13: }\n\n(End of file - total 13 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"rollout-lead\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-6239404c8f40351310c8abf0\",\n  \"id\": \"s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Allow verifier launch in verification and integration; reject owner overlap, source drift and open surprises in both.\",\n  \"role\": \"lead\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent Astra R8: verifier launch permits verification only, but final integrated evidence requires a fresh verifier execution in integration.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:09:56.316247+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"rollout-lead\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-6239404c8f40351310c8abf0\",\n  \"id\": \"s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Allow verifier launch in verification and integration; reject owner overlap, source drift and open surprises in both.\",\n  \"role\": \"lead\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent Astra R8: verifier launch permits verification only, but final integrated evidence requires a fresh verifier execution in integration.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T22:09:56.316247+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":13,"totalLines":13,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc.json","time":{"start":1788999256891,"end":1788999256918}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c6468df5f1aff39016aa1f658825887d187b8b3fa9aaa4724"}},"id":"prt_088aa4b15001FRERZZpjv3b4dG","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa0e3d001JCan4WZGflnesT"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999256971,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_pN25gD9zHpePw0ApXxzLZ1RQ","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n4:   \"decision\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n5:   \"id\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n6:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n7:   \"probe\": \"First verify 0x0046f8c0 is std::string equality (or otherwise characterize it) from independent raw instructions/callers; then use or construct two same-bucket PlayerEvents identical in EvAct/EvLoc/EvPos/EvMsg/EvImg but differing only in EvDsc. If 0x00825d40 returns null they are distinct and EvDsc is compared; if it returns the existing element the inherited omission survives and the call has another meaning.\",\n8:   \"role\": \"analyst\",\n9:   \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n10:   \"status\": \"resolved\",\n11:   \"summary\": \"Fresh raw GNU objdump capture contradicts the standing event dedup semantic claim in findings/subsystems/events.md:185 that EvDsc is not compared. At 0x00825e11 candidate+0x08 and 0x00825e15 stored+0x08 are passed to 0x0046f8c0; its boolean result at 0x00825e21 branches to match return only when true. This occurs after EvAct, EvLoc, EvPos, EvMsg and EvImg comparisons, so description appears to participate in equality. The affected dedup interpretation is paused; no implementation or acceptance claim may use either version pending Astra resolution.\",\n12:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:47:56.138628+00:00\"\n13: }\n\n(End of file - total 13 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n  \"id\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"probe\": \"First verify 0x0046f8c0 is std::string equality (or otherwise characterize it) from independent raw instructions/callers; then use or construct two same-bucket PlayerEvents identical in EvAct/EvLoc/EvPos/EvMsg/EvImg but differing only in EvDsc. If 0x00825d40 returns null they are distinct and EvDsc is compared; if it returns the existing element the inherited omission survives and the call has another meaning.\",\n  \"role\": \"analyst\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Fresh raw GNU objdump capture contradicts the standing event dedup semantic claim in findings/subsystems/events.md:185 that EvDsc is not compared. At 0x00825e11 candidate+0x08 and 0x00825e15 stored+0x08 are passed to 0x0046f8c0; its boolean result at 0x00825e21 branches to match return only when true. This occurs after EvAct, EvLoc, EvPos, EvMsg and EvImg comparisons, so description appears to participate in equality. The affected dedup interpretation is paused; no implementation or acceptance claim may use either version pending Astra resolution.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:47:56.138628+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n  \"id\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"probe\": \"First verify 0x0046f8c0 is std::string equality (or otherwise characterize it) from independent raw instructions/callers; then use or construct two same-bucket PlayerEvents identical in EvAct/EvLoc/EvPos/EvMsg/EvImg but differing only in EvDsc. If 0x00825d40 returns null they are distinct and EvDsc is compared; if it returns the existing element the inherited omission survives and the call has another meaning.\",\n  \"role\": \"analyst\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Fresh raw GNU objdump capture contradicts the standing event dedup semantic claim in findings/subsystems/events.md:185 that EvDsc is not compared. At 0x00825e11 candidate+0x08 and 0x00825e15 stored+0x08 are passed to 0x0046f8c0; its boolean result at 0x00825e21 branches to match return only when true. This occurs after EvAct, EvLoc, EvPos, EvMsg and EvImg comparisons, so description appears to participate in equality. The affected dedup interpretation is paused; no implementation or acceptance claim may use either version pending Astra resolution.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:47:56.138628+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":13,"totalLines":13,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f.json","time":{"start":1788999256954,"end":1788999256969}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c6468df5f1aff39016aa1f658825c87d1bd2d3addc002eb30"}},"id":"prt_088aa4b59001Q9yozVsNxCOULf","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa0e3d001JCan4WZGflnesT"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999257448,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_dCCNRb40EK9yG4aIh5pmZ9iD","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"controls-architect\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n4:   \"decision\": \"d-ab717735fc6c1661919f6894\",\n5:   \"id\": \"s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902\",\n6:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n7:   \"probe\": \"Separate recovery identity/basis/artifact validation from end-run freshness; test old valid recovery state, missing/mismatched state, fresh end-run checkpoint and a resolution-only Astra launch with affected workers still blocked.\",\n8:   \"role\": \"architecture-review\",\n9:   \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n10:   \"status\": \"resolved\",\n11:   \"summary\": \"Independent review R6: current launch guard applies 15-minute end-run freshness to recovery, preventing next-day recovery from valid durable state; unconditional open-surprise rejection also prevents a resolver quantum. Assignment explicitly requested no-open-surprise launch guards, so the resolver exception requires lead clarification.\",\n12:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T21:34:59.734916+00:00\"\n13: }\n\n(End of file - total 13 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"controls-architect\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-ab717735fc6c1661919f6894\",\n  \"id\": \"s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Separate recovery identity/basis/artifact validation from end-run freshness; test old valid recovery state, missing/mismatched state, fresh end-run checkpoint and a resolution-only Astra launch with affected workers still blocked.\",\n  \"role\": \"architecture-review\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent review R6: current launch guard applies 15-minute end-run freshness to recovery, preventing next-day recovery from valid durable state; unconditional open-surprise rejection also prevents a resolver quantum. Assignment explicitly requested no-open-surprise launch guards, so the resolver exception requires lead clarification.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T21:34:59.734916+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"controls-architect\",\n  \"contract\": \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"decision\": \"d-ab717735fc6c1661919f6894\",\n  \"id\": \"s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Separate recovery identity/basis/artifact validation from end-run freshness; test old valid recovery state, missing/mismatched state, fresh end-run checkpoint and a resolution-only Astra launch with affected workers still blocked.\",\n  \"role\": \"architecture-review\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"resolved\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent review R6: current launch guard applies 15-minute end-run freshness to recovery, preventing next-day recovery from valid durable state; unconditional open-surprise rejection also prevents a resolver quantum. Assignment explicitly requested no-open-surprise launch guards, so the resolver exception requires lead clarification.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T21:34:59.734916+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":13,"totalLines":13,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902.json","time":{"start":1788999257439,"end":1788999257446}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c6468df5f1aff39016aa1f658826487d1a0c736698a7871b8"}},"id":"prt_088aa4b7d001AvOkkW6q0bWDtu","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa0e3d001JCan4WZGflnesT"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999257556,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aa4dd00017ffWoozBEhJA26","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"fe25b374a9bce0cfc24ded23b464cd88fffcdce1","messageID":"msg_088aa0e3d001JCan4WZGflnesT","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":30596,"input":14953,"output":284,"reasoning":127,"cache":{"write":0,"read":15232}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999272372,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aa87b0001XIBMkzi5X5VuW3","messageID":"msg_088aa4df70015NKxmhF4ski6w4","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"4eaeae8a45ca488d9ffbcec41c1a0cdff1d4d374","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999272483,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_uajyh0ANZq24yNF0rZH7PyLQ","state":{"status":"error","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/sots-engine/docs/architecture.md"},"error":"File not found: /home/alex/sots-re/sots-engine/docs/architecture.md","time":{"start":1788999272477,"end":1788999272482}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06c7da1c706911c6016aa1f66848c887d18c5229030eef3945"}},"id":"prt_088aa8818001UwAtbD00Mxxv7I","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa4df70015NKxmhF4ski6w4"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999272571,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_EuYfXnqebLCR19ozw3d56J6s","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"git rev-parse HEAD && git rev-parse --git-common-dir && git status --short","workdir":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine"},"output":"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\n/home/alex/sots-engine/.git\n M CONTRIBUTING.md\n M README.md\n M docs/S-standalone.md\n M src/app/turn.cpp\n M src/game/sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.cpp\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.h\n M tests/app/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/app/test_command_replay.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn_record.cpp\n M tests/game_config/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_data/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/test_census_saves.cpp\n M tests/game_sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/test_domains.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_rng.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_save.cpp\n M tests/mars_text/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_vfs/CMakeLists.txt\n M tools/clean_room_check.sh\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? docs/architecture.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/clean_room_check.py\n","metadata":{"output":"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\n/home/alex/sots-engine/.git\n M CONTRIBUTING.md\n M README.md\n M docs/S-standalone.md\n M src/app/turn.cpp\n M src/game/sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.cpp\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.h\n M tests/app/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/app/test_command_replay.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn_record.cpp\n M tests/game_config/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_data/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/test_census_saves.cpp\n M tests/game_sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/test_domains.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_rng.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_save.cpp\n M tests/mars_text/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_vfs/CMakeLists.txt\n M tools/clean_room_check.sh\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? docs/architecture.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/clean_room_check.py\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"git rev-parse HEAD && git rev-parse --git-common-dir && git status --short","time":{"start":1788999272435,"end":1788999272553}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06c7da1c706911c6016aa1f668489087d1a4fe93f5507d2939"}},"id":"prt_088aa87b30014fZI2BLBb0nY8x","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa4df70015NKxmhF4ski6w4"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999272571,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_CelQDLXrv86jSVPyfl6ylDcr","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"git rev-parse HEAD && git rev-parse --git-common-dir && git status --short","workdir":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re"},"output":"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\n/home/alex/sots-re/.git\n M README.md\n M campaign/DASHBOARD.md\n M campaign/backlog.md\n M campaign/board.md\n M campaign/open-questions.md\n M findings/00-strategy.md\n M findings/subsystems/nav-classifier-live.md\n M findings/subsystems/research-replace.md\n M guides/method-rules.md\n D scripts/forgejo_campaign.py\n M tools/DASHBOARD_README.md\n M tools/dashboard.py\n D tools/displacement.py\n M tools/gate.sh\n M tools/standalone_report.py\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? campaign/README.md\n?? campaign/agents/\n?? campaign/contract.schema.json\n?? campaign/contracts/\n?? campaign/current.json\n?? campaign/models.json\n?? campaign/pilots/\n?? campaign/research/\n?? campaign/rollout/\n?? guides/multi-agent-workflow.md\n?? guides/windows-lab-housekeeping.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/campaign.py\n?? tools/check_agent_config.py\n?? tools/evidence.py\n?? tools/gate.py\n?? tools/run_agent.py\n?? tools/select_evidence.py\n?? tools/windows-housekeeping/\n?? verify/campaign/\n?? verify/config/\n?? verify/publishing/\n?? verify/results/housekeeping/\n?? verify/tooling/\n","metadata":{"output":"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\n/home/alex/sots-re/.git\n M README.md\n M campaign/DASHBOARD.md\n M campaign/backlog.md\n M campaign/board.md\n M campaign/open-questions.md\n M findings/00-strategy.md\n M findings/subsystems/nav-classifier-live.md\n M findings/subsystems/research-replace.md\n M guides/method-rules.md\n D scripts/forgejo_campaign.py\n M tools/DASHBOARD_README.md\n M tools/dashboard.py\n D tools/displacement.py\n M tools/gate.sh\n M tools/standalone_report.py\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? campaign/README.md\n?? campaign/agents/\n?? campaign/contract.schema.json\n?? campaign/contracts/\n?? campaign/current.json\n?? campaign/models.json\n?? campaign/pilots/\n?? campaign/research/\n?? campaign/rollout/\n?? guides/multi-agent-workflow.md\n?? guides/windows-lab-housekeeping.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/campaign.py\n?? tools/check_agent_config.py\n?? tools/evidence.py\n?? tools/gate.py\n?? tools/run_agent.py\n?? tools/select_evidence.py\n?? tools/windows-housekeeping/\n?? verify/campaign/\n?? verify/config/\n?? verify/publishing/\n?? verify/results/housekeeping/\n?? verify/tooling/\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"git rev-parse HEAD && git rev-parse --git-common-dir && git status --short","time":{"start":1788999272445,"end":1788999272558}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06c7da1c706911c6016aa1f66848a887d1a8ae31deb0ef8b84"}},"id":"prt_088aa87f5001HcsjVArr2YfSGr","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa4df70015NKxmhF4ski6w4"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999272578,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_Yq65eUIDuDy6nLOLGj3Z4wsl","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"sha256sum dumps/sots.exe verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md && md5sum dumps/sots.exe && objdump --version","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re"},"output":"970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841  dumps/sots.exe\n3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06  verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\nfd0337bf2135341843738adc831ea3bd94fa6b87f5c21e652df919a5d2bec9df  verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md\n613314318a89efa3ea51e0ee3f43bc2ecd67ff01950a4da77036c1d95c566e5d  campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md\n9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c  dumps/sots.exe\nGNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38\nCopyright (C) 2022 Free Software Foundation, Inc.\nThis program is free software; you may redistribute it under the terms of\nthe GNU General Public License version 3 or (at your option) any later version.\nThis program has absolutely no warranty.\n","metadata":{"output":"970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841  dumps/sots.exe\n3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06  verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\nfd0337bf2135341843738adc831ea3bd94fa6b87f5c21e652df919a5d2bec9df  verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md\n613314318a89efa3ea51e0ee3f43bc2ecd67ff01950a4da77036c1d95c566e5d  campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md\n9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c  dumps/sots.exe\nGNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38\nCopyright (C) 2022 Free Software Foundation, Inc.\nThis program is free software; you may redistribute it under the terms of\nthe GNU General Public License version 3 or (at your option) any later version.\nThis program has absolutely no warranty.\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"sha256sum dumps/sots.exe verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md && md5sum dumps/sots.exe && objdump --version","time":{"start":1788999272465,"end":1788999272576}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06c7da1c706911c6016aa1f66848c087d1b21b644272065c7e"}},"id":"prt_088aa880d00155L96klLtNsPAd","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa4df70015NKxmhF4ski6w4"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999272607,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_dZcKAUFx1UfKbSI7gbKzObxi","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-completion-abi && python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"[\n  {\n    \"acceptance\": [\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n        \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n      },\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"validation\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n        \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"baseline\": {\n      \"engine\": {\n        \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n      },\n      \"re\": {\n        \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n      }\n    },\n    \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241.json\",\n    \"dependencies\": [\n      \"controls-bootstrap\"\n    ],\n    \"effects\": [\n      \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n    ],\n    \"evidence\": [],\n    \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n    \"inputs\": [\n      \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n      \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n      \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n      \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n    ],\n    \"open_surprises\": [],\n    \"original_dependencies\": [\n      \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n    ],\n    \"owner\": {\n      \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n      \"role\": \"analyst\"\n    },\n    \"predictions\": [\n      \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n      \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n    ],\n    \"scope\": [\n      \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n      \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n      \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n      \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n      \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n    ],\n    \"status\": \"verification\",\n    \"stop_conditions\": [\n      \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n      \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n      \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n    ],\n    \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n  }\n]\n[\n  \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"launcher-smoke\",\n  \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"research-replacement\"\n]\n","metadata":{"output":"[\n  {\n    \"acceptance\": [\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n        \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n      },\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"validation\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n        \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"baseline\": {\n      \"engine\": {\n        \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n      },\n      \"re\": {\n        \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n      }\n    },\n    \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-5bc0703a8f5dcc03cb44d241.json\",\n    \"dependencies\": [\n      \"controls-bootstrap\"\n    ],\n    \"effects\": [\n      \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n    ],\n    \"evidence\": [],\n    \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n    \"inputs\": [\n      \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n      \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n      \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n      \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n    ],\n    \"open_surprises\": [],\n    \"original_dependencies\": [\n      \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n    ],\n    \"owner\": {\n      \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n      \"role\": \"analyst\"\n    },\n    \"predictions\": [\n      \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n      \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n    ],\n    \"scope\": [\n      \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n      \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n      \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n      \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n      \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n    ],\n    \"status\": \"verification\",\n    \"stop_conditions\": [\n      \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n      \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n      \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n    ],\n    \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n  }\n]\n[\n  \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"launcher-smoke\",\n  \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"research-replacement\"\n]\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-completion-abi && python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate","time":{"start":1788999272451,"end":1788999272605}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06c7da1c706911c6016aa1f66848b087d1aebe613bd3ff6361"}},"id":"prt_088aa87ff001xu0nQZMcPL2AeN","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa4df70015NKxmhF4ski6w4"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999272676,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_x340mbqIHkgCqxCsPlgO5n3S","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re source-binding research-completion-abi --engine-worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine --re-worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"{\n  \"engine\": {\n    \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n    \"path\": \"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine\",\n    \"sha256\": \"ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd\"\n  },\n  \"re\": {\n    \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n    \"path\": \"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re\",\n    \"sha256\": \"6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8\"\n  }\n}\n","metadata":{"output":"{\n  \"engine\": {\n    \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n    \"path\": \"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine\",\n    \"sha256\": \"ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd\"\n  },\n  \"re\": {\n    \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n    \"path\": \"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re\",\n    \"sha256\": \"6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8\"\n  }\n}\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re source-binding research-completion-abi --engine-worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine --re-worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re","time":{"start":1788999272459,"end":1788999272672}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06c7da1c706911c6016aa1f66848b887d1a0d765053b57aa42"}},"id":"prt_088aa8804001CQs73uN6qUgnyM","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa4df70015NKxmhF4ski6w4"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999272718,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aa890a001LkH5yFt0HmB9Ny","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"1e458846d56c6fd562a06872bec6737c1d9cd939","messageID":"msg_088aa4df70015NKxmhF4ski6w4","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":33314,"input":2857,"output":377,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":30080}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999275171,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aa929b001gCZ046gr2cJZGE","messageID":"msg_088aa8934001dgcS8BMiH22ty9","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"0c5b9c99304dab7bb29e5876ba5648bb2586a75e","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999283772,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_UNV9pOCoghz1tZMg7bBXcDho","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine/docs/architecture.md"},"output":"<path>/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine/docs/architecture.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Engine architecture and reconstruction contract\n2: \n3: ## Boundaries\n4: \n5: ```text\n6: owner assets / save / captured commands / explicit runtime inputs\n7:                          │\n8:                 mars I/O and game catalogs\n9:                          │\n10:           game rules + typed simulation state/effects\n11:                   ┌──────┴──────┐\n12:              app frontend    shim adapters\n13:             standalone turn   original process\n14:                   └──────┬──────┘\n15:                  independent verification\n16:                      in sots-re\n17: ```\n18: \n19: - `mars/`: parsing, text, archives, serialization and RNG. No strategic decisions.\n20: - `game/`: catalogs and reusable rules/state transformations. No original-process pointers,\n21:   Windows allocation assumptions, or direct UI/lab behavior.\n22: - `app/`: adapters from saved/explicit runtime inputs, command application, ordered phase\n23:   orchestration and write-back. Reports distinguish evaluated/committed/blocked effects.\n24: - `shim/`: 32-bit live-process marshalling, ABI adapters and trace/compare/replace instrumentation.\n25:   Original helper dependencies must be declared. Guards bound observed writes, not universal\n26:   heap coverage. Comparing a copied original output is not an independent calculation.\n27: - `include/generated/`: generated facts/specification channels with RE provenance.\n28: - `tests/`: synthetic contract/boundary tests and external-data checks. A missing fixture is\n29:   skipped explicitly; a configured but invalid fixture is a failure.\n30: \n31: ## Phase contract\n32: \n33: Every new or materially changed phase specifies:\n34: \n35: 1. Required inputs and their origin: serialized state, assets, captured commands, runtime-only\n36:    state, or original helpers. Missing required inputs block commit; they are not implicit zero.\n37: 2. Ordered behavior, predicates, numeric precision and RNG word consumption.\n38: 3. Complete effects, including newly allocated objects, membership, IDs, event records and all\n39:    container elements. A count/header change is not equivalent to producing the elements.\n40: 4. Supported domain and known unsupported cases, with executable preconditions where feasible.\n41: 5. Independent expected outputs and the workload/branch coverage needed to accept the claim.\n42: \n43: This is the contract for new work, not a claim that every existing partial phase already meets\n44: it. Existing approximations are tracked as dependencies in the RE campaign and retired by slice.\n45: \n46: ## State and time\n47: \n48: A save is not the entire runtime state. Replay must explicitly supply commands and any unsaved\n49: inputs needed by its scope. Generator state and ordering are part of the observable contract.\n50: Count actual generator words, including rejection draws and twists; administrative counters\n51: must not modify serialized RNG layout or values. Aggregate each leaf operation once; parent\n52: summary records must not double-count child effects.\n53: \n54: ## Verification and integration\n55: \n56: Use fresh source-bound builds. File bytes, inflated stream bytes, typed semantic state and\n57: gameplay behavior are different comparison surfaces and must be labelled separately. Roundtrip\n58: proves conservation on the sampled corpus, not correct interpretation of every possible field.\n59: Synthetic boundary tests complement real original-vs-new experiments. Accepted replacement\n60: requires positive execution evidence and no original execution performing the claimed work.\n61: \n62: Planning, model routing, checkpoints, resource leases, surprise resolution and result publication\n63: live only in `sots-re`. Architecture changes and plan-changing surprises require GPT-6 Astra.\n64: See that repository's `AGENTS.md`, `campaign/README.md`, and `guides/multi-agent-workflow.md`.\n\n(End of file - total 64 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Engine architecture and reconstruction contract\n\n## Boundaries\n\n```text\nowner assets / save / captured commands / explicit runtime inputs\n                         │\n                mars I/O and game catalogs\n                         │\n          game rules + typed simulation state/effects\n                  ┌──────┴──────┐\n             app frontend    shim adapters\n            standalone turn   original process\n                  └──────┬──────┘\n                 independent verification\n                     in sots-re\n```\n\n- `mars/`: parsing, text, archives, serialization and RNG. No strategic decisions.\n- `game/`: catalogs and reusable rules/state transformations. No original-process pointers,","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine/docs/architecture.md","text":"# Engine architecture and reconstruction contract\n\n## Boundaries\n\n```text\nowner assets / save / captured commands / explicit runtime inputs\n                         │\n                mars I/O and game catalogs\n                         │\n          game rules + typed simulation state/effects\n                  ┌──────┴──────┐\n             app frontend    shim adapters\n            standalone turn   original process\n                  └──────┬──────┘\n                 independent verification\n                     in sots-re\n```\n\n- `mars/`: parsing, text, archives, serialization and RNG. No strategic decisions.\n- `game/`: catalogs and reusable rules/state transformations. No original-process pointers,\n  Windows allocation assumptions, or direct UI/lab behavior.\n- `app/`: adapters from saved/explicit runtime inputs, command application, ordered phase\n  orchestration and write-back. Reports distinguish evaluated/committed/blocked effects.\n- `shim/`: 32-bit live-process marshalling, ABI adapters and trace/compare/replace instrumentation.\n  Original helper dependencies must be declared. Guards bound observed writes, not universal\n  heap coverage. Comparing a copied original output is not an independent calculation.\n- `include/generated/`: generated facts/specification channels with RE provenance.\n- `tests/`: synthetic contract/boundary tests and external-data checks. A missing fixture is\n  skipped explicitly; a configured but invalid fixture is a failure.\n\n## Phase contract\n\nEvery new or materially changed phase specifies:\n\n1. Required inputs and their origin: serialized state, assets, captured commands, runtime-only\n   state, or original helpers. Missing required inputs block commit; they are not implicit zero.\n2. Ordered behavior, predicates, numeric precision and RNG word consumption.\n3. Complete effects, including newly allocated objects, membership, IDs, event records and all\n   container elements. A count/header change is not equivalent to producing the elements.\n4. Supported domain and known unsupported cases, with executable preconditions where feasible.\n5. Independent expected outputs and the workload/branch coverage needed to accept the claim.\n\nThis is the contract for new work, not a claim that every existing partial phase already meets\nit. Existing approximations are tracked as dependencies in the RE campaign and retired by slice.\n\n## State and time\n\nA save is not the entire runtime state. Replay must explicitly supply commands and any unsaved\ninputs needed by its scope. Generator state and ordering are part of the observable contract.\nCount actual generator words, including rejection draws and twists; administrative counters\nmust not modify serialized RNG layout or values. Aggregate each leaf operation once; parent\nsummary records must not double-count child effects.\n\n## Verification and integration\n\nUse fresh source-bound builds. File bytes, inflated stream bytes, typed semantic state and\ngameplay behavior are different comparison surfaces and must be labelled separately. Roundtrip\nproves conservation on the sampled corpus, not correct interpretation of every possible field.\nSynthetic boundary tests complement real original-vs-new experiments. Accepted replacement\nrequires positive execution evidence and no original execution performing the claimed work.\n\nPlanning, model routing, checkpoints, resource leases, surprise resolution and result publication\nlive only in `sots-re`. Architecture changes and plan-changing surprises require GPT-6 Astra.\nSee that repository's `AGENTS.md`, `campaign/README.md`, and `guides/multi-agent-workflow.md`.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":64,"totalLines":64,"truncated":false}},"title":"../../../tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine/docs/architecture.md","time":{"start":1788999283704,"end":1788999283748}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06b0ec8f46a6a6c1016aa1f67392d487d187aa5d9ae5ed1b2e"}},"id":"prt_088aab3f20012gpg5d5ytHkh0C","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa8934001dgcS8BMiH22ty9"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999283773,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_Kc2WS1hVPdGr7UHk9Fz7Cia9","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/events.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/events.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Player event posting API (lane E, 2026-09-08)\n2: \n3: Target: recover the API the game uses to post player-visible turn events, so the\n4: reimplementation can post them and so the compare harness can *see* them.\n5: \n6: Motivation: `TechTree::ProcessResearch` (P2-B3) failed its replace-mode oracle by exactly\n7: one item across 40,300 — an unposted `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`. `ServerPlayer::\n8: OnTechResearched` (P2-B2) has the same gap. Until events are modelled, both \"0 divergence\"\n9: verdicts bound the economy fields only.\n10: \n11: **Everything below with an address was read out of the instruction stream** (bytes fetched\n12: with `read-memory` over the ReVa HTTP shim, disassembled locally with capstone) unless the\n13: line says *inferred*. Layout claims are additionally confirmed against three real saves via\n14: `verify/save-reader/save_reader.py`.\n15: \n16: ---\n17: \n18: ## 1. The container\n19: \n20: `ServerPlayer::Events` is an **`EventStorage` embedded at `ServerPlayer+0x29c`**, size `0x1c`.\n21: \n22: Verified by `ServerPlayer::GetEventStorage` at **0x0080db00**, which is the whole function:\n23: \n24: ```\n25: 0080db00  8d819c020000   lea eax, [ecx + 0x29c]\n26: 0080db06  c3             ret\n27: ```\n28: \n29: `__thiscall EventStorage* ServerPlayer::GetEventStorage(ServerPlayer* this)` — no stack args,\n30: plain `ret`. Every research-path post site either calls it (`ProcessResearch`) or inlines the\n31: `lea ecx,[esi+0x29c]` (`OnTechResearched`, 0x008919ab / 0x0089241d).\n32: \n33: ### `EventStorage` (0x1c bytes) — already in the Ghidra project, now confirmed by code\n34: \n35: | off | type | name | evidence |\n36: |---|---|---|---|\n37: | 0x00 | `void*` | vptr | not touched by the post path |\n38: | 0x04 | `TurnEvents*` | `Events._Myfirst` | 0x008853aa `mov edx,[esi+8]; sub edx,[esi+4]` |\n39: | 0x08 | `TurnEvents*` | `Events._Mylast` | same |\n40: | 0x0c | `TurnEvents*` | `Events._Myend` | vector growth in 0x00885427+ |\n41: | 0x10 | `allocator` | `Events._Alval` | MSVC `_Vector_val` tail, 4 B |\n42: | 0x14 | `int` | **`EvNxID`** | 0x008863e3–0x008863f6 |\n43: | 0x18 | — | padding | struct size 0x1c |\n44: \n45: `EvNxID` lands at **`ServerPlayer+0x2b0`** — exactly the byte run the harness guard reported\n46: as `player+0x2b0:4`. That is now explained, not merely observed.\n47: \n48: The vector element stride is **0x18**: `0x008853b3 mov eax,0x2aaaaaab; imul edx; sar edx,2`\n49: = signed divide by 24.\n50: \n51: ### `TurnEvents` (0x18 bytes) — new\n52: \n53: | off | type | name | evidence |\n54: |---|---|---|---|\n55: | 0x00 | `void*` | vptr | virtual dtor called at 0x00879f21 (`mov edx,[edi]; mov eax,[edx]; push 0; call eax`) |\n56: | 0x04 | `int` | **`EvTurn`** | 0x008853d3 `cmp [edx+4], ebx` (ebx = the turn argument) |\n57: | 0x08 | `PlayerEvent*` | `Events._Myfirst` | `lea ecx,[esi+8]` handed to `vector::push_back` at 0x008863db |\n58: | 0x0c | `PlayerEvent*` | `Events._Mylast` | 0x008863f9 `mov eax,[esi+0xc]` |\n59: | 0x10 | `PlayerEvent*` | `Events._Myend` | |\n60: | 0x14 | `allocator` | `Events._Alval` | |\n61: \n62: ### `PlayerEvent` (0x74 = 116 bytes) — new\n63: \n64: Stride confirmed two independent ways: the duplicate scanner's divisor at 0x00825d5f\n65: (`mov eax,0x8d3dcb09; imul ecx; add edx,ecx; sar edx,6` = signed divide by 116) and the\n66: post function's `mov [eax-0x70], ecx` writing `id` at `element+4` off `_Mylast`.\n67: \n68: | off | type | on-disk tag | set by |\n69: |---|---|---|---|\n70: | 0x00 | `void*` | — | ctor: vftable `0x00a21958` |\n71: | 0x04 | `int` | `EvEID` | `PostEvent`: `EvNxID++` (or the duplicate's id) |\n72: | 0x08 | `std::string` (0x1c) | `EvDsc` | `PostEvent` arg 0 (summary / title) |\n73: | 0x24 | `std::string` (0x1c) | `EvMsg` | `PostEvent` arg 1 (body) |\n74: | 0x40 | `int` | `EvLoc` | `obj ? obj->[+4] : 0` |\n75: | 0x44 | `float[3]` | `EvPos` | `obj ? obj->[+0x18..0x20] : (pos ? *pos : ctor default)` |\n76: | 0x50 | `std::string` (0x1c) | `EvImg` | `PostEvent` arg `img` (`\"\"` if NULL) |\n77: | 0x6c | `int` | `EvAct` | `PostEvent` arg `act`; forced to **2** if `act==0 && !obj && !pos` |\n78: | 0x70 | `int` | `EvCID` | ctor 0; never written by `PostEvent` |\n79: \n80: **Correction to `formula-gaps.md`:** the default `EvPos` is **`FLT_MAX` (0x7f7fffff), not\n81: infinity**. `PlayerEvent::PlayerEvent` (0x0084ee30) copies the three floats from the global\n82: `Vector3` at `0x00af0dc8`, whose bytes are `FF FF 7F 7F` × 3. Confirmed in the save:\n83: `EvPos = 2139095039 (0x7f7fffff)` for `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`. Writing `+inf`\n84: (0x7f800000) would produce a different save byte and a different oracle hash.\n85: \n86: Ctor also sets `EvEID=0`, `EvLoc=0`, `EvAct=0`, `EvCID=0` and the three strings to `\"\"`\n87: (`0x009e100c`).\n88: \n89: ### Serialization (matches the save exactly)\n90: \n91: `PlayerEvent::Serialize` = vftable slot 1 at **0x00825970**, `__thiscall`, `ret 4`. Tag\n92: pointers all come from the table at `0x00a2bd88` (stride 8): `EvEID EvNxID EvTurn Events\n93: EvPos EvLoc EvMsg EvImg EvDsc EvCID EvAct sasc`. Emission order read off the instruction\n94: stream: `EvEID, EvDsc, EvMsg, EvImg, EvLoc, EvPos, EvAct, EvCID`.\n95: \n96: `TurnEvents` write 0x00825bb0 / read 0x00825c40: `EvTurn` then the nested collection `Events`.\n97: `EventStorage` read 0x00825cc0: `EvNxID` then the nested collection `Events`.\n98: \n99: So on disk the shape is **nested, not flat**:\n100: \n101: ```\n102: Events (EventStorage)\n103:   EvNxID : int\n104:   Events : n × TurnEvents\n105:       EvTurn : int\n106:       Events : m × PlayerEvent\n107:           EvEID EvDsc EvMsg EvImg EvLoc EvPos{x,y,z} EvAct EvCID\n108: ```\n109: \n110: `findings/objects/save-editor-structs.md:271` models this as\n111: `SimPlayerEventsSaveStruct events (Int32 evNxId; ComplexArray<SimPlayerEvent>)` — a **flat**\n112: array of events. That is wrong (or at least the R1 C# editor's simplification): the\n113: `ComplexArray` elements are *turn groups*, each holding its own array. `save_reader.py`\n114: parses it correctly today because `Events` falls into the generic tree; nothing needs fixing\n115: in the reader, but the struct note should be corrected.\n116: \n117: ### Ground truth: `verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav`\n118: \n119: Player index 1 (`/Sim/Player[1]/Events`, file offset 120372):\n120: \n121: ```\n122: EvNxID = 4\n123:   EvTurn = 2\n124:     EvEID 1  EvDsc \"Ships Constructed At Ke'Dolarra\"\n125:              EvMsg \"1 ship built in system Ke'Dolarra\"\n126:              EvImg \"EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT\"  EvLoc 288  EvPos {-11.9286, 4.71900, 2.31785}\n127:              EvAct 0  EvCID 0\n128:   EvTurn = 3\n129:     EvEID 2  (the same EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT record, next turn)\n130:     EvEID 3  EvDsc \"Research Over Budget\"\n131:              EvMsg \"Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.\"\n132:              EvImg \"EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET\"  EvLoc 0\n133:              EvPos {0x7f7fffff, 0x7f7fffff, 0x7f7fffff}  EvAct 1  EvCID 0\n134: ```\n135: \n136: Player index 0 has two `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` records (turns 2 and 3, ids 1 and 2, `EvNxID` 3).\n137: Players 2 and 3 have `EvNxID = 0` and an empty list — note **`EvNxID` starts at 0**, and\n138: `PostEvent` lazily promotes 0 → 1 on the first post (0x008863e3).\n139: \n140: ---\n141: \n142: ## 2. The entry point\n143: \n144: ```c\n145: // 0x008862b0\n146: int __thiscall EventStorage::PostEvent(\n147:         EventStorage* this,          // ecx\n148:         std::string   summary,       // [ebp+0x08], BY VALUE, 0x1c bytes  -> EvDsc\n149:         std::string   message,       // [ebp+0x24], BY VALUE, 0x1c bytes  -> EvMsg\n150:         void*         obj,           // [ebp+0x40]  may be NULL\n151:         Vector3*      pos,           // [ebp+0x44]  may be NULL\n152:         int           turn,          // [ebp+0x48]\n153:         const char*   img,           // [ebp+0x4c]  may be NULL -> \"\"\n154:         int           act);          // [ebp+0x50]\n155: // returns the event id; ret 0x4c\n156: ```\n157: \n158: `ret 0x4c` = 76 = 2 × 0x1c (the two by-value `std::string`s) + 5 × 4. Both string arguments\n159: are built **in the caller's frame by `sub esp,0x1c`** and a copy-construct, which is the MSVC\n160: by-value-`std::string` idiom; `PostEvent` frees their buffers itself before returning\n161: (0x00886415–0x00886446), so the caller must not.\n162: \n163: Body, in order (all read from the instruction stream):\n164: \n165: 1. `PlayerEvent ev;` — default ctor `0x0084ee30` on a `[ebp-0x84]` temporary.\n166: 2. `ev.EvDsc = summary; ev.EvMsg = message;` (0x0088630d, 0x0088631a).\n167: 3. `ev.EvLoc = obj ? obj->[+4] : 0` (0x00886322).\n168: 4. `ev.EvImg = img ? img : \"\"` — `\"\"` is `0x009e100c`; length by inline `strlen` (0x00886330).\n169: 5. `ev.EvAct = act`; **if `act == 0 && obj == NULL && pos == NULL` then `ev.EvAct = 2`**\n170:    (0x00886353–0x0088636f). This default is easy to miss and changes the save bytes.\n171: 6. Position: `obj` wins (`obj->[+0x18/+0x1c/+0x20]`), else `pos` (`pos->[0/4/8]`), else the\n172:    ctor's `FLT_MAX` triple (0x0088637a–0x008863a7).\n173: 7. `PruneOldTurns(turn)` — 0x00879eb0.\n174: 8. `TurnEvents* bucket = GetOrCreateTurnBucket(turn)` — 0x00885380.\n175: 9. `PlayerEvent* dup = FindDuplicate(bucket, &ev)` — 0x00825d40. **If non-NULL, return\n176:    `dup->EvEID` and post nothing.**\n177: 10. else `bucket->Events.push_back(ev)`; `if (EvNxID == 0) EvNxID = 1;`\n178:     `id = EvNxID++; back().EvEID = id;` return `id`.\n179: \n180: ### `EventStorage::FindDuplicate` — 0x00825d40, `__thiscall (TurnEvents*, PlayerEvent*)`, `ret 8`\n181: \n182: Linear scan of the bucket. Two events are the same when **all** of these match:\n183: `EvAct` (+0x6c), `EvLoc` (+0x40), the three `EvPos` floats (`fucompp`, so bitwise-unequal\n184: NaNs never match but the `FLT_MAX` sentinels always do), `EvMsg` (+0x24) and `EvImg` (+0x50).\n185: **`EvDsc` is NOT compared.** A NULL bucket returns 0 immediately.\n186: \n187: This is why the two identical `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT` records in `turn3-state.sav` survive as\n188: separate events: they are in different turn buckets, and dedup is per-bucket.\n189: \n190: ### `EventStorage::GetOrCreateTurnBucket` — 0x00885380, `__thiscall (int turn)`, `ret 4`\n191: \n192: Scans `Events` for `EvTurn == turn`; **keeps scanning to the end and returns the *last*\n193: match** (0x008853d0–0x008853de has no early exit). If none, constructs a bucket\n194: (`0x00884cb0`, vtable `0x00a0f07c`), appends, and sets `_Mylast[-1].EvTurn = turn`\n195: (0x0088542d, `mov [eax-0x14], ecx`, i.e. `+4` off the new element at `_Mylast-0x18`).\n196: \n197: ### `EventStorage::PruneOldTurns` — 0x00879eb0, `__thiscall (int turn)`\n198: \n199: Cutoff is `turn - 0x32` (**50 turns**), constant, not from config: `0x00879ec3 add ebx,-0x32`.\n200: \n201: Precisely as coded — and this is a quirk worth reproducing rather than \"fixing\": it walks the\n202: **leading** run of buckets with `EvTurn < cutoff`, leaves `edi` pointing at the **last** one\n203: of that run, and then shifts from `edi` down to `_Myfirst`. So it erases `n-1` buckets, not\n204: `n`: **one stale bucket always survives**, and a single leading stale bucket is never\n205: removed at all (`0x00879ee2 cmp esi,edi; je` returns). It also stops at the first non-stale\n206: bucket, so a stale bucket after a fresh one is never reached.\n207: \n208: ### Convenience wrapper\n209: \n210: `0x00886470` (`ret` and prototype not verified by this lane) posts via `PostEvent` twice at\n211: 0x00886802 / 0x00886b22. **161 call sites in 113 functions** reference `PostEvent` directly —\n212: this is the single event API for the whole simulation, not a research-specific helper.\n213: \n214: ### Turn number\n215: \n216: Every research-path site computes the turn as `*(int*)(*(char**)(player + 8) + 8)`.\n217: `ServerPlayer+8` is the `StrategyServer` *second* base; `0x0080e320` is\n218: `__thiscall void* ServerPlayer::GetServer()` = `[this+8] ? [this+8]-4 : 0`, so the field is\n219: `StrategyServer(primary base)+0x0c`. This matches the B4 finding that `StrategyServer` has\n220: two bases four bytes apart.\n221: \n222: **CORRECTION (lane EV 2026-09-08): that field is the FRAME (the turn counter), not\n223: `ModCount`.** The two are different words and the saves separate them cleanly:\n224: `turn2-state.sav` has `Summary/Turn = 2`, `Sim/Frame = 2` and `Sim/ModCount = 12`, and every\n225: event the turn posted landed in bucket `EvTurn = 2`. If the argument were `ModCount` the\n226: buckets would be 12 and 24. The value is the **post-increment** turn — a turn run from a save\n227: at turn *N* posts into bucket *N+1* — because the frame is bumped in `BeginProcessTurn`,\n228: before either turn driver runs.\n229: \n230: ---\n231: \n232: ## 3. Which events the research path posts\n233: \n234: Order within `ServerPlayer::ProcessTurn` (0x00891340):\n235: \n236: | # | site | event | condition |\n237: |---|---|---|---|\n238: | 1 | `TechTree::ProcessResearch` 0x00587b97 | `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET` | per node, see below |\n239: | 2 | → `SetResearched` → `OnTechResearched` 0x008919b5 | `EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` / `_UNDERBUDGET` | see below |\n240: | 3 | → `OnTechResearched` 0x00892427 | `EVENT_TEMPERANCE` | temperance tech cured ≥1 addicted system |\n241: | 4 | `TechTree::ProcessResearch` 0x00587ff4 | `EVENT_TECHS_UNLOCKED` | tail loop, ≥1 newly available node |\n242: | 5 | `ProcessTurn` 0x0089168c | `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` | no target, no affordable tech, tree not exhausted |\n243: \n244: `ProcessResearch`'s two posts bracket the per-node loop: OVERBUDGET fires **inside** the loop\n245: (so once per over-budget node), TECHS_UNLOCKED **once** after it.\n246: \n247: ### 3.1 `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET` — the B3 defect, fully explained\n248: \n249: Posted at **0x00587b97**, in `TechTree::ProcessResearch` (0x005876c0).\n250: \n251: Per-node arithmetic recovered from 0x00587732–0x00587907 (naming `cost =\n252: TechTree::GetNodeCost(node)` = 0x0057da00, `pts = node->points` at `node+0x1c`):\n253: \n254: ```\n255: minPts  = max(cost * 50  / 100, 0)          ; 0x51eb851f/sar 5 = /100\n256: maxPts  = max(minPts, cost * 150 / 100)\n257: wasDone = (pts >= cost)                     ; [ebp-0xcd], setge @0x005877e1\n258: granted = min(requested, maxPts - pts)\n259: *overbudgetOut += requested - granted       ; the out-param accumulates unspent points\n260: pts    += granted\n261: nowDone = (pts >= cost)                     ; [ebp-0xce], setge @0x00587828\n262: \n263: if      (pts >= maxPts)  chance = 1.0f, draw = 0.0f          ; always completes\n264: else if (granted == 0)   chance = 0.0f, draw = 1.0f          ; never completes, no draw\n265: else                     chance = (float)(pts - minPts) / maxPts   ; NOTE: / maxPts, not /(max-min)\n266:                          draw   = rng.NextFloat()*(1.0-0.0) + 0.0  ; [0x009e1e68] == 0.0\n267:                          if (owner && owner->Species == 5)   ; Zuul\n268:                              draw = max(draw, rng.NextFloat()*(1.0-0.0)+0.0)\n269: \n270: if (chance < draw) {                         ; roll FAILED -> tech not completed this turn\n271:     if (!wasDone && nowDone && owner) {\n272:         PostEvent(EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET); node->flag(+0x2c) = 2;\n273:     }\n274: } else {                                     ; roll succeeded\n275:     log(\"Research completed at %d of %d (%.1f%%). (Odds: %.2f, Roll: %.2f)\\n\", ...)\n276:     if (pts/cost < 0.8) node->flag(+0x2c) = 0;\n277:     SetResearched(node->def, 2);             ; 0x00581e10 -> OnTechResearched\n278: }\n279: ```\n280: \n281: So **over budget means: the node has accumulated at least its full cost, but the completion\n282: roll failed, and this is the first turn that has been true.** `!wasDone` is what makes it\n283: fire exactly once per node.\n284: \n285: The record it posts:\n286: \n287: | field | value | evidence |\n288: |---|---|---|\n289: | `EvDsc` | `\"Research Over Budget\"` | key `EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, slot `0x00ae48e0`, thunk key at `0x00a00cac` |\n290: | `EvMsg` | `\"Research for %s has gone overbudget.\"` % `node->def->name` | key `EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, slot `0x00ae48e8`, key at `0x00a00ccc` |\n291: | `EvImg` | `\"EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET\"` | literal `0x00a0078c`, pushed at 0x00587b24 |\n292: | `EvLoc` | `0` | `obj = NULL` (0x00587b2c) |\n293: | `EvPos` | `{FLT_MAX, FLT_MAX, FLT_MAX}` | `pos = NULL` → ctor default |\n294: | `EvAct` | `1` | literal, 0x00587b22 |\n295: | `EvCID` | `0` | ctor |\n296: \n297: Both strings go through `0x008c97f0` (`__cdecl` format-into-`std::string`, 8 stack args:\n298: `out, fmt, a1..a6`) with the tech name as the single substitution; the summary format\n299: contains no `%s`, so it comes out literal. The tech name is `def+0x40` (a `std::string`;\n300: `_Myres` at `+0x54` selects heap vs. inline buffer, 0x00587a1d).\n301: \n302: **Save cross-check:** `turn3-state.sav`, player 1, turn-3 bucket, `EvEID 3` is exactly this\n303: record, with `EvMsg \"Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.\"` — the format string, the\n304: `%s` substitution, `EvAct 1`, `EvLoc 0` and the `FLT_MAX` position all match byte for byte.\n305: \n306: ### 3.2 `EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` / `EVENT_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET`\n307: \n308: Posted at **0x008919b5** in `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched` (0x00891790), guarded by\n309: `if (!silent)` (0x00891804 `cmp byte [ebp+0xc], 0; jne`).\n310: \n311: ```\n312: ratio = TechTree::GetProgressRatio(tree, def)      ; 0x0057e950, float\n313: if (ratio >= 0.8f)  img = \"EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE\"    (0x00a33368)\n314:                     sum = EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_COMPLETE   (slot 0x00af09e8)\n315:                     msg = EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_COMPLETE   (slot 0x00af09f0)\n316: else                img = \"EVENT_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET\" (0x00a33380)\n317:                     sum = EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET(slot 0x00af09f8)\n318:                     msg = EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET(slot 0x00af0a00)\n319: PostEvent(sum, snprintf(msg, 0x100, def->name), NULL, NULL, turn, img, 1)\n320: ```\n321: \n322: The 0.8 constant is the `double` at `0x009e20c8` = `0.800000011920929`, i.e. `(double)0.8f` —\n323: the comparison is `fcomp` of the `float` ratio against that double. Text:\n324: \n325: * `EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` = `\"Research Complete\"`,\n326:   `EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` = `\"Tech %s has been acquired\"`\n327: * `EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET` = `\"Research Breakthrough!\"`,\n328:   `EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET` = `\"Your scientists made a breakthrough with %s. Research has completed ahead of schedule!\"`\n329: \n330: `EvAct = 1`, `obj = pos = NULL`, so `EvLoc = 0` and `EvPos = FLT_MAX³`. Message buffer is a\n331: 0x100-byte stack buffer formatted with `0x008c8eb0` (`_snprintf`-shaped, 9 args), then\n332: assigned into a `std::string`, so **a message longer than 255 chars is truncated** — a real\n333: behaviour to reproduce.\n334: \n335: Note the naming is counter-intuitive: `UNDERBUDGET` is the *cheap* completion (ratio < 0.8).\n336: \n337: ### 3.3 `EVENT_TEMPERANCE`\n338: \n339: Posted at **0x00892427**, same function, after the per-species temperance sweep\n340: (0x00892280–0x008922b9: for each species with flag bit 5, cure every owned addicted system\n341: via 0x00745e40 / 0x00743800). Guarded by `!silent` **and** by a local \"something was cured\"\n342: flag (`[ebp-0x189]`, set at 0x008922a6). Strings `EVENTSUM_ADDICTION_TEMPERENCE` /\n343: `EVENTMSG_ADDICTION_TEMPERENCE` (slots `0x00af0a88` / `0x00af0a90`, note the shipped\n344: misspelling \"TEMPERENCE\").\n345: \n346: `EvImg = \"EVENT_TEMPERANCE\"` (0x00a33340), `obj = pos = NULL`, and **`EvAct = 0`** — which\n347: means rule 5 of `PostEvent` fires and the stored `EvAct` becomes **2**, not 0. Any\n348: reimplementation that stores the literal 0 will differ from the oracle here.\n349: \n350: ### 3.4 `EVENT_TECHS_UNLOCKED`\n351: \n352: Posted at **0x00587ff4**, at the tail of `ProcessResearch` (loop at 0x00587cc3). Collects\n353: every node `n` where `n != NULL`, `n->def != NULL`, `tree->nodes[n->def->index] != NULL`,\n354: that node's **`state` (`+0x14`) `== 2` (available)**, and **`n->turnAvailable` (`+0x20`)\n355: `== currentTurn`** (0x00587cfc–0x00587d42). If the collected vector is non-empty it posts\n356: once.\n357: \n358: *Correction to `strategic-turn-internals.md:233`*, which reads the condition as \"state==2 &&\n359: turnAvailable == currentTurn **&& parent researched**\". There is no parent test: the\n360: `mov ecx,[ecx]; mov eax,[eax+ecx*4]` pair at 0x00587d0d–0x00587d19 dereferences `n->def` and\n361: then indexes `tree->nodes` by `def->[0]`, which is the tech's **own** index (the same\n362: indirection the entry loop uses at 0x00587738–0x00587740). It resolves back to `n` itself;\n363: the two null checks around it are defensive. The state test is therefore on `n`, not on a\n364: parent.\n365: \n366: `EvDsc` = `EVENTSUM_UNLOCKEDTECHS` (slot `0x00ae48f0`) = `\"New Technologies Available\"`.\n367: `EvMsg` = `EVENTMSG_UNLOCKEDTECHS` (slot `0x00ae48f8`) =\n368: `\"The following technologies are now available for research:\"` followed by, per node, the\n369: separator string at `0x009e4588` and the node's `def->name` (0x00587f46–0x00587f82).\n370: `EvImg` = literal `\"EVENT_TECHS_UNLOCKED\"` (`0x00a00774`, length pushed as 0x14).\n371: `EvAct = 1`, `obj = pos = NULL`.\n372: \n373: ### 3.5 `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH`\n374: \n375: Posted at **0x0089168c** in `ServerPlayer::ProcessTurn`. Condition (0x0089162a–0x0089167e):\n376: \n377: ```\n378: if (player->ResT (+0x294) == NULL)\n379:     TechTree::CollectResearchedTechs(&out, turn, INT_MAX, sort=1)   ; 0x00584e50\n380:     if (out.empty() && TechTree::FindFirstAvailableTech() != NULL)  ; 0x0057da90\n381:         PostEvent(EVENTSUM_NO_RESEARCH, EVENTMSG_NO_RESEARCH, NULL, NULL, turn,\n382:                   \"EVENT_NO_RESEARCH\" (0x00a3332c), 1)\n383: ```\n384: \n385: Both strings are `\"No Research Project Assigned.\"` — matches `turn3-state.sav` player 0\n386: exactly (`EvAct 1`, `EvLoc 0`, `EvPos` FLT_MAX³).\n387: \n388: **CORRECTION (lane EV 2026-09-08) to this section as first written.** 0x00584e50 was named\n389: here as a `ListAvailableTechs` and the middle test read as \"no affordable tech\". It is\n390: `TechTree::CollectResearchedTechs` (lane T read the whole body; the call site's argument order\n391: was re-read here byte for byte from 0x00891600), and the test is about what was **researched**,\n392: not about what is available:\n393: \n394: 1. `ResT == NULL` — the player holds no research target;\n395: 2. **no tech has `state == 4` (researched) with `turnResearched (+0x24) >= turn`**, i.e.\n396:    nothing finished on this turn or later. The turn is passed as the collector's `minTurn`\n397:    and the range runs to `INT_MAX`;\n398: 3. at least one node is in `state == 2` (available) — that is the availability half, and it is\n399:    what excludes the four monster factions, whose entire tree is state 4.\n400: \n401: Test 2 is not decoration and the corpus exercises it: in `zuul-turn23-fleet23.sav` the human\n402: posts `EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` on turn 22 and **no** no-research event that turn, then\n403: `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` again on turn 23. `sots-engine`'s P11 implements all three tests; before\n404: this lane it implemented tests 1 and 3 only, and over-fired.\n405: \n406: Test 1 is the one a save cannot answer. `ResTNm` on the wire is the target the file was\n407: **written** with; on the reference pair all four real players start the turn with none and\n408: three of them acquire one *during* it, which is AI research selection. Across all eleven\n409: corpus saves no AI player ever posts `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` (~90 player-turns) while the human\n410: posts it on every turn it lacks a target — stated as a hypothesis, with the operator's\n411: `--ai-player` roster standing in for the missing input.\n412: \n413: Also in this window (0x008915ec–0x00891624): `RollResearchEvent` (0x0088df20) is called when\n414: `ResT != NULL && ResErrRoll(+0x3b4) != 0 && (const at 0x00a2c788) < progressRatio`, then\n415: `ResErrRoll` is cleared — the same draw the B2/B3 lanes measured. `RollResearchAccident`\n416: (0x00889dc0) posts the `EVENT_LABACCIDENT_*` family; not traced here.\n417: \n418: ---\n419: \n420: ## 4. What is *not* verified\n421: \n422: * `0x00886470` — the wrapper that also calls `PostEvent`. Its prototype and its two call\n423:   paths were not read; I only established that it exists and is not on the research path.\n424: * `TurnEvents`' vptr/vtable contents beyond slot 0 (the virtual dtor used by the pruner).\n425: * The `sasc` tag at `0x00a2bde0` — adjacent to the event tag block, owner unknown.\n426: * Whether `PostEvent`'s dedup can ever collapse two research events in practice. It cannot\n427:   for OVERBUDGET vs COMPLETE (different `EvImg`), but two *different techs* going over budget\n428:   in the same turn differ only in `EvMsg`, which **is** compared — so both are kept. Verified\n429:   by reading the comparator, not by observing it.\n430: * `EventStorage::Write` (the save-side counterpart of 0x00825cc0) was not located; only the\n431:   read/`0x8b9d50` direction and the two `TurnEvents` directions were disassembled. The field\n432:   order is identical in both directions and is confirmed by the save, so this is a gap in\n433:   coverage, not in confidence about the layout.\n434: * The 50-turn prune has never been observed running (our saves are at turn ≤ 3).\n435: \n436: ---\n437: \n438: ## 5. What a turn actually posts (lane EV 2026-09-08, measured over all 11 saves)\n439: \n440: Read out of the corpus with `verify/state-checksum/state_checksum.py`, not derived. Every\n441: `EvImg` value, bucket and id below is a file fact.\n442: \n443: **Only two players in the whole corpus ever hold an event.** `PlyrIdx 0` (the human) and\n444: `PlyrIdx 1` (the one AI empire that owns colonies). `PlyrIdx 2..3` are the dormant shadow\n445: empires — `Sav = 0`, no colonies — and although they *do* pick research targets every turn,\n446: their `EvNxID` is 0 on every save. `PlyrIdx 4..7` are the monster factions, whose whole tech\n447: tree is state 4 and whose `EvNxID` is likewise 0 throughout. So \"who posts\" is not a property\n448: of the event API; it is a property of who does anything.\n449: \n450: ### The reference pair\n451: \n452: | pair | player | bucket | id | image | EvAct | EvLoc |\n453: |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n454: | turn1 -> turn2 | 0 | `EvTurn=2` | 1 | `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` | 1 | 0 |\n455: | turn1 -> turn2 | 1 | `EvTurn=2` | 1 | `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT` | 0 | 288 |\n456: | turn2 -> turn3 | 0 | `EvTurn=3` | 2 | `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` | 1 | 0 |\n457: | turn2 -> turn3 | 1 | `EvTurn=3` | 2 | `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT` | 0 | 288 |\n458: | turn2 -> turn3 | 1 | `EvTurn=3` | 3 | `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET` | 1 | 0 |\n459: \n460: **Order within a player is readable off the ids**: on turn 3 player 1's construction event is\n461: id 2 and its research event id 3, so **the build pass posts before the research pass**. Ids\n462: are per player (`EvNxID` is on the player's own storage), so no cross-player order is\n463: observable from a save and none should be assumed.\n464: \n465: `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT` carries `EvAct = 0` **as stored**, because it has a subject (`EvLoc` 288,\n466: a real position) — the `act == 0 && !obj && !pos -> 2` rule does not fire. The only stored\n467: `EvAct = 2` in the corpus is `EVENT_LABACCIDENT_SMALL`.\n468: \n469: ### Every image the corpus contains\n470: \n471: `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH`, `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT`, `EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE`, `EVENT_TECHS_UNLOCKED`,\n472: `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, `EVENT_FLEET_ARRIVED`, `EVENT_FLEET_EXPLORED`,\n473: `EVENT_FLEET_MULTIPOINT_NONODE`, `EVENT_LABACCIDENT_SMALL`, `EVENT_COLONY_NEWSETTLERS`,\n474: `EVENT_ENEMY_INCOMING_Human`. The last is worth noting: the **event type is the `EvImg`\n475: string and it is composed at run time** — `_Human` is a species suffix, so the type space is\n476: not a fixed enumeration and never was.\n477: \n478: ### Text keys used, from `Locale/EN/Strings.csv`\n479: \n480: `EVENTSUM_SHIPS_BUILT` = `Ships Constructed At %s`; `EVENTMSG_SHIPS_BUILT_1SHIP` =\n481: `1 ship built in system %s`; `EVENTMSG_SHIPS_BUILT_NSHIPS` = `%s ships built in system %s`.\n482: So the construction event picks between **two** message keys on the ship count, and the count\n483: is substituted as a `%s`. Both `EVENTSUM_NO_RESEARCH` and `EVENTMSG_NO_RESEARCH` are the same\n484: string and take no parameter.\n485: \n486: ### Wired into `sots-engine`\n487: \n488: `src/app/event_phase.{h,cpp}` bridges the save's event subtree to `game::events` and P11 posts\n489: through it. On the reference pair, with the data root and the AI roster supplied and\n490: `--commit-blocked=P11`: **4 leaves closed on turn1->turn2 and 3 on turn2->turn3, 0 regressed**,\n491: and the posted record agrees with the oracle on every one of its eight fields. Engine-side\n492: write-up: `sots-engine docs/EV-events.md`.\n\n(End of file - total 492 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Player event posting API (lane E, 2026-09-08)\n\nTarget: recover the API the game uses to post player-visible turn events, so the\nreimplementation can post them and so the compare harness can *see* them.\n\nMotivation: `TechTree::ProcessResearch` (P2-B3) failed its replace-mode oracle by exactly\none item across 40,300 — an unposted `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`. `ServerPlayer::\nOnTechResearched` (P2-B2) has the same gap. Until events are modelled, both \"0 divergence\"\nverdicts bound the economy fields only.\n\n**Everything below with an address was read out of the instruction stream** (bytes fetched\nwith `read-memory` over the ReVa HTTP shim, disassembled locally with capstone) unless the\nline says *inferred*. Layout claims are additionally confirmed against three real saves via\n`verify/save-reader/save_reader.py`.\n\n---\n\n## 1. The container\n\n`ServerPlayer::Events` is an **`EventStorage` embedded at `ServerPlayer+0x29c`**, size `0x1c`.","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/events.md","text":"# Player event posting API (lane E, 2026-09-08)\n\nTarget: recover the API the game uses to post player-visible turn events, so the\nreimplementation can post them and so the compare harness can *see* them.\n\nMotivation: `TechTree::ProcessResearch` (P2-B3) failed its replace-mode oracle by exactly\none item across 40,300 — an unposted `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`. `ServerPlayer::\nOnTechResearched` (P2-B2) has the same gap. Until events are modelled, both \"0 divergence\"\nverdicts bound the economy fields only.\n\n**Everything below with an address was read out of the instruction stream** (bytes fetched\nwith `read-memory` over the ReVa HTTP shim, disassembled locally with capstone) unless the\nline says *inferred*. Layout claims are additionally confirmed against three real saves via\n`verify/save-reader/save_reader.py`.\n\n---\n\n## 1. The container\n\n`ServerPlayer::Events` is an **`EventStorage` embedded at `ServerPlayer+0x29c`**, size `0x1c`.\n\nVerified by `ServerPlayer::GetEventStorage` at **0x0080db00**, which is the whole function:\n\n```\n0080db00  8d819c020000   lea eax, [ecx + 0x29c]\n0080db06  c3             ret\n```\n\n`__thiscall EventStorage* ServerPlayer::GetEventStorage(ServerPlayer* this)` — no stack args,\nplain `ret`. Every research-path post site either calls it (`ProcessResearch`) or inlines the\n`lea ecx,[esi+0x29c]` (`OnTechResearched`, 0x008919ab / 0x0089241d).\n\n### `EventStorage` (0x1c bytes) — already in the Ghidra project, now confirmed by code\n\n| off | type | name | evidence |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 0x00 | `void*` | vptr | not touched by the post path |\n| 0x04 | `TurnEvents*` | `Events._Myfirst` | 0x008853aa `mov edx,[esi+8]; sub edx,[esi+4]` |\n| 0x08 | `TurnEvents*` | `Events._Mylast` | same |\n| 0x0c | `TurnEvents*` | `Events._Myend` | vector growth in 0x00885427+ |\n| 0x10 | `allocator` | `Events._Alval` | MSVC `_Vector_val` tail, 4 B |\n| 0x14 | `int` | **`EvNxID`** | 0x008863e3–0x008863f6 |\n| 0x18 | — | padding | struct size 0x1c |\n\n`EvNxID` lands at **`ServerPlayer+0x2b0`** — exactly the byte run the harness guard reported\nas `player+0x2b0:4`. That is now explained, not merely observed.\n\nThe vector element stride is **0x18**: `0x008853b3 mov eax,0x2aaaaaab; imul edx; sar edx,2`\n= signed divide by 24.\n\n### `TurnEvents` (0x18 bytes) — new\n\n| off | type | name | evidence |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 0x00 | `void*` | vptr | virtual dtor called at 0x00879f21 (`mov edx,[edi]; mov eax,[edx]; push 0; call eax`) |\n| 0x04 | `int` | **`EvTurn`** | 0x008853d3 `cmp [edx+4], ebx` (ebx = the turn argument) |\n| 0x08 | `PlayerEvent*` | `Events._Myfirst` | `lea ecx,[esi+8]` handed to `vector::push_back` at 0x008863db |\n| 0x0c | `PlayerEvent*` | `Events._Mylast` | 0x008863f9 `mov eax,[esi+0xc]` |\n| 0x10 | `PlayerEvent*` | `Events._Myend` | |\n| 0x14 | `allocator` | `Events._Alval` | |\n\n### `PlayerEvent` (0x74 = 116 bytes) — new\n\nStride confirmed two independent ways: the duplicate scanner's divisor at 0x00825d5f\n(`mov eax,0x8d3dcb09; imul ecx; add edx,ecx; sar edx,6` = signed divide by 116) and the\npost function's `mov [eax-0x70], ecx` writing `id` at `element+4` off `_Mylast`.\n\n| off | type | on-disk tag | set by |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 0x00 | `void*` | — | ctor: vftable `0x00a21958` |\n| 0x04 | `int` | `EvEID` | `PostEvent`: `EvNxID++` (or the duplicate's id) |\n| 0x08 | `std::string` (0x1c) | `EvDsc` | `PostEvent` arg 0 (summary / title) |\n| 0x24 | `std::string` (0x1c) | `EvMsg` | `PostEvent` arg 1 (body) |\n| 0x40 | `int` | `EvLoc` | `obj ? obj->[+4] : 0` |\n| 0x44 | `float[3]` | `EvPos` | `obj ? obj->[+0x18..0x20] : (pos ? *pos : ctor default)` |\n| 0x50 | `std::string` (0x1c) | `EvImg` | `PostEvent` arg `img` (`\"\"` if NULL) |\n| 0x6c | `int` | `EvAct` | `PostEvent` arg `act`; forced to **2** if `act==0 && !obj && !pos` |\n| 0x70 | `int` | `EvCID` | ctor 0; never written by `PostEvent` |\n\n**Correction to `formula-gaps.md`:** the default `EvPos` is **`FLT_MAX` (0x7f7fffff), not\ninfinity**. `PlayerEvent::PlayerEvent` (0x0084ee30) copies the three floats from the global\n`Vector3` at `0x00af0dc8`, whose bytes are `FF FF 7F 7F` × 3. Confirmed in the save:\n`EvPos = 2139095039 (0x7f7fffff)` for `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`. Writing `+inf`\n(0x7f800000) would produce a different save byte and a different oracle hash.\n\nCtor also sets `EvEID=0`, `EvLoc=0`, `EvAct=0`, `EvCID=0` and the three strings to `\"\"`\n(`0x009e100c`).\n\n### Serialization (matches the save exactly)\n\n`PlayerEvent::Serialize` = vftable slot 1 at **0x00825970**, `__thiscall`, `ret 4`. Tag\npointers all come from the table at `0x00a2bd88` (stride 8): `EvEID EvNxID EvTurn Events\nEvPos EvLoc EvMsg EvImg EvDsc EvCID EvAct sasc`. Emission order read off the instruction\nstream: `EvEID, EvDsc, EvMsg, EvImg, EvLoc, EvPos, EvAct, EvCID`.\n\n`TurnEvents` write 0x00825bb0 / read 0x00825c40: `EvTurn` then the nested collection `Events`.\n`EventStorage` read 0x00825cc0: `EvNxID` then the nested collection `Events`.\n\nSo on disk the shape is **nested, not flat**:\n\n```\nEvents (EventStorage)\n  EvNxID : int\n  Events : n × TurnEvents\n      EvTurn : int\n      Events : m × PlayerEvent\n          EvEID EvDsc EvMsg EvImg EvLoc EvPos{x,y,z} EvAct EvCID\n```\n\n`findings/objects/save-editor-structs.md:271` models this as\n`SimPlayerEventsSaveStruct events (Int32 evNxId; ComplexArray<SimPlayerEvent>)` — a **flat**\narray of events. That is wrong (or at least the R1 C# editor's simplification): the\n`ComplexArray` elements are *turn groups*, each holding its own array. `save_reader.py`\nparses it correctly today because `Events` falls into the generic tree; nothing needs fixing\nin the reader, but the struct note should be corrected.\n\n### Ground truth: `verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav`\n\nPlayer index 1 (`/Sim/Player[1]/Events`, file offset 120372):\n\n```\nEvNxID = 4\n  EvTurn = 2\n    EvEID 1  EvDsc \"Ships Constructed At Ke'Dolarra\"\n             EvMsg \"1 ship built in system Ke'Dolarra\"\n             EvImg \"EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT\"  EvLoc 288  EvPos {-11.9286, 4.71900, 2.31785}\n             EvAct 0  EvCID 0\n  EvTurn = 3\n    EvEID 2  (the same EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT record, next turn)\n    EvEID 3  EvDsc \"Research Over Budget\"\n             EvMsg \"Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.\"\n             EvImg \"EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET\"  EvLoc 0\n             EvPos {0x7f7fffff, 0x7f7fffff, 0x7f7fffff}  EvAct 1  EvCID 0\n```\n\nPlayer index 0 has two `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` records (turns 2 and 3, ids 1 and 2, `EvNxID` 3).\nPlayers 2 and 3 have `EvNxID = 0` and an empty list — note **`EvNxID` starts at 0**, and\n`PostEvent` lazily promotes 0 → 1 on the first post (0x008863e3).\n\n---\n\n## 2. The entry point\n\n```c\n// 0x008862b0\nint __thiscall EventStorage::PostEvent(\n        EventStorage* this,          // ecx\n        std::string   summary,       // [ebp+0x08], BY VALUE, 0x1c bytes  -> EvDsc\n        std::string   message,       // [ebp+0x24], BY VALUE, 0x1c bytes  -> EvMsg\n        void*         obj,           // [ebp+0x40]  may be NULL\n        Vector3*      pos,           // [ebp+0x44]  may be NULL\n        int           turn,          // [ebp+0x48]\n        const char*   img,           // [ebp+0x4c]  may be NULL -> \"\"\n        int           act);          // [ebp+0x50]\n// returns the event id; ret 0x4c\n```\n\n`ret 0x4c` = 76 = 2 × 0x1c (the two by-value `std::string`s) + 5 × 4. Both string arguments\nare built **in the caller's frame by `sub esp,0x1c`** and a copy-construct, which is the MSVC\nby-value-`std::string` idiom; `PostEvent` frees their buffers itself before returning\n(0x00886415–0x00886446), so the caller must not.\n\nBody, in order (all read from the instruction stream):\n\n1. `PlayerEvent ev;` — default ctor `0x0084ee30` on a `[ebp-0x84]` temporary.\n2. `ev.EvDsc = summary; ev.EvMsg = message;` (0x0088630d, 0x0088631a).\n3. `ev.EvLoc = obj ? obj->[+4] : 0` (0x00886322).\n4. `ev.EvImg = img ? img : \"\"` — `\"\"` is `0x009e100c`; length by inline `strlen` (0x00886330).\n5. `ev.EvAct = act`; **if `act == 0 && obj == NULL && pos == NULL` then `ev.EvAct = 2`**\n   (0x00886353–0x0088636f). This default is easy to miss and changes the save bytes.\n6. Position: `obj` wins (`obj->[+0x18/+0x1c/+0x20]`), else `pos` (`pos->[0/4/8]`), else the\n   ctor's `FLT_MAX` triple (0x0088637a–0x008863a7).\n7. `PruneOldTurns(turn)` — 0x00879eb0.\n8. `TurnEvents* bucket = GetOrCreateTurnBucket(turn)` — 0x00885380.\n9. `PlayerEvent* dup = FindDuplicate(bucket, &ev)` — 0x00825d40. **If non-NULL, return\n   `dup->EvEID` and post nothing.**\n10. else `bucket->Events.push_back(ev)`; `if (EvNxID == 0) EvNxID = 1;`\n    `id = EvNxID++; back().EvEID = id;` return `id`.\n\n### `EventStorage::FindDuplicate` — 0x00825d40, `__thiscall (TurnEvents*, PlayerEvent*)`, `ret 8`\n\nLinear scan of the bucket. Two events are the same when **all** of these match:\n`EvAct` (+0x6c), `EvLoc` (+0x40), the three `EvPos` floats (`fucompp`, so bitwise-unequal\nNaNs never match but the `FLT_MAX` sentinels always do), `EvMsg` (+0x24) and `EvImg` (+0x50).\n**`EvDsc` is NOT compared.** A NULL bucket returns 0 immediately.\n\nThis is why the two identical `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT` records in `turn3-state.sav` survive as\nseparate events: they are in different turn buckets, and dedup is per-bucket.\n\n### `EventStorage::GetOrCreateTurnBucket` — 0x00885380, `__thiscall (int turn)`, `ret 4`\n\nScans `Events` for `EvTurn == turn`; **keeps scanning to the end and returns the *last*\nmatch** (0x008853d0–0x008853de has no early exit). If none, constructs a bucket\n(`0x00884cb0`, vtable `0x00a0f07c`), appends, and sets `_Mylast[-1].EvTurn = turn`\n(0x0088542d, `mov [eax-0x14], ecx`, i.e. `+4` off the new element at `_Mylast-0x18`).\n\n### `EventStorage::PruneOldTurns` — 0x00879eb0, `__thiscall (int turn)`\n\nCutoff is `turn - 0x32` (**50 turns**), constant, not from config: `0x00879ec3 add ebx,-0x32`.\n\nPrecisely as coded — and this is a quirk worth reproducing rather than \"fixing\": it walks the\n**leading** run of buckets with `EvTurn < cutoff`, leaves `edi` pointing at the **last** one\nof that run, and then shifts from `edi` down to `_Myfirst`. So it erases `n-1` buckets, not\n`n`: **one stale bucket always survives**, and a single leading stale bucket is never\nremoved at all (`0x00879ee2 cmp esi,edi; je` returns). It also stops at the first non-stale\nbucket, so a stale bucket after a fresh one is never reached.\n\n### Convenience wrapper\n\n`0x00886470` (`ret` and prototype not verified by this lane) posts via `PostEvent` twice at\n0x00886802 / 0x00886b22. **161 call sites in 113 functions** reference `PostEvent` directly —\nthis is the single event API for the whole simulation, not a research-specific helper.\n\n### Turn number\n\nEvery research-path site computes the turn as `*(int*)(*(char**)(player + 8) + 8)`.\n`ServerPlayer+8` is the `StrategyServer` *second* base; `0x0080e320` is\n`__thiscall void* ServerPlayer::GetServer()` = `[this+8] ? [this+8]-4 : 0`, so the field is\n`StrategyServer(primary base)+0x0c`. This matches the B4 finding that `StrategyServer` has\ntwo bases four bytes apart.\n\n**CORRECTION (lane EV 2026-09-08): that field is the FRAME (the turn counter), not\n`ModCount`.** The two are different words and the saves separate them cleanly:\n`turn2-state.sav` has `Summary/Turn = 2`, `Sim/Frame = 2` and `Sim/ModCount = 12`, and every\nevent the turn posted landed in bucket `EvTurn = 2`. If the argument were `ModCount` the\nbuckets would be 12 and 24. The value is the **post-increment** turn — a turn run from a save\nat turn *N* posts into bucket *N+1* — because the frame is bumped in `BeginProcessTurn`,\nbefore either turn driver runs.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Which events the research path posts\n\nOrder within `ServerPlayer::ProcessTurn` (0x00891340):\n\n| # | site | event | condition |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 | `TechTree::ProcessResearch` 0x00587b97 | `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET` | per node, see below |\n| 2 | → `SetResearched` → `OnTechResearched` 0x008919b5 | `EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` / `_UNDERBUDGET` | see below |\n| 3 | → `OnTechResearched` 0x00892427 | `EVENT_TEMPERANCE` | temperance tech cured ≥1 addicted system |\n| 4 | `TechTree::ProcessResearch` 0x00587ff4 | `EVENT_TECHS_UNLOCKED` | tail loop, ≥1 newly available node |\n| 5 | `ProcessTurn` 0x0089168c | `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` | no target, no affordable tech, tree not exhausted |\n\n`ProcessResearch`'s two posts bracket the per-node loop: OVERBUDGET fires **inside** the loop\n(so once per over-budget node), TECHS_UNLOCKED **once** after it.\n\n### 3.1 `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET` — the B3 defect, fully explained\n\nPosted at **0x00587b97**, in `TechTree::ProcessResearch` (0x005876c0).\n\nPer-node arithmetic recovered from 0x00587732–0x00587907 (naming `cost =\nTechTree::GetNodeCost(node)` = 0x0057da00, `pts = node->points` at `node+0x1c`):\n\n```\nminPts  = max(cost * 50  / 100, 0)          ; 0x51eb851f/sar 5 = /100\nmaxPts  = max(minPts, cost * 150 / 100)\nwasDone = (pts >= cost)                     ; [ebp-0xcd], setge @0x005877e1\ngranted = min(requested, maxPts - pts)\n*overbudgetOut += requested - granted       ; the out-param accumulates unspent points\npts    += granted\nnowDone = (pts >= cost)                     ; [ebp-0xce], setge @0x00587828\n\nif      (pts >= maxPts)  chance = 1.0f, draw = 0.0f          ; always completes\nelse if (granted == 0)   chance = 0.0f, draw = 1.0f          ; never completes, no draw\nelse                     chance = (float)(pts - minPts) / maxPts   ; NOTE: / maxPts, not /(max-min)\n                         draw   = rng.NextFloat()*(1.0-0.0) + 0.0  ; [0x009e1e68] == 0.0\n                         if (owner && owner->Species == 5)   ; Zuul\n                             draw = max(draw, rng.NextFloat()*(1.0-0.0)+0.0)\n\nif (chance < draw) {                         ; roll FAILED -> tech not completed this turn\n    if (!wasDone && nowDone && owner) {\n        PostEvent(EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET); node->flag(+0x2c) = 2;\n    }\n} else {                                     ; roll succeeded\n    log(\"Research completed at %d of %d (%.1f%%). (Odds: %.2f, Roll: %.2f)\\n\", ...)\n    if (pts/cost < 0.8) node->flag(+0x2c) = 0;\n    SetResearched(node->def, 2);             ; 0x00581e10 -> OnTechResearched\n}\n```\n\nSo **over budget means: the node has accumulated at least its full cost, but the completion\nroll failed, and this is the first turn that has been true.** `!wasDone` is what makes it\nfire exactly once per node.\n\nThe record it posts:\n\n| field | value | evidence |\n|---|---|---|\n| `EvDsc` | `\"Research Over Budget\"` | key `EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, slot `0x00ae48e0`, thunk key at `0x00a00cac` |\n| `EvMsg` | `\"Research for %s has gone overbudget.\"` % `node->def->name` | key `EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, slot `0x00ae48e8`, key at `0x00a00ccc` |\n| `EvImg` | `\"EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET\"` | literal `0x00a0078c`, pushed at 0x00587b24 |\n| `EvLoc` | `0` | `obj = NULL` (0x00587b2c) |\n| `EvPos` | `{FLT_MAX, FLT_MAX, FLT_MAX}` | `pos = NULL` → ctor default |\n| `EvAct` | `1` | literal, 0x00587b22 |\n| `EvCID` | `0` | ctor |\n\nBoth strings go through `0x008c97f0` (`__cdecl` format-into-`std::string`, 8 stack args:\n`out, fmt, a1..a6`) with the tech name as the single substitution; the summary format\ncontains no `%s`, so it comes out literal. The tech name is `def+0x40` (a `std::string`;\n`_Myres` at `+0x54` selects heap vs. inline buffer, 0x00587a1d).\n\n**Save cross-check:** `turn3-state.sav`, player 1, turn-3 bucket, `EvEID 3` is exactly this\nrecord, with `EvMsg \"Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.\"` — the format string, the\n`%s` substitution, `EvAct 1`, `EvLoc 0` and the `FLT_MAX` position all match byte for byte.\n\n### 3.2 `EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` / `EVENT_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET`\n\nPosted at **0x008919b5** in `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched` (0x00891790), guarded by\n`if (!silent)` (0x00891804 `cmp byte [ebp+0xc], 0; jne`).\n\n```\nratio = TechTree::GetProgressRatio(tree, def)      ; 0x0057e950, float\nif (ratio >= 0.8f)  img = \"EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE\"    (0x00a33368)\n                    sum = EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_COMPLETE   (slot 0x00af09e8)\n                    msg = EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_COMPLETE   (slot 0x00af09f0)\nelse                img = \"EVENT_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET\" (0x00a33380)\n                    sum = EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET(slot 0x00af09f8)\n                    msg = EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET(slot 0x00af0a00)\nPostEvent(sum, snprintf(msg, 0x100, def->name), NULL, NULL, turn, img, 1)\n```\n\nThe 0.8 constant is the `double` at `0x009e20c8` = `0.800000011920929`, i.e. `(double)0.8f` —\nthe comparison is `fcomp` of the `float` ratio against that double. Text:\n\n* `EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` = `\"Research Complete\"`,\n  `EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` = `\"Tech %s has been acquired\"`\n* `EVENTSUM_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET` = `\"Research Breakthrough!\"`,\n  `EVENTMSG_RESEARCH_UNDERBUDGET` = `\"Your scientists made a breakthrough with %s. Research has completed ahead of schedule!\"`\n\n`EvAct = 1`, `obj = pos = NULL`, so `EvLoc = 0` and `EvPos = FLT_MAX³`. Message buffer is a\n0x100-byte stack buffer formatted with `0x008c8eb0` (`_snprintf`-shaped, 9 args), then\nassigned into a `std::string`, so **a message longer than 255 chars is truncated** — a real\nbehaviour to reproduce.\n\nNote the naming is counter-intuitive: `UNDERBUDGET` is the *cheap* completion (ratio < 0.8).\n\n### 3.3 `EVENT_TEMPERANCE`\n\nPosted at **0x00892427**, same function, after the per-species temperance sweep\n(0x00892280–0x008922b9: for each species with flag bit 5, cure every owned addicted system\nvia 0x00745e40 / 0x00743800). Guarded by `!silent` **and** by a local \"something was cured\"\nflag (`[ebp-0x189]`, set at 0x008922a6). Strings `EVENTSUM_ADDICTION_TEMPERENCE` /\n`EVENTMSG_ADDICTION_TEMPERENCE` (slots `0x00af0a88` / `0x00af0a90`, note the shipped\nmisspelling \"TEMPERENCE\").\n\n`EvImg = \"EVENT_TEMPERANCE\"` (0x00a33340), `obj = pos = NULL`, and **`EvAct = 0`** — which\nmeans rule 5 of `PostEvent` fires and the stored `EvAct` becomes **2**, not 0. Any\nreimplementation that stores the literal 0 will differ from the oracle here.\n\n### 3.4 `EVENT_TECHS_UNLOCKED`\n\nPosted at **0x00587ff4**, at the tail of `ProcessResearch` (loop at 0x00587cc3). Collects\nevery node `n` where `n != NULL`, `n->def != NULL`, `tree->nodes[n->def->index] != NULL`,\nthat node's **`state` (`+0x14`) `== 2` (available)**, and **`n->turnAvailable` (`+0x20`)\n`== currentTurn`** (0x00587cfc–0x00587d42). If the collected vector is non-empty it posts\nonce.\n\n*Correction to `strategic-turn-internals.md:233`*, which reads the condition as \"state==2 &&\nturnAvailable == currentTurn **&& parent researched**\". There is no parent test: the\n`mov ecx,[ecx]; mov eax,[eax+ecx*4]` pair at 0x00587d0d–0x00587d19 dereferences `n->def` and\nthen indexes `tree->nodes` by `def->[0]`, which is the tech's **own** index (the same\nindirection the entry loop uses at 0x00587738–0x00587740). It resolves back to `n` itself;\nthe two null checks around it are defensive. The state test is therefore on `n`, not on a\nparent.\n\n`EvDsc` = `EVENTSUM_UNLOCKEDTECHS` (slot `0x00ae48f0`) = `\"New Technologies Available\"`.\n`EvMsg` = `EVENTMSG_UNLOCKEDTECHS` (slot `0x00ae48f8`) =\n`\"The following technologies are now available for research:\"` followed by, per node, the\nseparator string at `0x009e4588` and the node's `def->name` (0x00587f46–0x00587f82).\n`EvImg` = literal `\"EVENT_TECHS_UNLOCKED\"` (`0x00a00774`, length pushed as 0x14).\n`EvAct = 1`, `obj = pos = NULL`.\n\n### 3.5 `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH`\n\nPosted at **0x0089168c** in `ServerPlayer::ProcessTurn`. Condition (0x0089162a–0x0089167e):\n\n```\nif (player->ResT (+0x294) == NULL)\n    TechTree::CollectResearchedTechs(&out, turn, INT_MAX, sort=1)   ; 0x00584e50\n    if (out.empty() && TechTree::FindFirstAvailableTech() != NULL)  ; 0x0057da90\n        PostEvent(EVENTSUM_NO_RESEARCH, EVENTMSG_NO_RESEARCH, NULL, NULL, turn,\n                  \"EVENT_NO_RESEARCH\" (0x00a3332c), 1)\n```\n\nBoth strings are `\"No Research Project Assigned.\"` — matches `turn3-state.sav` player 0\nexactly (`EvAct 1`, `EvLoc 0`, `EvPos` FLT_MAX³).\n\n**CORRECTION (lane EV 2026-09-08) to this section as first written.** 0x00584e50 was named\nhere as a `ListAvailableTechs` and the middle test read as \"no affordable tech\". It is\n`TechTree::CollectResearchedTechs` (lane T read the whole body; the call site's argument order\nwas re-read here byte for byte from 0x00891600), and the test is about what was **researched**,\nnot about what is available:\n\n1. `ResT == NULL` — the player holds no research target;\n2. **no tech has `state == 4` (researched) with `turnResearched (+0x24) >= turn`**, i.e.\n   nothing finished on this turn or later. The turn is passed as the collector's `minTurn`\n   and the range runs to `INT_MAX`;\n3. at least one node is in `state == 2` (available) — that is the availability half, and it is\n   what excludes the four monster factions, whose entire tree is state 4.\n\nTest 2 is not decoration and the corpus exercises it: in `zuul-turn23-fleet23.sav` the human\nposts `EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE` on turn 22 and **no** no-research event that turn, then\n`EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` again on turn 23. `sots-engine`'s P11 implements all three tests; before\nthis lane it implemented tests 1 and 3 only, and over-fired.\n\nTest 1 is the one a save cannot answer. `ResTNm` on the wire is the target the file was\n**written** with; on the reference pair all four real players start the turn with none and\nthree of them acquire one *during* it, which is AI research selection. Across all eleven\ncorpus saves no AI player ever posts `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` (~90 player-turns) while the human\nposts it on every turn it lacks a target — stated as a hypothesis, with the operator's\n`--ai-player` roster standing in for the missing input.\n\nAlso in this window (0x008915ec–0x00891624): `RollResearchEvent` (0x0088df20) is called when\n`ResT != NULL && ResErrRoll(+0x3b4) != 0 && (const at 0x00a2c788) < progressRatio`, then\n`ResErrRoll` is cleared — the same draw the B2/B3 lanes measured. `RollResearchAccident`\n(0x00889dc0) posts the `EVENT_LABACCIDENT_*` family; not traced here.\n\n---\n\n## 4. What is *not* verified\n\n* `0x00886470` — the wrapper that also calls `PostEvent`. Its prototype and its two call\n  paths were not read; I only established that it exists and is not on the research path.\n* `TurnEvents`' vptr/vtable contents beyond slot 0 (the virtual dtor used by the pruner).\n* The `sasc` tag at `0x00a2bde0` — adjacent to the event tag block, owner unknown.\n* Whether `PostEvent`'s dedup can ever collapse two research events in practice. It cannot\n  for OVERBUDGET vs COMPLETE (different `EvImg`), but two *different techs* going over budget\n  in the same turn differ only in `EvMsg`, which **is** compared — so both are kept. Verified\n  by reading the comparator, not by observing it.\n* `EventStorage::Write` (the save-side counterpart of 0x00825cc0) was not located; only the\n  read/`0x8b9d50` direction and the two `TurnEvents` directions were disassembled. The field\n  order is identical in both directions and is confirmed by the save, so this is a gap in\n  coverage, not in confidence about the layout.\n* The 50-turn prune has never been observed running (our saves are at turn ≤ 3).\n\n---\n\n## 5. What a turn actually posts (lane EV 2026-09-08, measured over all 11 saves)\n\nRead out of the corpus with `verify/state-checksum/state_checksum.py`, not derived. Every\n`EvImg` value, bucket and id below is a file fact.\n\n**Only two players in the whole corpus ever hold an event.** `PlyrIdx 0` (the human) and\n`PlyrIdx 1` (the one AI empire that owns colonies). `PlyrIdx 2..3` are the dormant shadow\nempires — `Sav = 0`, no colonies — and although they *do* pick research targets every turn,\ntheir `EvNxID` is 0 on every save. `PlyrIdx 4..7` are the monster factions, whose whole tech\ntree is state 4 and whose `EvNxID` is likewise 0 throughout. So \"who posts\" is not a property\nof the event API; it is a property of who does anything.\n\n### The reference pair\n\n| pair | player | bucket | id | image | EvAct | EvLoc |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| turn1 -> turn2 | 0 | `EvTurn=2` | 1 | `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` | 1 | 0 |\n| turn1 -> turn2 | 1 | `EvTurn=2` | 1 | `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT` | 0 | 288 |\n| turn2 -> turn3 | 0 | `EvTurn=3` | 2 | `EVENT_NO_RESEARCH` | 1 | 0 |\n| turn2 -> turn3 | 1 | `EvTurn=3` | 2 | `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT` | 0 | 288 |\n| turn2 -> turn3 | 1 | `EvTurn=3` | 3 | `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET` | 1 | 0 |\n\n**Order within a player is readable off the ids**: on turn 3 player 1's construction event is\nid 2 and its research event id 3, so **the build pass posts before the research pass**. Ids\nare per player (`EvNxID` is on the player's own storage), so no cross-player order is\nobservable from a save and none should be assumed.\n\n`EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT` carries `EvAct = 0` **as stored**, because it has a subject (`EvLoc` 288,\na real position) — the `act == 0 && !obj && !pos -> 2` rule does not fire. The only stored\n`EvAct = 2` in the corpus is `EVENT_LABACCIDENT_SMALL`.\n\n### Every image the corpus contains\n\n`EVENT_NO_RESEARCH`, `EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT`, `EVENT_RESEARCH_COMPLETE`, `EVENT_TECHS_UNLOCKED`,\n`EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, `EVENT_FLEET_ARRIVED`, `EVENT_FLEET_EXPLORED`,\n`EVENT_FLEET_MULTIPOINT_NONODE`, `EVENT_LABACCIDENT_SMALL`, `EVENT_COLONY_NEWSETTLERS`,\n`EVENT_ENEMY_INCOMING_Human`. The last is worth noting: the **event type is the `EvImg`\nstring and it is composed at run time** — `_Human` is a species suffix, so the type space is\nnot a fixed enumeration and never was.\n\n### Text keys used, from `Locale/EN/Strings.csv`\n\n`EVENTSUM_SHIPS_BUILT` = `Ships Constructed At %s`; `EVENTMSG_SHIPS_BUILT_1SHIP` =\n`1 ship built in system %s`; `EVENTMSG_SHIPS_BUILT_NSHIPS` = `%s ships built in system %s`.\nSo the construction event picks between **two** message keys on the ship count, and the count\nis substituted as a `%s`. Both `EVENTSUM_NO_RESEARCH` and `EVENTMSG_NO_RESEARCH` are the same\nstring and take no parameter.\n\n### Wired into `sots-engine`\n\n`src/app/event_phase.{h,cpp}` bridges the save's event subtree to `game::events` and P11 posts\nthrough it. On the reference pair, with the data root and the AI roster supplied and\n`--commit-blocked=P11`: **4 leaves closed on turn1->turn2 and 3 on turn2->turn3, 0 regressed**,\nand the posted record agrees with the oracle on every one of its eight fields. Engine-side\nwrite-up: `sots-engine docs/EV-events.md`.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":492,"totalLines":492,"truncated":false}},"title":"findings/subsystems/events.md","time":{"start":1788999283718,"end":1788999283756}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06b0ec8f46a6a6c1016aa1f673930887d1b22a0a652ab82741"}},"id":"prt_088aab40200162DAv623632O0z","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa8934001dgcS8BMiH22ty9"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999283773,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_FFNe2C8kou2xGZiQ40ttOLDD","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/observedtech-append.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/observedtech-append.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # `vector<ObservedTech> otch` — pinned, and the displacement scanner that pinned it\n2: \n3: Lane X. Static/host only; VM140 was held by lane F and the game was never run.\n4: \n5: Two things here: a general-purpose tool (`tools/x86disp.py`) for a class of cross-reference\n6: Ghidra cannot index, and the `ServerPlayer+0x274` answer it was built to get.\n7: \n8: ---\n9: \n10: ## 1. The gap the tool fills\n11: \n12: Ghidra indexes **immediate** operands. It does not index **ModRM displacements**. On a\n13: 41,411-function MSVC C++ binary `lea reg,[reg+disp]` is *the* idiom for taking the address of\n14: a member — it is how every `std::vector`, every `std::string`, every embedded sub-object gets\n15: passed to a method or a constructor. So `find-constant-uses 0x274` returned 13 unrelated hits\n16: and none of them was the vector, and lane P correctly concluded the search was a limitation\n17: rather than evidence of absence.\n18: \n19: Lane E only found `EventStorage` at `+0x29c` because a whole accessor function happened to\n20: exist (`lea eax,[ecx+0x29c]; ret`). We were blind to this whole reference class all campaign,\n21: with ~1,600 classes still to go.\n22: \n23: ## 2. The tool — `tools/x86disp.py`\n24: \n25: A real x86-32 **length decoder** (legacy prefixes, 1-/2-/3-byte opcodes, ModRM, SIB, disp8\n26: sign-extended, disp32, every immediate form), swept from Ghidra's function starts so every\n27: decode begins on a genuine instruction boundary. It indexes every memory operand that carries\n28: a displacement, then answers \"what code touches offset N off some object?\" with the containing\n29: function, instruction address, base register and decoded instruction.\n30: \n31: Correctness points that would otherwise produce confident garbage, all handled:\n32: \n33: * `mod=0,rm=5` and `mod=0,rm=4,sib.base=5` are **disp32 with no base** — an absolute global\n34:   address, not a member offset. Excluded from member queries. (Without this, every\n35:   `mov eax,[0x00a2bd88]` in the binary shows up as a \"displacement\".)\n36: * `mod=1` disp8 is **sign-extended**: `-0x08` must not be reported as `+0xf8`.\n37: * `mod=3` is a register operand with no displacement at all.\n38: * `0x67` address-size prefix means 16-bit ModRM, a different layout entirely — refused rather\n39:   than mis-decoded.\n40: \n41: Commands: `build`, `query <disp>`, `cohort`, `func <va>`, `dis <va>`, `stats`, `brute`.\n42: \n43: **Decode quality:**\n44: \n45: ```\n46: functions swept : 41089\n47: instructions    : 2174504\n48: disp sites      : 612166\n49: desyncs         : 70 (0.17% of functions)\n50: code coverage   : 6142049/6142358 (100.0%)\n51: ```\n52: \n53: Zero unknown-opcode desyncs — the opcode tables cover everything this binary contains. All 70\n54: desyncs are truncations at a section/function boundary, not lost sync inside real code.\n55: \n56: > Gotcha worth carrying: the first build clipped each sweep at `fva + Ghidra's sizeInBytes`\n57: > and lost 11% of functions to mid-instruction truncation — Ghidra's `sizeInBytes` understates\n58: > real bodies often enough to matter (it was cutting valid `mov esp,ebp; pop ebp; ret`\n59: > epilogues in half). Sweeping to the **next function start** instead took coverage 89% → 100%.\n60: \n61: The tool works off a local cache (`dumps/`, gitignored: the exe, the function list, the index)\n62: so it never hammers the shared Ghidra box. `tools/cache_functions.py` pulls the function list\n63: once.\n64: \n65: ## 3. Validation — it rediscovers what we already knew\n66: \n67: Run before any new claim was made.\n68: \n69: **GT1 — `ServerPlayer::GetEventStorage`, the one accessor we already had:**\n70: \n71: ```\n72: $ uv run python3 tools/x86disp.py func 0x0080db00\n73: ServerPlayer_GetEventStorage @ 0x0080db00 size 7\n74:   0x0080db00  lea eax,[ecx+0x29c]   ServerPlayer_GetEventStorage+0x0  (8d819c020000)\n75: ```\n76: \n77: **GT2 — lane E's two `OnTechResearched` sites, plus one it did not have:**\n78: \n79: ```\n80: $ uv run python3 tools/x86disp.py query 0x29c --lea\n81:  ProcessTurn  @0x00891340\n82:   0x00891713  lea ecx,[esi+0x29c]   ProcessTurn+0x3d3          <-- NEW\n83:  OnTechResearched  @0x00891790\n84:   0x008919ab  lea ecx,[esi+0x29c]   OnTechResearched+0x21b     <-- known\n85:   0x0089241d  lea ecx,[esi+0x29c]   OnTechResearched+0xc8d     <-- known\n86: ```\n87: \n88: **GT3 — `EvNxID` at `ServerPlayer+0x2b0`:** 90 sites found; the `ServerPlayer` ones are present.\n89: This one is also the honest illustration of the precision problem — see §5.\n90: \n91: **GT4 — positive control for the cohort ranker.** Given the 50 `ServerPlayer` offsets already\n92: in `struct-recovery.md`, `FUN_0087fac0` scores **50 co-hits out of 50** — it is the\n93: `ServerPlayer` serializer, and nothing else in the binary comes close. A scanner that could\n94: not surface that function from a bare offset query would not be worth using.\n95: \n96: ## 4. The answer: `sizeof(ObservedTech)` and the append site\n97: \n98: ### `sizeof(Game::ObservedTech) = 0x2c` (44 bytes) — verified, three independent ways\n99: \n100: **(a)** `vector<ObservedTech>::operator=` at `0x00872380` divides the vector's byte span by a\n101: constant using MSVC's magic-number sequence:\n102: \n103: ```\n104: 0x00872398  mov ecx,[edi+0x4]      ; src._Mylast\n105: 0x0087239b  mov edi,[edi]          ; src._Myfirst\n106: 0x0087239d  sub ecx,edi            ; byte span\n107: 0x0087239f  mov eax,0x2e8ba2e9\n108: 0x008723a4  imul ecx\n109: 0x008723a6  sar edx,3\n110: ```\n111: \n112: `ceil(2^35 / 44) == 0x2e8ba2e9` **exactly**, and emulating the full sequence reproduces\n113: n = 0,1,2,3,10,71,1000 from spans of 0,44,88,132,440,3124,44000. Divisor = 44, unambiguously.\n114: \n115: **(b)** The same function then multiplies back by the literal stride:\n116: \n117: ```\n118: 0x0087243a  imul ecx,ecx,0x2c\n119: 0x0087243d  add ecx,[esi]          ; this->_Myfirst + n*44\n120: 0x00872441  mov [esi+0x4],ecx      ; this->_Mylast = ...\n121: ```\n122: \n123: Same literal at `0x00872468` and at `0x007b735b` inside `push_back`.\n124: \n125: **(c)** The linear search in the append function advances its iterator by `add edi,0x2c`\n126: (`0x007ba257`).\n127: \n128: This matches the on-disk lower bound *exactly* — 4 × `int` + one `0x1c` `std::string` = 44 —\n129: so there is no padding slack anywhere in the element.\n130: \n131: ### The append site\n132: \n133: ```\n134: FUN_007ba1a0 = RecordObservedTech   (direct callee of ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched 0x00891790)\n135: \n136: 0x007ba221  mov edi,[esi+0x274]     ; it = observer->otch._Myfirst\n137: 0x007ba227  cmp edi,[esi+0x278]     ; ... != _Mylast ?\n138: 0x007ba22d  je  0x007ba274          ; empty -> append\n139:       loop: compare each element's name string (this = elem+0x0c, length = [elem+0x1c])\n140: 0x007ba257  add edi,0x2c            ; ++it   *** stride 44 ***\n141: 0x007ba25a  cmp edi,[esi+0x278]\n142: 0x007ba260  jne loop\n143: 0x007ba274  lea ecx,[ebp-0x3c]\n144: 0x007ba277  call 0x008562a0         ; ObservedTech::ObservedTech()  on the stack\n145: 0x007ba27e  push eax\n146: 0x007ba27f  lea ecx,[esi+0x274]     ; this = &player->otch      <<< THE APPEND\n147: 0x007ba288  call 0x007b7320         ; vector<ObservedTech>::push_back\n148: ```\n149: \n150: `push_back` (`0x007b7320`) grows via `0x007b5820` when `_Mylast == _Myend` — **that realloc is\n151: exactly why lane R's guard saw all three of `player+0x274/0x278/0x27c` move on a completion**,\n152: rather than only `_Mylast`.\n153: \n154: `RecordObservedTech` is called from `OnTechResearched` (`0x00891790`) and from `0x007be228`,\n155: `0x007be4e1`, `0x007be535`. It is a **de-duplicating** append: it appends only if no existing\n156: element already carries that tech name — worth knowing for the reimplementation, since a naive\n157: `push_back` would diverge on a re-observation.\n158: \n159: Neither `push_back` nor `operator=` is COMDAT-ambiguous: `0x007b7320` has exactly one caller\n160: (`RecordObservedTech`, `ecx = player+0x274`) and `0x00872380` has two, both passing\n161: `ServerPlayer+0x274`. `0x007b5820` **is** shared with `FUN_0086dec0` and may be a folded body,\n162: so it is labelled `vector_44B_grow`, not as ObservedTech-specific.\n163: \n164: ### Element layout — as far as the evidence actually goes\n165: \n166: The default ctor at `0x008562a0` writes vtable `0x00a2439c` at `+0x00`. RTTI:\n167: COL `0x00a81c78` → type descriptor `0x00aeede4` → **`.?AVObservedTech@Game@@`**. So\n168: `ObservedTech` is polymorphic and its first word is a vptr, not a data field — which the\n169: on-disk shape does not tell you.\n170: \n171: > **Superseded 2026-09-08 by lane S — see §9.** The table as first written called the\n172: > embedded string 0x18 bytes and left `+0x08`, `+0x24`, `+0x28` unaccounted. `+0x24` is not a\n173: > field: it is the string's own trailing allocator word. The corrected map is below; the\n174: > original reasoning is kept in §9 because the way it went wrong is the useful part.\n175: \n176: | offset | size | member | evidence |\n177: |---|---|---|---|\n178: | `+0x00` | 4 | vptr `0x00a2439c` | ctor writes it, RTTI-confirmed |\n179: | `+0x04` | 2 | `uint16 otnF` (turn first observed) | `mov word [eax-0x28],cx` at `0x007ba2b0` (`eax` = `_Mylast`, element = `_Mylast-0x2c`), source `[ebx+0xc]`; tag from `ObservedTech::Write` |\n180: | `+0x06` | 2 | `uint16 otnL` (turn last observed) | `mov word [eax-0x26],dx` at `0x007ba2c6`, **same source word** `[ebx+0xc]` — first sighting sets first == last |\n181: | `+0x08` | 1 | `bool odet` | ctor stores a **byte** (`mov [esi+0x8],bl`, `0x008562f4`); copy-ctor copies a byte; serialised with `WriteBool`/`ReadBool` |\n182: | `+0x0c..+0x27` | 0x1c | `std::string otch` (tech name) | object base `+0x0c`, MSVC `{_Bx[16] @0, _Mysize @0x10, _Myres @0x14, _Alval @0x18}`. Ctor writes `[+0x0c]=0`, `[+0x1c]=0`, `[+0x20]=0xf`; the search loop reads `[+0x1c]` as the length and calls compare with `this = +0x0c`; the post-append assign uses `lea ecx,[_Mylast-0x20]` = `+0x0c`. `+0x24` is `_Alval` — never read, never written, by anything |\n183: | `+0x28` | 4 | `int owith` | ctor zeroes it; `ObservedTech::Write` emits it last |\n184: \n185: `4 + 2 + 2 + 1(+3 pad) + 0x1c + 4 = 0x2c` exactly — sizeof is fully accounted for, with no\n186: padding slack and no unaccounted field.\n187: \n188: ### Where the mapping came from — the serializer\n189: \n190: `Game::ObservedTech`'s vftable `0x00a2439c` is the usual 3 slots\n191: `{ [0] 0x00793610 scalar deleting dtor, [1] 0x00817c40 Read, [2] 0x00817cf0 Write }`.\n192: `Write` enumerates the entire object, in order, and touches nothing else:\n193: \n194: ```\n195: 0x00817cff  movzx ecx,word [edi+0x04]   push 0xa2b38c \"otnF\"   -> stream vft+0x24 (int)\n196: 0x00817d0f  movzx ecx,word [edi+0x06]   push 0xa2b384 \"otnL\"   -> stream vft+0x24 (int)\n197: 0x00817d26  lea   eax,[edi+0x08]        push 0xa2b36c \"odet\"   -> WriteBool  0x008b9c20\n198: 0x00817d37  lea   ecx,[edi+0x0c]        push 0xa2b3e8 \"otch\"   -> WriteString 0x008b9d70\n199: 0x00817d46  mov   eax,[edi+0x28]        push 0xa2b364 \"owith\"  -> stream vft+0x24 (int)\n200: ```\n201: \n202: `Read` (`0x00817c40`) is the exact mirror: `otnF`/`otnL` read as ints and stored back with\n203: 16-bit `mov word [ebx],ax`, `odet` through `ReadBool`, `otch` through `ReadString`, `owith`\n204: reached as `add edi,0x28`. That matches the on-disk order `save_reader.py` already had\n205: (`Otch = otnF otnL odet otch(string) owith`), which is a nice independent agreement between\n206: the disassembly and the save oracle.\n207: \n208: `Game::ObservedWeapon` (`Write` `0x00817bc0`, `Read` `0x00817b10`) is the same element shape\n209: with tag `owep` (`0x00a2b3f0`) in place of `otch` — a second instance of the identical 0x2c\n210: layout.\n211: \n212: Lane P's `observed_techs` region byte delta remains a valid live cross-check and should come\n213: back as exactly 44 per completion.\n214: \n215: ## 5. False-positive rate, honestly\n216: \n217: Two different error rates, and the interesting one is not the one you'd expect.\n218: \n219: **Decode-level error of the naive method is low.** A raw byte scan for `8D` + ModRM + the\n220: displacement — the thing you'd write without a decoder — is mostly *right*:\n221: \n222: | query | naive candidates | not actually an instruction | real sites the naive scan **missed** |\n223: |---|---|---|---|\n224: | `lea`, disp32 `0x274` | 19 | 0 (0.0%) | **80 of 99** |\n225: | 11 common opcodes, disp32 `0x274` | 89 | 1 (1.1%) | 11 of 99 |\n226: | `lea`, disp8 `0x14` | 828 | 1 (0.1%) | **13,784 of 14,611** |\n227: | 11 common opcodes, disp8 `0x14` | 10,326 | 59 (0.6%) | 4,344 of 14,611 |\n228: \n229: So the decoder's win is **recall, not decode precision**. A hand-written opcode set misses\n230: 80–94% of the real accesses, because a member is read, written, compared, and float-loaded far\n231: more often than its address is taken, and you cannot enumerate those opcodes by hand.\n232: \n233: **Class-level precision is the real problem, and it is poor.** The scanner knows the\n234: displacement; it cannot know what class the base register holds. `query 0x274` returns 99 sites\n235: in 45 functions and only about 6 of those functions are actually touching `ServerPlayer::otch`\n236: — roughly **13% precision by function**. The honest way to state the value is as search-space\n237: reduction: 41,411 functions → 45, about **900×**, down to a list a human reads in two minutes.\n238: \n239: **The cohort ranker helps, and has a trap.** Scoring functions by how many *already-known*\n240: offsets of the same class they touch pulls real class methods to the top (the serializer hits\n241: 50/50). But it would have **thrown away the correct answer**: `RecordObservedTech` touches only\n242: `0x274` and `0x278` and nothing else on `ServerPlayer`, so any `--min>=1` filter drops it. Use\n243: cohort as a ranker, never as a filter. This is now written into the tool's own docstring.\n244: \n245: What actually closed the case was the plain `query 0x274` list **intersected with one call-graph\n246: lookup** (`OnTechResearched`'s direct callees). Displacement scan for recall, call graph for\n247: disambiguation — neither alone was enough.\n248: \n249: ## 6. Previously anonymous offsets — attribution results\n250: \n251: The payoff was smaller than hoped, because most of the audit's anonymous offsets had already\n252: been named by other lanes since the audit was written.\n253: \n254: | offset | status before | after |\n255: |---|---|---|\n256: | `player+0x274/0x278/0x27c` | \"vector grew, append site unknown\" | **`RecordObservedTech+0xdf` (0x007ba27f)**, `sizeof` = 0x2c |\n257: | `player+0x2b0` | already named by lane E | unchanged (`EvNxID`) |\n258: | `TechTree+0x20` | already `TechTree_off_OrderCounter` | unchanged |\n259: | `ServerPlayer+0x308` | already `ServerPlayer_off_NodeBore` | unchanged |\n260: | `Budget+0x64` | harness-audit row 11: \"the original writes it\" | **not supported.** See below |\n261: \n262: **`Budget+0x64` (harness-audit row 11) — a correction.** `ServerPlayer::ComputeBudget`\n263: (`0x00863030`) writes its `Budget*` out-param through `esi`, and every such store lands in\n264: `+0x00..+0x54` (the 22-int block). The only two `+0x64` accesses in the whole function are\n265: **loads off a different base register** (`mov ecx,[eax+0x64]` at `0x0086328c`,\n266: `mov edx,[eax+0x64]` at `0x0086335d`). There is no store to `Budget+0x64` in `ComputeBudget`.\n267: \n268: Separately, `TechTree::ProcessResearch`'s `int* overbudget` fourth argument is **not**\n269: `Budget+0x64`: its only caller is `ProcessTurn` (`0x00891340`) and the call at `0x008914a5`\n270: passes `lea edx,[ebp-0x14]` — a stack local, consumed immediately after the call\n271: (`mov eax,[ebp-0x14]; cmp eax,0; jle`).\n272: \n273: This agrees with lane R, whose `budget_object` guard saw `Budget+0x64` change in **0 of 4284\n274: calls**. Row 11 should be reclassified from \"the original writes it and B1 never checked\" to\n275: \"nothing has been shown to write it\"; the remaining way to settle it is a write watchpoint on\n276: that word, not another static search.\n277: \n278: ## 7. Verdict on the technique\n279: \n280: Worth keeping, with its limits stated. It answered a question that had been parked, and the\n281: `0x29c` validation turned up a `ProcessTurn` `EventStorage` site nobody had. But it is a\n282: **recall** tool that produces a 20–100 line candidate list per offset, not an oracle: every\n283: result still needs a call-graph or decompiler check before it is a fact. For the ~1,600\n284: remaining classes the realistic workflow is `query <offset>` → read the list → confirm with one\n285: cross-reference call.\n286: \n287: ## 8. Ghidra writeback\n288: \n289: Labels: `RecordObservedTech` `0x007ba1a0`, `vector_ObservedTech_push_back` `0x007b7320`,\n290: `ObservedTech_ctor` `0x008562a0`, `vector_ObservedTech_assign` `0x00872380`,\n291: `vector_44B_grow` `0x007b5820`, `vftable_ObservedTech` `0x00a2439c`. Plate comments carrying\n292: the stride evidence on the first four.\n293: \n294: `addresses.json`: `ObservedTech_sizeof`, `ObservedTech_vftable`, `ObservedTech_off_Name`,\n295: `RecordObservedTech`, `vector_ObservedTech_push_back`, `vector_ObservedTech_assign`,\n296: `ObservedTech_ctor`, `vector_44B_grow`; `ServerPlayer_off_ObservedTechs` updated from\n297: \"NOT PINNED\" to `verified`.\n298: \n299: **Lane S round (2026-09-08).** Labels: `ObservedTech_Write` `0x00817cf0`, `ObservedTech_Read`\n300: `0x00817c40`, `ObservedTech_scalar_deleting_dtor` `0x00793610`, `ObservedWeapon_Write`\n301: `0x00817bc0`, `ObservedWeapon_Read` `0x00817b10`, `vector_ObservedTech_uninit_copy` `0x0079a150`,\n302: `vector_string_find_by_name` `0x00699bd0`. Prototypes on the five class methods. Plate comments\n303: carrying the full member map on the two serializers, the ctor, the dtor and the copy helper, and\n304: the `sizeof(std::string) = 0x1c` fact on `Stream::WriteString` `0x008b9d70` and on the\n305: `vector<string>` stride site `0x00699bd0` — the two places a future lane is most likely to look.\n306: `addresses.json` +10 entries (`std_string_sizeof`, `ObservedTech_Read/_Write/_dtor/_copy_ctor`,\n307: `ObservedTech_off_TurnFirst/_TurnLast/_Detected/_With`, `ObservedWeapon_Write`), 4 corrected.\n308: \n309: ---\n310: \n311: ## 9. `std::string` is 0x1c, not 0x18 — the correction, and why it mattered (lane S, 2026-09-08)\n312: \n313: §4 above originally reported the embedded string as **0x18 bytes**, against the campaign-wide\n314: `_Bx@0, _Mysize@0x10, _Myres@0x14, _Alval@0x18`, sizeof `0x1c`. Lane X flagged it as \"worth\n315: re-checking\" rather than asserting it, which was the right call: **`0x1c` is correct, and it is\n316: correct everywhere in this binary.** `ObservedTech+0x24` is the string's own trailing allocator\n317: word, not a data member.\n318: \n319: ### Why the 0x18 reading looked right\n320: \n321: Everything lane X observed was accurate. The string's *live* fields really do stop at `+0x14`\n322: (`_Bx@0`, `_Mysize@0x10`, `_Myres@0x14`), because `_Alval` is `std::allocator<char>` — an empty\n323: class. It occupies a word of the object but is never loaded or stored, so it is invisible to\n324: any evidence based on **what the code touches**. Sizing a type from its accessed fields\n325: undercounts it by exactly the tail padding. The same trap is live for `std::vector` in this\n326: build, which is `{_Myfirst, _Mylast, _Myend, _Alval}` = `0x10` while only three words are ever\n327: read (`events.md` already records the `_Alval` word at `EventStorage+0x10` and `+0x14`).\n328: \n329: ### The three things that settle it inside `ObservedTech`\n330: \n331: Each is a *complete enumeration* of the object, which is the right instrument here — an\n332: enumeration can show a field's **absence**, a touch-scan cannot.\n333: \n334: 1. **`ObservedTech::Write` `0x00817cf0`** serialises `+0x04, +0x06, +0x08, +0x0c, +0x28`.\n335:    No `+0x24`. (`Read` `0x00817c40` mirrors it.)\n336: 2. **`ObservedTech_ctor` `0x008562a0`** initialises `+0x00, +0x04, +0x08, +0x0c(string), +0x28`.\n337:    No `+0x24` — while zeroing every other scalar in the object.\n338: 3. **The copy constructor**, inlined at `0x0079a184` inside the vector's uninitialised-copy\n339:    helper `FUN_0079a150`, copies `+0x04, +0x06, +0x08`, the string at `+0x0c`, and `+0x28`.\n340:    No `+0x24`.\n341: \n342: A 4-byte data member that the constructor, the copy constructor and the serializer all ignore\n343: is not a data member.\n344: \n345: ### Binary-wide check — `tools/strfootprint.py`\n346: \n347: One class is an anecdote, so the same question was put to the whole binary. Every serializer\n348: hands member pointers to the `Mars::Stream` primitive helpers with a fixed idiom\n349: (`lea r,[base+disp]; push r; push tag; push stream; call helper`), so the scanner recovers\n350: `(base, disp, tag)` for every string site and then asks: does the same function touch any other\n351: offset inside `(N, N+0x1c)` off the same base register?\n352: \n353: ```\n354: string helper call sites            : 241\n355:   resolved to a class member offset : 65\n356:   stack temporaries (ebp/esp base)  : 30\n357:   offset not reached by a plain lea : 146\n358: \n359: members with a sibling inside (N, N+0x1c) : 0\n360: \n361: gap from a string member to the next member on the same base:\n362:   +0x1c   : 51\n363:   +0x20   : 1\n364: ```\n365: \n366: **65 string members across every serializer in the exe, zero collisions, and 51 of the 52\n367: measurable gaps are exactly `0x1c`.** The single `+0x20` is `StrategyServer::KeyPath` at\n368: `+0x134`, whose *Read* side gives `+0x1c` to `+0x150` — the writer simply skips a member.\n369: There is no `0x18` instantiation, no empty-base-optimised variant, and no game-local string\n370: class. One layout, `0x1c`.\n371: \n372: Two exclusions matter or the scan reports noise, and both are why a naive version of this\n373: would have \"confirmed\" 0x18:\n374: \n375: * **`ebp`/`esp` bases are stack temporaries, not members.** A local string at `[ebp-0x2c]`\n376:   shows accesses at `-0x1c` and `-0x18` — which read exactly like two sibling fields inside\n377:   the span. All 30 such sites are excluded.\n378: * **`N+0x10` and `N+0x14` are the string's own `_Mysize`/`_Myres`**, touched inline whenever\n379:   the compiler expands the `_Myres >= 16 ? _Ptr : _Buf` test at a call site.\n380: \n381: ### Independent corroboration outside the scan\n382: \n383: * `FUN_00699bd0` walks a `vector<std::string>` doing the SSO test at `[esi+0x14]`/`[esi]` —\n384:   element base *is* string base — and advances `add esi,0x1c` (`0x00699c29`). The stride of a\n385:   vector of strings **is** `sizeof(std::string)`.\n386: * `EventStorage::PostEvent` `0x008862b0` takes two by-value `std::string`s at `[ebp+0x08]` and\n387:   `[ebp+0x24]` (spacing `0x1c`) and `RET 0x4c` = `2*0x1c + 5*4`.\n388: * `MoraleEvent` is 0x50 bytes with its name string at `+0x34`: `0x34 + 0x1c = 0x50` exactly.\n389: \n390: ### Blast radius — what actually had to change\n391: \n392: Nothing in any recovered struct table. Every string-bearing layout in `struct-recovery.md`,\n393: `save-editor-structs.md`, `events.md` and `schema-gaps-resolved.md` already used `0x1c` spans\n394: and `0x1c` inter-field gaps, and the binary agrees with all of them. `ServerPlayer::pswd` at\n395: `0x2dc..0x2f7` — the row §4 asked to re-check — is **correct**: `Write` `0x008563e0` puts the\n396: next member exactly `0x1c` above it. The corrections were confined to three prose statements\n397: that had propagated the 0x18 number (`loader-prototypes.md` conventions line, the\n398: `GlobalConst_ParseString` prototype in `addresses.json`, and §4 here) plus one transposition in\n399: `struct-recovery.md` §0 that said `size@0x14, res@0x18` where the verified offsets are\n400: `0x10`/`0x14`.\n401: \n402: The lesson worth carrying, and the reason this was worth chasing rather than reconciling: **do\n403: not size a struct member from the offsets the code touches.** Trailing empty-allocator words in\n404: this build's STL are invisible to a touch-scan and cost exactly 4 bytes every time. Size types\n405: from an enumeration — a serializer, a constructor, a copy constructor, or a container stride.\n\n(End of file - total 405 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# `vector<ObservedTech> otch` — pinned, and the displacement scanner that pinned it\n\nLane X. Static/host only; VM140 was held by lane F and the game was never run.\n\nTwo things here: a general-purpose tool (`tools/x86disp.py`) for a class of cross-reference\nGhidra cannot index, and the `ServerPlayer+0x274` answer it was built to get.\n\n---\n\n## 1. The gap the tool fills\n\nGhidra indexes **immediate** operands. It does not index **ModRM displacements**. On a\n41,411-function MSVC C++ binary `lea reg,[reg+disp]` is *the* idiom for taking the address of\na member — it is how every `std::vector`, every `std::string`, every embedded sub-object gets\npassed to a method or a constructor. So `find-constant-uses 0x274` returned 13 unrelated hits\nand none of them was the vector, and lane P correctly concluded the search was a limitation\nrather than evidence of absence.\n\nLane E only found `EventStorage` at `+0x29c` because a whole accessor function happened to\nexist (`lea eax,[ecx+0x29c]; ret`). We were blind to this whole reference class all campaign,","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/observedtech-append.md","text":"# `vector<ObservedTech> otch` — pinned, and the displacement scanner that pinned it\n\nLane X. Static/host only; VM140 was held by lane F and the game was never run.\n\nTwo things here: a general-purpose tool (`tools/x86disp.py`) for a class of cross-reference\nGhidra cannot index, and the `ServerPlayer+0x274` answer it was built to get.\n\n---\n\n## 1. The gap the tool fills\n\nGhidra indexes **immediate** operands. It does not index **ModRM displacements**. On a\n41,411-function MSVC C++ binary `lea reg,[reg+disp]` is *the* idiom for taking the address of\na member — it is how every `std::vector`, every `std::string`, every embedded sub-object gets\npassed to a method or a constructor. So `find-constant-uses 0x274` returned 13 unrelated hits\nand none of them was the vector, and lane P correctly concluded the search was a limitation\nrather than evidence of absence.\n\nLane E only found `EventStorage` at `+0x29c` because a whole accessor function happened to\nexist (`lea eax,[ecx+0x29c]; ret`). We were blind to this whole reference class all campaign,\nwith ~1,600 classes still to go.\n\n## 2. The tool — `tools/x86disp.py`\n\nA real x86-32 **length decoder** (legacy prefixes, 1-/2-/3-byte opcodes, ModRM, SIB, disp8\nsign-extended, disp32, every immediate form), swept from Ghidra's function starts so every\ndecode begins on a genuine instruction boundary. It indexes every memory operand that carries\na displacement, then answers \"what code touches offset N off some object?\" with the containing\nfunction, instruction address, base register and decoded instruction.\n\nCorrectness points that would otherwise produce confident garbage, all handled:\n\n* `mod=0,rm=5` and `mod=0,rm=4,sib.base=5` are **disp32 with no base** — an absolute global\n  address, not a member offset. Excluded from member queries. (Without this, every\n  `mov eax,[0x00a2bd88]` in the binary shows up as a \"displacement\".)\n* `mod=1` disp8 is **sign-extended**: `-0x08` must not be reported as `+0xf8`.\n* `mod=3` is a register operand with no displacement at all.\n* `0x67` address-size prefix means 16-bit ModRM, a different layout entirely — refused rather\n  than mis-decoded.\n\nCommands: `build`, `query <disp>`, `cohort`, `func <va>`, `dis <va>`, `stats`, `brute`.\n\n**Decode quality:**\n\n```\nfunctions swept : 41089\ninstructions    : 2174504\ndisp sites      : 612166\ndesyncs         : 70 (0.17% of functions)\ncode coverage   : 6142049/6142358 (100.0%)\n```\n\nZero unknown-opcode desyncs — the opcode tables cover everything this binary contains. All 70\ndesyncs are truncations at a section/function boundary, not lost sync inside real code.\n\n> Gotcha worth carrying: the first build clipped each sweep at `fva + Ghidra's sizeInBytes`\n> and lost 11% of functions to mid-instruction truncation — Ghidra's `sizeInBytes` understates\n> real bodies often enough to matter (it was cutting valid `mov esp,ebp; pop ebp; ret`\n> epilogues in half). Sweeping to the **next function start** instead took coverage 89% → 100%.\n\nThe tool works off a local cache (`dumps/`, gitignored: the exe, the function list, the index)\nso it never hammers the shared Ghidra box. `tools/cache_functions.py` pulls the function list\nonce.\n\n## 3. Validation — it rediscovers what we already knew\n\nRun before any new claim was made.\n\n**GT1 — `ServerPlayer::GetEventStorage`, the one accessor we already had:**\n\n```\n$ uv run python3 tools/x86disp.py func 0x0080db00\nServerPlayer_GetEventStorage @ 0x0080db00 size 7\n  0x0080db00  lea eax,[ecx+0x29c]   ServerPlayer_GetEventStorage+0x0  (8d819c020000)\n```\n\n**GT2 — lane E's two `OnTechResearched` sites, plus one it did not have:**\n\n```\n$ uv run python3 tools/x86disp.py query 0x29c --lea\n ProcessTurn  @0x00891340\n  0x00891713  lea ecx,[esi+0x29c]   ProcessTurn+0x3d3          <-- NEW\n OnTechResearched  @0x00891790\n  0x008919ab  lea ecx,[esi+0x29c]   OnTechResearched+0x21b     <-- known\n  0x0089241d  lea ecx,[esi+0x29c]   OnTechResearched+0xc8d     <-- known\n```\n\n**GT3 — `EvNxID` at `ServerPlayer+0x2b0`:** 90 sites found; the `ServerPlayer` ones are present.\nThis one is also the honest illustration of the precision problem — see §5.\n\n**GT4 — positive control for the cohort ranker.** Given the 50 `ServerPlayer` offsets already\nin `struct-recovery.md`, `FUN_0087fac0` scores **50 co-hits out of 50** — it is the\n`ServerPlayer` serializer, and nothing else in the binary comes close. A scanner that could\nnot surface that function from a bare offset query would not be worth using.\n\n## 4. The answer: `sizeof(ObservedTech)` and the append site\n\n### `sizeof(Game::ObservedTech) = 0x2c` (44 bytes) — verified, three independent ways\n\n**(a)** `vector<ObservedTech>::operator=` at `0x00872380` divides the vector's byte span by a\nconstant using MSVC's magic-number sequence:\n\n```\n0x00872398  mov ecx,[edi+0x4]      ; src._Mylast\n0x0087239b  mov edi,[edi]          ; src._Myfirst\n0x0087239d  sub ecx,edi            ; byte span\n0x0087239f  mov eax,0x2e8ba2e9\n0x008723a4  imul ecx\n0x008723a6  sar edx,3\n```\n\n`ceil(2^35 / 44) == 0x2e8ba2e9` **exactly**, and emulating the full sequence reproduces\nn = 0,1,2,3,10,71,1000 from spans of 0,44,88,132,440,3124,44000. Divisor = 44, unambiguously.\n\n**(b)** The same function then multiplies back by the literal stride:\n\n```\n0x0087243a  imul ecx,ecx,0x2c\n0x0087243d  add ecx,[esi]          ; this->_Myfirst + n*44\n0x00872441  mov [esi+0x4],ecx      ; this->_Mylast = ...\n```\n\nSame literal at `0x00872468` and at `0x007b735b` inside `push_back`.\n\n**(c)** The linear search in the append function advances its iterator by `add edi,0x2c`\n(`0x007ba257`).\n\nThis matches the on-disk lower bound *exactly* — 4 × `int` + one `0x1c` `std::string` = 44 —\nso there is no padding slack anywhere in the element.\n\n### The append site\n\n```\nFUN_007ba1a0 = RecordObservedTech   (direct callee of ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched 0x00891790)\n\n0x007ba221  mov edi,[esi+0x274]     ; it = observer->otch._Myfirst\n0x007ba227  cmp edi,[esi+0x278]     ; ... != _Mylast ?\n0x007ba22d  je  0x007ba274          ; empty -> append\n      loop: compare each element's name string (this = elem+0x0c, length = [elem+0x1c])\n0x007ba257  add edi,0x2c            ; ++it   *** stride 44 ***\n0x007ba25a  cmp edi,[esi+0x278]\n0x007ba260  jne loop\n0x007ba274  lea ecx,[ebp-0x3c]\n0x007ba277  call 0x008562a0         ; ObservedTech::ObservedTech()  on the stack\n0x007ba27e  push eax\n0x007ba27f  lea ecx,[esi+0x274]     ; this = &player->otch      <<< THE APPEND\n0x007ba288  call 0x007b7320         ; vector<ObservedTech>::push_back\n```\n\n`push_back` (`0x007b7320`) grows via `0x007b5820` when `_Mylast == _Myend` — **that realloc is\nexactly why lane R's guard saw all three of `player+0x274/0x278/0x27c` move on a completion**,\nrather than only `_Mylast`.\n\n`RecordObservedTech` is called from `OnTechResearched` (`0x00891790`) and from `0x007be228`,\n`0x007be4e1`, `0x007be535`. It is a **de-duplicating** append: it appends only if no existing\nelement already carries that tech name — worth knowing for the reimplementation, since a naive\n`push_back` would diverge on a re-observation.\n\nNeither `push_back` nor `operator=` is COMDAT-ambiguous: `0x007b7320` has exactly one caller\n(`RecordObservedTech`, `ecx = player+0x274`) and `0x00872380` has two, both passing\n`ServerPlayer+0x274`. `0x007b5820` **is** shared with `FUN_0086dec0` and may be a folded body,\nso it is labelled `vector_44B_grow`, not as ObservedTech-specific.\n\n### Element layout — as far as the evidence actually goes\n\nThe default ctor at `0x008562a0` writes vtable `0x00a2439c` at `+0x00`. RTTI:\nCOL `0x00a81c78` → type descriptor `0x00aeede4` → **`.?AVObservedTech@Game@@`**. So\n`ObservedTech` is polymorphic and its first word is a vptr, not a data field — which the\non-disk shape does not tell you.\n\n> **Superseded 2026-09-08 by lane S — see §9.** The table as first written called the\n> embedded string 0x18 bytes and left `+0x08`, `+0x24`, `+0x28` unaccounted. `+0x24` is not a\n> field: it is the string's own trailing allocator word. The corrected map is below; the\n> original reasoning is kept in §9 because the way it went wrong is the useful part.\n\n| offset | size | member | evidence |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| `+0x00` | 4 | vptr `0x00a2439c` | ctor writes it, RTTI-confirmed |\n| `+0x04` | 2 | `uint16 otnF` (turn first observed) | `mov word [eax-0x28],cx` at `0x007ba2b0` (`eax` = `_Mylast`, element = `_Mylast-0x2c`), source `[ebx+0xc]`; tag from `ObservedTech::Write` |\n| `+0x06` | 2 | `uint16 otnL` (turn last observed) | `mov word [eax-0x26],dx` at `0x007ba2c6`, **same source word** `[ebx+0xc]` — first sighting sets first == last |\n| `+0x08` | 1 | `bool odet` | ctor stores a **byte** (`mov [esi+0x8],bl`, `0x008562f4`); copy-ctor copies a byte; serialised with `WriteBool`/`ReadBool` |\n| `+0x0c..+0x27` | 0x1c | `std::string otch` (tech name) | object base `+0x0c`, MSVC `{_Bx[16] @0, _Mysize @0x10, _Myres @0x14, _Alval @0x18}`. Ctor writes `[+0x0c]=0`, `[+0x1c]=0`, `[+0x20]=0xf`; the search loop reads `[+0x1c]` as the length and calls compare with `this = +0x0c`; the post-append assign uses `lea ecx,[_Mylast-0x20]` = `+0x0c`. `+0x24` is `_Alval` — never read, never written, by anything |\n| `+0x28` | 4 | `int owith` | ctor zeroes it; `ObservedTech::Write` emits it last |\n\n`4 + 2 + 2 + 1(+3 pad) + 0x1c + 4 = 0x2c` exactly — sizeof is fully accounted for, with no\npadding slack and no unaccounted field.\n\n### Where the mapping came from — the serializer\n\n`Game::ObservedTech`'s vftable `0x00a2439c` is the usual 3 slots\n`{ [0] 0x00793610 scalar deleting dtor, [1] 0x00817c40 Read, [2] 0x00817cf0 Write }`.\n`Write` enumerates the entire object, in order, and touches nothing else:\n\n```\n0x00817cff  movzx ecx,word [edi+0x04]   push 0xa2b38c \"otnF\"   -> stream vft+0x24 (int)\n0x00817d0f  movzx ecx,word [edi+0x06]   push 0xa2b384 \"otnL\"   -> stream vft+0x24 (int)\n0x00817d26  lea   eax,[edi+0x08]        push 0xa2b36c \"odet\"   -> WriteBool  0x008b9c20\n0x00817d37  lea   ecx,[edi+0x0c]        push 0xa2b3e8 \"otch\"   -> WriteString 0x008b9d70\n0x00817d46  mov   eax,[edi+0x28]        push 0xa2b364 \"owith\"  -> stream vft+0x24 (int)\n```\n\n`Read` (`0x00817c40`) is the exact mirror: `otnF`/`otnL` read as ints and stored back with\n16-bit `mov word [ebx],ax`, `odet` through `ReadBool`, `otch` through `ReadString`, `owith`\nreached as `add edi,0x28`. That matches the on-disk order `save_reader.py` already had\n(`Otch = otnF otnL odet otch(string) owith`), which is a nice independent agreement between\nthe disassembly and the save oracle.\n\n`Game::ObservedWeapon` (`Write` `0x00817bc0`, `Read` `0x00817b10`) is the same element shape\nwith tag `owep` (`0x00a2b3f0`) in place of `otch` — a second instance of the identical 0x2c\nlayout.\n\nLane P's `observed_techs` region byte delta remains a valid live cross-check and should come\nback as exactly 44 per completion.\n\n## 5. False-positive rate, honestly\n\nTwo different error rates, and the interesting one is not the one you'd expect.\n\n**Decode-level error of the naive method is low.** A raw byte scan for `8D` + ModRM + the\ndisplacement — the thing you'd write without a decoder — is mostly *right*:\n\n| query | naive candidates | not actually an instruction | real sites the naive scan **missed** |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| `lea`, disp32 `0x274` | 19 | 0 (0.0%) | **80 of 99** |\n| 11 common opcodes, disp32 `0x274` | 89 | 1 (1.1%) | 11 of 99 |\n| `lea`, disp8 `0x14` | 828 | 1 (0.1%) | **13,784 of 14,611** |\n| 11 common opcodes, disp8 `0x14` | 10,326 | 59 (0.6%) | 4,344 of 14,611 |\n\nSo the decoder's win is **recall, not decode precision**. A hand-written opcode set misses\n80–94% of the real accesses, because a member is read, written, compared, and float-loaded far\nmore often than its address is taken, and you cannot enumerate those opcodes by hand.\n\n**Class-level precision is the real problem, and it is poor.** The scanner knows the\ndisplacement; it cannot know what class the base register holds. `query 0x274` returns 99 sites\nin 45 functions and only about 6 of those functions are actually touching `ServerPlayer::otch`\n— roughly **13% precision by function**. The honest way to state the value is as search-space\nreduction: 41,411 functions → 45, about **900×**, down to a list a human reads in two minutes.\n\n**The cohort ranker helps, and has a trap.** Scoring functions by how many *already-known*\noffsets of the same class they touch pulls real class methods to the top (the serializer hits\n50/50). But it would have **thrown away the correct answer**: `RecordObservedTech` touches only\n`0x274` and `0x278` and nothing else on `ServerPlayer`, so any `--min>=1` filter drops it. Use\ncohort as a ranker, never as a filter. This is now written into the tool's own docstring.\n\nWhat actually closed the case was the plain `query 0x274` list **intersected with one call-graph\nlookup** (`OnTechResearched`'s direct callees). Displacement scan for recall, call graph for\ndisambiguation — neither alone was enough.\n\n## 6. Previously anonymous offsets — attribution results\n\nThe payoff was smaller than hoped, because most of the audit's anonymous offsets had already\nbeen named by other lanes since the audit was written.\n\n| offset | status before | after |\n|---|---|---|\n| `player+0x274/0x278/0x27c` | \"vector grew, append site unknown\" | **`RecordObservedTech+0xdf` (0x007ba27f)**, `sizeof` = 0x2c |\n| `player+0x2b0` | already named by lane E | unchanged (`EvNxID`) |\n| `TechTree+0x20` | already `TechTree_off_OrderCounter` | unchanged |\n| `ServerPlayer+0x308` | already `ServerPlayer_off_NodeBore` | unchanged |\n| `Budget+0x64` | harness-audit row 11: \"the original writes it\" | **not supported.** See below |\n\n**`Budget+0x64` (harness-audit row 11) — a correction.** `ServerPlayer::ComputeBudget`\n(`0x00863030`) writes its `Budget*` out-param through `esi`, and every such store lands in\n`+0x00..+0x54` (the 22-int block). The only two `+0x64` accesses in the whole function are\n**loads off a different base register** (`mov ecx,[eax+0x64]` at `0x0086328c`,\n`mov edx,[eax+0x64]` at `0x0086335d`). There is no store to `Budget+0x64` in `ComputeBudget`.\n\nSeparately, `TechTree::ProcessResearch`'s `int* overbudget` fourth argument is **not**\n`Budget+0x64`: its only caller is `ProcessTurn` (`0x00891340`) and the call at `0x008914a5`\npasses `lea edx,[ebp-0x14]` — a stack local, consumed immediately after the call\n(`mov eax,[ebp-0x14]; cmp eax,0; jle`).\n\nThis agrees with lane R, whose `budget_object` guard saw `Budget+0x64` change in **0 of 4284\ncalls**. Row 11 should be reclassified from \"the original writes it and B1 never checked\" to\n\"nothing has been shown to write it\"; the remaining way to settle it is a write watchpoint on\nthat word, not another static search.\n\n## 7. Verdict on the technique\n\nWorth keeping, with its limits stated. It answered a question that had been parked, and the\n`0x29c` validation turned up a `ProcessTurn` `EventStorage` site nobody had. But it is a\n**recall** tool that produces a 20–100 line candidate list per offset, not an oracle: every\nresult still needs a call-graph or decompiler check before it is a fact. For the ~1,600\nremaining classes the realistic workflow is `query <offset>` → read the list → confirm with one\ncross-reference call.\n\n## 8. Ghidra writeback\n\nLabels: `RecordObservedTech` `0x007ba1a0`, `vector_ObservedTech_push_back` `0x007b7320`,\n`ObservedTech_ctor` `0x008562a0`, `vector_ObservedTech_assign` `0x00872380`,\n`vector_44B_grow` `0x007b5820`, `vftable_ObservedTech` `0x00a2439c`. Plate comments carrying\nthe stride evidence on the first four.\n\n`addresses.json`: `ObservedTech_sizeof`, `ObservedTech_vftable`, `ObservedTech_off_Name`,\n`RecordObservedTech`, `vector_ObservedTech_push_back`, `vector_ObservedTech_assign`,\n`ObservedTech_ctor`, `vector_44B_grow`; `ServerPlayer_off_ObservedTechs` updated from\n\"NOT PINNED\" to `verified`.\n\n**Lane S round (2026-09-08).** Labels: `ObservedTech_Write` `0x00817cf0`, `ObservedTech_Read`\n`0x00817c40`, `ObservedTech_scalar_deleting_dtor` `0x00793610`, `ObservedWeapon_Write`\n`0x00817bc0`, `ObservedWeapon_Read` `0x00817b10`, `vector_ObservedTech_uninit_copy` `0x0079a150`,\n`vector_string_find_by_name` `0x00699bd0`. Prototypes on the five class methods. Plate comments\ncarrying the full member map on the two serializers, the ctor, the dtor and the copy helper, and\nthe `sizeof(std::string) = 0x1c` fact on `Stream::WriteString` `0x008b9d70` and on the\n`vector<string>` stride site `0x00699bd0` — the two places a future lane is most likely to look.\n`addresses.json` +10 entries (`std_string_sizeof`, `ObservedTech_Read/_Write/_dtor/_copy_ctor`,\n`ObservedTech_off_TurnFirst/_TurnLast/_Detected/_With`, `ObservedWeapon_Write`), 4 corrected.\n\n---\n\n## 9. `std::string` is 0x1c, not 0x18 — the correction, and why it mattered (lane S, 2026-09-08)\n\n§4 above originally reported the embedded string as **0x18 bytes**, against the campaign-wide\n`_Bx@0, _Mysize@0x10, _Myres@0x14, _Alval@0x18`, sizeof `0x1c`. Lane X flagged it as \"worth\nre-checking\" rather than asserting it, which was the right call: **`0x1c` is correct, and it is\ncorrect everywhere in this binary.** `ObservedTech+0x24` is the string's own trailing allocator\nword, not a data member.\n\n### Why the 0x18 reading looked right\n\nEverything lane X observed was accurate. The string's *live* fields really do stop at `+0x14`\n(`_Bx@0`, `_Mysize@0x10`, `_Myres@0x14`), because `_Alval` is `std::allocator<char>` — an empty\nclass. It occupies a word of the object but is never loaded or stored, so it is invisible to\nany evidence based on **what the code touches**. Sizing a type from its accessed fields\nundercounts it by exactly the tail padding. The same trap is live for `std::vector` in this\nbuild, which is `{_Myfirst, _Mylast, _Myend, _Alval}` = `0x10` while only three words are ever\nread (`events.md` already records the `_Alval` word at `EventStorage+0x10` and `+0x14`).\n\n### The three things that settle it inside `ObservedTech`\n\nEach is a *complete enumeration* of the object, which is the right instrument here — an\nenumeration can show a field's **absence**, a touch-scan cannot.\n\n1. **`ObservedTech::Write` `0x00817cf0`** serialises `+0x04, +0x06, +0x08, +0x0c, +0x28`.\n   No `+0x24`. (`Read` `0x00817c40` mirrors it.)\n2. **`ObservedTech_ctor` `0x008562a0`** initialises `+0x00, +0x04, +0x08, +0x0c(string), +0x28`.\n   No `+0x24` — while zeroing every other scalar in the object.\n3. **The copy constructor**, inlined at `0x0079a184` inside the vector's uninitialised-copy\n   helper `FUN_0079a150`, copies `+0x04, +0x06, +0x08`, the string at `+0x0c`, and `+0x28`.\n   No `+0x24`.\n\nA 4-byte data member that the constructor, the copy constructor and the serializer all ignore\nis not a data member.\n\n### Binary-wide check — `tools/strfootprint.py`\n\nOne class is an anecdote, so the same question was put to the whole binary. Every serializer\nhands member pointers to the `Mars::Stream` primitive helpers with a fixed idiom\n(`lea r,[base+disp]; push r; push tag; push stream; call helper`), so the scanner recovers\n`(base, disp, tag)` for every string site and then asks: does the same function touch any other\noffset inside `(N, N+0x1c)` off the same base register?\n\n```\nstring helper call sites            : 241\n  resolved to a class member offset : 65\n  stack temporaries (ebp/esp base)  : 30\n  offset not reached by a plain lea : 146\n\nmembers with a sibling inside (N, N+0x1c) : 0\n\ngap from a string member to the next member on the same base:\n  +0x1c   : 51\n  +0x20   : 1\n```\n\n**65 string members across every serializer in the exe, zero collisions, and 51 of the 52\nmeasurable gaps are exactly `0x1c`.** The single `+0x20` is `StrategyServer::KeyPath` at\n`+0x134`, whose *Read* side gives `+0x1c` to `+0x150` — the writer simply skips a member.\nThere is no `0x18` instantiation, no empty-base-optimised variant, and no game-local string\nclass. One layout, `0x1c`.\n\nTwo exclusions matter or the scan reports noise, and both are why a naive version of this\nwould have \"confirmed\" 0x18:\n\n* **`ebp`/`esp` bases are stack temporaries, not members.** A local string at `[ebp-0x2c]`\n  shows accesses at `-0x1c` and `-0x18` — which read exactly like two sibling fields inside\n  the span. All 30 such sites are excluded.\n* **`N+0x10` and `N+0x14` are the string's own `_Mysize`/`_Myres`**, touched inline whenever\n  the compiler expands the `_Myres >= 16 ? _Ptr : _Buf` test at a call site.\n\n### Independent corroboration outside the scan\n\n* `FUN_00699bd0` walks a `vector<std::string>` doing the SSO test at `[esi+0x14]`/`[esi]` —\n  element base *is* string base — and advances `add esi,0x1c` (`0x00699c29`). The stride of a\n  vector of strings **is** `sizeof(std::string)`.\n* `EventStorage::PostEvent` `0x008862b0` takes two by-value `std::string`s at `[ebp+0x08]` and\n  `[ebp+0x24]` (spacing `0x1c`) and `RET 0x4c` = `2*0x1c + 5*4`.\n* `MoraleEvent` is 0x50 bytes with its name string at `+0x34`: `0x34 + 0x1c = 0x50` exactly.\n\n### Blast radius — what actually had to change\n\nNothing in any recovered struct table. Every string-bearing layout in `struct-recovery.md`,\n`save-editor-structs.md`, `events.md` and `schema-gaps-resolved.md` already used `0x1c` spans\nand `0x1c` inter-field gaps, and the binary agrees with all of them. `ServerPlayer::pswd` at\n`0x2dc..0x2f7` — the row §4 asked to re-check — is **correct**: `Write` `0x008563e0` puts the\nnext member exactly `0x1c` above it. The corrections were confined to three prose statements\nthat had propagated the 0x18 number (`loader-prototypes.md` conventions line, the\n`GlobalConst_ParseString` prototype in `addresses.json`, and §4 here) plus one transposition in\n`struct-recovery.md` §0 that said `size@0x14, res@0x18` where the verified offsets are\n`0x10`/`0x14`.\n\nThe lesson worth carrying, and the reason this was worth chasing rather than reconciling: **do\nnot size a struct member from the offsets the code touches.** Trailing empty-allocator words in\nthis build's STL are invisible to a touch-scan and cost exactly 4 bytes every time. Size types\nfrom an enumeration — a serializer, a constructor, a copy constructor, or a container stride.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":405,"totalLines":405,"truncated":false}},"title":"findings/subsystems/observedtech-append.md","time":{"start":1788999283723,"end":1788999283760}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06b0ec8f46a6a6c1016aa1f673931c87d1b0788f05d6922d01"}},"id":"prt_088aab408001ngrCDFJ6pA6teP","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa8934001dgcS8BMiH22ty9"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999283774,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_QL8AqTMZCn0PkQkY13En8FDO","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/research-replace.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/research-replace.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Taking `TechTree::ProcessResearch` + the unlock cascade from `compare` to `replace` (lane CR)\n2: \n3: Historical experiment record. The displacement/board workflow referenced below is retired;\n4: current scope and acceptance criteria are in `campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md`.\n5: That pilot also records the independently observed installed-hook inventory and runtime FPU\n6: word corrections; the original prediction and raw observation history below is preserved.\n7: \n8: **Lane CR, 2026-09-09. Guest: VM145 (`sots-re-win10-145`, `re@192.168.10.145`) — held by this lane.**\n9: VM140 is untouched (it is the exclusive reference guest).\n10: \n11: The board's headline metric is `tools/displacement.py`: **3 replaced / 7 compared / 7 modelled /\n12: 3 mapped**. `TechTree::ProcessResearch + unlock cascade` is the best-evidenced `compared` row — 35\n13: calls, three workloads, 0 divergences, `tracecmp` exit 0, and an advance prediction that held on a\n14: *changed* workload. This lane asks the only question that moves the metric: **can our code run\n15: INSTEAD of the original's, live, with a byte-level oracle holding afterwards?**\n16: \n17: Everything above the `## 4.` heading was committed **before** the shim was built or staged\n18: (rule 2). Nothing above that line is edited afterwards; corrections are made below it and named as\n19: corrections (rule 11).\n20: \n21: ---\n22: \n23: ## 1. The state, and why this one\n24: \n25: ### 1.1 The candidate the brief names, and why it is not sufficient on its own\n26: \n27: `ref-turn2.sav` (`ab4ac2d7…`, = `verify/results/saves/turn2-state.sav`) is the campaign's oldest and\n28: most reproduced oracle: one End Turn by the **load** route, `(Autosave EndTurn)` `bb4fd9ac…` /\n29: `(Autosave)` `978041ac…`, **5 + 1 processes**, certified-pairs row 1.\n30: \n31: **It does not exercise a research completion.** This is not an inference from the exit code — it is\n32: read off lane U's own instruments, both of which are in this repo:\n33: \n34: * `verify/results/compare/unlock-b3-t1.md`: 3 calls, 3 compared, 0 diverged, and\n35:   **`0 undeclared write(s) in 0 call(s)`**. Every completion in every measured run produces\n36:   undeclared writes on the `player` and `tree_header` guards, because that is where\n37:   `OnTechResearched`'s tech effects and the tree's order counter land. Zero undeclared writes is\n38:   zero completions.\n39: * `verify/results/shim/unlock-shim.log`: the first three `research: cascade ok=1 …` lines of the\n40:   five-turn continuation read `completions=0 unlocked=0 otch_appends=0`. Those three lines *are*\n41:   the `ref-turn2` End Turn.\n42: \n43: Reading the trace rather than the verdict (rule 1) says what that turn *does* do: call 0 advances\n44: the generator by one word (`left` 432 → 431), pushes node 144's progress 2879 → 5768, sets its flag\n45: 1 → 2 (`OverBudgetNotified`) and posts one event (`next_id` 3 → 4). Calls 1 and 2 change **nothing\n46: at all**. So `ref-turn2` + one End Turn is a real workload for the *pass* and an empty one for the\n47: *completion path*. **A replace-mode oracle taken there would be exactly the green verdict on a hook\n48: that compared nothing that rule 1 exists to catch.**\n49: \n50: ### 1.2 The state this lane uses\n51: \n52: **`verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav`** — 67,219 B, sha256\n53: `978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921`, `Summary.Turn = 3`,\n54: `Sim.ModCount = 24`. It is *the output of certified-pairs row 1*: the `(Autosave).sav` that\n55: `ref-turn2` + one End Turn produces. It is already on VM145 under that hash as `(Autosave).sav`.\n56: \n57: **Procedure: one End Turn. Route: LOAD.** Stated because the route is part of the pair\n58: (rule 26(c) fourth term; lane BS): the same turn reached by continuation and by load is two\n59: different, individually reproducible things, and this lane deliberately does **not** inherit the\n60: continuation's turn-4 numbers as an assumption — it predicts them and lets the load route falsify\n61: them (P1).\n62: \n63: Why this turn: in lane U's five-turn continuation the **fourth-turn** call is the completing one.\n64: The call that enters with `turn = 4` allocates 2,898 points to tech 144, completes it, and runs the\n65: cascade — `completions=1 unlocked=3 otch_appends=1` in the shim log, `next_id` 5 → 7 and\n66: `observed_techs` 440 → 484 bytes in the trace. `turn3-state.sav` is the state that turn starts from.\n67: \n68: ### 1.3 The exposure screen (rule 26(c)) — a screen, not a decision procedure\n69: \n70: Read from `turn3-state.sav` with `verify/save-reader/save_reader.py`. Eight players; per lane BP the\n71: engine builds AI clients for net ids **32, 496, 512** only, and the four factions at 528–576 carry\n72: their signature **inertly**.\n73: \n74: | player | species | `ResTNm` | `Status` | AI client | pick-turn signature? |\n75: |---|---|---|---|---|---|\n76: | 16 (human `re`) | 0 | `''` | 4 | **no** (local human) | **false positive** — no client |\n77: | 32 | 2 | `IND_Waldo` | 4 | yes | **no** — mid-research |\n78: | 496 | 0 | `DRV_PlsFiss` | 4 | yes | **no** — mid-research |\n79: | 512 | 2 | `BIO_GnMod` | 4 | yes | **no** — mid-research |\n80: | 528, 544, 560, 576 | 4 | `''` | 0 | **no** | **false positive** — no client, `Status 0` |\n81: \n82: **No player that actually runs enters this turn with an empty research target.** That is the best\n83: the screen can say. It cannot say the control will agree — rule 26(c)'s own retraction is explicit\n84: that `candidatesTried` is not readable from a save, that there is a combat term, and that the load\n85: route is a fourth term that is not a predicate on the save at all. **So the screen is why this turn\n86: is worth trying, and the two-process control in §4.1 is the only thing that decides it.**\n87: \n88: The lineage where exposure is saturated (`ad-…`/`ar-…`, every turn carrying a signature) is\n89: deliberately not used here.\n90: \n91: ### 1.4 What is being asked of `hooks=off`\n92: \n93: Three fresh-process runs are planned before any replace result is read:\n94: \n95: | run | config | what it establishes |\n96: |---|---|---|\n97: | **C1**, **C2** | `shim.cfg.croff` (`hooks=off`, the proxy loads and installs nothing) | the control agrees with itself across two fresh processes (rule 26) |\n98: | **N** | `shim.cfg.crcompare` (one detour, `compare`) | the instrument is behaviour-neutral on *this* save and route (rule 19), **and** it is where the completion count comes from the hook itself |\n99: \n100: Only then the replace runs. C1/C2 use the *same proxy DLL* as every measured run, so the only\n101: difference between control and measurement is the config (lane CB's shape).\n102: \n103: ---\n104: \n105: ## 2. The four bytes of every float literal on this path (rule 23)\n106: \n107: Two float literals are on the research pass's arithmetic path, and **both are widened `float`s**.\n108: Read here directly out of `dumps/sots.exe` (PE image base `0x00400000`, `.rdata` at `0x009dd000`\n109: file offset `0x5dbe00`), not taken from an earlier note:\n110: \n111: | VA | bytes (LE) | value as `double` | is it `(double)float`? | engine constant |\n112: |---|---|---|---|---|\n113: | `0x009e20c8` | `00 00 00 a0 99 99 e9 3f` | `0.80000001192092896` | **yes** (low 29 bits zero) | `kEarlyCompletionRatio = 0.800000011920929` |\n114: | `0x009e5060` | `00 00 00 a0 99 99 a9 3f` | `0.05000000074505806` | **yes** | `kDecayFraction = 0.05000000074505806` |\n115: \n116: Both source literals were re-parsed and re-packed: `0.800000011920929` → `000000a09999e93f` and\n117: `0.05000000074505806` → `000000a09999a93f`. **Bit-identical to the image.** So the two constants\n118: `sots-engine/src/game/sim/research.cpp` relies on are exactly the image's, not the exact decimals\n119: that bit the money chain twice.\n120: \n121: Two literals that are **not** on this path, and why:\n122: \n123: * the tech-cost multiplier (`1.0 − 0.25·n`, floor `0.25`) — `ours` never evaluates it. It calls the\n124:   game's own read-only `TechTree::Cost` for every cost it needs, in both modes (`g_env.cost`). This\n125:   is a genuine, declared dependency on the original: the effective cost is **not** displaced.\n126: * `ResearchSpendFloor` / `Ceiling` are integer `×50/100` and `×150/100` with a 32-bit wrapping\n127:   multiply — no float involved.\n128: \n129: ---\n130: \n131: ## 3. Predictions, committed before the build\n132: \n133: Falsification symptoms are given for each. Predictions are made **per site** and not at a bracket\n134: total (rule 23's 2026-09-09 corollary).\n135: \n136: ### P0 — the control agrees with itself\n137: `turn3-state.sav`, one End Turn, load route, `hooks=off`, **two fresh processes** produce identical\n138: `(Autosave EndTurn).sav` and `(Autosave).sav`.\n139: *Falsified if:* the two processes differ. Then this workload is exposed, the screen in §1.3 was\n140: insufficient (which is what rule 26(c)'s retraction predicts is possible), and the honest move is to\n141: report that and pin the source of variation — **not** to pick the run that suits.\n142: \n143: ### P1 — the turn is not quiet, and the load route reproduces the continuation's turn-4 call\n144: Exactly **3** `ProcessResearch` calls, one per AI client, in the same owner order. Allocations:\n145: **A → {tech 144, 2898 points}**, **B → {tech 90, 0 points}**, **C → {tech 9, 0 points}**. Exactly\n146: **one completion** (tech 144) and the cascade unlocks exactly **three** nodes:\n147: \n148: | node | `state` | `cost_rp` | `turn_available` |\n149: |---|---|---|---|\n150: | 132 | 0 → 2 | `INT_MAX` → **10000** | −1 → **4** |\n151: | 136 | 0 → 2 | `INT_MAX` → **16000** | −1 → **4** |\n152: | 142 | 0 → 2 | `INT_MAX` → **8000** | −1 → **4** |\n153: \n154: *Falsified if:* a different allocation, a different completion count, or a different unlock set. That\n155: would be a **route** result — the load route not reproducing the continuation — and it is worth as\n156: much as the replace result. It is exactly what rule 26(c)'s fourth term says can happen.\n157: \n158: ### P2 — the arithmetic, hand-computed on the boundary\n159: For node 144: `cost = 5000`, `lo = ResearchSpendFloor = 2500`, `hi = ResearchSpendCeiling = 7500`.\n160: Entering progress **5768**, allocation **2898**:\n161: \n162: * `spent = min(2898, 7500 − 5768) = 1732` — the cap binds, so this call lands **exactly on the\n163:   ceiling**, which is the boundary rule 23 says to test by hand rather than trust a compare on.\n164: * `progress 5768 → 7500`, `overbudget 0 → 1166`.\n165: * `progress (7500) < hi (7500)` is **false**, so the odds/roll branch is skipped: **zero RNG draws**.\n166:   I predict `rng.left` is **unchanged at 413** across all three calls and the `mt` digest does not\n167:   move on any of them.\n168: * `ratio = (float)(7500/5000) = 1.5`, and `1.5 < 0.800000011920929` is false → **not** completed\n169:   early → `flag` **unchanged**.\n170: * `state 3 → 4`, `turn_researched −1 → 4`, `order −1 → 22`, and the tree's order counter\n171:   `22 → 23`.\n172: \n173: *Falsified if:* any single one of these moves. A wrong `hi` shows up as a wrong `overbudget`; a\n174: wrong early-completion literal shows up as `flag` moving.\n175: \n176: ### P3 — the instrument is neutral, and the completion is counted by the instrument\n177: Run N (`crcompare`, one detour) produces autosaves **byte-identical to C1/C2**, and `tracecmp`\n178: reports **3 calls / 3 compared / 0 diverged / exit 0**. The hook's own per-call log line reads\n179: `completions=1 … unlocked=3 otch_appends=1` on the completing call and all-zero on the other two.\n180: Undeclared writes: **6 spans in 1 call** —\n181: `player +0x10c/3`, `player +0x110/3`, `player +0x114/3`, `player +0x124/3`, `player +0x294/4`\n182: (`ResT`, the research target being cleared) and `tree_header +0x20/1` (the order counter).\n183: \n184: *Falsified if:* the autosaves move (then rule 19 bites and nothing below is readable), or the\n185: undeclared-write set differs (then the workload or the model moved).\n186: \n187: ### P4 — replace with the cascade OFF (`crreplace0`, the shipped behaviour) diverges\n188: The autosave is **not** byte-identical. Predicted diverging leaves, by name:\n189: \n190: 1. `Player[32]` tech tree: node 144 `turn_researched` and `order` unstamped (−1/−1); nodes 132, 136\n191:    and 142 unchanged at `state 0`, `cost_rp INT_MAX`, `turn_available −1`.\n192: 2. the tree's completion-order counter left at 22.\n193: 3. `Player[32]` events: `next_id` short by **2**, two event records absent.\n194: 4. `Player[32]` `otch`: one `ObservedTech` element absent (**44 bytes**).\n195: 5. `Player[32]` scalar fields at `+0x10c`, `+0x110`, `+0x114`, `+0x124` unchanged, and `ResTNm` still\n196:    reading `IND_Waldo` because `ResT` was never cleared.\n197: \n198: What **will** be right even here: node 144's `state = 4`, `progress = 7500`, `flag`, the decay sweep\n199: over every other node, and the `overbudget` accumulator.\n200: \n201: ### P5 — replace with the cascade ON (`crreplace1`) diverges, by strictly less\n202: Same binary, one config line different (`research.replace_cascade=on`; see §3.1). Predicted:\n203: **strictly fewer diverging leaves than P4**, with items 1 and 2 of P4 **closed** — node 144 stamped\n204: `turn_researched 4` / `order 22`, nodes 132/136/142 at `state 2` with `cost_rp` 10000/16000/8000 and\n205: `turn_available 4`, counter at 23 — and items 3, 4 and 5 **still open**.\n206: \n207: ### P6 — the headline, stated in advance\n208: **`game/sim/research` does NOT move from `compared` to `replaced` this session, and the named cause\n209: is `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`, not the research model.** The research pass itself — the spend\n210: cap, the odds branch, the completion, the decay sweep, and (with the flag on) the whole\n211: `SetResearched` cascade — is displaceable and I expect it to reproduce the original's TechTree state\n212: exactly. What blocks the oracle is the *callback*: it posts events whose text comes from the game's\n213: string table, appends an `ObservedTech` element `ours` decides but does not construct, and writes\n214: ~90 `ServerPlayer` fields that are a different subsystem's milestone (B2) and a separate `compared`\n215: row on the board. A replace of the research pass is **gated on displacing `OnTechResearched`**, and\n216: that is a statement about a boundary, not about the research model.\n217: \n218: *Falsified if:* `crreplace1`'s autosave is byte-identical to the oracle. That would mean the\n219: callback's writes do not reach the save on this workload, P6 is wrong, and the row moves to\n220: `replaced` — which is the outcome I would rather have and do not expect.\n221: \n222: ### P7 — the numbers I expect to be able to quote honestly afterwards\n223: **1** distinct completion, **1** distinct tech (144), **3** unlocked nodes, **3** calls of which\n224: **2** allocate zero points and write nothing at all. That is thin, and it will be reported as\n225: thin (rule 15/23) whatever the verdict.\n226: \n227: ### 3.1 The one engine change this lane makes, and why it is not a thumb on the scale\n228: \n229: `sots-engine` worktree `wip/cr` (rule 21), branched from `main` at `e7e2bd6`.\n230: \n231: * **`research.replace_cascade=on|off`, default `off`.** With it off the binary behaves *exactly* as\n232:   `main` does today, so P4 measures the shipped behaviour rather than a straw man. With it on, a\n233:   **replace**-mode call also writes the four `TechNode` words `SetResearched` stamps and the tree's\n234:   completion-order counter. It does **not** post events, does **not** move the `ObservedTech` vector\n235:   and does **not** apply a single tech effect — those stay gated on compare mode and stay declared\n236:   unmodelled. The flag exists so P4 and P5 differ by a **config line and not by a binary**, which is\n237:   what makes the leaf difference between their autosaves attributable to the cascade.\n238: * **A per-call log line in every mode.** The old line was gated on the cascade having run, so a\n239:   replace run with the cascade off had no counter at all and \"a completion happened\" could only be\n240:   inferred from the save — the artefact under test. It now prints `steps`, `completions` (counted\n241:   from the pass's own step results), `overbudget` and the cascade counters, in compare **and**\n242:   replace. This is the instrument answering the brief's \"show it fired — a count, from the hook\n243:   itself\".\n244: \n245: No new binary facts: `ghidra/addresses.d/cr.json` is **not** created, because this lane reads no new\n246: address. Every offset used already exists in the generated header. Host build: 253 targets, **59/59\n247: tests pass** (the denominator is the healthy 59, per rule 24's signature check); `clean_room_check`\n248: OK; `tools/check_shim_configs.py` OK with 27 registered hooks and all four CR configs\n249: (`croff`, `crcompare`, `crreplace0`, `crreplace1`) — the three `hooks=trace` ones marked\n250: `# exhaustive` and naming all 27.\n251: \n252: ---\n253: \n254: ## 4. Results\n255: \n256: *(added after the runs; nothing above this line is edited)*\n257: \n258: ### 4.0 The five runs, in order\n259: \n260: All five on **VM145**, held by this lane, each a **fresh process**, `SavedGames` reset to exactly\n261: `turn3-state.sav` before every launch, `C:\\SOTS\\shimdist-cr\\binkw32.dll`\n262: (25,274,723 B, sha256 `d2ad56b32c1b5f6b…`, `BUILD_ID cr-618ccb1-20260909T131556Z`, exports 66/66\n263: identical to the real `binkw32.dll`), one config per run and nothing else changed. Every screen —\n264: main menu, Load-Game chooser, the one-row file list, the **lobby**, the loaded map at \"Turn 3\", the\n265: post-turn map at \"Turn 4\" — was verified from a live `qm monitor` screendump before the next click.\n266: No run was driven by sleeping.\n267: \n268: | run | config | mode | `research.replace_cascade` | `(Autosave EndTurn).sav` | `(Autosave).sav` |\n269: |---|---|---|---|---|---|\n270: | **C1** | `croff` | `hooks=off` | – | 67,212 `e00eed0c…` | 67,811 `79df5047…` |\n271: | **C2** | `croff` | `hooks=off` | – | 67,212 **`e00eed0c…`** | 67,811 **`79df5047…`** |\n272: | **N** | `crcompare` | compare | off | 67,212 **`e00eed0c…`** | 67,811 **`79df5047…`** |\n273: | **R0** | `crreplace0` | **replace** | off | 67,212 `e00eed0c…` | 67,511 **`6b51db99…`** |\n274: | **R1** | `crreplace1` | **replace** | **on** | 67,212 `e00eed0c…` | 67,537 **`8a4309ee…`** |\n275: \n276: `(Autosave EndTurn).sav` is the *pre*-turn resave and is identical in all five runs, as it must be —\n277: nothing has run yet when it is written. The verdict is carried entirely by `(Autosave).sav`.\n278: \n279: ### 4.1 P0 held: the oracle\n280: \n281: **C1 and C2 agree byte-for-byte in two fresh processes.** The pair, in the standing\n282: `certified-pairs.md` format:\n283: \n284: | input | procedure | route | `(Autosave EndTurn)` | `(Autosave)` | processes | evidence |\n285: |---|---|---|---|---|---:|---|\n286: | `turn3-state.sav` `978041ac…` | one End Turn | **load** | `e00eed0c…` | `79df5047…` | **3** | lane CR ×2 `hooks=off`, ×1 compare-instrumented |\n287: \n288: **Masks that must be on the line.** Measured, not assumed —\n289: `state_checksum.py turn3-state.sav <(Autosave EndTurn)>` gives **exactly 5 leaves**:\n290: `/Summary/Checksum` and `Player.Status 4 → 0` on each of the four live players (16 `re`,\n291: 32 `Fane Lao`, 496 and 512 `Singularity`). **There is no `/CD[1]/NPrvVa` term on this state** —\n292: `CD[1]`'s diplomacy block is early-game and the leaf does not move — so the `--mask resave` rule\n293: holds here in the form the docs originally stated, and the lane BQ exception does not apply.\n294: \n295: **Exposure facts next to the hashes** (certified-pairs standing rule 4): §1.3's table — no player\n296: with an AI client enters the turn with `ResTNm == ''`; `NumDes` does not move; the two ships that\n297: complete join existing fleets; the four factions at 528–576 carry the empty-`ResTNm` signature\n298: inertly (`Status 0`, no client). The turn does create fleets (`Flt[50]`, `Flt[1808]`) and retire one\n299: (`Flt[1776]`) — that is a fleet-assignment shape, and it agreed anyway. **Which is the point of\n300: rule 26(c)'s retraction: the screen said \"likely fine\" and only the two-process control decided it.**\n301: \n302: ### 4.2 P3 held: the instrument is neutral, and it counts the completion itself\n303: \n304: Run **N** reproduced the control's two hashes exactly, so rule 19 is satisfied on *this* save and\n305: *this* route and everything below is read from runs that passed their own check.\n306: `tracecmp verify/traces/cr-N.jsonl.gz`: **3 calls, 3 compared, 0 diverged, exit 0**, coverage verdict\n307: `partial`, 8 unmodelled notes — and the undeclared-write set is **exactly the six spans predicted**:\n308: \n309: ```\n310: player+0x10c:3  player+0x110:3  player+0x114:3  player+0x124:3  player+0x294:4  tree_header+0x20:1\n311: ```\n312: \n313: The hook's own per-call line, which is the instrument saying a completion fired rather than the save\n314: being asked to imply it:\n315: \n316: ```\n317: research: mode=compare steps=1 completions=1 overbudget=1166 cascade_possible=1 ok=1\n318:           cascade_completions=1 unlocked=3 otch_appends=1 roll_draws=0 failures=0 depth=0\n319: research: mode=compare steps=1 completions=0 …   (×2, all zero)\n320: ```\n321: \n322: **A correction to the campaign's read of the detour count, and it goes the other way from the\n323: brief's warning.** My config names all **27** registered template hooks and\n324: `check_shim_configs.py` passes it as `# exhaustive` — and the shim still installed **six** detours,\n325: not one:\n326: \n327: | detour | source | named by a `hook.` key? |\n328: |---|---|---|\n329: | `Mars::Application::Initialize` | the M0 asm stub, installed unconditionally whenever `hooks != off` | **no** |\n330: | `Game::TechTree::ProcessResearch` | the one template hook | yes |\n331: | `StrategyClient::EndTurn`, `StrategyServer::BeginProcessTurn`, `StrategyServer::ProcessTurn`, `DemoApp::OnTick` | the **FPU-force module**, which installs four *sampling* detours by default (`fpu: module init … force=off value=0x0000 sample_ticks=on`, `sample_turn=on`) | **no** |\n332: \n333: `Shim::SelfTest::Fill` additionally emits one `trace` record at startup; it is an in-shim self-test,\n334: not a detour on the game. So **`# exhaustive` is exhaustive over the template-hook set only**, and\n335: `tools/check_shim_configs.py` cannot see the other five. It was the *neutrality check* (N identical\n336: to C1/C2), not the config check, that made this run safe — which is worth saying plainly, because a\n337: lane reading \"exhaustive, therefore one detour\" would be wrong by five.\n338: \n339: For the record, `fpu_cw = 0x027f` (53-bit, round-to-nearest) in every CR run.\n340: \n341: ### 4.3 P1 and P2 held exactly, on the LOAD route\n342: \n343: The load route reproduced the continuation's turn-4 call in every particular — allocations, the\n344: completion, the unlock set, the arithmetic. From `cr-N.jsonl.gz` (compare) and confirmed identically\n345: in `cr-R1.jsonl.gz` (replace):\n346: \n347: | call | owner | species | alloc | what moved |\n348: |---|---|---|---|---|\n349: | 1 | `Player[32 \"Fane Lao\"]` | 2 | `{144, 2898}` | the completion (below) |\n350: | 2 | `Player[496 \"Singularity\"]` | 0 | `{90, 0}` | **nothing at all** |\n351: | 3 | `Player[512 \"Singularity\"]` | 2 | `{9, 0}` | **nothing at all** |\n352: \n353: Call 1, node **144 `IND_Waldo`**: `state 3 → 4`, `progress 5768 → 7500`, `turn_researched −1 → 4`,\n354: `order −1 → 22`; `overbudget 0 → 1166`; three nodes unlocked —\n355: **132 `IND_OrbFound` @ 10000**, **136 `IND_RefCoat` @ 16000**, **142 `IND_TrkStl` @ 8000**, each\n356: `state 0 → 2`, `cost_rp INT_MAX → …`, `turn_available −1 → 4`; `events.next_id 5 → 7`;\n357: `observed_techs 440 → 484 bytes`.\n358: \n359: P2's hand arithmetic is confirmed to the unit: `cost 5000`, `lo 2500`, `hi 7500`,\n360: `spent = min(2898, 1732) = 1732`, `progress = 7500` **exactly on the ceiling**,\n361: `overbudget = 2898 − 1732 = 1166`; `progress < hi` false so **no draw**; `ratio = 1.5`, not below\n362: `0.800000011920929`, so **`flag` unchanged**. The `rng` region **did not move on any of the three\n363: calls** in any run.\n364: \n365: That last fact is a coverage hole, not a success — see §4.6.\n366: \n367: ### 4.4 P4 and P5 held: replace diverges, and the cascade closes exactly eleven leaves\n368: \n369: `state_checksum.py cr-oracle-autosave.sav <replace autosave>`:\n370: \n371: | run | diverging leaves | file size |\n372: |---|---:|---|\n373: | **R0** — replace, cascade **off** (the shipped behaviour) | **27** | 67,511 B |\n374: | **R1** — replace, cascade **on** | **16** | 67,537 B |\n375: | (the turn itself, `turn3-state` → oracle, for scale) | 128 | – |\n376: \n377: **The eleven leaves the cascade closes — R0 has them, R1 does not.** All eleven are `TechTree`:\n378: \n379: ```\n380: Player[32]/TechTree/St[94]   TResCost[94]   TUnlck[94]      (node 132 IND_OrbFound, 10000)\n381: Player[32]/TechTree/St[98]   TResCost[98]   TUnlck[98]      (node 136 IND_RefCoat,  16000)\n382: Player[32]/TechTree/St[104]  TResCost[104]  TUnlck[104]     (node 142 IND_TrkStl,    8000)\n383: Player[32]/TechTree/TAcq[106]  TiAcq[106]                   (node 144, turn 4 / order 22)\n384: ```\n385: \n386: The tree is serialised as parallel arrays indexed by **tree slot**, not tech id — slots 94/98/104/106\n387: are tech ids 132/136/142/144 — and the pass's own two words, `St[106] 3 → 4` and\n388: `TResDone[106] 5768 → 7500`, are correct in **both** replace runs because\n389: `ProcessResearchTurn` writes them without the cascade. So of the **13 tech-tree leaves this turn\n390: moves, our code produced all 13 in live memory with the original's `ProcessResearch` never\n391: executing** — 2 from the pass, 11 from `SetResearched`.\n392: \n393: **One prediction I cannot test and must retract as written.** P4 item 2 said the completion-order\n394: counter would be \"left at 22\" in R0. `TechTree+0x20` **is not a save leaf** — the counter's value\n395: surfaces only through the per-node `TiAcq` stamp — so the oracle cannot see it either way. What is\n396: observable is the trace: R1's only guard hit is `tree_header+0x20:1` (ours writing 22 → 23, the same\n397: byte the original moves in compare mode) and R0 has **0 undeclared writes in 0 calls**. The counter\n398: matters for the *next* completion, not for this save.\n399: \n400: ### 4.5 P6 held: the residual is `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`, entirely\n401: \n402: R1's **16** leaves, every one of them named, with nothing left over:\n403: \n404: | leaf | what it is | modelled by `ours`? |\n405: |---|---|---|\n406: | `Player[32]/OutMod` `1.25 → 1.1` | a tech effect | no — B2's milestone |\n407: | `Player[32]/ConMod[0..2]` `0.9 → 1.0` (×3) | tech effects | no — B2's milestone |\n408: | `Player[32]/Events/EvNxID` `7 → 5` | the two events not posted | decision modelled, **write is compare-only** |\n409: | `…/Events/.[EvTurn=4]/Events/.[EvEID=5]`, `.[EvEID=6]` `only-in-A` | the two event records | text comes from the game's string table |\n410: | `…/Events/.[EvTurn=4]/Events/.[0]` `3 → 1` | that turn's event count | ditto |\n411: | `Player[32]/otch/.[11]` `only-in-A`, `otch/.[0]` `11 → 10` | the `ObservedTech` element | append **decided** (`otch_appends=1`), element not constructed |\n412: | `Player[32]/ResTNm` `'' → 'IND_Waldo'` | `ResT` never cleared | inside the callback |\n413: | `Player[32]/BnkPr`, `BnkEl` | bankruptcy projection | **downstream of `OutMod`** |\n414: | `Sys[288 \"Ke'Dolarra\"]/RepCur`, `RepMax` `421640 → 371040` | repair capacity | **downstream of `ConMod`** |\n415: | `/Summary/Checksum` | derived | derived |\n416: \n417: So the residual decomposes into **5 primary player fields** (`OutMod`, `ConMod[0..2]`, `ResTNm`),\n418: **1 `ObservedTech` element**, **2 event records + their id counter**, and **5 derived leaves** that\n419: follow from those. Every single one is written by `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`, none of them by\n420: `TechTree::ProcessResearch` or by `SetResearched`.\n421: \n422: That also closes the loop with §4.2's guard: the four `player` spans the compare reported as\n423: undeclared (`+0x10c`, `+0x110`, `+0x114`, `+0x124`, all three bytes wide — float writes whose top\n424: byte did not change) plus `+0x294` (`ResT`, four bytes) are **five** writes, and the save shows\n425: **five** primary player fields. The guard was reporting exactly what the oracle later billed us for.\n426: \n427: **The input class that breaks it is a completion, and only a completion.** Both replace runs are\n428: byte-perfect on the two null calls and on every other leaf of the 128 the turn moves. A replace run\n429: over a turn where research does not complete would be byte-identical — and would prove nothing\n430: (rule 1), which is why this lane refused to run it on `ref-turn2`.\n431: \n432: ### 4.6 Coverage, reported as loudly as the result (rules 15 and 23)\n433: \n434: * **1 completion. 1 distinct tech (144 `IND_Waldo`). 3 unlocked nodes. 3 calls.**\n435: * **2 of the 3 calls allocate zero points and write nothing at all**, in any mode. Their entire\n436:   contribution to \"3 calls, 0 diverged\" is that two null calls stayed null.\n437: * **1 of 4 tech trees is exercised.** Player 16's tree is never processed (`ResTNm == ''`); players\n438:   496 and 512 are the null calls.\n439: * **The RNG region did not move on any call in any run.** The spend cap bound exactly, so the\n440:   odds/roll branch was skipped, and `roll_pending_in` was false on the completing call, so\n441:   `RollResearchEvent` drew nothing (`roll_draws=0`). **`region:rng` — the single strongest check in\n442:   this hook's compare — compared \"unchanged against unchanged\" on this workload and established\n443:   nothing.** The generator parity evidence for this module is entirely lane U's and lane V's,\n444:   on other turns.\n445: * **Branches that did not execute here:** the Zuul double roll (species 2, not 5); the\n446:   completed-early flag (`ratio 1.5`); the over-budget notification (`flag` already 2 from turn 3);\n447:   `RollResearchEvent`'s draw and, behind it, the plague / AI-rebellion paths; `SetResearched`'s\n448:   zero-cost recursion; the `def+0xb0` `NoAutoAvailable` skip; an empty prerequisite group; a\n449:   re-observed tech (the dedup's negative case); and the decay sweep, which ran over every node and\n450:   **changed nothing** because no other `Available` node had non-zero progress.\n451: * **The event model is count-only by construction** and stayed compare-only in replace mode by\n452:   design; the two missing records are two of the sixteen residual leaves.\n453: * **`TechTree::Cost` is the original's.** `ours` calls the game's read-only `Cost` for every cost it\n454:   needs, in both modes. The effective-cost formula is **not** displaced, and any claim about this\n455:   module inherits that dependency.\n456: \n457: ### 4.7 Verdict\n458: \n459: **No. `game/sim/research` does not move from `compared` to `replaced`.**\n460: \n461: The bar is \"our code ran instead of the original's **and a byte-level oracle held afterwards**\". Our\n462: code did run instead — `mode=replace`, `completions=1`, `unlocked=3`, the original's\n463: `ProcessResearch` never executed, and the game finished the turn and wrote a save. The oracle did\n464: **not** hold: 16 leaves in the best configuration. There is no qualified reading that rescues it,\n465: because the failure is not a rounding residual — it is a set of writes nobody has implemented.\n466: \n467: What the lane did establish, and it is worth more than the rung would have been:\n468: \n469: 1. **The research pass and the entire `SetResearched` cascade are displaceable and were displaced.**\n470:    All 13 tech-tree leaves the turn moves were produced by our code in live game memory, on a turn\n471:    with a real completion and a real three-node unlock cascade — which is a strictly stronger\n472:    statement than the 35 compared calls the board already carried, because in a compare the\n473:    original's code still did the work.\n474: 2. **The blocking boundary is named and measured, not guessed:** `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`,\n475:    5 player fields + 1 `ObservedTech` element + 2 events, and 5 derived leaves behind them.\n476:    `ProcessResearch` **cannot** reach `replaced` on any workload containing a completion until\n477:    `OnTechResearched` is displaced — and that is B2's milestone and its own `compared` board row,\n478:    not a defect in the research model.\n479: 3. **A new certified pair** on a turn that exercises the completion path, which the campaign did not\n480:    have: `ref-turn2` + one End Turn is a *quiet* turn for research, and every oracle the module had\n481:    been checked against was that one.\n482: \n483: The cheapest route to the rung, now that the boundary is priced: implement the ~90-field\n484: `ApplyTechEffect` write-back live (B2 already has `game/effects/tech_effects` host-tested), construct\n485: the `ObservedTech` element, and decide what to do about the two event records — whose *text* comes\n486: from the game's string table and therefore cannot be produced clean-room at all. **The event text is\n487: a hard stop for a byte-identical oracle on any completion turn**, and that should be settled as a\n488: policy question (call the game's `PostEvent`, and accept the `ComputeBudget`-shaped QUALIFIED\n489: caveat) before anyone spends another lane on it.\n490: \n491: ---\n492: \n493: ## 5. Proposed board rows\n494: \n495: **I have not edited `campaign/board.md`.** I *have* added the certified pair to\n496: `verify/results/saves/certified-pairs.md`, which the brief pointed at as the standing format and\n497: whose four standing rules for adding a row are all satisfied (two fresh `hooks=off` processes; the\n498: control run before anything was read from an instrumented run; not an extension of an existing pair\n499: but its own agreement; exposure facts recorded beside the hashes).\n500: \n501: ### 5.1 `tools/displacement.py` — the rung does NOT move\n502: \n503: The verdict is **no**, so `\"compared\"` stays. What I do propose is replacing the evidence and caveat\n504: strings, which currently understate what is known and do not name the gate:\n505: \n506: ```python\n507:     (\"TechTree::ProcessResearch + unlock cascade\", \"compared\",\n508:      \"35 calls across 3 workloads, 0 divergences, tracecmp exit 0; advance prediction held on a \"\n509:      \"changed workload (unlock costs no earlier report contained); REPLACE ATTEMPTED live (lane \"\n510:      \"CR): ours ran instead of the original on a real completion and produced all 13 tech-tree \"\n511:      \"leaves the turn moves, but the save oracle missed by 16 leaves\",\n512:      \"compare only. The replace attempt failed on ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched, not on the \"\n513:      \"research model: 5 player tech-effect fields, 1 ObservedTech element and 2 event records, \"\n514:      \"plus 5 derived leaves. Gated on B2. Thin: 1 completion, 1 tech, 2 of 3 calls allocate zero \"\n515:      \"points, and the RNG region did not move at all on the replace workload\"),\n516: ```\n517: \n518: ### 5.2 Board rows to add\n519: \n520: | row | class | status | conf | cov | date | evidence |\n521: |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n522: | **`ProcessResearch` replace: our code ran instead of the original's, and the oracle missed by 16 leaves — all of them `OnTechResearched`'s** | phase2 | verified | high | 95% | 2026-09-09 | **Lane CR, VM145**, `findings/subsystems/research-replace.md`. Predictions committed before the build (`sots-re` 4b3cc82); engine `wip/cr` 618ccb1 adds `research.replace_cascade=on\\|off` (default off) so the shipped and extended behaviours differ by **a config line, not a binary**. New certified pair `turn3-state.sav` → one End Turn, **load** route, `e00eed0c…`/`79df5047…`, 2 `hooks=off` processes + 1 compare. Compare run **3/3/0 exit 0** and byte-identical to the control (rule 19 satisfied), undeclared writes exactly the 6 predicted spans. **Replace, cascade on: 16 diverging leaves; cascade off: 27.** The 11-leaf delta is the whole `SetResearched` cascade and it is **ours**; with the pass's own 2 words that is **13 of 13 tech-tree leaves the turn moves, produced live by our code**. The 16 residual leaves are `OutMod`, `ConMod[0..2]`, `ResTNm`, one `ObservedTech` element, two event records + `EvNxID`, and 5 derived. **Verdict: stays `compared`.** |\n523: | **`ref-turn2` + one End Turn does NOT exercise a research completion** | verify | verified | high | 100% | 2026-09-09 | Lane CR. The campaign's most-reproduced oracle is a **quiet turn for the completion path**: `unlock-b3-t1.md` reports `0 undeclared write(s) in 0 call(s)` and `unlock-shim.log`'s first three lines read `completions=0`. It *is* a real workload for the pass (one RNG word, `flag 1 → 2`, one over-budget event) — but a replace-mode oracle taken there would be rule 1's green verdict on a hook comparing nothing. The completing turn is the **next** one, from `turn3-state.sav`. |\n524: | **`# exhaustive` is exhaustive over the 27 template hooks only — six detours are installed, not one** | phase2 | verified | high | 100% | 2026-09-09 | Lane CR. A config naming all 27 registered hooks `off` except one, passing `tools/check_shim_configs.py`, still installs **6** detours: the M0 `Application::Initialize` asm stub (unconditional whenever `hooks != off`) and the **FPU-force module's four sampling detours** (`force=off value=0x0000 sample_ticks=on sample_turn=on`, on by default). `check_shim_configs.py` cannot see either group — no `hook.` key names them. What made lane CR's runs safe was the **neutrality check** (compare run byte-identical to two `hooks=off` controls), not the config check. A lane reading \"exhaustive, therefore one detour\" is wrong by five. |\n525: | **A replace of `ProcessResearch` is gated on `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`, and partly on a policy question** | phase2 | open | high | – | 2026-09-09 | Lane CR. To reach `replaced`, three things are needed: the ~90-field tech-effect write-back applied live (B2 has `game/effects/tech_effects` host-tested), the `ObservedTech` element constructed (`ours` already decides the append), and the two research event **records** written. The third is not an implementation gap: their `EvDsc`/`EvMsg` text comes from the game's string table, which the engine must not carry, so a byte-identical oracle on any completion turn requires calling the game's own `PostEvent` and accepting a `ComputeBudget`-shaped **QUALIFIED** `replaced`. Settle that before spending a lane. |\n526: \n527: ### 5.3 Artefacts\n528: \n529: | what | where |\n530: |---|---|\n531: | predictions commit (before the build) | `sots-re` `4b3cc82` |\n532: | engine change | `sots-engine` worktree `wip/cr`, `618ccb1` — `research.replace_cascade`, a mode-independent completion counter, four `shim.cfg.cr*` configs |\n533: | oracle + replace saves | `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-{oracle-endturn,oracle-autosave,replace0-autosave,replace1-autosave}.sav` |\n534: | traces | `verify/traces/cr-{N,R0,R1}.jsonl.gz` |\n535: | `tracecmp` reports | `verify/results/compare/cr-{compare,replace0,replace1}.{md,json}` |\n536: | shim logs (the per-call counters) | `verify/results/shim/cr/cr-{N,R0,R1}.log` |\n537: | certified pair | `verify/results/saves/certified-pairs.md`, row 4 |\n538: \n539: No `ghidra/addresses.d/cr.json`: this lane read no new address. No game data, save, disassembly or\n540: `FUN_xxxxxxxx` name reached `sots-engine`; `tools/clean_room_check.sh` OK.\n541: \n542: ### 5.4 VM145 released\n543: \n544: Held for this lane only; **VM140 untouched**. Restored and verified byte-for-byte to as-found:\n545: \n546: ```\n547: binkw32.dll  15,527,327 B  903527F4A698EEA9FBE25F3A6236657C7D8348F994EEF394696F187E5E554B97  (= shimdist-recap)\n548: shim.cfg                   0AE410CC72FE155837D711C78543E14B1F5743310CD023298EB1E5BBD5457E71  (= shimdist-recap\\shim.cfg.recaptrace)\n549: SavedGames   the same 9 files, every size and sha256 identical to the as-found survey\n550: game         not running (as found)\n551: ```\n552: \n553: Left behind: `C:\\SOTS\\shimdist-cr\\`, `C:\\SOTS\\ui\\cr\\` (the input save, the four run outputs and the\n554: restore set) and `C:\\SOTS\\ui\\cr{deploy,click,grab,snap,restore,find}.ps1`. `click_helper.ps1` is\n555: unmodified. **One thing not restored:** my deploy helper *deletes* `C:\\SOTS\\shim.log` rather than\n556: rotating it to `.prev` the way lane BQ's does, so whatever log was there when I took the guest is\n557: gone. Logs are not simulation state and no measurement depends on it, but the next lane should\n558: rotate rather than delete.\n\n(End of file - total 558 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Taking `TechTree::ProcessResearch` + the unlock cascade from `compare` to `replace` (lane CR)\n\nHistorical experiment record. The displacement/board workflow referenced below is retired;\ncurrent scope and acceptance criteria are in `campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md`.\nThat pilot also records the independently observed installed-hook inventory and runtime FPU\nword corrections; the original prediction and raw observation history below is preserved.\n\n**Lane CR, 2026-09-09. Guest: VM145 (`sots-re-win10-145`, `re@192.168.10.145`) — held by this lane.**\nVM140 is untouched (it is the exclusive reference guest).\n\nThe board's headline metric is `tools/displacement.py`: **3 replaced / 7 compared / 7 modelled /\n3 mapped**. `TechTree::ProcessResearch + unlock cascade` is the best-evidenced `compared` row — 35\ncalls, three workloads, 0 divergences, `tracecmp` exit 0, and an advance prediction that held on a\n*changed* workload. This lane asks the only question that moves the metric: **can our code run\nINSTEAD of the original's, live, with a byte-level oracle holding afterwards?**\n\nEverything above the `## 4.` heading was committed **before** the shim was built or staged\n(rule 2). Nothing above that line is edited afterwards; corrections are made below it and named as\ncorrections (rule 11).\n","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/findings/subsystems/research-replace.md","text":"# Taking `TechTree::ProcessResearch` + the unlock cascade from `compare` to `replace` (lane CR)\n\nHistorical experiment record. The displacement/board workflow referenced below is retired;\ncurrent scope and acceptance criteria are in `campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md`.\nThat pilot also records the independently observed installed-hook inventory and runtime FPU\nword corrections; the original prediction and raw observation history below is preserved.\n\n**Lane CR, 2026-09-09. Guest: VM145 (`sots-re-win10-145`, `re@192.168.10.145`) — held by this lane.**\nVM140 is untouched (it is the exclusive reference guest).\n\nThe board's headline metric is `tools/displacement.py`: **3 replaced / 7 compared / 7 modelled /\n3 mapped**. `TechTree::ProcessResearch + unlock cascade` is the best-evidenced `compared` row — 35\ncalls, three workloads, 0 divergences, `tracecmp` exit 0, and an advance prediction that held on a\n*changed* workload. This lane asks the only question that moves the metric: **can our code run\nINSTEAD of the original's, live, with a byte-level oracle holding afterwards?**\n\nEverything above the `## 4.` heading was committed **before** the shim was built or staged\n(rule 2). Nothing above that line is edited afterwards; corrections are made below it and named as\ncorrections (rule 11).\n\n---\n\n## 1. The state, and why this one\n\n### 1.1 The candidate the brief names, and why it is not sufficient on its own\n\n`ref-turn2.sav` (`ab4ac2d7…`, = `verify/results/saves/turn2-state.sav`) is the campaign's oldest and\nmost reproduced oracle: one End Turn by the **load** route, `(Autosave EndTurn)` `bb4fd9ac…` /\n`(Autosave)` `978041ac…`, **5 + 1 processes**, certified-pairs row 1.\n\n**It does not exercise a research completion.** This is not an inference from the exit code — it is\nread off lane U's own instruments, both of which are in this repo:\n\n* `verify/results/compare/unlock-b3-t1.md`: 3 calls, 3 compared, 0 diverged, and\n  **`0 undeclared write(s) in 0 call(s)`**. Every completion in every measured run produces\n  undeclared writes on the `player` and `tree_header` guards, because that is where\n  `OnTechResearched`'s tech effects and the tree's order counter land. Zero undeclared writes is\n  zero completions.\n* `verify/results/shim/unlock-shim.log`: the first three `research: cascade ok=1 …` lines of the\n  five-turn continuation read `completions=0 unlocked=0 otch_appends=0`. Those three lines *are*\n  the `ref-turn2` End Turn.\n\nReading the trace rather than the verdict (rule 1) says what that turn *does* do: call 0 advances\nthe generator by one word (`left` 432 → 431), pushes node 144's progress 2879 → 5768, sets its flag\n1 → 2 (`OverBudgetNotified`) and posts one event (`next_id` 3 → 4). Calls 1 and 2 change **nothing\nat all**. So `ref-turn2` + one End Turn is a real workload for the *pass* and an empty one for the\n*completion path*. **A replace-mode oracle taken there would be exactly the green verdict on a hook\nthat compared nothing that rule 1 exists to catch.**\n\n### 1.2 The state this lane uses\n\n**`verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav`** — 67,219 B, sha256\n`978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921`, `Summary.Turn = 3`,\n`Sim.ModCount = 24`. It is *the output of certified-pairs row 1*: the `(Autosave).sav` that\n`ref-turn2` + one End Turn produces. It is already on VM145 under that hash as `(Autosave).sav`.\n\n**Procedure: one End Turn. Route: LOAD.** Stated because the route is part of the pair\n(rule 26(c) fourth term; lane BS): the same turn reached by continuation and by load is two\ndifferent, individually reproducible things, and this lane deliberately does **not** inherit the\ncontinuation's turn-4 numbers as an assumption — it predicts them and lets the load route falsify\nthem (P1).\n\nWhy this turn: in lane U's five-turn continuation the **fourth-turn** call is the completing one.\nThe call that enters with `turn = 4` allocates 2,898 points to tech 144, completes it, and runs the\ncascade — `completions=1 unlocked=3 otch_appends=1` in the shim log, `next_id` 5 → 7 and\n`observed_techs` 440 → 484 bytes in the trace. `turn3-state.sav` is the state that turn starts from.\n\n### 1.3 The exposure screen (rule 26(c)) — a screen, not a decision procedure\n\nRead from `turn3-state.sav` with `verify/save-reader/save_reader.py`. Eight players; per lane BP the\nengine builds AI clients for net ids **32, 496, 512** only, and the four factions at 528–576 carry\ntheir signature **inertly**.\n\n| player | species | `ResTNm` | `Status` | AI client | pick-turn signature? |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 16 (human `re`) | 0 | `''` | 4 | **no** (local human) | **false positive** — no client |\n| 32 | 2 | `IND_Waldo` | 4 | yes | **no** — mid-research |\n| 496 | 0 | `DRV_PlsFiss` | 4 | yes | **no** — mid-research |\n| 512 | 2 | `BIO_GnMod` | 4 | yes | **no** — mid-research |\n| 528, 544, 560, 576 | 4 | `''` | 0 | **no** | **false positive** — no client, `Status 0` |\n\n**No player that actually runs enters this turn with an empty research target.** That is the best\nthe screen can say. It cannot say the control will agree — rule 26(c)'s own retraction is explicit\nthat `candidatesTried` is not readable from a save, that there is a combat term, and that the load\nroute is a fourth term that is not a predicate on the save at all. **So the screen is why this turn\nis worth trying, and the two-process control in §4.1 is the only thing that decides it.**\n\nThe lineage where exposure is saturated (`ad-…`/`ar-…`, every turn carrying a signature) is\ndeliberately not used here.\n\n### 1.4 What is being asked of `hooks=off`\n\nThree fresh-process runs are planned before any replace result is read:\n\n| run | config | what it establishes |\n|---|---|---|\n| **C1**, **C2** | `shim.cfg.croff` (`hooks=off`, the proxy loads and installs nothing) | the control agrees with itself across two fresh processes (rule 26) |\n| **N** | `shim.cfg.crcompare` (one detour, `compare`) | the instrument is behaviour-neutral on *this* save and route (rule 19), **and** it is where the completion count comes from the hook itself |\n\nOnly then the replace runs. C1/C2 use the *same proxy DLL* as every measured run, so the only\ndifference between control and measurement is the config (lane CB's shape).\n\n---\n\n## 2. The four bytes of every float literal on this path (rule 23)\n\nTwo float literals are on the research pass's arithmetic path, and **both are widened `float`s**.\nRead here directly out of `dumps/sots.exe` (PE image base `0x00400000`, `.rdata` at `0x009dd000`\nfile offset `0x5dbe00`), not taken from an earlier note:\n\n| VA | bytes (LE) | value as `double` | is it `(double)float`? | engine constant |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| `0x009e20c8` | `00 00 00 a0 99 99 e9 3f` | `0.80000001192092896` | **yes** (low 29 bits zero) | `kEarlyCompletionRatio = 0.800000011920929` |\n| `0x009e5060` | `00 00 00 a0 99 99 a9 3f` | `0.05000000074505806` | **yes** | `kDecayFraction = 0.05000000074505806` |\n\nBoth source literals were re-parsed and re-packed: `0.800000011920929` → `000000a09999e93f` and\n`0.05000000074505806` → `000000a09999a93f`. **Bit-identical to the image.** So the two constants\n`sots-engine/src/game/sim/research.cpp` relies on are exactly the image's, not the exact decimals\nthat bit the money chain twice.\n\nTwo literals that are **not** on this path, and why:\n\n* the tech-cost multiplier (`1.0 − 0.25·n`, floor `0.25`) — `ours` never evaluates it. It calls the\n  game's own read-only `TechTree::Cost` for every cost it needs, in both modes (`g_env.cost`). This\n  is a genuine, declared dependency on the original: the effective cost is **not** displaced.\n* `ResearchSpendFloor` / `Ceiling` are integer `×50/100` and `×150/100` with a 32-bit wrapping\n  multiply — no float involved.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Predictions, committed before the build\n\nFalsification symptoms are given for each. Predictions are made **per site** and not at a bracket\ntotal (rule 23's 2026-09-09 corollary).\n\n### P0 — the control agrees with itself\n`turn3-state.sav`, one End Turn, load route, `hooks=off`, **two fresh processes** produce identical\n`(Autosave EndTurn).sav` and `(Autosave).sav`.\n*Falsified if:* the two processes differ. Then this workload is exposed, the screen in §1.3 was\ninsufficient (which is what rule 26(c)'s retraction predicts is possible), and the honest move is to\nreport that and pin the source of variation — **not** to pick the run that suits.\n\n### P1 — the turn is not quiet, and the load route reproduces the continuation's turn-4 call\nExactly **3** `ProcessResearch` calls, one per AI client, in the same owner order. Allocations:\n**A → {tech 144, 2898 points}**, **B → {tech 90, 0 points}**, **C → {tech 9, 0 points}**. Exactly\n**one completion** (tech 144) and the cascade unlocks exactly **three** nodes:\n\n| node | `state` | `cost_rp` | `turn_available` |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 132 | 0 → 2 | `INT_MAX` → **10000** | −1 → **4** |\n| 136 | 0 → 2 | `INT_MAX` → **16000** | −1 → **4** |\n| 142 | 0 → 2 | `INT_MAX` → **8000** | −1 → **4** |\n\n*Falsified if:* a different allocation, a different completion count, or a different unlock set. That\nwould be a **route** result — the load route not reproducing the continuation — and it is worth as\nmuch as the replace result. It is exactly what rule 26(c)'s fourth term says can happen.\n\n### P2 — the arithmetic, hand-computed on the boundary\nFor node 144: `cost = 5000`, `lo = ResearchSpendFloor = 2500`, `hi = ResearchSpendCeiling = 7500`.\nEntering progress **5768**, allocation **2898**:\n\n* `spent = min(2898, 7500 − 5768) = 1732` — the cap binds, so this call lands **exactly on the\n  ceiling**, which is the boundary rule 23 says to test by hand rather than trust a compare on.\n* `progress 5768 → 7500`, `overbudget 0 → 1166`.\n* `progress (7500) < hi (7500)` is **false**, so the odds/roll branch is skipped: **zero RNG draws**.\n  I predict `rng.left` is **unchanged at 413** across all three calls and the `mt` digest does not\n  move on any of them.\n* `ratio = (float)(7500/5000) = 1.5`, and `1.5 < 0.800000011920929` is false → **not** completed\n  early → `flag` **unchanged**.\n* `state 3 → 4`, `turn_researched −1 → 4`, `order −1 → 22`, and the tree's order counter\n  `22 → 23`.\n\n*Falsified if:* any single one of these moves. A wrong `hi` shows up as a wrong `overbudget`; a\nwrong early-completion literal shows up as `flag` moving.\n\n### P3 — the instrument is neutral, and the completion is counted by the instrument\nRun N (`crcompare`, one detour) produces autosaves **byte-identical to C1/C2**, and `tracecmp`\nreports **3 calls / 3 compared / 0 diverged / exit 0**. The hook's own per-call log line reads\n`completions=1 … unlocked=3 otch_appends=1` on the completing call and all-zero on the other two.\nUndeclared writes: **6 spans in 1 call** —\n`player +0x10c/3`, `player +0x110/3`, `player +0x114/3`, `player +0x124/3`, `player +0x294/4`\n(`ResT`, the research target being cleared) and `tree_header +0x20/1` (the order counter).\n\n*Falsified if:* the autosaves move (then rule 19 bites and nothing below is readable), or the\nundeclared-write set differs (then the workload or the model moved).\n\n### P4 — replace with the cascade OFF (`crreplace0`, the shipped behaviour) diverges\nThe autosave is **not** byte-identical. Predicted diverging leaves, by name:\n\n1. `Player[32]` tech tree: node 144 `turn_researched` and `order` unstamped (−1/−1); nodes 132, 136\n   and 142 unchanged at `state 0`, `cost_rp INT_MAX`, `turn_available −1`.\n2. the tree's completion-order counter left at 22.\n3. `Player[32]` events: `next_id` short by **2**, two event records absent.\n4. `Player[32]` `otch`: one `ObservedTech` element absent (**44 bytes**).\n5. `Player[32]` scalar fields at `+0x10c`, `+0x110`, `+0x114`, `+0x124` unchanged, and `ResTNm` still\n   reading `IND_Waldo` because `ResT` was never cleared.\n\nWhat **will** be right even here: node 144's `state = 4`, `progress = 7500`, `flag`, the decay sweep\nover every other node, and the `overbudget` accumulator.\n\n### P5 — replace with the cascade ON (`crreplace1`) diverges, by strictly less\nSame binary, one config line different (`research.replace_cascade=on`; see §3.1). Predicted:\n**strictly fewer diverging leaves than P4**, with items 1 and 2 of P4 **closed** — node 144 stamped\n`turn_researched 4` / `order 22`, nodes 132/136/142 at `state 2` with `cost_rp` 10000/16000/8000 and\n`turn_available 4`, counter at 23 — and items 3, 4 and 5 **still open**.\n\n### P6 — the headline, stated in advance\n**`game/sim/research` does NOT move from `compared` to `replaced` this session, and the named cause\nis `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`, not the research model.** The research pass itself — the spend\ncap, the odds branch, the completion, the decay sweep, and (with the flag on) the whole\n`SetResearched` cascade — is displaceable and I expect it to reproduce the original's TechTree state\nexactly. What blocks the oracle is the *callback*: it posts events whose text comes from the game's\nstring table, appends an `ObservedTech` element `ours` decides but does not construct, and writes\n~90 `ServerPlayer` fields that are a different subsystem's milestone (B2) and a separate `compared`\nrow on the board. A replace of the research pass is **gated on displacing `OnTechResearched`**, and\nthat is a statement about a boundary, not about the research model.\n\n*Falsified if:* `crreplace1`'s autosave is byte-identical to the oracle. That would mean the\ncallback's writes do not reach the save on this workload, P6 is wrong, and the row moves to\n`replaced` — which is the outcome I would rather have and do not expect.\n\n### P7 — the numbers I expect to be able to quote honestly afterwards\n**1** distinct completion, **1** distinct tech (144), **3** unlocked nodes, **3** calls of which\n**2** allocate zero points and write nothing at all. That is thin, and it will be reported as\nthin (rule 15/23) whatever the verdict.\n\n### 3.1 The one engine change this lane makes, and why it is not a thumb on the scale\n\n`sots-engine` worktree `wip/cr` (rule 21), branched from `main` at `e7e2bd6`.\n\n* **`research.replace_cascade=on|off`, default `off`.** With it off the binary behaves *exactly* as\n  `main` does today, so P4 measures the shipped behaviour rather than a straw man. With it on, a\n  **replace**-mode call also writes the four `TechNode` words `SetResearched` stamps and the tree's\n  completion-order counter. It does **not** post events, does **not** move the `ObservedTech` vector\n  and does **not** apply a single tech effect — those stay gated on compare mode and stay declared\n  unmodelled. The flag exists so P4 and P5 differ by a **config line and not by a binary**, which is\n  what makes the leaf difference between their autosaves attributable to the cascade.\n* **A per-call log line in every mode.** The old line was gated on the cascade having run, so a\n  replace run with the cascade off had no counter at all and \"a completion happened\" could only be\n  inferred from the save — the artefact under test. It now prints `steps`, `completions` (counted\n  from the pass's own step results), `overbudget` and the cascade counters, in compare **and**\n  replace. This is the instrument answering the brief's \"show it fired — a count, from the hook\n  itself\".\n\nNo new binary facts: `ghidra/addresses.d/cr.json` is **not** created, because this lane reads no new\naddress. Every offset used already exists in the generated header. Host build: 253 targets, **59/59\ntests pass** (the denominator is the healthy 59, per rule 24's signature check); `clean_room_check`\nOK; `tools/check_shim_configs.py` OK with 27 registered hooks and all four CR configs\n(`croff`, `crcompare`, `crreplace0`, `crreplace1`) — the three `hooks=trace` ones marked\n`# exhaustive` and naming all 27.\n\n---\n\n## 4. Results\n\n*(added after the runs; nothing above this line is edited)*\n\n### 4.0 The five runs, in order\n\nAll five on **VM145**, held by this lane, each a **fresh process**, `SavedGames` reset to exactly\n`turn3-state.sav` before every launch, `C:\\SOTS\\shimdist-cr\\binkw32.dll`\n(25,274,723 B, sha256 `d2ad56b32c1b5f6b…`, `BUILD_ID cr-618ccb1-20260909T131556Z`, exports 66/66\nidentical to the real `binkw32.dll`), one config per run and nothing else changed. Every screen —\nmain menu, Load-Game chooser, the one-row file list, the **lobby**, the loaded map at \"Turn 3\", the\npost-turn map at \"Turn 4\" — was verified from a live `qm monitor` screendump before the next click.\nNo run was driven by sleeping.\n\n| run | config | mode | `research.replace_cascade` | `(Autosave EndTurn).sav` | `(Autosave).sav` |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| **C1** | `croff` | `hooks=off` | – | 67,212 `e00eed0c…` | 67,811 `79df5047…` |\n| **C2** | `croff` | `hooks=off` | – | 67,212 **`e00eed0c…`** | 67,811 **`79df5047…`** |\n| **N** | `crcompare` | compare | off | 67,212 **`e00eed0c…`** | 67,811 **`79df5047…`** |\n| **R0** | `crreplace0` | **replace** | off | 67,212 `e00eed0c…` | 67,511 **`6b51db99…`** |\n| **R1** | `crreplace1` | **replace** | **on** | 67,212 `e00eed0c…` | 67,537 **`8a4309ee…`** |\n\n`(Autosave EndTurn).sav` is the *pre*-turn resave and is identical in all five runs, as it must be —\nnothing has run yet when it is written. The verdict is carried entirely by `(Autosave).sav`.\n\n### 4.1 P0 held: the oracle\n\n**C1 and C2 agree byte-for-byte in two fresh processes.** The pair, in the standing\n`certified-pairs.md` format:\n\n| input | procedure | route | `(Autosave EndTurn)` | `(Autosave)` | processes | evidence |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---:|---|\n| `turn3-state.sav` `978041ac…` | one End Turn | **load** | `e00eed0c…` | `79df5047…` | **3** | lane CR ×2 `hooks=off`, ×1 compare-instrumented |\n\n**Masks that must be on the line.** Measured, not assumed —\n`state_checksum.py turn3-state.sav <(Autosave EndTurn)>` gives **exactly 5 leaves**:\n`/Summary/Checksum` and `Player.Status 4 → 0` on each of the four live players (16 `re`,\n32 `Fane Lao`, 496 and 512 `Singularity`). **There is no `/CD[1]/NPrvVa` term on this state** —\n`CD[1]`'s diplomacy block is early-game and the leaf does not move — so the `--mask resave` rule\nholds here in the form the docs originally stated, and the lane BQ exception does not apply.\n\n**Exposure facts next to the hashes** (certified-pairs standing rule 4): §1.3's table — no player\nwith an AI client enters the turn with `ResTNm == ''`; `NumDes` does not move; the two ships that\ncomplete join existing fleets; the four factions at 528–576 carry the empty-`ResTNm` signature\ninertly (`Status 0`, no client). The turn does create fleets (`Flt[50]`, `Flt[1808]`) and retire one\n(`Flt[1776]`) — that is a fleet-assignment shape, and it agreed anyway. **Which is the point of\nrule 26(c)'s retraction: the screen said \"likely fine\" and only the two-process control decided it.**\n\n### 4.2 P3 held: the instrument is neutral, and it counts the completion itself\n\nRun **N** reproduced the control's two hashes exactly, so rule 19 is satisfied on *this* save and\n*this* route and everything below is read from runs that passed their own check.\n`tracecmp verify/traces/cr-N.jsonl.gz`: **3 calls, 3 compared, 0 diverged, exit 0**, coverage verdict\n`partial`, 8 unmodelled notes — and the undeclared-write set is **exactly the six spans predicted**:\n\n```\nplayer+0x10c:3  player+0x110:3  player+0x114:3  player+0x124:3  player+0x294:4  tree_header+0x20:1\n```\n\nThe hook's own per-call line, which is the instrument saying a completion fired rather than the save\nbeing asked to imply it:\n\n```\nresearch: mode=compare steps=1 completions=1 overbudget=1166 cascade_possible=1 ok=1\n          cascade_completions=1 unlocked=3 otch_appends=1 roll_draws=0 failures=0 depth=0\nresearch: mode=compare steps=1 completions=0 …   (×2, all zero)\n```\n\n**A correction to the campaign's read of the detour count, and it goes the other way from the\nbrief's warning.** My config names all **27** registered template hooks and\n`check_shim_configs.py` passes it as `# exhaustive` — and the shim still installed **six** detours,\nnot one:\n\n| detour | source | named by a `hook.` key? |\n|---|---|---|\n| `Mars::Application::Initialize` | the M0 asm stub, installed unconditionally whenever `hooks != off` | **no** |\n| `Game::TechTree::ProcessResearch` | the one template hook | yes |\n| `StrategyClient::EndTurn`, `StrategyServer::BeginProcessTurn`, `StrategyServer::ProcessTurn`, `DemoApp::OnTick` | the **FPU-force module**, which installs four *sampling* detours by default (`fpu: module init … force=off value=0x0000 sample_ticks=on`, `sample_turn=on`) | **no** |\n\n`Shim::SelfTest::Fill` additionally emits one `trace` record at startup; it is an in-shim self-test,\nnot a detour on the game. So **`# exhaustive` is exhaustive over the template-hook set only**, and\n`tools/check_shim_configs.py` cannot see the other five. It was the *neutrality check* (N identical\nto C1/C2), not the config check, that made this run safe — which is worth saying plainly, because a\nlane reading \"exhaustive, therefore one detour\" would be wrong by five.\n\nFor the record, `fpu_cw = 0x027f` (53-bit, round-to-nearest) in every CR run.\n\n### 4.3 P1 and P2 held exactly, on the LOAD route\n\nThe load route reproduced the continuation's turn-4 call in every particular — allocations, the\ncompletion, the unlock set, the arithmetic. From `cr-N.jsonl.gz` (compare) and confirmed identically\nin `cr-R1.jsonl.gz` (replace):\n\n| call | owner | species | alloc | what moved |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 | `Player[32 \"Fane Lao\"]` | 2 | `{144, 2898}` | the completion (below) |\n| 2 | `Player[496 \"Singularity\"]` | 0 | `{90, 0}` | **nothing at all** |\n| 3 | `Player[512 \"Singularity\"]` | 2 | `{9, 0}` | **nothing at all** |\n\nCall 1, node **144 `IND_Waldo`**: `state 3 → 4`, `progress 5768 → 7500`, `turn_researched −1 → 4`,\n`order −1 → 22`; `overbudget 0 → 1166`; three nodes unlocked —\n**132 `IND_OrbFound` @ 10000**, **136 `IND_RefCoat` @ 16000**, **142 `IND_TrkStl` @ 8000**, each\n`state 0 → 2`, `cost_rp INT_MAX → …`, `turn_available −1 → 4`; `events.next_id 5 → 7`;\n`observed_techs 440 → 484 bytes`.\n\nP2's hand arithmetic is confirmed to the unit: `cost 5000`, `lo 2500`, `hi 7500`,\n`spent = min(2898, 1732) = 1732`, `progress = 7500` **exactly on the ceiling**,\n`overbudget = 2898 − 1732 = 1166`; `progress < hi` false so **no draw**; `ratio = 1.5`, not below\n`0.800000011920929`, so **`flag` unchanged**. The `rng` region **did not move on any of the three\ncalls** in any run.\n\nThat last fact is a coverage hole, not a success — see §4.6.\n\n### 4.4 P4 and P5 held: replace diverges, and the cascade closes exactly eleven leaves\n\n`state_checksum.py cr-oracle-autosave.sav <replace autosave>`:\n\n| run | diverging leaves | file size |\n|---|---:|---|\n| **R0** — replace, cascade **off** (the shipped behaviour) | **27** | 67,511 B |\n| **R1** — replace, cascade **on** | **16** | 67,537 B |\n| (the turn itself, `turn3-state` → oracle, for scale) | 128 | – |\n\n**The eleven leaves the cascade closes — R0 has them, R1 does not.** All eleven are `TechTree`:\n\n```\nPlayer[32]/TechTree/St[94]   TResCost[94]   TUnlck[94]      (node 132 IND_OrbFound, 10000)\nPlayer[32]/TechTree/St[98]   TResCost[98]   TUnlck[98]      (node 136 IND_RefCoat,  16000)\nPlayer[32]/TechTree/St[104]  TResCost[104]  TUnlck[104]     (node 142 IND_TrkStl,    8000)\nPlayer[32]/TechTree/TAcq[106]  TiAcq[106]                   (node 144, turn 4 / order 22)\n```\n\nThe tree is serialised as parallel arrays indexed by **tree slot**, not tech id — slots 94/98/104/106\nare tech ids 132/136/142/144 — and the pass's own two words, `St[106] 3 → 4` and\n`TResDone[106] 5768 → 7500`, are correct in **both** replace runs because\n`ProcessResearchTurn` writes them without the cascade. So of the **13 tech-tree leaves this turn\nmoves, our code produced all 13 in live memory with the original's `ProcessResearch` never\nexecuting** — 2 from the pass, 11 from `SetResearched`.\n\n**One prediction I cannot test and must retract as written.** P4 item 2 said the completion-order\ncounter would be \"left at 22\" in R0. `TechTree+0x20` **is not a save leaf** — the counter's value\nsurfaces only through the per-node `TiAcq` stamp — so the oracle cannot see it either way. What is\nobservable is the trace: R1's only guard hit is `tree_header+0x20:1` (ours writing 22 → 23, the same\nbyte the original moves in compare mode) and R0 has **0 undeclared writes in 0 calls**. The counter\nmatters for the *next* completion, not for this save.\n\n### 4.5 P6 held: the residual is `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`, entirely\n\nR1's **16** leaves, every one of them named, with nothing left over:\n\n| leaf | what it is | modelled by `ours`? |\n|---|---|---|\n| `Player[32]/OutMod` `1.25 → 1.1` | a tech effect | no — B2's milestone |\n| `Player[32]/ConMod[0..2]` `0.9 → 1.0` (×3) | tech effects | no — B2's milestone |\n| `Player[32]/Events/EvNxID` `7 → 5` | the two events not posted | decision modelled, **write is compare-only** |\n| `…/Events/.[EvTurn=4]/Events/.[EvEID=5]`, `.[EvEID=6]` `only-in-A` | the two event records | text comes from the game's string table |\n| `…/Events/.[EvTurn=4]/Events/.[0]` `3 → 1` | that turn's event count | ditto |\n| `Player[32]/otch/.[11]` `only-in-A`, `otch/.[0]` `11 → 10` | the `ObservedTech` element | append **decided** (`otch_appends=1`), element not constructed |\n| `Player[32]/ResTNm` `'' → 'IND_Waldo'` | `ResT` never cleared | inside the callback |\n| `Player[32]/BnkPr`, `BnkEl` | bankruptcy projection | **downstream of `OutMod`** |\n| `Sys[288 \"Ke'Dolarra\"]/RepCur`, `RepMax` `421640 → 371040` | repair capacity | **downstream of `ConMod`** |\n| `/Summary/Checksum` | derived | derived |\n\nSo the residual decomposes into **5 primary player fields** (`OutMod`, `ConMod[0..2]`, `ResTNm`),\n**1 `ObservedTech` element**, **2 event records + their id counter**, and **5 derived leaves** that\nfollow from those. Every single one is written by `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`, none of them by\n`TechTree::ProcessResearch` or by `SetResearched`.\n\nThat also closes the loop with §4.2's guard: the four `player` spans the compare reported as\nundeclared (`+0x10c`, `+0x110`, `+0x114`, `+0x124`, all three bytes wide — float writes whose top\nbyte did not change) plus `+0x294` (`ResT`, four bytes) are **five** writes, and the save shows\n**five** primary player fields. The guard was reporting exactly what the oracle later billed us for.\n\n**The input class that breaks it is a completion, and only a completion.** Both replace runs are\nbyte-perfect on the two null calls and on every other leaf of the 128 the turn moves. A replace run\nover a turn where research does not complete would be byte-identical — and would prove nothing\n(rule 1), which is why this lane refused to run it on `ref-turn2`.\n\n### 4.6 Coverage, reported as loudly as the result (rules 15 and 23)\n\n* **1 completion. 1 distinct tech (144 `IND_Waldo`). 3 unlocked nodes. 3 calls.**\n* **2 of the 3 calls allocate zero points and write nothing at all**, in any mode. Their entire\n  contribution to \"3 calls, 0 diverged\" is that two null calls stayed null.\n* **1 of 4 tech trees is exercised.** Player 16's tree is never processed (`ResTNm == ''`); players\n  496 and 512 are the null calls.\n* **The RNG region did not move on any call in any run.** The spend cap bound exactly, so the\n  odds/roll branch was skipped, and `roll_pending_in` was false on the completing call, so\n  `RollResearchEvent` drew nothing (`roll_draws=0`). **`region:rng` — the single strongest check in\n  this hook's compare — compared \"unchanged against unchanged\" on this workload and established\n  nothing.** The generator parity evidence for this module is entirely lane U's and lane V's,\n  on other turns.\n* **Branches that did not execute here:** the Zuul double roll (species 2, not 5); the\n  completed-early flag (`ratio 1.5`); the over-budget notification (`flag` already 2 from turn 3);\n  `RollResearchEvent`'s draw and, behind it, the plague / AI-rebellion paths; `SetResearched`'s\n  zero-cost recursion; the `def+0xb0` `NoAutoAvailable` skip; an empty prerequisite group; a\n  re-observed tech (the dedup's negative case); and the decay sweep, which ran over every node and\n  **changed nothing** because no other `Available` node had non-zero progress.\n* **The event model is count-only by construction** and stayed compare-only in replace mode by\n  design; the two missing records are two of the sixteen residual leaves.\n* **`TechTree::Cost` is the original's.** `ours` calls the game's read-only `Cost` for every cost it\n  needs, in both modes. The effective-cost formula is **not** displaced, and any claim about this\n  module inherits that dependency.\n\n### 4.7 Verdict\n\n**No. `game/sim/research` does not move from `compared` to `replaced`.**\n\nThe bar is \"our code ran instead of the original's **and a byte-level oracle held afterwards**\". Our\ncode did run instead — `mode=replace`, `completions=1`, `unlocked=3`, the original's\n`ProcessResearch` never executed, and the game finished the turn and wrote a save. The oracle did\n**not** hold: 16 leaves in the best configuration. There is no qualified reading that rescues it,\nbecause the failure is not a rounding residual — it is a set of writes nobody has implemented.\n\nWhat the lane did establish, and it is worth more than the rung would have been:\n\n1. **The research pass and the entire `SetResearched` cascade are displaceable and were displaced.**\n   All 13 tech-tree leaves the turn moves were produced by our code in live game memory, on a turn\n   with a real completion and a real three-node unlock cascade — which is a strictly stronger\n   statement than the 35 compared calls the board already carried, because in a compare the\n   original's code still did the work.\n2. **The blocking boundary is named and measured, not guessed:** `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`,\n   5 player fields + 1 `ObservedTech` element + 2 events, and 5 derived leaves behind them.\n   `ProcessResearch` **cannot** reach `replaced` on any workload containing a completion until\n   `OnTechResearched` is displaced — and that is B2's milestone and its own `compared` board row,\n   not a defect in the research model.\n3. **A new certified pair** on a turn that exercises the completion path, which the campaign did not\n   have: `ref-turn2` + one End Turn is a *quiet* turn for research, and every oracle the module had\n   been checked against was that one.\n\nThe cheapest route to the rung, now that the boundary is priced: implement the ~90-field\n`ApplyTechEffect` write-back live (B2 already has `game/effects/tech_effects` host-tested), construct\nthe `ObservedTech` element, and decide what to do about the two event records — whose *text* comes\nfrom the game's string table and therefore cannot be produced clean-room at all. **The event text is\na hard stop for a byte-identical oracle on any completion turn**, and that should be settled as a\npolicy question (call the game's `PostEvent`, and accept the `ComputeBudget`-shaped QUALIFIED\ncaveat) before anyone spends another lane on it.\n\n---\n\n## 5. Proposed board rows\n\n**I have not edited `campaign/board.md`.** I *have* added the certified pair to\n`verify/results/saves/certified-pairs.md`, which the brief pointed at as the standing format and\nwhose four standing rules for adding a row are all satisfied (two fresh `hooks=off` processes; the\ncontrol run before anything was read from an instrumented run; not an extension of an existing pair\nbut its own agreement; exposure facts recorded beside the hashes).\n\n### 5.1 `tools/displacement.py` — the rung does NOT move\n\nThe verdict is **no**, so `\"compared\"` stays. What I do propose is replacing the evidence and caveat\nstrings, which currently understate what is known and do not name the gate:\n\n```python\n    (\"TechTree::ProcessResearch + unlock cascade\", \"compared\",\n     \"35 calls across 3 workloads, 0 divergences, tracecmp exit 0; advance prediction held on a \"\n     \"changed workload (unlock costs no earlier report contained); REPLACE ATTEMPTED live (lane \"\n     \"CR): ours ran instead of the original on a real completion and produced all 13 tech-tree \"\n     \"leaves the turn moves, but the save oracle missed by 16 leaves\",\n     \"compare only. The replace attempt failed on ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched, not on the \"\n     \"research model: 5 player tech-effect fields, 1 ObservedTech element and 2 event records, \"\n     \"plus 5 derived leaves. Gated on B2. Thin: 1 completion, 1 tech, 2 of 3 calls allocate zero \"\n     \"points, and the RNG region did not move at all on the replace workload\"),\n```\n\n### 5.2 Board rows to add\n\n| row | class | status | conf | cov | date | evidence |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| **`ProcessResearch` replace: our code ran instead of the original's, and the oracle missed by 16 leaves — all of them `OnTechResearched`'s** | phase2 | verified | high | 95% | 2026-09-09 | **Lane CR, VM145**, `findings/subsystems/research-replace.md`. Predictions committed before the build (`sots-re` 4b3cc82); engine `wip/cr` 618ccb1 adds `research.replace_cascade=on\\|off` (default off) so the shipped and extended behaviours differ by **a config line, not a binary**. New certified pair `turn3-state.sav` → one End Turn, **load** route, `e00eed0c…`/`79df5047…`, 2 `hooks=off` processes + 1 compare. Compare run **3/3/0 exit 0** and byte-identical to the control (rule 19 satisfied), undeclared writes exactly the 6 predicted spans. **Replace, cascade on: 16 diverging leaves; cascade off: 27.** The 11-leaf delta is the whole `SetResearched` cascade and it is **ours**; with the pass's own 2 words that is **13 of 13 tech-tree leaves the turn moves, produced live by our code**. The 16 residual leaves are `OutMod`, `ConMod[0..2]`, `ResTNm`, one `ObservedTech` element, two event records + `EvNxID`, and 5 derived. **Verdict: stays `compared`.** |\n| **`ref-turn2` + one End Turn does NOT exercise a research completion** | verify | verified | high | 100% | 2026-09-09 | Lane CR. The campaign's most-reproduced oracle is a **quiet turn for the completion path**: `unlock-b3-t1.md` reports `0 undeclared write(s) in 0 call(s)` and `unlock-shim.log`'s first three lines read `completions=0`. It *is* a real workload for the pass (one RNG word, `flag 1 → 2`, one over-budget event) — but a replace-mode oracle taken there would be rule 1's green verdict on a hook comparing nothing. The completing turn is the **next** one, from `turn3-state.sav`. |\n| **`# exhaustive` is exhaustive over the 27 template hooks only — six detours are installed, not one** | phase2 | verified | high | 100% | 2026-09-09 | Lane CR. A config naming all 27 registered hooks `off` except one, passing `tools/check_shim_configs.py`, still installs **6** detours: the M0 `Application::Initialize` asm stub (unconditional whenever `hooks != off`) and the **FPU-force module's four sampling detours** (`force=off value=0x0000 sample_ticks=on sample_turn=on`, on by default). `check_shim_configs.py` cannot see either group — no `hook.` key names them. What made lane CR's runs safe was the **neutrality check** (compare run byte-identical to two `hooks=off` controls), not the config check. A lane reading \"exhaustive, therefore one detour\" is wrong by five. |\n| **A replace of `ProcessResearch` is gated on `ServerPlayer::OnTechResearched`, and partly on a policy question** | phase2 | open | high | – | 2026-09-09 | Lane CR. To reach `replaced`, three things are needed: the ~90-field tech-effect write-back applied live (B2 has `game/effects/tech_effects` host-tested), the `ObservedTech` element constructed (`ours` already decides the append), and the two research event **records** written. The third is not an implementation gap: their `EvDsc`/`EvMsg` text comes from the game's string table, which the engine must not carry, so a byte-identical oracle on any completion turn requires calling the game's own `PostEvent` and accepting a `ComputeBudget`-shaped **QUALIFIED** `replaced`. Settle that before spending a lane. |\n\n### 5.3 Artefacts\n\n| what | where |\n|---|---|\n| predictions commit (before the build) | `sots-re` `4b3cc82` |\n| engine change | `sots-engine` worktree `wip/cr`, `618ccb1` — `research.replace_cascade`, a mode-independent completion counter, four `shim.cfg.cr*` configs |\n| oracle + replace saves | `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-{oracle-endturn,oracle-autosave,replace0-autosave,replace1-autosave}.sav` |\n| traces | `verify/traces/cr-{N,R0,R1}.jsonl.gz` |\n| `tracecmp` reports | `verify/results/compare/cr-{compare,replace0,replace1}.{md,json}` |\n| shim logs (the per-call counters) | `verify/results/shim/cr/cr-{N,R0,R1}.log` |\n| certified pair | `verify/results/saves/certified-pairs.md`, row 4 |\n\nNo `ghidra/addresses.d/cr.json`: this lane read no new address. No game data, save, disassembly or\n`FUN_xxxxxxxx` name reached `sots-engine`; `tools/clean_room_check.sh` OK.\n\n### 5.4 VM145 released\n\nHeld for this lane only; **VM140 untouched**. Restored and verified byte-for-byte to as-found:\n\n```\nbinkw32.dll  15,527,327 B  903527F4A698EEA9FBE25F3A6236657C7D8348F994EEF394696F187E5E554B97  (= shimdist-recap)\nshim.cfg                   0AE410CC72FE155837D711C78543E14B1F5743310CD023298EB1E5BBD5457E71  (= shimdist-recap\\shim.cfg.recaptrace)\nSavedGames   the same 9 files, every size and sha256 identical to the as-found survey\ngame         not running (as found)\n```\n\nLeft behind: `C:\\SOTS\\shimdist-cr\\`, `C:\\SOTS\\ui\\cr\\` (the input save, the four run outputs and the\nrestore set) and `C:\\SOTS\\ui\\cr{deploy,click,grab,snap,restore,find}.ps1`. `click_helper.ps1` is\nunmodified. **One thing not restored:** my deploy helper *deletes* `C:\\SOTS\\shim.log` rather than\nrotating it to `.prev` the way lane BQ's does, so whatever log was there when I took the guest is\ngone. Logs are not simulation state and no measurement depends on it, but the next lane should\nrotate rather than delete.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":558,"totalLines":558,"truncated":false}},"title":"findings/subsystems/research-replace.md","time":{"start":1788999283729,"end":1788999283764}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06b0ec8f46a6a6c1016aa1f673932c87d1aa14c14fc599f39e"}},"id":"prt_088aab40d0015ou3El0Fjb5iJ7","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa8934001dgcS8BMiH22ty9"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999283775,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_8o9uRje2Yku2ySuvlAUyctpc","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Proposed pilot: completion-bearing research replacement\n2: \n3: Status: **proposed**. This is a contract design, not replacement acceptance. Owner/authority:\n4: openai/gpt-6-astra; subsequent implementation and independent verification use the campaign roles.\n5: The target is a bounded replacement of `Game::TechTree::ProcessResearch`, its `SetResearched`\n6: cascade and required completion callback writes on explicitly certified workloads. Broad research\n7: displacement remains unproved. No new live address, remote deployment or dependency policy is\n8: authorized by this document.\n9: \n10: ## 1. Evidence inspected independently (2026-09-09)\n11: \n12: Sources: `findings/subsystems/research-replace.md`; archived CR compare JSON, raw compressed\n13: traces, shim logs and saves; current engine research, tech-effect and event interfaces. Archived\n14: engine build is `cr-618ccb1-20260909T131556Z`, not the rollout's current source snapshot.\n15: \n16: Recomputed SHA-256:\n17: \n18: | RE-relative file | bytes | SHA-256 |\n19: |---|---:|---|\n20: | `verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav` | 67219 | `978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921` |\n21: | `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-endturn.sav` | 67212 | `e00eed0c03a31d27a81b7470a9dcc9ba08a2ac48c20baeee4f34749164743e3f` |\n22: | `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-autosave.sav` | 67811 | `79df50475a7b83afa927d992b9f030dcf45710f4bda0133b8b1fa4800a72e420` |\n23: | `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-replace0-autosave.sav` | 67511 | `6b51db992b158caa5424d71b2dccf72924af7198b4165bfcfc870e0d438fb6d5` |\n24: | `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-replace1-autosave.sav` | 67537 | `8a4309ee4fe0b3177a2820600b5016c7c256d0f51b065df469ecd0b4f2342235` |\n25: \n26: Local reproduction (diagnostic tool exit alone is not an equality verdict):\n27: \n28: ```sh\n29: python3 verify/state-checksum/state_checksum.py verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-autosave.sav verify/results/saves/cr/cr-replace1-autosave.sav --limit 40\n30: ```\n31: \n32: This reports **16** exact-bit, unmasked leaf differences. Oracle -> R1: OutMod 1.25 -> 1.1;\n33: ConMod[0..2] 0.9 -> 1; ResTNm empty -> IND_Waldo; EvNxID 7 -> 5; events 5/6 absent and\n34: turn-bucket count 3 -> 1; observed-tech element 11 absent and count 11 -> 10; BnkPr/BnkEl,\n35: RepCur/RepMax and Summary.Checksum differ. These are five primary scalar fields, collection\n36: writes/counts and five derived leaves. They are not permission to patch five downstream values.\n37: \n38: `verify/results/compare/cr-compare.json:289-357` reports partial coverage: three comparisons,\n39: six undeclared spans in one call and eight unmodelled notes. In\n40: `verify/traces/cr-R1.jsonl.gz`, call 1 is replace, allocation tech 144 / 2898, input turn 4,\n41: order counter 22, observed count 10, roll_pending false, RNG left 413 and CW 4735 (`0x127f`).\n42: Its RNG digest/index/left are unchanged. Logs `verify/results/shim/cr/cr-R1.log:116-118`\n43: count one completion and three unlocks, then two zero-point calls. `otch_appends=1` counts a\n44: decision; it does **not** mean an element was constructed live.\n45: \n46: ### Corrections to inherited narrative\n47: \n48: 1. R1 log lines 75-94 show seven drawsite detours and twelve probes in addition to the six\n49:    sites enumerated in CR findings. Instrumentation is broader than the template-hook config.\n50:    Every fresh run needs a complete installed-site manifest, not an “exhaustive config” assertion.\n51: 2. R1 runtime CW is `0x127f`, including the research trace argument; initialization prints\n52:    `0x027f`. Preserve the full measured word and precision/rounding separately.\n53: 3. Runtime string lookup is already an engine interface (`research_events.h:95-105`,\n54:    `app/event_phase.cpp:10-14`). The absence of bundled game prose does not establish that\n55:    original `PostEvent` is mandatory. Runtime asset loading is a concrete route to investigate.\n56: 4. `shim/hooks/tech_effects.cpp:354-365` already writes player state/design masks and delegates\n57:    node-bore updates in replace mode. The research hook does not integrate that complete callback;\n58:    calling the helper “host-tested” is not evidence its full live boundary is implemented.\n59: \n60: ## 2. Workloads and access paths\n61: \n62: ### W1 — primary positive workload, exact LOAD route\n63: \n64: On a future explicitly leased lab with operator-supplied executable/data paths: restore the\n65: hashed turn3 input as the only selected input save; start a fresh process; use Load Game, select\n66: the input, enter its lobby/map at Turn 3, then one End Turn to Turn 4. Verify UI/state transitions\n67: rather than sleep-and-assume. Preserve both output saves before any reset. Bind save selection,\n68: route, process identity, executable hash, assets, shim hash, config and instrumentation to evidence.\n69: \n70: Historical predictions to re-certify before measuring candidate results:\n71: - Exactly three research calls, owners 32/496/512 in order, allocations 144:2898, 90:0, 9:0.\n72: - One IND_Waldo completion: progress 5768 -> 7500, state 3 -> 4, turn_researched -1 -> 4,\n73:   order -1 -> 22, counter 22 -> 23, refund 1166. Flag unchanged.\n74: - Nodes 132/136/142 unlock, costs 10000/16000/8000, available turn 4. Save tree slots are\n75:   94/98/104; tech 144 is slot 106. Never equate tech id with serialized slot.\n76: - One full ObservedTech record, two full events (completion followed by unlocked-techs),\n77:   event next id 5 -> 7; primary effect fields reach oracle values; target clears.\n78: - Zero RNG words in this workload. This is a negative RNG control, not evidence for draws.\n79: \n80: ### W0 — regression control, insufficient for completion acceptance\n81: \n82: `verify/results/saves/turn2-state.sav`, one End Turn via LOAD, reaches the turn3 input above.\n83: This exercises the research pass/overbudget event and a RNG word, but zero completions. Re-certify\n84: its two-process oracle independently and pin its input hash before use. Do not substitute W0\n85: for W1, or use zero-allocation calls as the positive execution threshold.\n86: \n87: ### W2 — path to broader completion evidence (not yet certified)\n88: \n89: Select a different, archived completion-bearing input from the unlock continuations, or generate\n90: one under an approved lab contract; record the input hash and exact LOAD/continuation route before\n91: prediction. Require a different tech/effect family, a positive RNG draw and a second completion\n92: that observes the advanced order counter. The existing U/V evidence motivates selection but is\n93: not a ready executable workload contract. Separate controls are required for that exact route.\n94: Until W2 exists, any accepted pilot claim is restricted to W1 plus its declared regression checks.\n95: \n96: ## 3. Full write boundary and responsibilities\n97: \n98: | Boundary | Required state / behavior | Existing interface and current gap |\n99: |---|---|---|\n100: | Research pass | all node progress/state/flag writes; signed capped spend and refund accumulator; decay of other Available nodes; RNG state, left and next index | `sim::ProcessResearchTurn`, `ResearchCompletionHook`; current CR pass writes live |\n101: | Unlock cascade | node costRP, availability/researched turn, order; tree order counter; child/prerequisite availability; recursive zero-cost completions and ordering | `sim::TechGraph` / `SetResearched`; replace cascade opt-in exists, transcription failures can currently skip it |\n102: | Completion callback | target pointer/ResTNm; pending-roll flags; every applicable player economy float, masks, boolean/species flags, design-option masks; node-bore storage/lifetime | `ApplyTechCompletion`, `RunCompletionTail`, `tfx::ReadPlayerState`/`WritePlayerState`; integrate with research on pre-call inputs, avoid already-researched guard |\n103: | Observed technology | dedup/update semantics, entire 0x2c record (name, first/last turns, detected, with), vector content/count/capacity and allocator ownership | research hook currently alters scratch span only; full live construction and update semantics need evidence |\n104: | Events | complete turn buckets and ordered records: id, summary, message, location, position, image, action, chainId; next id; dedup and pruning; all owned allocations | `events::EventStorage`, `PostResearchPassEvents`; research hook is count-only/compare-only; runtime text and live ABI adapter missing |\n105: | Callback outcomes beyond player | owned-system AI flags/caps/addiction/plague; ships' plague state; recursive Zuul tech grants; pending research-event RNG and plague/rebellion consequences including allocations/cancel research | `TechApplyOutcome` reports work, does not execute it; broader closure remains incomplete |\n106: | Downstream observation | budget/bankruptcy/repair/checksum consequences of primary effects | let ordinary turn processing derive them; full oracle must expose them, never harvest original post-state or hardcode expected leaves |\n107: \n108: The W1 observed write set is a subset of this boundary. The complete callback has conditional\n109: system/ship/object writes absent on W1. A narrow pilot must preflight its supported class and\n110: fail closed before mutating on unsupported branches. Suppressed writes, unavailable graph/text,\n111: unknown pointers, unreadable names, failed allocation, or unmodelled fired rolls are blockers,\n112: not successful no-ops. General displacement requires separate evidence for all reachable effects.\n113: \n114: Events require exact formatting/dedup order, `FLT_MAX` no-position values, action conversion,\n115: the original prune-window behavior and preexisting event contents. `KeylessEventText` substitutes\n116: tokens for prose and must never be serialized as a passing oracle. Completion message length\n117: above 255 has an explicitly documented divergence/undefined-original boundary; exclude or resolve\n118: it explicitly. Seed comparisons from pre-call state, not the original callback's output.\n119: \n120: ## 4. Inputs and original dependencies\n121: \n122: Required immutable input manifest before ready:\n123: - Exact engine and RE baseline commits plus actual source-content hashes; paired worktrees;\n124:   compiler/toolchain/build flags, host and shim binaries, generated-address provenance.\n125: - The hashed W1 input and oracle archive above, plus selected W0/W2 inputs as applicable.\n126: - Operator-owned game executable and proxy originals with hashes. The archived trace reports exe\n127:   SHA-256 `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`; remeasure it.\n128: - Explicit runtime data root, manifest of tech definitions/graph, tuning/constants/species inputs,\n129:   localized string-table files and locale/encoding/load order. Existing parser data must come\n130:   from user assets, not copies of game prose embedded in source. Missing table/key is not empty text\n131:   for acceptance. Asset paths and hashes are not yet supplied for this pilot.\n132: - Full configs and actually installed interceptors (template hooks, init, FPU sampling, probes,\n133:   drawsites), FPU CW per call, input route/process-reset record, output/log/trace file hashes.\n134: \n135: Original dependency ledger (each needs a lead decision and explicit qualification):\n136: 1. **Existing:** research calls original `TechTree::Cost` for effective cost and cascade cost\n137:    lookup (`shim/hooks/research.cpp:568-573,916-919`). Formula and applicable bonus-tech discovery\n138:    are not displaced by this pilot merely because a host formula exists.\n139: 2. **Existing separate B2 hook:** original has-researched lookup and node-bore updater\n140:    (`tech_effects.cpp:325-328,358-365`). Node-bore updater allocates/frees state; it is not\n141:    read-only despite the source comment's analogy. Reuse requires disclosure and effect accounting.\n142: 3. **Proposed, undecided:** original string lookup / allocator / event posting helpers versus a\n143:    runtime-asset text adapter and compatible live allocation. No selected policy or guessed address.\n144: 4. **Outside replaced root:** original turn driver, budget allocator and remaining simulation,\n145:    asset loading and save serializer still run in the shim experiment. Whole standalone turn\n146:    equality is a different acceptance axis and cannot be inferred from this partial replacement.\n147: \n148: ## 5. Executable acceptance to provide before ready\n149: \n150: The contract must eventually name real, versioned commands and dependencies for this sequence;\n151: the following are precise requirements, not a presently implemented runner:\n152: \n153: 1. Fresh full gate on hashed source/inputs, expected test identities, positive corpus execution,\n154:    asset-dependent tests and shim build. A host-only pass is insufficient. Bind full gate manifest\n155:    and resulting binary to every experiment and reject source/input changes.\n156: 2. Two fresh-process C1/C2 controls with hooks off, same proxy, input, assets and exact W1 route;\n157:    both output pairs equal byte-for-byte. Archive independent process logs; one saved oracle\n158:    copy is not independent proof that two processes agreed.\n159: 3. Compare-neutral N with the candidate binary and complete instrumentation manifest; both\n160:    output saves byte-equal controls; positive W1 counters and decoded state. Zero compared calls,\n161:    partial required-region coverage or undeclared required writes cannot pass.\n162: 4. Replace R, same baseline and binary, bypass original ProcessResearch and required displaced\n163:    callback implementation (count explicit original helper calls separately). Require exactly\n164:    one W1 completion/three unlocks, real element/event writes, zero failures/unreadable inputs,\n165:    and full declared state validation including nonserialized order counter and RNG state.\n166: 5. Require **post-turn** autosave byte equality, inflated equality and exact-bit unmasked state\n167:    equality independently, with reader reconstruction coverage. Pre-turn EndTurn equality alone\n168:    cannot satisfy acceptance. No masks for event text, callback fields or derived discrepancies.\n169: 6. Negative controls must fail: archived R0 (27 differences) and R1 (16); zero-completion W0\n170:    cannot satisfy W1 threshold; omit callback/event/ObservedTech write or use wrong input hash;\n171:    remove a trace/log/output; mark unknown RNG as zero. Checker rejects all.\n172: 7. Independently assigned verifier re-runs the checks and ties verdict to contract, source,\n173:    binary, asset and evidence digests. Implementation worker cannot self-certify acceptance.\n174:    Integration requires revalidation of integrated source; changed inputs invalidate evidence.\n175: \n176: W2 and branch-specific tests must be added before expanding the claim to RNG-consuming,\n177: Zuul/early-completion, nonzero-decay, zero-cost recursion, prerequisite/no-auto-available,\n178: re-observed/deduplicated, temperance, plague or rebellion cases. Their absence is visible coverage\n179: debt, not satisfied execution. Local simulation tests alone do not establish live allocator safety.\n180: \n181: ## 6. Current blockers / stop conditions\n182: \n183: - No executable pilot-specific acceptance runner or full input/asset manifest, and no certified W2.\n184: - Live research callback integration, complete ObservedTech/event construction, broader callback\n185:   outcomes and unsupported-path preflight remain unimplemented/unverified.\n186: - Original Cost dependence and allocator/text/PostEvent policy require recorded Astra decisions.\n187: - Archived C1/C2 equality is documented but independent raw control-run bundles are not established\n188:   by the single oracle pair inspected here. Fresh controls are mandatory.\n189: - Instrumentation and runtime FPU narrative need correction in acceptance inputs; archives are\n190:   historical observations, not the current candidate's attestation.\n191: - Stop on control disagreement, silent fallback, missing data, branch outside approved class,\n192:   unexpected writes/draws, stale evidence, source drift, or scope/architecture surprises; persist\n193:   checkpoint and escalate to Astra before changing the contract.\n194: \n195: This proposal authorizes planning only. Keep lifecycle **proposed** until required dependencies,\n196: input manifests, bounded implementation scope and executable acceptance exist.\n\n(End of file - total 196 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Proposed pilot: completion-bearing research replacement\n\nStatus: **proposed**. This is a contract design, not replacement acceptance. Owner/authority:\nopenai/gpt-6-astra; subsequent implementation and independent verification use the campaign roles.\nThe target is a bounded replacement of `Game::TechTree::ProcessResearch`, its `SetResearched`\ncascade and required completion callback writes on explicitly certified workloads. Broad research\ndisplacement remains unproved. No new live address, remote deployment or dependency policy is\nauthorized by this document.\n\n## 1. Evidence inspected independently (2026-09-09)\n\nSources: `findings/subsystems/research-replace.md`; archived CR compare JSON, raw compressed\ntraces, shim logs and saves; current engine research, tech-effect and event interfaces. Archived\nengine build is `cr-618ccb1-20260909T131556Z`, not the rollout's current source snapshot.\n\nRecomputed SHA-256:\n\n| RE-relative file | bytes | SHA-256 |\n|---|---:|---|\n| `verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav` | 67219 | `978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921` |","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md","text":"# Proposed pilot: completion-bearing research replacement\n\nStatus: **proposed**. This is a contract design, not replacement acceptance. Owner/authority:\nopenai/gpt-6-astra; subsequent implementation and independent verification use the campaign roles.\nThe target is a bounded replacement of `Game::TechTree::ProcessResearch`, its `SetResearched`\ncascade and required completion callback writes on explicitly certified workloads. Broad research\ndisplacement remains unproved. No new live address, remote deployment or dependency policy is\nauthorized by this document.\n\n## 1. Evidence inspected independently (2026-09-09)\n\nSources: `findings/subsystems/research-replace.md`; archived CR compare JSON, raw compressed\ntraces, shim logs and saves; current engine research, tech-effect and event interfaces. Archived\nengine build is `cr-618ccb1-20260909T131556Z`, not the rollout's current source snapshot.\n\nRecomputed SHA-256:\n\n| RE-relative file | bytes | SHA-256 |\n|---|---:|---|\n| `verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav` | 67219 | `978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921` |\n| `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-endturn.sav` | 67212 | `e00eed0c03a31d27a81b7470a9dcc9ba08a2ac48c20baeee4f34749164743e3f` |\n| `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-autosave.sav` | 67811 | `79df50475a7b83afa927d992b9f030dcf45710f4bda0133b8b1fa4800a72e420` |\n| `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-replace0-autosave.sav` | 67511 | `6b51db992b158caa5424d71b2dccf72924af7198b4165bfcfc870e0d438fb6d5` |\n| `verify/results/saves/cr/cr-replace1-autosave.sav` | 67537 | `8a4309ee4fe0b3177a2820600b5016c7c256d0f51b065df469ecd0b4f2342235` |\n\nLocal reproduction (diagnostic tool exit alone is not an equality verdict):\n\n```sh\npython3 verify/state-checksum/state_checksum.py verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-autosave.sav verify/results/saves/cr/cr-replace1-autosave.sav --limit 40\n```\n\nThis reports **16** exact-bit, unmasked leaf differences. Oracle -> R1: OutMod 1.25 -> 1.1;\nConMod[0..2] 0.9 -> 1; ResTNm empty -> IND_Waldo; EvNxID 7 -> 5; events 5/6 absent and\nturn-bucket count 3 -> 1; observed-tech element 11 absent and count 11 -> 10; BnkPr/BnkEl,\nRepCur/RepMax and Summary.Checksum differ. These are five primary scalar fields, collection\nwrites/counts and five derived leaves. They are not permission to patch five downstream values.\n\n`verify/results/compare/cr-compare.json:289-357` reports partial coverage: three comparisons,\nsix undeclared spans in one call and eight unmodelled notes. In\n`verify/traces/cr-R1.jsonl.gz`, call 1 is replace, allocation tech 144 / 2898, input turn 4,\norder counter 22, observed count 10, roll_pending false, RNG left 413 and CW 4735 (`0x127f`).\nIts RNG digest/index/left are unchanged. Logs `verify/results/shim/cr/cr-R1.log:116-118`\ncount one completion and three unlocks, then two zero-point calls. `otch_appends=1` counts a\ndecision; it does **not** mean an element was constructed live.\n\n### Corrections to inherited narrative\n\n1. R1 log lines 75-94 show seven drawsite detours and twelve probes in addition to the six\n   sites enumerated in CR findings. Instrumentation is broader than the template-hook config.\n   Every fresh run needs a complete installed-site manifest, not an “exhaustive config” assertion.\n2. R1 runtime CW is `0x127f`, including the research trace argument; initialization prints\n   `0x027f`. Preserve the full measured word and precision/rounding separately.\n3. Runtime string lookup is already an engine interface (`research_events.h:95-105`,\n   `app/event_phase.cpp:10-14`). The absence of bundled game prose does not establish that\n   original `PostEvent` is mandatory. Runtime asset loading is a concrete route to investigate.\n4. `shim/hooks/tech_effects.cpp:354-365` already writes player state/design masks and delegates\n   node-bore updates in replace mode. The research hook does not integrate that complete callback;\n   calling the helper “host-tested” is not evidence its full live boundary is implemented.\n\n## 2. Workloads and access paths\n\n### W1 — primary positive workload, exact LOAD route\n\nOn a future explicitly leased lab with operator-supplied executable/data paths: restore the\nhashed turn3 input as the only selected input save; start a fresh process; use Load Game, select\nthe input, enter its lobby/map at Turn 3, then one End Turn to Turn 4. Verify UI/state transitions\nrather than sleep-and-assume. Preserve both output saves before any reset. Bind save selection,\nroute, process identity, executable hash, assets, shim hash, config and instrumentation to evidence.\n\nHistorical predictions to re-certify before measuring candidate results:\n- Exactly three research calls, owners 32/496/512 in order, allocations 144:2898, 90:0, 9:0.\n- One IND_Waldo completion: progress 5768 -> 7500, state 3 -> 4, turn_researched -1 -> 4,\n  order -1 -> 22, counter 22 -> 23, refund 1166. Flag unchanged.\n- Nodes 132/136/142 unlock, costs 10000/16000/8000, available turn 4. Save tree slots are\n  94/98/104; tech 144 is slot 106. Never equate tech id with serialized slot.\n- One full ObservedTech record, two full events (completion followed by unlocked-techs),\n  event next id 5 -> 7; primary effect fields reach oracle values; target clears.\n- Zero RNG words in this workload. This is a negative RNG control, not evidence for draws.\n\n### W0 — regression control, insufficient for completion acceptance\n\n`verify/results/saves/turn2-state.sav`, one End Turn via LOAD, reaches the turn3 input above.\nThis exercises the research pass/overbudget event and a RNG word, but zero completions. Re-certify\nits two-process oracle independently and pin its input hash before use. Do not substitute W0\nfor W1, or use zero-allocation calls as the positive execution threshold.\n\n### W2 — path to broader completion evidence (not yet certified)\n\nSelect a different, archived completion-bearing input from the unlock continuations, or generate\none under an approved lab contract; record the input hash and exact LOAD/continuation route before\nprediction. Require a different tech/effect family, a positive RNG draw and a second completion\nthat observes the advanced order counter. The existing U/V evidence motivates selection but is\nnot a ready executable workload contract. Separate controls are required for that exact route.\nUntil W2 exists, any accepted pilot claim is restricted to W1 plus its declared regression checks.\n\n## 3. Full write boundary and responsibilities\n\n| Boundary | Required state / behavior | Existing interface and current gap |\n|---|---|---|\n| Research pass | all node progress/state/flag writes; signed capped spend and refund accumulator; decay of other Available nodes; RNG state, left and next index | `sim::ProcessResearchTurn`, `ResearchCompletionHook`; current CR pass writes live |\n| Unlock cascade | node costRP, availability/researched turn, order; tree order counter; child/prerequisite availability; recursive zero-cost completions and ordering | `sim::TechGraph` / `SetResearched`; replace cascade opt-in exists, transcription failures can currently skip it |\n| Completion callback | target pointer/ResTNm; pending-roll flags; every applicable player economy float, masks, boolean/species flags, design-option masks; node-bore storage/lifetime | `ApplyTechCompletion`, `RunCompletionTail`, `tfx::ReadPlayerState`/`WritePlayerState`; integrate with research on pre-call inputs, avoid already-researched guard |\n| Observed technology | dedup/update semantics, entire 0x2c record (name, first/last turns, detected, with), vector content/count/capacity and allocator ownership | research hook currently alters scratch span only; full live construction and update semantics need evidence |\n| Events | complete turn buckets and ordered records: id, summary, message, location, position, image, action, chainId; next id; dedup and pruning; all owned allocations | `events::EventStorage`, `PostResearchPassEvents`; research hook is count-only/compare-only; runtime text and live ABI adapter missing |\n| Callback outcomes beyond player | owned-system AI flags/caps/addiction/plague; ships' plague state; recursive Zuul tech grants; pending research-event RNG and plague/rebellion consequences including allocations/cancel research | `TechApplyOutcome` reports work, does not execute it; broader closure remains incomplete |\n| Downstream observation | budget/bankruptcy/repair/checksum consequences of primary effects | let ordinary turn processing derive them; full oracle must expose them, never harvest original post-state or hardcode expected leaves |\n\nThe W1 observed write set is a subset of this boundary. The complete callback has conditional\nsystem/ship/object writes absent on W1. A narrow pilot must preflight its supported class and\nfail closed before mutating on unsupported branches. Suppressed writes, unavailable graph/text,\nunknown pointers, unreadable names, failed allocation, or unmodelled fired rolls are blockers,\nnot successful no-ops. General displacement requires separate evidence for all reachable effects.\n\nEvents require exact formatting/dedup order, `FLT_MAX` no-position values, action conversion,\nthe original prune-window behavior and preexisting event contents. `KeylessEventText` substitutes\ntokens for prose and must never be serialized as a passing oracle. Completion message length\nabove 255 has an explicitly documented divergence/undefined-original boundary; exclude or resolve\nit explicitly. Seed comparisons from pre-call state, not the original callback's output.\n\n## 4. Inputs and original dependencies\n\nRequired immutable input manifest before ready:\n- Exact engine and RE baseline commits plus actual source-content hashes; paired worktrees;\n  compiler/toolchain/build flags, host and shim binaries, generated-address provenance.\n- The hashed W1 input and oracle archive above, plus selected W0/W2 inputs as applicable.\n- Operator-owned game executable and proxy originals with hashes. The archived trace reports exe\n  SHA-256 `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`; remeasure it.\n- Explicit runtime data root, manifest of tech definitions/graph, tuning/constants/species inputs,\n  localized string-table files and locale/encoding/load order. Existing parser data must come\n  from user assets, not copies of game prose embedded in source. Missing table/key is not empty text\n  for acceptance. Asset paths and hashes are not yet supplied for this pilot.\n- Full configs and actually installed interceptors (template hooks, init, FPU sampling, probes,\n  drawsites), FPU CW per call, input route/process-reset record, output/log/trace file hashes.\n\nOriginal dependency ledger (each needs a lead decision and explicit qualification):\n1. **Existing:** research calls original `TechTree::Cost` for effective cost and cascade cost\n   lookup (`shim/hooks/research.cpp:568-573,916-919`). Formula and applicable bonus-tech discovery\n   are not displaced by this pilot merely because a host formula exists.\n2. **Existing separate B2 hook:** original has-researched lookup and node-bore updater\n   (`tech_effects.cpp:325-328,358-365`). Node-bore updater allocates/frees state; it is not\n   read-only despite the source comment's analogy. Reuse requires disclosure and effect accounting.\n3. **Proposed, undecided:** original string lookup / allocator / event posting helpers versus a\n   runtime-asset text adapter and compatible live allocation. No selected policy or guessed address.\n4. **Outside replaced root:** original turn driver, budget allocator and remaining simulation,\n   asset loading and save serializer still run in the shim experiment. Whole standalone turn\n   equality is a different acceptance axis and cannot be inferred from this partial replacement.\n\n## 5. Executable acceptance to provide before ready\n\nThe contract must eventually name real, versioned commands and dependencies for this sequence;\nthe following are precise requirements, not a presently implemented runner:\n\n1. Fresh full gate on hashed source/inputs, expected test identities, positive corpus execution,\n   asset-dependent tests and shim build. A host-only pass is insufficient. Bind full gate manifest\n   and resulting binary to every experiment and reject source/input changes.\n2. Two fresh-process C1/C2 controls with hooks off, same proxy, input, assets and exact W1 route;\n   both output pairs equal byte-for-byte. Archive independent process logs; one saved oracle\n   copy is not independent proof that two processes agreed.\n3. Compare-neutral N with the candidate binary and complete instrumentation manifest; both\n   output saves byte-equal controls; positive W1 counters and decoded state. Zero compared calls,\n   partial required-region coverage or undeclared required writes cannot pass.\n4. Replace R, same baseline and binary, bypass original ProcessResearch and required displaced\n   callback implementation (count explicit original helper calls separately). Require exactly\n   one W1 completion/three unlocks, real element/event writes, zero failures/unreadable inputs,\n   and full declared state validation including nonserialized order counter and RNG state.\n5. Require **post-turn** autosave byte equality, inflated equality and exact-bit unmasked state\n   equality independently, with reader reconstruction coverage. Pre-turn EndTurn equality alone\n   cannot satisfy acceptance. No masks for event text, callback fields or derived discrepancies.\n6. Negative controls must fail: archived R0 (27 differences) and R1 (16); zero-completion W0\n   cannot satisfy W1 threshold; omit callback/event/ObservedTech write or use wrong input hash;\n   remove a trace/log/output; mark unknown RNG as zero. Checker rejects all.\n7. Independently assigned verifier re-runs the checks and ties verdict to contract, source,\n   binary, asset and evidence digests. Implementation worker cannot self-certify acceptance.\n   Integration requires revalidation of integrated source; changed inputs invalidate evidence.\n\nW2 and branch-specific tests must be added before expanding the claim to RNG-consuming,\nZuul/early-completion, nonzero-decay, zero-cost recursion, prerequisite/no-auto-available,\nre-observed/deduplicated, temperance, plague or rebellion cases. Their absence is visible coverage\ndebt, not satisfied execution. Local simulation tests alone do not establish live allocator safety.\n\n## 6. Current blockers / stop conditions\n\n- No executable pilot-specific acceptance runner or full input/asset manifest, and no certified W2.\n- Live research callback integration, complete ObservedTech/event construction, broader callback\n  outcomes and unsupported-path preflight remain unimplemented/unverified.\n- Original Cost dependence and allocator/text/PostEvent policy require recorded Astra decisions.\n- Archived C1/C2 equality is documented but independent raw control-run bundles are not established\n  by the single oracle pair inspected here. Fresh controls are mandatory.\n- Instrumentation and runtime FPU narrative need correction in acceptance inputs; archives are\n  historical observations, not the current candidate's attestation.\n- Stop on control disagreement, silent fallback, missing data, branch outside approved class,\n  unexpected writes/draws, stale evidence, source drift, or scope/architecture surprises; persist\n  checkpoint and escalate to Astra before changing the contract.\n\nThis proposal authorizes planning only. Keep lifecycle **proposed** until required dependencies,\ninput manifests, bounded implementation scope and executable acceptance exist.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":196,"totalLines":196,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md","time":{"start":1788999283734,"end":1788999283768}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06b0ec8f46a6a6c1016aa1f673933c87d1ae17e4bb56ba1214"}},"id":"prt_088aab412001GjDZNHIdHbT3L7","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa8934001dgcS8BMiH22ty9"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999283791,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_wtMs5zQUmpluvrNfoo4KXPD9","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"ls verify/results","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re"},"output":"compare\ndata-catalogs\nfpu-cw\nhousekeeping\nmultiplayer\nresearch-callback\nresearch-completion-abi\nsaves\nshim\nstandalone\nstate-checksum\nturncommands\n","metadata":{"output":"compare\ndata-catalogs\nfpu-cw\nhousekeeping\nmultiplayer\nresearch-callback\nresearch-completion-abi\nsaves\nshim\nstandalone\nstate-checksum\nturncommands\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"ls verify/results","time":{"start":1788999283710,"end":1788999283789}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06b0ec8f46a6a6c1016aa1f67392f887d1ac1c6bc11cea18da"}},"id":"prt_088aab3fa001E1e6G4pzodFn78","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aa8934001dgcS8BMiH22ty9"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999283872,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aab49d001oOgwa34DOcVeZq","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"1d2e876d90b23ff664737c7506d928bc88e452d1","messageID":"msg_088aa8934001dgcS8BMiH22ty9","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":35639,"input":2604,"output":192,"reasoning":75,"cache":{"write":0,"read":32768}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999290936,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aad035001CqRzEXcDGzD4MB","messageID":"msg_088aab4ca001Ornj0wySXzPV8h","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"ae21f2b5a7df76fbe3c84ae75aa1cfeb147eb425","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999296581,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_nT6GYIGk5A5eTGhE3HC2CQo6","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"mkdir verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re"},"output":"(no output)","metadata":{"output":"(no output)","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"mkdir verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent","time":{"start":1788999296571,"end":1788999296579}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_061547c987d05457016aa1f67e775487d19cf2d5a1870bf445"}},"id":"prt_088aadf95001GxBg4MlQu6eeIi","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aab4ca001Ornj0wySXzPV8h"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999296854,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aae7530017sf4SmYCGJEP4a","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"25d44371299e9327e3be71b7849b60e3e361eacb","messageID":"msg_088aab4ca001Ornj0wySXzPV8h","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":70868,"input":35540,"output":40,"reasoning":88,"cache":{"write":0,"read":35200}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999301539,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aaf99b001rDKOgbcENqju41","messageID":"msg_088aae78a001Wzo2PyBv7XD59I","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"d9f332f1e5803f85ce3690f1d66345df0c4b0bcb","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999329167,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"apply_patch","callID":"call_5brI0xUNDm0kMhSkF9NiALKw","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"patchText":"*** Begin Patch\n*** Add File: /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n+# Independent ABI verification plan\n+\n+Session `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\n+requested model `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n+\n+This plan was fixed before running the independent objdump reproductions. The object is the\n+owner-supplied `dumps/sots.exe` whose required SHA-256 is\n+`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`.\n+\n+## Falsifiers\n+\n+1. Stop if the executable hash, GNU objdump identity, paired baseline HEAD/common-directory, or\n+   source-binding differs from the handoff.\n+2. Reject the dedup interpretation if complete independent windows do not show: both description\n+   string addresses passed to `0x0046f8c0`; caller cleanup; helper result tested; zero selecting the\n+   match return; and the helper/callees implementing byte-and-length inequality with independent\n+   inline/heap selection at capacity `0x10`.\n+3. Reject an ownership claim if append/growth paths use raw element-header transfer, if the\n+   `0x2c` and `0x74` strides collapse to one shape, if long-string destruction does not call the\n+   recorded delete thunk, or if old elements are not destroyed/freed after deep copy.\n+4. Reject archived record-value claims if an independent parser does not recover the stated event\n+   IDs, nested turn buckets, strings, action/location, and exact `0x7f7fffff` position words from\n+   the named save.\n+5. Reject acceptance on zero instruction output, nonzero command exit, missing requested address\n+   ranges, unexpected skips, hash mismatch, or reliance on counters without inspecting bytes/state.\n+\n+## Required branch exposures and distinct states\n+\n+Static instruction exposures required in this quantum: dedup null/empty return, scalar mismatch\n+continuation, description equal match, description unequal continuation, short/long selection for\n+both operands, byte mismatch, length mismatch, and equal return; ObservedTech spare/full append and\n+deep copy; PlayerEvent spare/full append, three-string copy, and long cleanup; TurnEvents hit/miss,\n+outer spare/full growth, nested empty/nonempty copy, and destruction; prune zero/one/two leading\n+stale plus stale-after-fresh control flow.\n+\n+Distinct semantic states to keep separate: empty/short/long descriptions; equal versus\n+description-only-different events; new versus existing tech name; spare versus full capacity;\n+empty versus nonempty nested vectors; duplicate versus no duplicate; zero/one/two leading stale\n+buckets; stale-after-fresh; duplicate turn buckets versus miss. Static branch exposure is not live\n+execution of these states.\n+\n+## Independent challenge\n+\n+Held-out negative control: inspect unordered/NaN position behavior in the dedup comparator, which\n+the handoff summarizes as finite-position fixtures. Prediction from x87 `fucompp` plus\n+`test ah,0x44; jp mismatch`: otherwise-identical records containing NaN in any compared coordinate\n+must not deduplicate, including two records carrying the same NaN payload. This challenges any\n+implicit whole-bit-equality interpretation without using a live allocator.\n+\n+Scope labels will remain separate: this quantum can establish an **independent static\n+reproduction** and an **archived-save value cross-check**. It is not original-assisted runtime\n+execution, full live compare, independent replacement, or integrated replay, and makes no live\n+allocator-safety or replacement-acceptance claim.\n*** End Patch"},"output":"Success. Updated the following files:\nA verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md","metadata":{"diff":"Index: /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n===================================================================\n--- /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n+++ /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n@@ -0,0 +1,53 @@\n+# Independent ABI verification plan\n+\n+Session `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\n+requested model `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n+\n+This plan was fixed before running the independent objdump reproductions. The object is the\n+owner-supplied `dumps/sots.exe` whose required SHA-256 is\n+`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`.\n+\n+## Falsifiers\n+\n+1. Stop if the executable hash, GNU objdump identity, paired baseline HEAD/common-directory, or\n+   source-binding differs from the handoff.\n+2. Reject the dedup interpretation if complete independent windows do not show: both description\n+   string addresses passed to `0x0046f8c0`; caller cleanup; helper result tested; zero selecting the\n+   match return; and the helper/callees implementing byte-and-length inequality with independent\n+   inline/heap selection at capacity `0x10`.\n+3. Reject an ownership claim if append/growth paths use raw element-header transfer, if the\n+   `0x2c` and `0x74` strides collapse to one shape, if long-string destruction does not call the\n+   recorded delete thunk, or if old elements are not destroyed/freed after deep copy.\n+4. Reject archived record-value claims if an independent parser does not recover the stated event\n+   IDs, nested turn buckets, strings, action/location, and exact `0x7f7fffff` position words from\n+   the named save.\n+5. Reject acceptance on zero instruction output, nonzero command exit, missing requested address\n+   ranges, unexpected skips, hash mismatch, or reliance on counters without inspecting bytes/state.\n+\n+## Required branch exposures and distinct states\n+\n+Static instruction exposures required in this quantum: dedup null/empty return, scalar mismatch\n+continuation, description equal match, description unequal continuation, short/long selection for\n+both operands, byte mismatch, length mismatch, and equal return; ObservedTech spare/full append and\n+deep copy; PlayerEvent spare/full append, three-string copy, and long cleanup; TurnEvents hit/miss,\n+outer spare/full growth, nested empty/nonempty copy, and destruction; prune zero/one/two leading\n+stale plus stale-after-fresh control flow.\n+\n+Distinct semantic states to keep separate: empty/short/long descriptions; equal versus\n+description-only-different events; new versus existing tech name; spare versus full capacity;\n+empty versus nonempty nested vectors; duplicate versus no duplicate; zero/one/two leading stale\n+buckets; stale-after-fresh; duplicate turn buckets versus miss. Static branch exposure is not live\n+execution of these states.\n+\n+## Independent challenge\n+\n+Held-out negative control: inspect unordered/NaN position behavior in the dedup comparator, which\n+the handoff summarizes as finite-position fixtures. Prediction from x87 `fucompp` plus\n+`test ah,0x44; jp mismatch`: otherwise-identical records containing NaN in any compared coordinate\n+must not deduplicate, including two records carrying the same NaN payload. This challenges any\n+implicit whole-bit-equality interpretation without using a live allocator.\n+\n+Scope labels will remain separate: this quantum can establish an **independent static\n+reproduction** and an **archived-save value cross-check**. It is not original-assisted runtime\n+execution, full live compare, independent replacement, or integrated replay, and makes no live\n+allocator-safety or replacement-acceptance claim.\n\n","files":[{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md","relativePath":"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md","type":"add","patch":"Index: /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n===================================================================\n--- /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n+++ /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n@@ -0,0 +1,53 @@\n+# Independent ABI verification plan\n+\n+Session `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\n+requested model `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n+\n+This plan was fixed before running the independent objdump reproductions. The object is the\n+owner-supplied `dumps/sots.exe` whose required SHA-256 is\n+`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`.\n+\n+## Falsifiers\n+\n+1. Stop if the executable hash, GNU objdump identity, paired baseline HEAD/common-directory, or\n+   source-binding differs from the handoff.\n+2. Reject the dedup interpretation if complete independent windows do not show: both description\n+   string addresses passed to `0x0046f8c0`; caller cleanup; helper result tested; zero selecting the\n+   match return; and the helper/callees implementing byte-and-length inequality with independent\n+   inline/heap selection at capacity `0x10`.\n+3. Reject an ownership claim if append/growth paths use raw element-header transfer, if the\n+   `0x2c` and `0x74` strides collapse to one shape, if long-string destruction does not call the\n+   recorded delete thunk, or if old elements are not destroyed/freed after deep copy.\n+4. Reject archived record-value claims if an independent parser does not recover the stated event\n+   IDs, nested turn buckets, strings, action/location, and exact `0x7f7fffff` position words from\n+   the named save.\n+5. Reject acceptance on zero instruction output, nonzero command exit, missing requested address\n+   ranges, unexpected skips, hash mismatch, or reliance on counters without inspecting bytes/state.\n+\n+## Required branch exposures and distinct states\n+\n+Static instruction exposures required in this quantum: dedup null/empty return, scalar mismatch\n+continuation, description equal match, description unequal continuation, short/long selection for\n+both operands, byte mismatch, length mismatch, and equal return; ObservedTech spare/full append and\n+deep copy; PlayerEvent spare/full append, three-string copy, and long cleanup; TurnEvents hit/miss,\n+outer spare/full growth, nested empty/nonempty copy, and destruction; prune zero/one/two leading\n+stale plus stale-after-fresh control flow.\n+\n+Distinct semantic states to keep separate: empty/short/long descriptions; equal versus\n+description-only-different events; new versus existing tech name; spare versus full capacity;\n+empty versus nonempty nested vectors; duplicate versus no duplicate; zero/one/two leading stale\n+buckets; stale-after-fresh; duplicate turn buckets versus miss. Static branch exposure is not live\n+execution of these states.\n+\n+## Independent challenge\n+\n+Held-out negative control: inspect unordered/NaN position behavior in the dedup comparator, which\n+the handoff summarizes as finite-position fixtures. Prediction from x87 `fucompp` plus\n+`test ah,0x44; jp mismatch`: otherwise-identical records containing NaN in any compared coordinate\n+must not deduplicate, including two records carrying the same NaN payload. This challenges any\n+implicit whole-bit-equality interpretation without using a live allocator.\n+\n+Scope labels will remain separate: this quantum can establish an **independent static\n+reproduction** and an **archived-save value cross-check**. It is not original-assisted runtime\n+execution, full live compare, independent replacement, or integrated replay, and makes no live\n+allocator-safety or replacement-acceptance claim.\n","additions":53,"deletions":0}],"diagnostics":{},"truncated":false},"title":"Success. Updated the following files:\nA verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md","time":{"start":1788999329158,"end":1788999329165}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0de9df398f6b64ae016aa1f68583bc87d18493b8ce1f5a4554"}},"id":"prt_088aaf9a1001NGCV2WX0nf7JMB","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aae78a001Wzo2PyBv7XD59I"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999329321,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ab6625001f9arSghM1B1zvG","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"dca82763d540ce1cf3a9c968647b3eabcd7a5b33","messageID":"msg_088aae78a001Wzo2PyBv7XD59I","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":71753,"input":226,"output":871,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":70656}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999332198,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ab7162001uzPmhMRNTyT3Cj","messageID":"msg_088ab665f0015c73pcQuRH7Loh","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"a4363757ace2cd43638ef888eb89f6cafb401067","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999334750,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_X0Xw81pePMjmJ2R7RWhqC1N9","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"sha256sum verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re"},"output":"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008  verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n","metadata":{"output":"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008  verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"sha256sum verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md","time":{"start":1788999334739,"end":1788999334749}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0f9acfa8d406b13b016aa1f6a5b7e887d180af9adcd186b2d3"}},"id":"prt_088ab7787001eCBiLVMrUM93Mg","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ab665f0015c73pcQuRH7Loh"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999334909,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ab7bfa001Kg05gIqSSmA48g","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"371803ea1b5ed0b04bab09cafec39f0bb8283e8b","messageID":"msg_088ab665f0015c73pcQuRH7Loh","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":71861,"input":1001,"output":46,"reasoning":30,"cache":{"write":0,"read":70784}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999337363,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ab8590001Xd2Zwp4nNYk3hJ","messageID":"msg_088ab7c29001yaTKg71jj3gWuS","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"0932205e18da02b47cb25e809924099b40e46b3d","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999354353,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_eyT1b2DdzXmZsrLGjdNHMhSR","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint research-completion-abi --actor research-abi-independent --role verifier --model openai/gpt-5.6-sol --session run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f --summary 'Pre-experiment verifier checkpoint. Observation: contract is in verification, campaign status and validate succeed, and all six canonical surprises are resolved with none open for this contract. Requested model matches campaign/models.json verifier registry. Assigned engine worktree HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23, common dir /home/alex/sots-engine/.git, binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd; assigned RE worktree HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7, common dir /home/alex/sots-re/.git, binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Both have the expected pre-existing dirty inventories; no source worktree edits were made. Input independently hashes SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; GNU objdump is 2.38. Decision: fixed falsifiers, branch exposures, distinct states, scope labels, and a held-out NaN negative control in the attached verifier-owned plan before reproduction. No lab resource is leased or touched. Tests so far are identity/hash/status checks only; no independent instruction reproduction has started. Blocker: live allocator safety and live empty/short/long fixtures remain unavailable and cannot be promoted by static work.' --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md --next-action 'Run the four unfiltered objdump commands from the analyst handoff against the independently rehashed dumps/sots.exe into a verifier-owned raw capture, checking exit status and requested range coverage.'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"49350005b48eb04a30cd156f\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Run the four unfiltered objdump commands from the analyst handoff against the independently rehashed dumps/sots.exe into a verifier-owned raw capture, checking exit status and requested range coverage.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f\",\n  \"summary\": \"Pre-experiment verifier checkpoint. Observation: contract is in verification, campaign status and validate succeed, and all six canonical surprises are resolved with none open for this contract. Requested model matches campaign/models.json verifier registry. Assigned engine worktree HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23, common dir /home/alex/sots-engine/.git, binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd; assigned RE worktree HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7, common dir /home/alex/sots-re/.git, binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Both have the expected pre-existing dirty inventories; no source worktree edits were made. Input independently hashes SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; GNU objdump is 2.38. Decision: fixed falsifiers, branch exposures, distinct states, scope labels, and a held-out NaN negative control in the attached verifier-owned plan before reproduction. No lab resource is leased or touched. Tests so far are identity/hash/status checks only; no independent instruction reproduction has started. Blocker: live allocator safety and live empty/short/long fixtures remain unavailable and cannot be promoted by static work.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:15:54.329971+00:00\"\n}\n","metadata":{"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"49350005b48eb04a30cd156f\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Run the four unfiltered objdump commands from the analyst handoff against the independently rehashed dumps/sots.exe into a verifier-owned raw capture, checking exit status and requested range coverage.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f\",\n  \"summary\": \"Pre-experiment verifier checkpoint. Observation: contract is in verification, campaign status and validate succeed, and all six canonical surprises are resolved with none open for this contract. Requested model matches campaign/models.json verifier registry. Assigned engine worktree HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23, common dir /home/alex/sots-engine/.git, binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd; assigned RE worktree HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7, common dir /home/alex/sots-re/.git, binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Both have the expected pre-existing dirty inventories; no source worktree edits were made. Input independently hashes SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; GNU objdump is 2.38. Decision: fixed falsifiers, branch exposures, distinct states, scope labels, and a held-out NaN negative control in the attached verifier-owned plan before reproduction. No lab resource is leased or touched. Tests so far are identity/hash/status checks only; no independent instruction reproduction has started. Blocker: live allocator safety and live empty/short/long fixtures remain unavailable and cannot be promoted by static work.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:15:54.329971+00:00\"\n}\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint research-completion-abi --actor research-abi-independent --role verifier --model openai/gpt-5.6-sol --session run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f --summary 'Pre-experiment verifier checkpoint. Observation: contract is in verification, campaign status and validate succeed, and all six canonical surprises are resolved with none open for this contract. Requested model matches campaign/models.json verifier registry. Assigned engine worktree HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23, common dir /home/alex/sots-engine/.git, binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd; assigned RE worktree HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7, common dir /home/alex/sots-re/.git, binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Both have the expected pre-existing dirty inventories; no source worktree edits were made. Input independently hashes SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; GNU objdump is 2.38. Decision: fixed falsifiers, branch exposures, distinct states, scope labels, and a held-out NaN negative control in the attached verifier-owned plan before reproduction. No lab resource is leased or touched. Tests so far are identity/hash/status checks only; no independent instruction reproduction has started. Blocker: live allocator safety and live empty/short/long fixtures remain unavailable and cannot be promoted by static work.' --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md --next-action 'Run the four unfiltered objdump commands from the analyst handoff against the independently rehashed dumps/sots.exe into a verifier-owned raw capture, checking exit status and requested range coverage.'","time":{"start":1788999354287,"end":1788999354351}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_06f2c999f6e554c9016aa1f6a9591887d1818f2e3d1f3abae2"}},"id":"prt_088ab8592001mpBTKKaN8Zuy4r","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ab7c29001yaTKg71jj3gWuS"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999354489,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088abc876001gXDQIdXHb1k78B","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"922eef5695f020ddf0d418bf750cd4ae3a5713f4","messageID":"msg_088ab7c29001yaTKg71jj3gWuS","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":72456,"input":242,"output":534,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":71680}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999356959,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088abd218001neS2P0LSaqSiX6","messageID":"msg_088abc8ae0016NHCREfr4og1Qt","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"ff25b16694abf03234212c975fd5333833525e54","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999368293,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_hc4GxRbW6kyGxxaDThxyJN0Z","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe && objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe && objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe && objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00825d40 <.text+0x424d40>:\n  825d40:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  825d41:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  825d43:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825d44:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  825d45:\t8b 5d 08             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d48:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  825d49:\t33 f6                \txor    esi,esi\n  825d4b:\t3b de                \tcmp    ebx,esi\n  825d4d:\t75 0a                \tjne    0x825d59\n  825d4f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825d50:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  825d52:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825d53:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825d55:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825d56:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n  825d59:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n  825d5c:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825d5f:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n  825d64:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n  825d66:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n  825d68:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n  825d6b:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n  825d6d:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n  825d70:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n  825d72:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  825d73:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n  825d76:\t0f 84 d5 00 00 00    \tje     0x825e51\n  825d7c:\t8b 7d 0c             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  825d7f:\t89 75 08             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],esi\n  825d82:\t8b 73 08             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825d85:\t03 75 08             \tadd    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d88:\t8b 4e 6c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x6c]\n  825d8b:\t3b 4f 6c             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x6c]\n  825d8e:\t0f 85 91 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n  825d94:\t8b 56 40             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x40]\n  825d97:\t3b 57 40             \tcmp    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x40]\n  825d9a:\t0f 85 85 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n  825da0:\td9 46 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x44]\n  825da3:\td9 47 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x44]\n  825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n  825da8:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825daa:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dad:\t7a 76                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825daf:\td9 46 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x48]\n  825db2:\td9 47 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x48]\n  825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n  825db7:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825db9:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dbc:\t7a 67                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825dbe:\td9 46 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4c]\n  825dc1:\td9 47 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4c]\n  825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n  825dc6:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825dc8:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dcb:\t7a 58                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825dcd:\t83 7f 38 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x38],0x10\n  825dd1:\t8b 57 34             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x34]\n  825dd4:\t8d 47 24             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x24]\n  825dd7:\t8d 4e 24             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x24]\n  825dda:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825dde\n  825ddc:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  825dde:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825ddf:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825de0:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  825de3:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825de4:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  825de6:\te8 b5 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  825deb:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  825ded:\t75 36                \tjne    0x825e25\n  825def:\t83 7f 64 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x64],0x10\n  825df3:\t8b 57 60             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x60]\n  825df6:\t8d 47 50             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x50]\n  825df9:\t8d 4e 50             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x50]\n  825dfc:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825e00\n  825dfe:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  825e00:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825e01:\t8b 51 10             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  825e04:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825e05:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825e06:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  825e08:\te8 93 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  825e0d:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  825e0f:\t75 14                \tjne    0x825e25\n  825e11:\t8d 47 08             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x8]\n  825e14:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825e15:\t8d 4e 08             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n  825e18:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825e19:\te8 a2 9a c4 ff       \tcall   0x46f8c0\n  825e1e:\t83 c4 08             \tadd    esp,0x8\n  825e21:\t84 c0                \ttest   al,al\n  825e23:\t74 37                \tje     0x825e5c\n  825e25:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n  825e28:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825e2b:\t8b 75 fc             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4]\n  825e2e:\t83 45 08 74          \tadd    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],0x74\n  825e32:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n  825e37:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n  825e39:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n  825e3b:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n  825e3e:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n  825e40:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n  825e43:\t46                   \tinc    esi\n  825e44:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n  825e46:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n  825e49:\t3b f0                \tcmp    esi,eax\n  825e4b:\t0f 82 31 ff ff ff    \tjb     0x825d82\n  825e51:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  825e52:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825e53:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  825e55:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825e56:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825e58:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825e59:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n  825e5c:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  825e5d:\t8b c6                \tmov    eax,esi\n  825e5f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825e60:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825e61:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825e64:\tc2               \tret    0x8\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n0046f8c0 <.text+0x6e8c0>:\n  46f8c0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  46f8c1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  46f8c3:\t8b 45 0c             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  46f8c6:\t83 78 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [eax+0x14],0x10\n  46f8ca:\t8b 48 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [eax+0x10]\n  46f8cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x46f8d1\n  46f8cf:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  46f8d1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  46f8d2:\t8b 4d 08             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  46f8d5:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  46f8d6:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  46f8d9:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  46f8da:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  46f8dc:\te8 bf 3d fb ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  46f8e1:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n  46f8e3:\t1b c0                \tsbb    eax,eax\n  46f8e5:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n  46f8e7:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  46f8e8:\tc3                   \tret    \n  46f8e9:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ea:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8eb:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ec:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ed:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ee:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ef:\tcc                   \tint3   \n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n004236a0 <.text+0x226a0>:\n  4236a0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  4236a1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  4236a3:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  4236a6:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  4236a7:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  4236a8:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  4236a9:\t8b 7d 08             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  4236ac:\t3b c7                \tcmp    eax,edi\n  4236ae:\t73 0b                \tjae    0x4236bb\n  4236b0:\t68 60 1f 9e 00       \tpush   0x9e1f60\n  4236b5:\tff 15 54 d1 9d 00    \tcall   DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd154\n  4236bb:\t8b 75 0c             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  4236be:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  4236c0:\t3b c6                \tcmp    eax,esi\n  4236c2:\t73 02                \tjae    0x4236c6\n  4236c4:\t8b f0                \tmov    esi,eax\n  4236c6:\t8b 5d 14             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x14]\n  4236c9:\t8b d6                \tmov    edx,esi\n  4236cb:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  4236cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x4236d1\n  4236cf:\t8b d3                \tmov    edx,ebx\n  4236d1:\t83 79 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0x10\n  4236d5:\t72 04                \tjb     0x4236db\n  4236d7:\t8b 01                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n  4236d9:\teb 02                \tjmp    0x4236dd\n  4236db:\t8b c1                \tmov    eax,ecx\n  4236dd:\t8b 4d 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  4236e0:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  4236e1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  4236e2:\t03 c7                \tadd    eax,edi\n  4236e4:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  4236e5:\te8 36 f0 ff ff       \tcall   0x422720\n  4236ea:\t83 c4 0c             \tadd    esp,0xc\n  4236ed:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  4236ef:\t75 15                \tjne    0x423706\n  4236f1:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  4236f3:\t73 0a                \tjae    0x4236ff\n  4236f5:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  4236f6:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  4236f7:\t83 c8 ff             \tor     eax,0xffffffff\n  4236fa:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  4236fb:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  4236fc:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n  4236ff:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  423701:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  423703:\t0f 95 c0             \tsetne  al\n  423706:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  423707:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  423708:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  423709:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  42370a:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00422720 <.text+0x21720>:\n  422720:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  422721:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  422723:\t8b 4d 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  422726:\t8b 55 08             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  422729:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  42272a:\t8b 75 10             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  42272d:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  42272e:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n  422731:\t72 14                \tjb     0x422747\n  422733:\t8b 02                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n  422735:\t3b 01                \tcmp    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n  422737:\t75 12                \tjne    0x42274b\n  422739:\t83 ee 04             \tsub    esi,0x4\n  42273c:\t83 c1 04             \tadd    ecx,0x4\n  42273f:\t83 c2 04             \tadd    edx,0x4\n  422742:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n  422745:\t73 ec                \tjae    0x422733\n  422747:\t85 f6                \ttest   esi,esi\n  422749:\t74 45                \tje     0x422790\n  42274b:\t0f b6 02             \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx]\n  42274e:\t0f b6 39             \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx]\n  422751:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422753:\t75 31                \tjne    0x422786\n  422755:\t83 fe 01             \tcmp    esi,0x1\n  422758:\t76 36                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42275a:\t0f b6 42 01          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x1]\n  42275e:\t0f b6 79 01          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x1]\n  422762:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422764:\t75 20                \tjne    0x422786\n  422766:\t83 fe 02             \tcmp    esi,0x2\n  422769:\t76 25                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42276b:\t0f b6 42 02          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x2]\n  42276f:\t0f b6 79 02          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x2]\n  422773:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422775:\t75 0f                \tjne    0x422786\n  422777:\t83 fe 03             \tcmp    esi,0x3\n  42277a:\t76 14                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42277c:\t0f b6 42 03          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x3]\n  422780:\t0f b6 49 03          \tmovzx  ecx,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x3]\n  422784:\t2b c1                \tsub    eax,ecx\n  422786:\tc1 f8 1f             \tsar    eax,0x1f\n  422789:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  42278a:\t83 c8 01             \tor     eax,0x1\n  42278d:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  42278e:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  42278f:\tc3                   \tret    \n  422790:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  422791:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  422793:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  422794:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  422795:\tc3                   \tret    \n","metadata":{"output":"\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00825d40 <.text+0x424d40>:\n  825d40:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  825d41:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  825d43:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825d44:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  825d45:\t8b 5d 08             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d48:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  825d49:\t33 f6                \txor    esi,esi\n  825d4b:\t3b de                \tcmp    ebx,esi\n  825d4d:\t75 0a                \tjne    0x825d59\n  825d4f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825d50:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  825d52:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825d53:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825d55:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825d56:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n  825d59:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n  825d5c:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825d5f:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n  825d64:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n  825d66:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n  825d68:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n  825d6b:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n  825d6d:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n  825d70:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n  825d72:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  825d73:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n  825d76:\t0f 84 d5 00 00 00    \tje     0x825e51\n  825d7c:\t8b 7d 0c             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  825d7f:\t89 75 08             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],esi\n  825d82:\t8b 73 08             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825d85:\t03 75 08             \tadd    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d88:\t8b 4e 6c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x6c]\n  825d8b:\t3b 4f 6c             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x6c]\n  825d8e:\t0f 85 91 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n  825d94:\t8b 56 40             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x40]\n  825d97:\t3b 57 40             \tcmp    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x40]\n  825d9a:\t0f 85 85 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n  825da0:\td9 46 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x44]\n  825da3:\td9 47 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x44]\n  825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n  825da8:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825daa:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dad:\t7a 76                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825daf:\td9 46 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x48]\n  825db2:\td9 47 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x48]\n  825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n  825db7:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825db9:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dbc:\t7a 67                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825dbe:\td9 46 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4c]\n  825dc1:\td9 47 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4c]\n  825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n  825dc6:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825dc8:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dcb:\t7a 58                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825dcd:\t83 7f 38 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x38],0x10\n  825dd1:\t8b 57 34             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x34]\n  825dd4:\t8d 47 24             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x24]\n  825dd7:\t8d 4e 24             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x24]\n  825dda:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825dde\n  825ddc:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  825dde:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825ddf:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825de0:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  825de3:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825de4:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  825de6:\te8 b5 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  825deb:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  825ded:\t75 36                \tjne    0x825e25\n  825def:\t83 7f 64 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x64],0x10\n  825df3:\t8b 57 60             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x60]\n  825df6:\t8d 47 50             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x50]\n  825df9:\t8d 4e 50             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x50]\n  825dfc:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825e00\n  825dfe:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  825e00:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825e01:\t8b 51 10             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  825e04:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825e05:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825e06:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  825e08:\te8 93 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  825e0d:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  825e0f:\t75 14                \tjne    0x825e25\n  825e11:\t8d 47 08             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x8]\n  825e14:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825e15:\t8d 4e 08             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n  825e18:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825e19:\te8 a2 9a c4 ff       \tcall   0x46f8c0\n  825e1e:\t83 c4 08             \tadd    esp,0x8\n  825e21:\t84 c0                \ttest   al,al\n  825e23:\t74 37                \tje     0x825e5c\n  825e25:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n  825e28:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825e2b:\t8b 75 fc             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4]\n  825e2e:\t83 45 08 74          \tadd    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],0x74\n  825e32:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n  825e37:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n  825e39:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n  825e3b:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n  825e3e:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n  825e40:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n  825e43:\t46                   \tinc    esi\n  825e44:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n  825e46:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n  825e49:\t3b f0                \tcmp    esi,eax\n  825e4b:\t0f 82 31 ff ff ff    \tjb     0x825d82\n  825e51:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  825e52:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825e53:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  825e55:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825e56:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825e58:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825e59:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n  825e5c:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  825e5d:\t8b c6                \tmov    eax,esi\n  825e5f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825e60:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825e61:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825e64:\tc2               \tret    0x8\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n0046f8c0 <.text+0x6e8c0>:\n  46f8c0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  46f8c1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  46f8c3:\t8b 45 0c             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  46f8c6:\t83 78 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [eax+0x14],0x10\n  46f8ca:\t8b 48 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [eax+0x10]\n  46f8cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x46f8d1\n  46f8cf:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  46f8d1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  46f8d2:\t8b 4d 08             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  46f8d5:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  46f8d6:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  46f8d9:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  46f8da:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  46f8dc:\te8 bf 3d fb ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  46f8e1:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n  46f8e3:\t1b c0                \tsbb    eax,eax\n  46f8e5:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n  46f8e7:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  46f8e8:\tc3                   \tret    \n  46f8e9:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ea:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8eb:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ec:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ed:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ee:\tcc                   \tint3   \n  46f8ef:\tcc                   \tint3   \n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n004236a0 <.text+0x226a0>:\n  4236a0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  4236a1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  4236a3:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  4236a6:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  4236a7:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  4236a8:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  4236a9:\t8b 7d 08             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  4236ac:\t3b c7                \tcmp    eax,edi\n  4236ae:\t73 0b                \tjae    0x4236bb\n  4236b0:\t68 60 1f 9e 00       \tpush   0x9e1f60\n  4236b5:\tff 15 54 d1 9d 00    \tcall   DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd154\n  4236bb:\t8b 75 0c             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  4236be:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  4236c0:\t3b c6                \tcmp    eax,esi\n  4236c2:\t73 02                \tjae    0x4236c6\n  4236c4:\t8b f0                \tmov    esi,eax\n  4236c6:\t8b 5d 14             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x14]\n  4236c9:\t8b d6                \tmov    edx,esi\n  4236cb:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  4236cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x4236d1\n  4236cf:\t8b d3                \tmov    edx,ebx\n  4236d1:\t83 79 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0x10\n  4236d5:\t72 04                \tjb     0x4236db\n  4236d7:\t8b 01                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n  4236d9:\teb 02                \tjmp    0x4236dd\n  4236db:\t8b c1                \tmov    eax,ecx\n  4236dd:\t8b 4d 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  4236e0:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  4236e1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  4236e2:\t03 c7                \tadd    eax,edi\n  4236e4:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  4236e5:\te8 36 f0 ff ff       \tcall   0x422720\n  4236ea:\t83 c4 0c             \tadd    esp,0xc\n  4236ed:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  4236ef:\t75 15                \tjne    0x423706\n  4236f1:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  4236f3:\t73 0a                \tjae    0x4236ff\n  4236f5:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  4236f6:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  4236f7:\t83 c8 ff             \tor     eax,0xffffffff\n  4236fa:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  4236fb:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  4236fc:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n  4236ff:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  423701:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  423703:\t0f 95 c0             \tsetne  al\n  423706:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  423707:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  423708:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  423709:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  42370a:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00422720 <.text+0x21720>:\n  422720:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  422721:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  422723:\t8b 4d 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  422726:\t8b 55 08             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  422729:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  42272a:\t8b 75 10             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  42272d:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  42272e:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n  422731:\t72 14                \tjb     0x422747\n  422733:\t8b 02                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n  422735:\t3b 01                \tcmp    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n  422737:\t75 12                \tjne    0x42274b\n  422739:\t83 ee 04             \tsub    esi,0x4\n  42273c:\t83 c1 04             \tadd    ecx,0x4\n  42273f:\t83 c2 04             \tadd    edx,0x4\n  422742:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n  422745:\t73 ec                \tjae    0x422733\n  422747:\t85 f6                \ttest   esi,esi\n  422749:\t74 45                \tje     0x422790\n  42274b:\t0f b6 02             \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx]\n  42274e:\t0f b6 39             \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx]\n  422751:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422753:\t75 31                \tjne    0x422786\n  422755:\t83 fe 01             \tcmp    esi,0x1\n  422758:\t76 36                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42275a:\t0f b6 42 01          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x1]\n  42275e:\t0f b6 79 01          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x1]\n  422762:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422764:\t75 20                \tjne    0x422786\n  422766:\t83 fe 02             \tcmp    esi,0x2\n  422769:\t76 25                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42276b:\t0f b6 42 02          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x2]\n  42276f:\t0f b6 79 02          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x2]\n  422773:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422775:\t75 0f                \tjne    0x422786\n  422777:\t83 fe 03             \tcmp    esi,0x3\n  42277a:\t76 14                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42277c:\t0f b6 42 03          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x3]\n  422780:\t0f b6 49 03          \tmovzx  ecx,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x3]\n  422784:\t2b c1                \tsub    eax,ecx\n  422786:\tc1 f8 1f             \tsar    eax,0x1f\n  422789:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  42278a:\t83 c8 01             \tor     eax,0x1\n  42278d:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  42278e:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  42278f:\tc3                   \tret    \n  422790:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  422791:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  422793:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  422794:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  422795:\tc3                   \tret    \n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe && objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe && objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe && objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe","time":{"start":1788999368251,"end":1788999368289}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c600dfa10aaf149016aa1f6c3cc7c87d1a591821990d90341"}},"id":"prt_088abed380017DI1ds7J7RgTls","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088abc8ae0016NHCREfr4og1Qt"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999368341,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088abfe91001wZGBYKq2Vov6jx","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"27cf8465625d8ca6a99c73c28d992b87a29f4238","messageID":"msg_088abc8ae0016NHCREfr4og1Qt","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":73494,"input":1327,"output":164,"reasoning":195,"cache":{"write":0,"read":71808}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999370259,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ac060f001dFoO7ZbiMiYtTs","messageID":"msg_088abfec9001lwqJTDgMPgwaH0","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"9ab48e0b4694d9f0034874c72413f3a531f9b08c","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999388195,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"grep","callID":"call_tQMzHJTutyPrd7Qzrpc3NwwH","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt","pattern":"^# \\$|^# SHA|^# Tool"},"output":"Found 10 matches\n/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt:\n  Line 2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n\n  Line 3: # Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands and selected raw instruction windows:\n\n\n/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt:\n  Line 2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n\n  Line 3: # Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands:\n\n\n/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt:\n  Line 2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n\n  Line 3: # Tool: GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38, Intel syntax.\n\n  Line 6: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe\n\n  Line 135: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe\n\n  Line 170: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe\n\n  Line 230: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe\n","metadata":{"matches":10,"truncated":false},"title":"^# \\$|^# SHA|^# Tool","time":{"start":1788999388153,"end":1788999388173}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0329115488c4ebd7016aa1f6dc015087d1bae614b34ca3108c"}},"id":"prt_088ac4bf5001NuLDmTstgBs6ts","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088abfec9001lwqJTDgMPgwaH0"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999388195,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"grep","callID":"call_IcenpsyPnVHYEPjXGMwEkDZj","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt","pattern":"^# \\$|^# SHA|^# Tool"},"output":"Found 10 matches\n/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt:\n  Line 2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n\n  Line 3: # Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands and selected raw instruction windows:\n\n\n/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt:\n  Line 2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n\n  Line 3: # Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands:\n\n\n/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt:\n  Line 2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n\n  Line 3: # Tool: GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38, Intel syntax.\n\n  Line 6: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe\n\n  Line 135: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe\n\n  Line 170: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe\n\n  Line 230: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe\n","metadata":{"matches":10,"truncated":false},"title":"^# \\$|^# SHA|^# Tool","time":{"start":1788999388146,"end":1788999388175}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0329115488c4ebd7016aa1f6dc014087d1ad035e4c52e01a12"}},"id":"prt_088ac4bed001Una4KKf1ixfyW6","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088abfec9001lwqJTDgMPgwaH0"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999388210,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"glob","callID":"call_61RV9BWIzRLA1wnglsVAR9BX","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/saves","pattern":"turn3-state.sav"},"output":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav","metadata":{"count":1,"truncated":false},"title":"verify/results/saves","time":{"start":1788999388187,"end":1788999388207}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0329115488c4ebd7016aa1f6dc016487d1ba9239d17d18eaee"}},"id":"prt_088ac4c18001LH1n4YTZ79B55r","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088abfec9001lwqJTDgMPgwaH0"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999388213,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"grep","callID":"call_fZpeASYJccfjnZebguEGI5yP","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/save-reader","include":"*.py","pattern":"argparse|add_argument|Events|EvNxID"},"output":"Found 17 matches\n/home/alex/sots-re/verify/save-reader/save_reader.py:\n  Line 54: import argparse\n\n  Line 569:     A(\"Events\", \"any\"), A(\"FNG\", \"any\"),\n\n  Line 1564:     ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=\"Sword of the Stars (2006) save reader\")\n\n  Line 1565:     ap.add_argument(\"save\", help=\".sav (gzip) or already-inflated stream\")\n\n  Line 1566:     ap.add_argument(\"--dump\", action=\"store_true\", help=\"print the generic tree (text, or JSON with --json)\")\n\n  Line 1567:     ap.add_argument(\"--json\", action=\"store_true\", help=\"emit JSON (typed view, or tree with --dump)\")\n\n  Line 1568:     ap.add_argument(\"--strict\", action=\"store_true\", help=\"fail on any schema/framing deviation\")\n\n  Line 1569:     ap.add_argument(\"--padding\", choices=(\"auto\", \"joint\", \"split\"), default=\"auto\")\n\n  Line 1570:     ap.add_argument(\"--out\", help=\"write output here instead of stdout\")\n\n  Line 1571:     ap.add_argument(\"--inflate\", metavar=\"FILE\", help=\"also write the inflated stream to FILE\")\n\n  Line 1572:     ap.add_argument(\"--issues\", type=int, default=30, help=\"max issues to print (default 30)\")\n\n  Line 1573:     ap.add_argument(\"--max-depth\", type=int, default=999, help=\"tree dump depth limit\")\n\n\n/home/alex/sots-re/verify/save-reader/save_writer_stub.py:\n  Line 16: import argparse\n\n  Line 302:     ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=\"write a synthetic SOTS1 save for reader tests\")\n\n  Line 303:     ap.add_argument(\"out\")\n\n  Line 304:     ap.add_argument(\"--padding\", choices=(\"joint\", \"split\"), default=\"joint\")\n\n  Line 305:     ap.add_argument(\"--inflated\", action=\"store_true\", help=\"write the raw stream, not gzip\")\n","metadata":{"matches":17,"truncated":false},"title":"argparse|add_argument|Events|EvNxID","time":{"start":1788999388192,"end":1788999388212}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0329115488c4ebd7016aa1f6dc016c87d1b6a2aad36376ce45"}},"id":"prt_088ac4c1c001s87oFIp4sllRaH","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088abfec9001lwqJTDgMPgwaH0"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999388231,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_xnDQKlQ3RSaFGZvQUFxHQASF","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 verify/save-reader/save_reader.py --help","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"usage: save_reader.py [-h] [--dump] [--json] [--strict]\n                      [--padding {auto,joint,split}] [--out OUT]\n                      [--inflate FILE] [--issues ISSUES]\n                      [--max-depth MAX_DEPTH]\n                      save\n\nSword of the Stars (2006) save reader\n\npositional arguments:\n  save                  .sav (gzip) or already-inflated stream\n\noptions:\n  -h, --help            show this help message and exit\n  --dump                print the generic tree (text, or JSON with --json)\n  --json                emit JSON (typed view, or tree with --dump)\n  --strict              fail on any schema/framing deviation\n  --padding {auto,joint,split}\n  --out OUT             write output here instead of stdout\n  --inflate FILE        also write the inflated stream to FILE\n  --issues ISSUES       max issues to print (default 30)\n  --max-depth MAX_DEPTH\n                        tree dump depth limit\n","metadata":{"output":"usage: save_reader.py [-h] [--dump] [--json] [--strict]\n                      [--padding {auto,joint,split}] [--out OUT]\n                      [--inflate FILE] [--issues ISSUES]\n                      [--max-depth MAX_DEPTH]\n                      save\n\nSword of the Stars (2006) save reader\n\npositional arguments:\n  save                  .sav (gzip) or already-inflated stream\n\noptions:\n  -h, --help            show this help message and exit\n  --dump                print the generic tree (text, or JSON with --json)\n  --json                emit JSON (typed view, or tree with --dump)\n  --strict              fail on any schema/framing deviation\n  --padding {auto,joint,split}\n  --out OUT             write output here instead of stdout\n  --inflate FILE        also write the inflated stream to FILE\n  --issues ISSUES       max issues to print (default 30)\n  --max-depth MAX_DEPTH\n                        tree dump depth limit\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 verify/save-reader/save_reader.py --help","time":{"start":1788999388180,"end":1788999388230}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0329115488c4ebd7016aa1f6dc015c87d185cb593c275afab8"}},"id":"prt_088ac4bfa001PRabZoZamghme9","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088abfec9001lwqJTDgMPgwaH0"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999388322,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ac4c9f001NvwMmBGnUzdqDa","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"56547d0557ded3a7632c8214997f1503dea0a060","messageID":"msg_088abfec9001lwqJTDgMPgwaH0","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":79338,"input":5822,"output":250,"reasoning":306,"cache":{"write":0,"read":72960}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999390699,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ac55e2001JDvGZ2DrRtyWZj","messageID":"msg_088ac4ccd001XDGfslmp6YREl6","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"b422fa498d9775f0a6e0dd4d4f4efd7fe5b98bbf","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999395685,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_xuEBj7dcXJehRxAZMg6tfUTY","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt","offset":1,"limit":180},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n3: # Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands and selected raw instruction windows:\n4: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x008562a0 --stop-address=0x0085630d dumps/sots.exe\n5: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007b7320 --stop-address=0x007b739f dumps/sots.exe\n6: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007b34e0 --stop-address=0x007b35ef dumps/sots.exe\n7: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0079a150 --stop-address=0x0079a1d9 dumps/sots.exe\n8: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0086c580 --stop-address=0x0086c62e dumps/sots.exe\n9: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007693f0 --stop-address=0x007694c0 dumps/sots.exe\n10: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0061ae90 --stop-address=0x0061aefc dumps/sots.exe\n11: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0057e590 --stop-address=0x0057e5e4 dumps/sots.exe\n12: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004249a0 --stop-address=0x00424ada dumps/sots.exe\n13: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00924faa --stop-address=0x00924fbc dumps/sots.exe\n14: \n15: 008562a0 <.text+0x4552a0>:\n16:   8562c5:\t8b f1                \tmov    esi,ecx\n17:   8562cc:\t8d 4e 0c             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0xc]\n18:   8562cf:\tc7 06 9c 43 a2 00    \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa2439c\n19:   8562d5:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n20:   8562d6:\tc7 41 14 0f 00 00 00 \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0xf\n21:   8562dd:\t89 59 10             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10],ebx\n22:   8562e0:\t68 0c 10 9e 00       \tpush   0x9e100c\n23:   8562e8:\t88 19                \tmov    BYTE PTR [ecx],bl\n24:   8562ea:\te8 61 f2 bc ff       \tcall   0x425550\n25:   8562ef:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n26:   8562f1:\t89 46 04             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n27:   8562f4:\t88 5e 08             \tmov    BYTE PTR [esi+0x8],bl\n28:   8562f7:\t89 5e 28             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x28],ebx\n29:   8562fa:\t8b c6                \tmov    eax,esi\n30:   85630c:\tc3                   \tret\n31: \n32: 007b7320 <.text+0x3b6320>:\n33:   7b734a:\t3b 4e 08             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n34:   7b734d:\t75 09                \tjne   0x7b7358\n35:   7b734f:\t6a 01                \tpush   0x1\n36:   7b7351:\t8b ce                \tmov    ecx,esi\n37:   7b7353:\te8 c8 e4 ff ff       \tcall   0x7b5820\n38:   7b7358:\t8b 46 04             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi+0x4]\n39:   7b735b:\t6b ff 2c             \timul   edi,edi,0x2c\n40:   7b735e:\t03 3e                \tadd    edi,DWORD PTR [esi]\n41:   7b7360:\t8d 4e 0c             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0xc]\n42:   7b7363:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n43:   7b7364:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n44:   7b7365:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n45:   7b7366:\te8 e5 2d fe ff       \tcall   0x79a150\n46:   7b736b:\t83 c4 0c             \tadd    esp,0xc\n47:   7b736e:\t83 46 04 2c          \tadd    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],0x2c\n48:   7b7375:\tc2 04 00             \tret   0x4\n49: \n50: 0079a150 <.text+0x399150>:\n51:   79a175:\t8b 75 0c             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n52:   79a184:\t8b 7d 10             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n53:   79a187:\tc7 06 9c 43 a2 00    \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa2439c\n54:   79a18d:\t66 8b 4f 04          \tmov    cx,WORD PTR [edi+0x4]\n55:   79a191:\t66 89 4e 04          \tmov    WORD PTR [esi+0x4],cx\n56:   79a195:\t66 8b 57 06          \tmov    dx,WORD PTR [edi+0x6]\n57:   79a199:\t66 89 56 06          \tmov    WORD PTR [esi+0x6],dx\n58:   79a19d:\t8a 4f 08             \tmov    cl,BYTE PTR [edi+0x8]\n59:   79a1a0:\t88 4e 08             \tmov    BYTE PTR [esi+0x8],cl\n60:   79a1a3:\t6a ff                \tpush   0xffffffff\n61:   79a1a5:\t8d 4e 0c             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0xc]\n62:   79a1a8:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n63:   79a1a9:\t8d 57 0c             \tlea    edx,[edi+0xc]\n64:   79a1ac:\tc7 41 14 0f 00 00 00 \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0xf\n65:   79a1b3:\t89 41 10             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10],eax\n66:   79a1b6:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n67:   79a1bb:\t88 01                \tmov    BYTE PTR [ecx],al\n68:   79a1bd:\te8 6e b2 c8 ff       \tcall   0x425430\n69:   79a1c2:\t8b 47 28             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi+0x28]\n70:   79a1c5:\t89 46 28             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x28],eax\n71:   79a1d8:\tc3                   \tret\n72: \n73: 007b34e0 <.text+0x3b24e0>:\n74:   7b3541:\t8d 7e 0c             \tlea    edi,[esi+0xc]\n75:   7b3544:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n76:   7b3545:\t8b cf                \tmov    ecx,edi\n77:   7b3547:\te8 44 b0 dc ff       \tcall   0x57e590\n78:   7b3557:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n79:   7b3558:\t8b 45 ec             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14]\n80:   7b355b:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n81:   7b355d:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n82:   7b355e:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n83:   7b355f:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n84:   7b3560:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n85:   7b3568:\te8 e3 b0 0a 00       \tcall   0x85e650\n86:   7b35a0:\t8b 13                \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebx]\n87:   7b35a2:\t8b 02                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n88:   7b35a4:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n89:   7b35a6:\t8b cb                \tmov    ecx,ebx\n90:   7b35a8:\tff d0                \tcall   eax\n91:   7b35aa:\t83 c3 2c             \tadd    ebx,0x2c\n92:   7b35b2:\t8b 0e                \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi]\n93:   7b35b4:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n94:   7b35b5:\te8 f0 19 17 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n95:   7b35c0:\t8b ce                \tmov    ecx,esi\n96:   7b35c2:\tff 15 2c d1 9d 00    \tcall   DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd12c\n97: \n98: 0057e590 <.text+0x17d590>:\n99:   57e5a7:\t6b c9 2c             \timul   ecx,ecx,0x2c\n100:   57e5aa:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n101:   57e5ab:\te8 06 6a 3a 00       \tcall   0x924fb6\n102:   57e5e3:\tc2 04 00             \tret   0x4\n103: \n104: 0086c580 <.text+0x46b580>:\n105:   86c5cc:\t3b 4f 08             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x8]\n106:   86c5cf:\t75 09                \tjne   0x86c5da\n107:   86c5d1:\t6a 01                \tpush   0x1\n108:   86c5d3:\t8b cf                \tmov    ecx,edi\n109:   86c5d5:\te8 26 cf ff ff       \tcall   0x869500\n110:   86c5da:\t8b 4f 04             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x4]\n111:   86c5dd:\t6b f6 74             \timul   esi,esi,0x74\n112:   86c5e0:\t03 37                \tadd    esi,DWORD PTR [edi]\n113:   86c60f:\t85 c9                \ttest   ecx,ecx\n114:   86c611:\t74 06                \tje     0x86c619\n115:   86c613:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n116:   86c614:\te8 d7 cd ef ff       \tcall   0x7693f0\n117:   86c619:\t83 47 04 74          \tadd    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4],0x74\n118:   86c62d:\tc2 04 00             \tret   0x4\n119: \n120: 007693f0 <.text+0x3683f0>:\n121:   76941b:\t8b 7d 08             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n122:   76941e:\tc7 06 58 19 a2 00    \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa21958\n123:   769424:\t8b 47 04             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi+0x4]\n124:   76942b:\t8d 4e 08             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n125:   769435:\tc7 41 14 0f 00 00 00 \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0xf\n126:   769445:\te8 e6 bf cb ff       \tcall   0x425430\n127:   76944c:\t8d 4e 24             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x24]\n128:   769464:\te8 c7 bf cb ff       \tcall   0x425430\n129:   769469:\t8b 4f 40             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x40]\n130:   76946c:\t89 4e 40             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x40],ecx\n131:   769481:\t6a ff                \tpush   0xffffffff\n132:   769483:\t8d 4e 50             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x50]\n133:   76949b:\te8 90 bf cb ff       \tcall   0x425430\n134:   7694a0:\t8b 47 6c             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi+0x6c]\n135:   7694a3:\t89 46 6c             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x6c],eax\n136:   7694a6:\t8b 4f 70             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x70]\n137:   7694a9:\t89 4e 70             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x70],ecx\n138:   7694bf:\tc2 04 00             \tret   0x4\n139: \n140: 0061ae90 <.text+0x219e90>:\n141:   61ae94:\t83 7e 64 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [esi+0x64],0x10\n142:   61ae9a:\t8b 46 50             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi+0x50]\n143:   61ae9d:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n144:   61ae9e:\te8 07 a1 30 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n145:   61aeb5:\t83 7e 38 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [esi+0x38],0x10\n146:   61aebb:\t8b 4e 24             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x24]\n147:   61aebe:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n148:   61aebf:\te8 e6 a0 30 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n149:   61aed4:\t83 7e 1c 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [esi+0x1c],0x10\n150:   61aeda:\t8b 56 08             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n151:   61aedd:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n152:   61aede:\te8 c7 a0 30 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n153:   61aefb:\tc3                   \tret\n154: \n155: 004249a0 <.text+0x239a0>:\n156:   424a19:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n157:   424a1a:\te8 97 05 50 00       \tcall   0x924fb6\n158:   424aa4:\t8b 0f                \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi]\n159:   424aa6:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n160:   424aa7:\te8 fe 04 50 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n161:   424ab5:\t89 07                \tmov    DWORD PTR [edi],eax\n162:   424ab7:\t89 77 14             \tmov    DWORD PTR [edi+0x14],esi\n163:   424aba:\t89 5f 10             \tmov    DWORD PTR [edi+0x10],ebx\n164: \n165: 00924faa <.text+0x523faa>:\n166:   924faa:\tff 25 c8 d1 9d 00    \tjmp    DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd1c8\n167:   924fb6:\tff 25 d0 d1 9d 00    \tjmp    DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd1d0\n\n(End of file - total 167 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n# SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n# Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands and selected raw instruction windows:\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x008562a0 --stop-address=0x0085630d dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007b7320 --stop-address=0x007b739f dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007b34e0 --stop-address=0x007b35ef dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0079a150 --stop-address=0x0079a1d9 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0086c580 --stop-address=0x0086c62e dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007693f0 --stop-address=0x007694c0 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0061ae90 --stop-address=0x0061aefc dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0057e590 --stop-address=0x0057e5e4 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004249a0 --stop-address=0x00424ada dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00924faa --stop-address=0x00924fbc dumps/sots.exe\n\n008562a0 <.text+0x4552a0>:\n  8562c5:\t8b f1                \tmov    esi,ecx\n  8562cc:\t8d 4e 0c             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0xc]\n  8562cf:\tc7 06 9c 43 a2 00    \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa2439c\n  8562d5:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  8562d6:\tc7 41 14 0f 00 00 00 \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0xf","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt","text":"# Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n# SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n# Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands and selected raw instruction windows:\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x008562a0 --stop-address=0x0085630d dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007b7320 --stop-address=0x007b739f dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007b34e0 --stop-address=0x007b35ef dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0079a150 --stop-address=0x0079a1d9 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0086c580 --stop-address=0x0086c62e dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007693f0 --stop-address=0x007694c0 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0061ae90 --stop-address=0x0061aefc dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0057e590 --stop-address=0x0057e5e4 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004249a0 --stop-address=0x00424ada dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00924faa --stop-address=0x00924fbc dumps/sots.exe\n\n008562a0 <.text+0x4552a0>:\n  8562c5:\t8b f1                \tmov    esi,ecx\n  8562cc:\t8d 4e 0c             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0xc]\n  8562cf:\tc7 06 9c 43 a2 00    \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa2439c\n  8562d5:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  8562d6:\tc7 41 14 0f 00 00 00 \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0xf\n  8562dd:\t89 59 10             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10],ebx\n  8562e0:\t68 0c 10 9e 00       \tpush   0x9e100c\n  8562e8:\t88 19                \tmov    BYTE PTR [ecx],bl\n  8562ea:\te8 61 f2 bc ff       \tcall   0x425550\n  8562ef:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  8562f1:\t89 46 04             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n  8562f4:\t88 5e 08             \tmov    BYTE PTR [esi+0x8],bl\n  8562f7:\t89 5e 28             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x28],ebx\n  8562fa:\t8b c6                \tmov    eax,esi\n  85630c:\tc3                   \tret\n\n007b7320 <.text+0x3b6320>:\n  7b734a:\t3b 4e 08             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n  7b734d:\t75 09                \tjne   0x7b7358\n  7b734f:\t6a 01                \tpush   0x1\n  7b7351:\t8b ce                \tmov    ecx,esi\n  7b7353:\te8 c8 e4 ff ff       \tcall   0x7b5820\n  7b7358:\t8b 46 04             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi+0x4]\n  7b735b:\t6b ff 2c             \timul   edi,edi,0x2c\n  7b735e:\t03 3e                \tadd    edi,DWORD PTR [esi]\n  7b7360:\t8d 4e 0c             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0xc]\n  7b7363:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  7b7364:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  7b7365:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  7b7366:\te8 e5 2d fe ff       \tcall   0x79a150\n  7b736b:\t83 c4 0c             \tadd    esp,0xc\n  7b736e:\t83 46 04 2c          \tadd    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],0x2c\n  7b7375:\tc2 04 00             \tret   0x4\n\n0079a150 <.text+0x399150>:\n  79a175:\t8b 75 0c             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  79a184:\t8b 7d 10             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  79a187:\tc7 06 9c 43 a2 00    \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa2439c\n  79a18d:\t66 8b 4f 04          \tmov    cx,WORD PTR [edi+0x4]\n  79a191:\t66 89 4e 04          \tmov    WORD PTR [esi+0x4],cx\n  79a195:\t66 8b 57 06          \tmov    dx,WORD PTR [edi+0x6]\n  79a199:\t66 89 56 06          \tmov    WORD PTR [esi+0x6],dx\n  79a19d:\t8a 4f 08             \tmov    cl,BYTE PTR [edi+0x8]\n  79a1a0:\t88 4e 08             \tmov    BYTE PTR [esi+0x8],cl\n  79a1a3:\t6a ff                \tpush   0xffffffff\n  79a1a5:\t8d 4e 0c             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0xc]\n  79a1a8:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  79a1a9:\t8d 57 0c             \tlea    edx,[edi+0xc]\n  79a1ac:\tc7 41 14 0f 00 00 00 \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0xf\n  79a1b3:\t89 41 10             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10],eax\n  79a1b6:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  79a1bb:\t88 01                \tmov    BYTE PTR [ecx],al\n  79a1bd:\te8 6e b2 c8 ff       \tcall   0x425430\n  79a1c2:\t8b 47 28             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi+0x28]\n  79a1c5:\t89 46 28             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x28],eax\n  79a1d8:\tc3                   \tret\n\n007b34e0 <.text+0x3b24e0>:\n  7b3541:\t8d 7e 0c             \tlea    edi,[esi+0xc]\n  7b3544:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  7b3545:\t8b cf                \tmov    ecx,edi\n  7b3547:\te8 44 b0 dc ff       \tcall   0x57e590\n  7b3557:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  7b3558:\t8b 45 ec             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14]\n  7b355b:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  7b355d:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  7b355e:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  7b355f:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  7b3560:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  7b3568:\te8 e3 b0 0a 00       \tcall   0x85e650\n  7b35a0:\t8b 13                \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebx]\n  7b35a2:\t8b 02                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n  7b35a4:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  7b35a6:\t8b cb                \tmov    ecx,ebx\n  7b35a8:\tff d0                \tcall   eax\n  7b35aa:\t83 c3 2c             \tadd    ebx,0x2c\n  7b35b2:\t8b 0e                \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi]\n  7b35b4:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  7b35b5:\te8 f0 19 17 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n  7b35c0:\t8b ce                \tmov    ecx,esi\n  7b35c2:\tff 15 2c d1 9d 00    \tcall   DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd12c\n\n0057e590 <.text+0x17d590>:\n  57e5a7:\t6b c9 2c             \timul   ecx,ecx,0x2c\n  57e5aa:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  57e5ab:\te8 06 6a 3a 00       \tcall   0x924fb6\n  57e5e3:\tc2 04 00             \tret   0x4\n\n0086c580 <.text+0x46b580>:\n  86c5cc:\t3b 4f 08             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x8]\n  86c5cf:\t75 09                \tjne   0x86c5da\n  86c5d1:\t6a 01                \tpush   0x1\n  86c5d3:\t8b cf                \tmov    ecx,edi\n  86c5d5:\te8 26 cf ff ff       \tcall   0x869500\n  86c5da:\t8b 4f 04             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x4]\n  86c5dd:\t6b f6 74             \timul   esi,esi,0x74\n  86c5e0:\t03 37                \tadd    esi,DWORD PTR [edi]\n  86c60f:\t85 c9                \ttest   ecx,ecx\n  86c611:\t74 06                \tje     0x86c619\n  86c613:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  86c614:\te8 d7 cd ef ff       \tcall   0x7693f0\n  86c619:\t83 47 04 74          \tadd    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4],0x74\n  86c62d:\tc2 04 00             \tret   0x4\n\n007693f0 <.text+0x3683f0>:\n  76941b:\t8b 7d 08             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  76941e:\tc7 06 58 19 a2 00    \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa21958\n  769424:\t8b 47 04             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi+0x4]\n  76942b:\t8d 4e 08             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n  769435:\tc7 41 14 0f 00 00 00 \tmov    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0xf\n  769445:\te8 e6 bf cb ff       \tcall   0x425430\n  76944c:\t8d 4e 24             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x24]\n  769464:\te8 c7 bf cb ff       \tcall   0x425430\n  769469:\t8b 4f 40             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x40]\n  76946c:\t89 4e 40             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x40],ecx\n  769481:\t6a ff                \tpush   0xffffffff\n  769483:\t8d 4e 50             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x50]\n  76949b:\te8 90 bf cb ff       \tcall   0x425430\n  7694a0:\t8b 47 6c             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi+0x6c]\n  7694a3:\t89 46 6c             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x6c],eax\n  7694a6:\t8b 4f 70             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x70]\n  7694a9:\t89 4e 70             \tmov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x70],ecx\n  7694bf:\tc2 04 00             \tret   0x4\n\n0061ae90 <.text+0x219e90>:\n  61ae94:\t83 7e 64 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [esi+0x64],0x10\n  61ae9a:\t8b 46 50             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi+0x50]\n  61ae9d:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  61ae9e:\te8 07 a1 30 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n  61aeb5:\t83 7e 38 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [esi+0x38],0x10\n  61aebb:\t8b 4e 24             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x24]\n  61aebe:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  61aebf:\te8 e6 a0 30 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n  61aed4:\t83 7e 1c 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [esi+0x1c],0x10\n  61aeda:\t8b 56 08             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n  61aedd:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  61aede:\te8 c7 a0 30 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n  61aefb:\tc3                   \tret\n\n004249a0 <.text+0x239a0>:\n  424a19:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  424a1a:\te8 97 05 50 00       \tcall   0x924fb6\n  424aa4:\t8b 0f                \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi]\n  424aa6:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  424aa7:\te8 fe 04 50 00       \tcall   0x924faa\n  424ab5:\t89 07                \tmov    DWORD PTR [edi],eax\n  424ab7:\t89 77 14             \tmov    DWORD PTR [edi+0x14],esi\n  424aba:\t89 5f 10             \tmov    DWORD PTR [edi+0x10],ebx\n\n00924faa <.text+0x523faa>:\n  924faa:\tff 25 c8 d1 9d 00    \tjmp    DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd1c8\n  924fb6:\tff 25 d0 d1 9d 00    \tjmp    DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd1d0","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":167,"totalLines":167,"truncated":false}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt","time":{"start":1788999395662,"end":1788999395678}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0130f2580d9cfb8d016aa1f6e362c087d1b68449a7e9d13d10"}},"id":"prt_088ac694a001ilxfM0X5Aam42C","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ac4ccd001XDGfslmp6YREl6"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999395685,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_JIVCYb3MHoWSDlAoU6ruWZxd","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt","offset":1,"limit":160},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n3: # Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands:\n4: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00885380 --stop-address=0x00885500 dumps/sots.exe\n5: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825f80 dumps/sots.exe\n6: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00879eb0 --stop-address=0x0087a020 dumps/sots.exe\n7: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00884cb0 --stop-address=0x00884dc0 dumps/sots.exe\n8: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x008841a0 --stop-address=0x00884440 dumps/sots.exe\n9: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00629580 --stop-address=0x00629620 dumps/sots.exe\n10: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00779850 --stop-address=0x00779a20 dumps/sots.exe\n11: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0062e120 --stop-address=0x0062e190 dumps/sots.exe\n12: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x006e8f50 --stop-address=0x006e8fb0 dumps/sots.exe\n13: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0077fed0 --stop-address=0x00780040 dumps/sots.exe\n14: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007725a0 --stop-address=0x007726d0 dumps/sots.exe\n15: # objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0078af40 --stop-address=0x0078afa8 dumps/sots.exe\n16: # objdump -s --start-address=0x00a0f070 --stop-address=0x00a0f0a0 dumps/sots.exe\n17: \n18: # EventStorage::GetOrCreateTurnBucket: count/stride, last-match scan, construction/append.\n19: 008853aa: 8b 56 08              mov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n20: 008853ad: 2b 56 04              sub    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x4]\n21: 008853b3: b8 ab aa aa 2a        mov    eax,0x2aaaaaab\n22: 008853d3: 39 5a 04              cmp    DWORD PTR [edx+0x4],ebx\n23: 008853d6: 75 02                 jne    0x8853da\n24: 008853d8: 8b fa                 mov    edi,edx\n25: 008853da: 83 c2 18              add    edx,0x18\n26: 008853e2: 3b fb                 cmp    edi,ebx\n27: 008853e4: 74 16                 je     0x8853fc\n28: 008853e6: 8b c7                 mov    eax,edi\n29: 008853f9: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n30: 008853fc: c7 45 dc 7c f0 a0 00  mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x24],0xa0f07c\n31: 00885403: 89 5d e4              mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x1c],ebx\n32: 00885406: 89 5d e8              mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x18],ebx\n33: 00885409: 89 5d ec              mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14],ebx\n34: 0088540c: 8d 45 dc              lea    eax,[ebp-0x24]\n35: 0088540f: 50                    push   eax\n36: 00885413: e8 98 f8 ff ff        call   0x884cb0\n37: 00885418: 8d 4d e4              lea    ecx,[ebp-0x1c]\n38: 00885422: e8 59 41 da ff        call   0x629580\n39: 00885427: 8b 46 08              mov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n40: 0088542a: 8b 4d 08              mov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n41: 0088542d: 89 48 ec              mov    DWORD PTR [eax-0x14],ecx\n42: 00885430: 8b 46 08              mov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n43: 00885433: 83 e8 18              sub    eax,0x18\n44: 00885447: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n45: \n46: # vector<TurnEvents>::push_back: alias-sensitive source and 0x18 deep copy.\n47: 00884cda: 8b 75 08              mov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n48: 00884cdd: 3b f1                 cmp    esi,ecx\n49: 00884cdf: 73 59                 jae    0x884d3a\n50: 00884ce3: 3b c6                 cmp    eax,esi\n51: 00884ce5: 77 53                 ja     0x884d3a\n52: 00884cfa: 3b 4f 08              cmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x8]\n53: 00884cff: 6a 01                 push   0x1\n54: 00884d03: e8 98 f4 ff ff        call   0x8841a0\n55: 00884d24: c7 00 7c f0 a0 00     mov    DWORD PTR [eax],0xa0f07c\n56: 00884d2a: 8b 51 04              mov    edx,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x4]\n57: 00884d34: 89 50 04              mov    DWORD PTR [eax+0x4],edx\n58: 00884d37: 51                    push   ecx\n59: 00884d3a: 3b 4f 08              cmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x8]\n60: 00884d43: e8 58 f4 ff ff        call   0x8841a0\n61: 00884d5c: c7 00 7c f0 a0 00     mov    DWORD PTR [eax],0xa0f07c\n62: 00884d62: 8b 4e 04              mov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x4]\n63: 00884d6c: 89 48 04              mov    DWORD PTR [eax+0x4],ecx\n64: 00884d6f: 56                    push   esi\n65: 00884d70: 8d 48 08              lea    ecx,[eax+0x8]\n66: 00884d73: e8 d8 4a ef ff        call   0x779850\n67: 00884d78: 83 47 04 18           add    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4],0x18\n68: 00884d8c: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n69: \n70: # Outer vector growth and allocation: 1.5x, count*0x18, deep-copy then destroy/free old range.\n71: 008841ee: 3b f0                 cmp    esi,eax\n72: 008841f2: 8b d0                 mov    edx,eax\n73: 008841f4: d1 ea                 shr    edx,1\n74: 00884205: 03 c2                 add    eax,edx\n75: 0088420d: 50                    push   eax\n76: 0088420e: e8 4d f8 ff ff        call   0x883a60\n77: 00883ac4: 57                    push   edi\n78: 00883ac7: e8 84 54 e6 ff        call   0x6e8f50\n79: 00883add: 89 7d e8              mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x18],edi\n80: 00883ae7: e8 e4 c3 ef ff        call   0x77fed0\n81: 00883b20: 8b 07                 mov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi]\n82: 00883b22: 8b 10                 mov    edx,DWORD PTR [eax]\n83: 00883b24: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n84: 00883b28: ff d2                 call   edx\n85: 00883b2a: 83 c7 18              add    edi,0x18\n86: 00883b35: e8 70 14 0a 00        call   0x924faa\n87: 00883b57: 89 56 08              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x8],edx\n88: 00883b5a: 89 4e 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],ecx\n89: 00883b5d: 89 3e                 mov    DWORD PTR [esi],edi\n90: 00883b73: 8b 55 e8              mov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x18]\n91: 00883b76: 52                    push   edx\n92: 00883b77: e8 2e 14 0a 00        call   0x924faa\n93: 00883b7f: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n94: 00883b81: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n95: 00883b83: e8 34 14 0a 00        call   0x924fbc\n96: 006e8f67: 8d 04 49              lea    eax,[ecx+ecx*2]\n97: 006e8f6a: 03 c0                 add    eax,eax\n98: 006e8f6c: 03 c0                 add    eax,eax\n99: 006e8f6e: 03 c0                 add    eax,eax\n100: 006e8f70: 50                    push   eax\n101: 006e8f71: e8 40 c0 23 00        call   0x924fb6\n102: 006e8fa9: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n103: \n104: # TurnEvents range copy: vptr/turn plus deep copy of nested vector; unwind destroys completed elements.\n105: 0077ff10: 3b 7d 0c              cmp    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n106: 0077ff1c: 8d 4f 08              lea    ecx,[edi+0x8]\n107: 0077ff1f: c7 06 7c f0 a0 00     mov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa0f07c\n108: 0077ff25: 8b 47 04              mov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi+0x4]\n109: 0077ff29: 8d 4e 08              lea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n110: 0077ff2f: 89 46 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n111: 0077ff32: e8 19 99 ff ff        call   0x779850\n112: 0077ff37: 83 c6 18              add    esi,0x18\n113: 0077ff41: 83 c7 18              add    edi,0x18\n114: 0077ff46: 8b 75 ec              mov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14]\n115: 0077ff50: 8b 16                 mov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi]\n116: 0077ff52: 8b 02                 mov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n117: 0077ff54: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n118: 0077ff58: ff d0                 call   eax\n119: 0077ff5a: 83 c6 18              add    esi,0x18\n120: 0077ff61: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n121: 0077ff63: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n122: 0077ff65: e8 52 50 1a 00        call   0x924fbc\n123: \n124: # Nested vector<PlayerEvent> copy and allocation; partial-copy unwind destroys completed events.\n125: 00779883: 33 c0                 xor    eax,eax\n126: 00779885: 89 06                 mov    DWORD PTR [esi],eax\n127: 00779887: 89 46 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n128: 0077988a: 89 46 08              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x8],eax\n129: 007798b2: 74 4b                 je     0x7798ff\n130: 007798ca: 57                    push   edi\n131: 007798cb: e8 70 16 01 00        call   0x78af40\n132: 007798d0: 6b ff 74              imul   edi,edi,0x74\n133: 007798dd: 89 06                 mov    DWORD PTR [esi],eax\n134: 007798df: 89 46 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n135: 007798e2: 89 7e 08              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x8],edi\n136: 007798f4: e8 a7 8c ff ff        call   0x7725a0\n137: 007798fc: 89 46 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n138: 00779912: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n139: 00779915: 8b 4d ec              mov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14]\n140: 00779918: e8 63 fc ea ff        call   0x629580\n141: 0077991d: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n142: 0077991f: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n143: 00779921: e8 96 b6 1a 00        call   0x924fbc\n144: 0078af57: 6b c9 74              imul   ecx,ecx,0x74\n145: 0078af5a: 51                    push   ecx\n146: 0078af5b: e8 56 a0 19 00        call   0x924fb6\n147: 0078af93: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n148: 007725e0: 3b 45 0c              cmp    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n149: 007725f2: 50                    push   eax\n150: 007725f5: e8 f6 6d ff ff        call   0x7693f0\n151: 007725fd: 83 c6 74              add    esi,0x74\n152: 00772600: 83 c0 74              add    eax,0x74\n153: 0077260f: 8b 75 ec              mov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14]\n154: 00772620: 8b 06                 mov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi]\n155: 00772622: 8b 10                 mov    edx,DWORD PTR [eax]\n156: 00772624: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n157: 00772628: ff d2                 call   edx\n158: 0077262a: 83 c6 74              add    esi,0x74\n159: 00772631: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n160: 00772633: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n\n(Showing lines 1-160 of 250. Use offset=161 to continue.)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n# SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n# Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands:\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00885380 --stop-address=0x00885500 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825f80 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00879eb0 --stop-address=0x0087a020 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00884cb0 --stop-address=0x00884dc0 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x008841a0 --stop-address=0x00884440 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00629580 --stop-address=0x00629620 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00779850 --stop-address=0x00779a20 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0062e120 --stop-address=0x0062e190 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x006e8f50 --stop-address=0x006e8fb0 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0077fed0 --stop-address=0x00780040 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007725a0 --stop-address=0x007726d0 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0078af40 --stop-address=0x0078afa8 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -s --start-address=0x00a0f070 --stop-address=0x00a0f0a0 dumps/sots.exe\n\n# EventStorage::GetOrCreateTurnBucket: count/stride, last-match scan, construction/append.\n008853aa: 8b 56 08              mov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n008853ad: 2b 56 04              sub    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x4]","truncated":true,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt","text":"# Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n# SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n# Tool: GNU objdump 2.38, Intel syntax. Commands:\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00885380 --stop-address=0x00885500 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825f80 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00879eb0 --stop-address=0x0087a020 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00884cb0 --stop-address=0x00884dc0 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x008841a0 --stop-address=0x00884440 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00629580 --stop-address=0x00629620 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00779850 --stop-address=0x00779a20 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0062e120 --stop-address=0x0062e190 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x006e8f50 --stop-address=0x006e8fb0 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0077fed0 --stop-address=0x00780040 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x007725a0 --stop-address=0x007726d0 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0078af40 --stop-address=0x0078afa8 dumps/sots.exe\n# objdump -s --start-address=0x00a0f070 --stop-address=0x00a0f0a0 dumps/sots.exe\n\n# EventStorage::GetOrCreateTurnBucket: count/stride, last-match scan, construction/append.\n008853aa: 8b 56 08              mov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n008853ad: 2b 56 04              sub    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x4]\n008853b3: b8 ab aa aa 2a        mov    eax,0x2aaaaaab\n008853d3: 39 5a 04              cmp    DWORD PTR [edx+0x4],ebx\n008853d6: 75 02                 jne    0x8853da\n008853d8: 8b fa                 mov    edi,edx\n008853da: 83 c2 18              add    edx,0x18\n008853e2: 3b fb                 cmp    edi,ebx\n008853e4: 74 16                 je     0x8853fc\n008853e6: 8b c7                 mov    eax,edi\n008853f9: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n008853fc: c7 45 dc 7c f0 a0 00  mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x24],0xa0f07c\n00885403: 89 5d e4              mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x1c],ebx\n00885406: 89 5d e8              mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x18],ebx\n00885409: 89 5d ec              mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14],ebx\n0088540c: 8d 45 dc              lea    eax,[ebp-0x24]\n0088540f: 50                    push   eax\n00885413: e8 98 f8 ff ff        call   0x884cb0\n00885418: 8d 4d e4              lea    ecx,[ebp-0x1c]\n00885422: e8 59 41 da ff        call   0x629580\n00885427: 8b 46 08              mov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n0088542a: 8b 4d 08              mov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n0088542d: 89 48 ec              mov    DWORD PTR [eax-0x14],ecx\n00885430: 8b 46 08              mov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi+0x8]\n00885433: 83 e8 18              sub    eax,0x18\n00885447: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n\n# vector<TurnEvents>::push_back: alias-sensitive source and 0x18 deep copy.\n00884cda: 8b 75 08              mov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n00884cdd: 3b f1                 cmp    esi,ecx\n00884cdf: 73 59                 jae    0x884d3a\n00884ce3: 3b c6                 cmp    eax,esi\n00884ce5: 77 53                 ja     0x884d3a\n00884cfa: 3b 4f 08              cmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x8]\n00884cff: 6a 01                 push   0x1\n00884d03: e8 98 f4 ff ff        call   0x8841a0\n00884d24: c7 00 7c f0 a0 00     mov    DWORD PTR [eax],0xa0f07c\n00884d2a: 8b 51 04              mov    edx,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x4]\n00884d34: 89 50 04              mov    DWORD PTR [eax+0x4],edx\n00884d37: 51                    push   ecx\n00884d3a: 3b 4f 08              cmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x8]\n00884d43: e8 58 f4 ff ff        call   0x8841a0\n00884d5c: c7 00 7c f0 a0 00     mov    DWORD PTR [eax],0xa0f07c\n00884d62: 8b 4e 04              mov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x4]\n00884d6c: 89 48 04              mov    DWORD PTR [eax+0x4],ecx\n00884d6f: 56                    push   esi\n00884d70: 8d 48 08              lea    ecx,[eax+0x8]\n00884d73: e8 d8 4a ef ff        call   0x779850\n00884d78: 83 47 04 18           add    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4],0x18\n00884d8c: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n\n# Outer vector growth and allocation: 1.5x, count*0x18, deep-copy then destroy/free old range.\n008841ee: 3b f0                 cmp    esi,eax\n008841f2: 8b d0                 mov    edx,eax\n008841f4: d1 ea                 shr    edx,1\n00884205: 03 c2                 add    eax,edx\n0088420d: 50                    push   eax\n0088420e: e8 4d f8 ff ff        call   0x883a60\n00883ac4: 57                    push   edi\n00883ac7: e8 84 54 e6 ff        call   0x6e8f50\n00883add: 89 7d e8              mov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x18],edi\n00883ae7: e8 e4 c3 ef ff        call   0x77fed0\n00883b20: 8b 07                 mov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi]\n00883b22: 8b 10                 mov    edx,DWORD PTR [eax]\n00883b24: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n00883b28: ff d2                 call   edx\n00883b2a: 83 c7 18              add    edi,0x18\n00883b35: e8 70 14 0a 00        call   0x924faa\n00883b57: 89 56 08              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x8],edx\n00883b5a: 89 4e 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],ecx\n00883b5d: 89 3e                 mov    DWORD PTR [esi],edi\n00883b73: 8b 55 e8              mov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x18]\n00883b76: 52                    push   edx\n00883b77: e8 2e 14 0a 00        call   0x924faa\n00883b7f: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n00883b81: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n00883b83: e8 34 14 0a 00        call   0x924fbc\n006e8f67: 8d 04 49              lea    eax,[ecx+ecx*2]\n006e8f6a: 03 c0                 add    eax,eax\n006e8f6c: 03 c0                 add    eax,eax\n006e8f6e: 03 c0                 add    eax,eax\n006e8f70: 50                    push   eax\n006e8f71: e8 40 c0 23 00        call   0x924fb6\n006e8fa9: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n\n# TurnEvents range copy: vptr/turn plus deep copy of nested vector; unwind destroys completed elements.\n0077ff10: 3b 7d 0c              cmp    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n0077ff1c: 8d 4f 08              lea    ecx,[edi+0x8]\n0077ff1f: c7 06 7c f0 a0 00     mov    DWORD PTR [esi],0xa0f07c\n0077ff25: 8b 47 04              mov    eax,DWORD PTR [edi+0x4]\n0077ff29: 8d 4e 08              lea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n0077ff2f: 89 46 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n0077ff32: e8 19 99 ff ff        call   0x779850\n0077ff37: 83 c6 18              add    esi,0x18\n0077ff41: 83 c7 18              add    edi,0x18\n0077ff46: 8b 75 ec              mov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14]\n0077ff50: 8b 16                 mov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi]\n0077ff52: 8b 02                 mov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n0077ff54: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n0077ff58: ff d0                 call   eax\n0077ff5a: 83 c6 18              add    esi,0x18\n0077ff61: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n0077ff63: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n0077ff65: e8 52 50 1a 00        call   0x924fbc\n\n# Nested vector<PlayerEvent> copy and allocation; partial-copy unwind destroys completed events.\n00779883: 33 c0                 xor    eax,eax\n00779885: 89 06                 mov    DWORD PTR [esi],eax\n00779887: 89 46 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n0077988a: 89 46 08              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x8],eax\n007798b2: 74 4b                 je     0x7798ff\n007798ca: 57                    push   edi\n007798cb: e8 70 16 01 00        call   0x78af40\n007798d0: 6b ff 74              imul   edi,edi,0x74\n007798dd: 89 06                 mov    DWORD PTR [esi],eax\n007798df: 89 46 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n007798e2: 89 7e 08              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x8],edi\n007798f4: e8 a7 8c ff ff        call   0x7725a0\n007798fc: 89 46 04              mov    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4],eax\n00779912: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n00779915: 8b 4d ec              mov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14]\n00779918: e8 63 fc ea ff        call   0x629580\n0077991d: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n0077991f: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n00779921: e8 96 b6 1a 00        call   0x924fbc\n0078af57: 6b c9 74              imul   ecx,ecx,0x74\n0078af5a: 51                    push   ecx\n0078af5b: e8 56 a0 19 00        call   0x924fb6\n0078af93: c2 04 00              ret    0x4\n007725e0: 3b 45 0c              cmp    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n007725f2: 50                    push   eax\n007725f5: e8 f6 6d ff ff        call   0x7693f0\n007725fd: 83 c6 74              add    esi,0x74\n00772600: 83 c0 74              add    eax,0x74\n0077260f: 8b 75 ec              mov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x14]\n00772620: 8b 06                 mov    eax,DWORD PTR [esi]\n00772622: 8b 10                 mov    edx,DWORD PTR [eax]\n00772624: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n00772628: ff d2                 call   edx\n0077262a: 83 c6 74              add    esi,0x74\n00772631: 6a 00                 push   0x0\n00772633: 6a 00                 push   0x0","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":160,"totalLines":250,"truncated":true}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt","time":{"start":1788999395670,"end":1788999395682}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0130f2580d9cfb8d016aa1f6e362d487d19ad46efa2413c882"}},"id":"prt_088ac69510017xsZHEN8asW6Nc","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ac4ccd001XDGfslmp6YREl6"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999395764,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ac69b1001bpcV6ogV6bjJHb","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"ff2a1015ca8eca3c96ee369b3e7842bf2f2ed0f6","messageID":"msg_088ac4ccd001XDGfslmp6YREl6","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":81133,"input":2393,"output":122,"reasoning":26,"cache":{"write":0,"read":78592}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999398945,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ac761e001l6PG2sLsIzzxva","messageID":"msg_088ac69e1001GZ0p7g6aW5Dsre","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"25e6ad935fc0042376f0f85de82e53db799aeaee","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999421080,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_ZvevBPcisMKJDYeJt9FJrODo","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 -c 'import json,subprocess; p=subprocess.run([\"python3\",\"verify/save-reader/save_reader.py\",\"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\"--dump\",\"--json\",\"--strict\"],capture_output=True,text=True); print(\"exit\",p.returncode,\"stderr\",p.stderr[:500]); x=json.loads(p.stdout); print(type(x).__name__, (list(x)[:20] if isinstance(x,dict) else len(x))); print(str(x)[:1500])'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"exit 0 stderr \ndict ['padding', 'stats', 'issues', 'tree']\n{'padding': 'joint', 'stats': {'items': 37847, 'frames': 2453, 'resyncs': 0, 'hint_failures': 0, 'guessed': 20104, 'raw_bytes': 2503, 'best_effort': 0}, 'issues': [{'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/FxCrID/idx', 'offset': 272, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'idx'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/Settings/treasury', 'offset': 420, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'treasury'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/Settings/colonies', 'offset': 432, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'colonies'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/Settings/techs', 'offset': 444, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'techs'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/Settings/difficulty', 'offset': 456, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'difficulty'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/FxCrID/idx', 'offset': 648, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'idx'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/Settings/treasury', 'offset': 796, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'treasury'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/Settings/colonies', 'offset': 808, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'colonies'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/Settings/techs', 'offset': 820, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'techs'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/Settings/difficulty', 'offset': 832, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as \n","metadata":{"output":"exit 0 stderr \ndict ['padding', 'stats', 'issues', 'tree']\n{'padding': 'joint', 'stats': {'items': 37847, 'frames': 2453, 'resyncs': 0, 'hint_failures': 0, 'guessed': 20104, 'raw_bytes': 2503, 'best_effort': 0}, 'issues': [{'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/FxCrID/idx', 'offset': 272, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'idx'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/Settings/treasury', 'offset': 420, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'treasury'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/Settings/colonies', 'offset': 432, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'colonies'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/Settings/techs', 'offset': 444, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'techs'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[0]/Slot/Settings/difficulty', 'offset': 456, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'difficulty'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/FxCrID/idx', 'offset': 648, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'idx'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/Settings/treasury', 'offset': 796, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'treasury'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/Settings/colonies', 'offset': 808, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'colonies'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/Settings/techs', 'offset': 820, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as 'techs'\"}, {'level': 'info', 'path': '/summary/Players[1]/Slot/Settings/difficulty', 'offset': 832, 'msg': \"tag '.' read positionally as \n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 -c 'import json,subprocess; p=subprocess.run([\"python3\",\"verify/save-reader/save_reader.py\",\"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\"--dump\",\"--json\",\"--strict\"],capture_output=True,text=True); print(\"exit\",p.returncode,\"stderr\",p.stderr[:500]); x=json.loads(p.stdout); print(type(x).__name__, (list(x)[:20] if isinstance(x,dict) else len(x))); print(str(x)[:1500])'","time":{"start":1788999411811,"end":1788999421077}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c9e7a43f33859ca016aa1f6ef120c87d18cdb0583638eb943"}},"id":"prt_088ac9622001UBr3CzzUIu3z7O","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ac69e1001GZ0p7g6aW5Dsre"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999421117,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088acccba0010YbTlkEbQFSuUA","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"7ae4c89cb9807a1e615818baca0293e6c899a610","messageID":"msg_088ac69e1001GZ0p7g6aW5Dsre","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":89792,"input":8514,"output":141,"reasoning":241,"cache":{"write":0,"read":80896}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999423806,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088acd73b001TDtbymeWZwTUMo","messageID":"msg_088acccf2001h58yiyIBQ4b59Y","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"81951459954a8361ff437418736370b32382eb96","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999438594,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_rFtyC6iBe03V9RMGe1qLaguI","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 -c 'import json,subprocess; x=json.loads(subprocess.check_output([\"python3\",\"verify/save-reader/save_reader.py\",\"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\"--dump\",\"--json\",\"--strict\"],text=True)); t=x[\"tree\"]; print(type(t).__name__, list(t) if isinstance(t,dict) else len(t)); print(str(t)[:2000])'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"list 8\n[{'_name': 'Summary', '_off': 0, '_items': [{'name': 'GameName', 'kind': 'string', 'value': 'MyGameverify1', 'off': 16}, {'name': 'Turn', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 3, 'off': 48, 'alt': 4.203895392974451e-45}, {'name': 'NumSys', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 28, 'off': 60, 'alt': 3.923635700109488e-44}, {'name': 'Checksum', 'kind': 'int', 'value': -769976634, 'off': 76, 'alt': -166525501440.0}, {'_name': 'Players', '_off': 92, '_items': [{'name': '.', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 2, 'off': 108, 'alt': 2.802596928649634e-45}, {'_name': '.', '_off': 120, '_items': [{'_name': 'Slot', '_off': 132, '_items': [{'name': 'IsPlay', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 144}, {'name': 'IsDead', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': False, 'off': 156}, {'name': 'IsReq', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 168}, {'name': 'IsRec', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': False, 'off': 180}, {'name': 'IsFxNm', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 192}, {'name': 'FxNm', 'kind': 'string', 'value': 're', 'off': 204}, {'name': 'IsFxSp', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 220}, {'name': 'FxSp', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 0, 'off': 232, 'alt': 0.0}, {'name': 'IsFxCr', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 244}, {'_name': 'FxCrID', '_off': 256, '_items': [{'name': '.', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 2, 'off': 272, 'alt': 2.802596928649634e-45}]}, {'name': 'IsFxBd', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 288}, {'name': 'FxBd', 'kind': 'string', 'value': 'BADGE_HUMAN13', 'off': 300}, {'name': 'IsFxAv', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 328}, {'name': 'FxAv', 'kind': 'string', 'value': 'AVATAR_HUMAN18', 'off': 340}, {'name': 'Tag', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 1466349286, 'off': 368, 'alt': 253673217196032.0}, {'name': 'Pwd', 'kind': 'string', 'value': '', 'off': 380}, {'name': 'Team', 'kind': 'int', 'value': -1, 'off': 392}, {'_name': 'Settings', '_off': 404, '_items': [{'name': '.', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 50000, 'off': 420, 'alt': 7.006492321624085e-41}, {'name': '.', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 1, 'off': 432, 'alt': 1.401298464324817e-45\n","metadata":{"output":"list 8\n[{'_name': 'Summary', '_off': 0, '_items': [{'name': 'GameName', 'kind': 'string', 'value': 'MyGameverify1', 'off': 16}, {'name': 'Turn', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 3, 'off': 48, 'alt': 4.203895392974451e-45}, {'name': 'NumSys', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 28, 'off': 60, 'alt': 3.923635700109488e-44}, {'name': 'Checksum', 'kind': 'int', 'value': -769976634, 'off': 76, 'alt': -166525501440.0}, {'_name': 'Players', '_off': 92, '_items': [{'name': '.', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 2, 'off': 108, 'alt': 2.802596928649634e-45}, {'_name': '.', '_off': 120, '_items': [{'_name': 'Slot', '_off': 132, '_items': [{'name': 'IsPlay', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 144}, {'name': 'IsDead', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': False, 'off': 156}, {'name': 'IsReq', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 168}, {'name': 'IsRec', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': False, 'off': 180}, {'name': 'IsFxNm', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 192}, {'name': 'FxNm', 'kind': 'string', 'value': 're', 'off': 204}, {'name': 'IsFxSp', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 220}, {'name': 'FxSp', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 0, 'off': 232, 'alt': 0.0}, {'name': 'IsFxCr', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 244}, {'_name': 'FxCrID', '_off': 256, '_items': [{'name': '.', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 2, 'off': 272, 'alt': 2.802596928649634e-45}]}, {'name': 'IsFxBd', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 288}, {'name': 'FxBd', 'kind': 'string', 'value': 'BADGE_HUMAN13', 'off': 300}, {'name': 'IsFxAv', 'kind': 'bool', 'value': True, 'off': 328}, {'name': 'FxAv', 'kind': 'string', 'value': 'AVATAR_HUMAN18', 'off': 340}, {'name': 'Tag', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 1466349286, 'off': 368, 'alt': 253673217196032.0}, {'name': 'Pwd', 'kind': 'string', 'value': '', 'off': 380}, {'name': 'Team', 'kind': 'int', 'value': -1, 'off': 392}, {'_name': 'Settings', '_off': 404, '_items': [{'name': '.', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 50000, 'off': 420, 'alt': 7.006492321624085e-41}, {'name': '.', 'kind': 'int', 'value': 1, 'off': 432, 'alt': 1.401298464324817e-45\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 -c 'import json,subprocess; x=json.loads(subprocess.check_output([\"python3\",\"verify/save-reader/save_reader.py\",\"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\"--dump\",\"--json\",\"--strict\"],text=True)); t=x[\"tree\"]; print(type(t).__name__, list(t) if isinstance(t,dict) else len(t)); print(str(t)[:2000])'","time":{"start":1788999429470,"end":1788999438592}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0d6715592139fbce016aa1f701f35087d1b8acebbf6c489b0d"}},"id":"prt_088acdff3001x2g3oXvVTY0mip","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088acccf2001h58yiyIBQ4b59Y"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999438634,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ad1127001mGc7DavHCfcOmC","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"e1d6c3300a5d638d4994dc2e1882e1aa3d7aa9fb","messageID":"msg_088acccf2001h58yiyIBQ4b59Y","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":90494,"input":1104,"output":124,"reasoning":50,"cache":{"write":0,"read":89216}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999443990,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ad2613001wOuJZDl5azpJ6F","messageID":"msg_088ad1153001Sctyx2wcpQWOdZ","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"7d10d8f58234d5194e3396a981f71fb3cc7c2c2b","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999460353,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_u07vwrzuzsodx6qDN3EZYF52","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 -c 'import json,subprocess; x=json.loads(subprocess.check_output([\"python3\",\"verify/save-reader/save_reader.py\",\"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\"--dump\",\"--json\",\"--strict\"],text=True))[\"tree\"]\ndef walk(xs,p=\"\"):\n for i,n in enumerate(xs):\n  name=n.get(\"_name\",n.get(\"name\",f\"[{i}]\")); q=p+\"/\"+str(name)\n  if \"/Sim/Player/Events\" in q: print(q, n.get(\"value\",\"\"), \"off\",n.get(\"off\",n.get(\"_off\")))\n  if \"_items\" in n: walk(n[\"_items\"],q)\nwalk(x)'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"/Sim/Player/Events  off 70276\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 3 off 70292\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 70308\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 2 off 70324\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/.  off 70336\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./EvTurn 2 off 70348\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events  off 70364\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/. 1 off 70380\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 70392\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 1 off 70404\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc No Research Project Assigned. off 70420\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg No Research Project Assigned. off 70464\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_NO_RESEARCH off 70508\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 0 off 70540\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 70556\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70572\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70584\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70596\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 1 off 70612\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 70628\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/.  off 70656\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./EvTurn 3 off 70668\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events  off 70684\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/. 1 off 70700\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 70712\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 2 off 70724\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc No Research Project Assigned. off 70740\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg No Research Project Assigned. off 70784\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_NO_RESEARCH off 70828\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 0 off 70860\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 70876\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70892\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70904\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70916\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 1 off 70932\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 70948\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 120372\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 4 off 120388\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 120404\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 2 off 120420\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/.  off 120432\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./EvTurn 2 off 120444\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events  off 120460\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/. 1 off 120476\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 120488\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 1 off 120500\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc Ships Constructed At Ke'Dolarra off 120516\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg 1 ship built in system Ke'Dolarra off 120560\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT off 120608\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 288 off 120640\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 120656\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. -11.92860221862793 off 120672\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 4.719004154205322 off 120684\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2.3178513050079346 off 120696\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 0 off 120712\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 120728\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/.  off 120756\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./EvTurn 3 off 120768\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events  off 120784\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/. 2 off 120800\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 120812\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 2 off 120824\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc Ships Constructed At Ke'Dolarra off 120840\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg 1 ship built in system Ke'Dolarra off 120884\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT off 120932\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 288 off 120964\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 120980\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. -11.92860221862793 off 120996\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 4.719004154205322 off 121008\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2.3178513050079346 off 121020\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 0 off 121036\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 121052\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 121072\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 3 off 121084\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc Research Over Budget off 121100\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget. off 121136\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET off 121196\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 0 off 121236\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 121252\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 121268\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 121280\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 121292\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 1 off 121308\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 121324\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 182640\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 182656\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 182672\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 182688\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 240468\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 240484\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 240500\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 240516\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 303412\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 303428\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 303444\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 303460\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 393888\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 393904\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 393920\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 393936\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 456180\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 456196\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 456212\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 456228\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 523688\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 523704\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 523720\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 523736\n","metadata":{"output":"/Sim/Player/Events  off 70276\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 3 off 70292\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 70308\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 2 off 70324\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/.  off 70336\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./EvTurn 2 off 70348\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events  off 70364\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/. 1 off 70380\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 70392\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 1 off 70404\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc No Research Project Assigned. off 70420\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg No Research Project Assigned. off 70464\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_NO_RESEARCH off 70508\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 0 off 70540\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 70556\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70572\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70584\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70596\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 1 off 70612\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 70628\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/.  off 70656\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./EvTurn 3 off 70668\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events  off 70684\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/. 1 off 70700\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 70712\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 2 off 70724\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc No Research Project Assigned. off 70740\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg No Research Project Assigned. off 70784\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_NO_RESEARCH off 70828\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 0 off 70860\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 70876\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70892\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70904\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 70916\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 1 off 70932\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 70948\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 120372\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 4 off 120388\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 120404\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 2 off 120420\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/.  off 120432\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./EvTurn 2 off 120444\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events  off 120460\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/. 1 off 120476\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 120488\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 1 off 120500\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc Ships Constructed At Ke'Dolarra off 120516\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg 1 ship built in system Ke'Dolarra off 120560\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT off 120608\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 288 off 120640\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 120656\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. -11.92860221862793 off 120672\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 4.719004154205322 off 120684\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2.3178513050079346 off 120696\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 0 off 120712\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 120728\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/.  off 120756\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./EvTurn 3 off 120768\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events  off 120784\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/. 2 off 120800\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 120812\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 2 off 120824\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc Ships Constructed At Ke'Dolarra off 120840\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg 1 ship built in system Ke'Dolarra off 120884\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_SHIPS_BUILT off 120932\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 288 off 120964\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 120980\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. -11.92860221862793 off 120996\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 4.719004154205322 off 121008\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2.3178513050079346 off 121020\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 0 off 121036\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 121052\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/.  off 121072\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvEID 3 off 121084\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvDsc Research Over Budget off 121100\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvMsg Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget. off 121136\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvImg EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET off 121196\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvLoc 0 off 121236\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos  off 121252\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 121268\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 121280\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvPos/. 2139095039 off 121292\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvAct 1 off 121308\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/./Events/./EvCID 0 off 121324\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 182640\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 182656\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 182672\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 182688\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 240468\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 240484\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 240500\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 240516\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 303412\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 303428\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 303444\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 303460\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 393888\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 393904\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 393920\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 393936\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 456180\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 456196\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 456212\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 456228\n/Sim/Player/Events  off 523688\n/Sim/Player/Events/EvNxID 0 off 523704\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events  off 523720\n/Sim/Player/Events/Events/. 0 off 523736\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 -c 'import json,subprocess; x=json.loads(subprocess.check_output([\"python3\",\"verify/save-reader/save_reader.py\",\"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\"--dump\",\"--json\",\"--strict\"],text=True))[\"tree\"]\ndef walk(xs,p=\"\"):\n for i,n in enumerate(xs):\n  name=n.get(\"_name\",n.get(\"name\",f\"[{i}]\")); q=p+\"/\"+str(name)\n  if \"/Sim/Player/Events\" in q: print(q, n.get(\"value\",\"\"), \"off\",n.get(\"off\",n.get(\"_off\")))\n  if \"_items\" in n: walk(n[\"_items\"],q)\nwalk(x)'","time":{"start":1788999451197,"end":1788999460345}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_01cd7c32e3451deb016aa1f71525a487d184aa9f357a15ab87"}},"id":"prt_088ad2b20001GaFjvnB1Mn0Ojr","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ad1153001Sctyx2wcpQWOdZ"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999460396,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ad6628001MzlhSyqaP68eeo","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"d826b565cdc3396385f966268e685bf261a19523","messageID":"msg_088ad1153001Sctyx2wcpQWOdZ","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":91543,"input":1084,"output":204,"reasoning":15,"cache":{"write":0,"read":90240}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999464137,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ad74c6001bYKa35ifqvokLE","messageID":"msg_088ad66620016Qi4E8dGHTdgoF","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"bc3378de7b8409cecfe78fe7b237bb1b000a19f8","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999489543,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_bLJXCR1M7URIbufr1bLNbF5f","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 -c 'import hashlib,pathlib,subprocess; p=pathlib.Path(\"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\"); text=p.read_text(); chunks=text.split(\"# $ \")[1:]; ok=True\nfor chunk in chunks:\n lines=chunk.splitlines(); cmd=lines[0]; expected=\"\\n\".join(lines[2:]).rstrip()+\"\\n\"; got=subprocess.run(cmd.split(),capture_output=True,text=True); same=got.returncode==0 and got.stdout.rstrip()==expected.rstrip(); ok &= same; print(cmd,\"exit\",got.returncode,\"bytes\",len(got.stdout.encode()),\"sha256\",hashlib.sha256(got.stdout.encode()).hexdigest(),\"archive_exact\",same,\"stderr_bytes\",len(got.stderr.encode()))\nprint(\"all_exact\",ok); raise SystemExit(0 if ok else 1)'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 bytes 6130 sha256 1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8 archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 bytes 1333 sha256 373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe exit 0 bytes 2570 sha256 1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66 archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 bytes 2644 sha256 4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580 archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nall_exact False\n","metadata":{"output":"objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 bytes 6130 sha256 1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8 archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 bytes 1333 sha256 373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe exit 0 bytes 2570 sha256 1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66 archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 bytes 2644 sha256 4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580 archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nall_exact False\n","exit":1,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 -c 'import hashlib,pathlib,subprocess; p=pathlib.Path(\"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\"); text=p.read_text(); chunks=text.split(\"# $ \")[1:]; ok=True\nfor chunk in chunks:\n lines=chunk.splitlines(); cmd=lines[0]; expected=\"\\n\".join(lines[2:]).rstrip()+\"\\n\"; got=subprocess.run(cmd.split(),capture_output=True,text=True); same=got.returncode==0 and got.stdout.rstrip()==expected.rstrip(); ok &= same; print(cmd,\"exit\",got.returncode,\"bytes\",len(got.stdout.encode()),\"sha256\",hashlib.sha256(got.stdout.encode()).hexdigest(),\"archive_exact\",same,\"stderr_bytes\",len(got.stderr.encode()))\nprint(\"all_exact\",ok); raise SystemExit(0 if ok else 1)'","time":{"start":1788999489481,"end":1788999489540}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0c96c930195db569016aa1f73ab4a487d1b52215e90c709547"}},"id":"prt_088adbe2a001OVrIPlorXZ06QR","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ad66620016Qi4E8dGHTdgoF"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999489591,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088add833001lKfDjGdmM71Tkn","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"afc7507dfb7ff33cf0fd2e06920b7cdfbd01be55","messageID":"msg_088ad66620016Qi4E8dGHTdgoF","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":94542,"input":2619,"output":234,"reasoning":553,"cache":{"write":0,"read":91136}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999491814,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ade0e3001IQWe2rI2DNrN2i","messageID":"msg_088add86e001TuKaIkybYaK1Gd","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"90e6a86a368b3751e9e9e01b7250c89b953e58a9","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999503244,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_YqOmPJUjz7Qt91GxAGUpCaRW","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 -c 'import pathlib,subprocess,difflib; text=pathlib.Path(\"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\").read_text(); chunk=text.split(\"# $ \")[1]; lines=chunk.splitlines(); cmd=lines[0]; expected=\"\\n\".join(lines[2:]).rstrip()+\"\\n\"; got=subprocess.check_output(cmd.split(),text=True); print(\"expected\",len(expected),\"got\",len(got)); print(\"\\n\".join(list(difflib.unified_diff(expected.splitlines(),got.splitlines(),n=2))[:30]))'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re"},"output":"expected 6130 got 6130\n--- \n\n+++ \n\n@@ -1,2 +1,3 @@\n\n+\n dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n \n@@ -44,5 +45,5 @@\n\n   825da0:\td9 46 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x44]\n   825da3:\td9 47 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x44]\n-  825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n+  825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n   825da8:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n   825daa:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n@@ -50,5 +51,5 @@\n\n   825daf:\td9 46 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x48]\n   825db2:\td9 47 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x48]\n-  825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n+  825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n   825db7:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n   825db9:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n@@ -56,5 +57,5 @@\n\n   825dbe:\td9 46 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4c]\n   825dc1:\td9 47 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4c]\n-  825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n+  825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n   825dc6:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n   825dc8:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n@@ -124,3 +125,3 @@\n\n   825e61:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n   825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n","metadata":{"output":"expected 6130 got 6130\n--- \n\n+++ \n\n@@ -1,2 +1,3 @@\n\n+\n dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n \n@@ -44,5 +45,5 @@\n\n   825da0:\td9 46 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x44]\n   825da3:\td9 47 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x44]\n-  825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n+  825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n   825da8:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n   825daa:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n@@ -50,5 +51,5 @@\n\n   825daf:\td9 46 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x48]\n   825db2:\td9 47 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x48]\n-  825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n+  825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n   825db7:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n   825db9:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n@@ -56,5 +57,5 @@\n\n   825dbe:\td9 46 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4c]\n   825dc1:\td9 47 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4c]\n-  825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n+  825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp \n   825dc6:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n   825dc8:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n@@ -124,3 +125,3 @@\n\n   825e61:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n   825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 -c 'import pathlib,subprocess,difflib; text=pathlib.Path(\"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\").read_text(); chunk=text.split(\"# $ \")[1]; lines=chunk.splitlines(); cmd=lines[0]; expected=\"\\n\".join(lines[2:]).rstrip()+\"\\n\"; got=subprocess.check_output(cmd.split(),text=True); print(\"expected\",len(expected),\"got\",len(got)); print(\"\\n\".join(list(difflib.unified_diff(expected.splitlines(),got.splitlines(),n=2))[:30]))'","time":{"start":1788999503206,"end":1788999503242}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0a1c9f4ccd941149016aa1f749748887d1a9afc6e9e6dd5498"}},"id":"prt_088adf71c0014usmzE26guv1ZL","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088add86e001TuKaIkybYaK1Gd"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999503349,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ae0df2001okqOK5sixysfA0","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"b0141eab2cac8f939050d7420567b7d10326cc74","messageID":"msg_088add86e001TuKaIkybYaK1Gd","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":95227,"input":1327,"output":175,"reasoning":157,"cache":{"write":0,"read":93568}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999506039,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ae18720014T1rTvk75wCN0V","messageID":"msg_088ae0e2d001sC3YQ7YWWMZR0e","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"ccf1e8813962b8898d387c1455bff936437c1e4e","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999526368,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_q9bJ6XWcJFUj4cgQAGeM9vX8","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 -c 'import hashlib,pathlib,subprocess,re; text=pathlib.Path(\"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\").read_text(); chunks=text.split(\"# $ \")[1:]; ok=True\nnorm=lambda s:\"\\n\".join(line.rstrip() for line in s.strip().splitlines())\nfor chunk in chunks:\n lines=chunk.splitlines(); cmd=lines[0]; expected=\"\\n\".join(lines[2:]); got=subprocess.run(cmd.split(),capture_output=True,text=True); same=got.returncode==0 and norm(got.stdout)==norm(expected); ok &= same; print(cmd,\"exit\",got.returncode,\"instructions\",sum(bool(re.match(r\"^\\s+[0-9a-f]+:\",z)) for z in got.stdout.splitlines()),\"stdout_sha256\",hashlib.sha256(got.stdout.encode()).hexdigest(),\"normalized_archive_exact\",same,\"stderr_bytes\",len(got.stderr.encode()))\nprint(\"all_normalized_exact\",ok); raise SystemExit(0 if ok else 1)'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 instructions 120 stdout_sha256 1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8 normalized_archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 instructions 26 stdout_sha256 373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed normalized_archive_exact True stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe exit 0 instructions 51 stdout_sha256 1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66 normalized_archive_exact True stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 instructions 51 stdout_sha256 4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580 normalized_archive_exact True stderr_bytes 0\nall_normalized_exact False\n","metadata":{"output":"objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 instructions 120 stdout_sha256 1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8 normalized_archive_exact False stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 instructions 26 stdout_sha256 373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed normalized_archive_exact True stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe exit 0 instructions 51 stdout_sha256 1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66 normalized_archive_exact True stderr_bytes 0\nobjdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe exit 0 instructions 51 stdout_sha256 4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580 normalized_archive_exact True stderr_bytes 0\nall_normalized_exact False\n","exit":1,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 -c 'import hashlib,pathlib,subprocess,re; text=pathlib.Path(\"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\").read_text(); chunks=text.split(\"# $ \")[1:]; ok=True\nnorm=lambda s:\"\\n\".join(line.rstrip() for line in s.strip().splitlines())\nfor chunk in chunks:\n lines=chunk.splitlines(); cmd=lines[0]; expected=\"\\n\".join(lines[2:]); got=subprocess.run(cmd.split(),capture_output=True,text=True); same=got.returncode==0 and norm(got.stdout)==norm(expected); ok &= same; print(cmd,\"exit\",got.returncode,\"instructions\",sum(bool(re.match(r\"^\\s+[0-9a-f]+:\",z)) for z in got.stdout.splitlines()),\"stdout_sha256\",hashlib.sha256(got.stdout.encode()).hexdigest(),\"normalized_archive_exact\",same,\"stderr_bytes\",len(got.stderr.encode()))\nprint(\"all_normalized_exact\",ok); raise SystemExit(0 if ok else 1)'","time":{"start":1788999526298,"end":1788999526366}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_04ef59a85a2d5eb8016aa1f766199887d19782e6054a5b732d"}},"id":"prt_088ae677e001cI9eghZKv2vjv2","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ae0e2d001sC3YQ7YWWMZR0e"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999526477,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ae6849001Ruom7OjfGTLEos","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"4ac619e3afbfe01cf66964decdc5c88c1f17bc2b","messageID":"msg_088ae0e2d001sC3YQ7YWWMZR0e","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":96074,"input":995,"output":276,"reasoning":83,"cache":{"write":0,"read":94720}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999530650,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ae78960010rydyBFAJkmicf","messageID":"msg_088ae6886001jLKq9gPBHPhqDg","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"4ebca898a0735f88f75d78a4323c559a614a2a51","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999540249,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_hV57psmwDciaa7ZRvml6TZzx","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 -c 'import pathlib,subprocess,difflib; text=pathlib.Path(\"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\").read_text(); chunk=text.split(\"# $ \")[1]; lines=chunk.splitlines(); cmd=lines[0]; norm=lambda s:[z.rstrip() for z in s.strip().splitlines()]; e=norm(\"\\n\".join(lines[2:])); g=norm(subprocess.check_output(cmd.split(),text=True)); print(\"\\n\".join(difflib.unified_diff(e,g,n=1)))'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re"},"output":"--- \n\n+++ \n\n@@ -125,2 +125,2 @@\n\n   825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n-  825e64:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n+  825e64:\tc2               \tret    0x8\n","metadata":{"output":"--- \n\n+++ \n\n@@ -125,2 +125,2 @@\n\n   825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n-  825e64:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n+  825e64:\tc2               \tret    0x8\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 -c 'import pathlib,subprocess,difflib; text=pathlib.Path(\"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\").read_text(); chunk=text.split(\"# $ \")[1]; lines=chunk.splitlines(); cmd=lines[0]; norm=lambda s:[z.rstrip() for z in s.strip().splitlines()]; e=norm(\"\\n\".join(lines[2:])); g=norm(subprocess.check_output(cmd.split(),text=True)); print(\"\\n\".join(difflib.unified_diff(e,g,n=1)))'","time":{"start":1788999540212,"end":1788999540247}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_040f02cbcf9eec0c016aa1f76f5c7487d1839cdf98890f3f6b"}},"id":"prt_088ae8b7f001xQmXr8M5xdRj4W","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ae6886001jLKq9gPBHPhqDg"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999540409,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088ae9eb60012eH5G5Ap9MrJcM","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"d500a7aaf15d32504d07a3873b71b89c48906db9","messageID":"msg_088ae6886001jLKq9gPBHPhqDg","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":96733,"input":817,"output":166,"reasoning":134,"cache":{"write":0,"read":95616}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999542868,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aea8500018s4tnp4wqUVZHU","messageID":"msg_088ae9eeb001coG4q6DNSP3CNN","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"aa80b86f884d74d42f70179dbc11054d0c8f8b3c","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999560603,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_PRj1dLAMv0R5z0E6ls3jccTD","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re surprise research-completion-abi --actor research-abi-independent --role verifier --model openai/gpt-5.6-sol --summary 'Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.' --probe 'Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"probe\": \"Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"open\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:19:20.577736+00:00\"\n}\n","metadata":{"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"probe\": \"Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"open\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:19:20.577736+00:00\"\n}\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re surprise research-completion-abi --actor research-abi-independent --role verifier --model openai/gpt-5.6-sol --summary 'Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.' --probe 'Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.'","time":{"start":1788999560530,"end":1788999560600}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0adc0dc1991b2cf5016aa1f77e642487d1bb77209e04974dae"}},"id":"prt_088aec764001Uh02Sso24CSm95","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088ae9eeb001coG4q6DNSP3CNN"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999560654,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aeedcb001gqZK8bXrIwrvcY","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"be0a5933375d8bc7e4419a2e84111689e913dfaf","messageID":"msg_088ae9eeb001coG4q6DNSP3CNN","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":97366,"input":556,"output":344,"reasoning":210,"cache":{"write":0,"read":96256}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999562614,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aef5710011LOAODJm1BUjh7","messageID":"msg_088aeee13001PWkPJsviS0oBPi","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"b4dd09caaad63423273ed76b7bdad2b4ebf7de5d","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999616532,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"apply_patch","callID":"call_yKV7YQVGTcly8Yz6T3BIX01y","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"patchText":"*** Begin Patch\n*** Add File: /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n+# Independent ABI verification result (paused)\n+\n+Session `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\n+model claim `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n+\n+## Classification and verdict\n+\n+**Fail / blocked for `independent-cross-check` pending Astra resolution of surprise\n+`s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f`.** This is an independent static reproduction plus archived-save\n+cross-check only. It is not original-assisted runtime execution, a partial or full live compare,\n+an independent replacement, or integrated replay. No live allocator-safety or replacement claim\n+was tested.\n+\n+## Identities\n+\n+* `dumps/sots.exe`: SHA-256\n+  `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, MD5\n+  `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c` (independently recomputed).\n+* Tool reports `GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38`.\n+* Engine worktree: HEAD `7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23`, common Git directory\n+  `/home/alex/sots-engine/.git`, source-binding\n+  `ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd`.\n+* RE worktree: HEAD `3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7`, common Git directory\n+  `/home/alex/sots-re/.git`, source-binding\n+  `6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8`.\n+* Both worktrees had the pre-existing dirty inventories recorded in the checkpoint. This verifier\n+  changed neither worktree and touched no lab resource.\n+\n+## Reproduction results\n+\n+All four handoff commands were executed directly, with no output filter. Each exited zero and\n+emitted nonzero instruction output. Fresh stdout SHA-256 and instruction counts were:\n+\n+| window | instructions | stdout SHA-256 | archive comparison |\n+|---|---:|---|---|\n+| `0x00825d40..0x00825e65` | 120 | `1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8` | **mismatch** |\n+| `0x0046f8c0..0x0046f8f0` | 26 | `373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+| `0x004236a0..0x0042370d` | 51 | `1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+| `0x00422720..0x00422796` | 51 | `4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+\n+The sole semantic-text mismatch is at the first window's terminal instruction. The exact declared\n+command stops at `0x00825e65`, one byte into the three-byte instruction beginning at\n+`0x00825e64`. Fresh objdump stdout reports only byte `c2` while still decoding `ret 0x8`; the\n+archive reports bytes `c2 08 00`. Therefore the archive cannot be unfiltered stdout from the\n+declared command under the recorded effective instrument. The mismatch is not dismissed merely\n+because widening the boundary would likely recover the missing bytes.\n+\n+This failed the predeclared provenance/instrument falsifier. The dedup ABI interpretation is paused;\n+the three matching windows and zero exit statuses are measurements, not a pass.\n+\n+## Independent archived-state check (completed before pause)\n+\n+`python3 verify/save-reader/save_reader.py verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav --dump --json\n+--strict` exited zero. The parser reported 37,847 items, 2,453 frames, zero resyncs, zero hint\n+failures and zero best-effort recoveries (informational positional-tag issues remain). Direct tree\n+inspection, rather than a reported event count, recovered player 1's event storage at inflated\n+offset 120372: `EvNxID=4`; turn-2 bucket with event id 1; turn-3 bucket with event ids 2 and 3.\n+Event 3 is `Research Over Budget`, message `Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.`, image\n+`EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, location 0, action 1, chain id 0, and all three position words are\n+the integer bit pattern `2139095039` (`0x7f7fffff`). Players 2 and 3 each have `EvNxID=0` and an\n+empty event collection. This supports those archived record values only; it is not live execution.\n+\n+## Challenge status, failed predictions, and residuals\n+\n+The planned held-out NaN-position negative control was not promoted to a result after the instrument\n+provenance surprise. Its prediction remains untested in this quantum. Live empty/short/long\n+description fixtures, allocation failure, allocator compatibility, runtime event construction,\n+full-capacity pre/post memory, RNG state and integrated replay also remain residuals. No RNG counter\n+was treated as state evidence; no runtime workload executed, so RNG behavior is outside this result.\n+\n+Reproduction commands are the four exact commands printed in\n+`objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`, followed by the strict save-reader command above. The exact\n+next action belongs to Astra and is recorded in the canonical checkpoint.\n*** End Patch"},"output":"Success. Updated the following files:\nA verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md","metadata":{"diff":"Index: /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n===================================================================\n--- /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n+++ /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n@@ -0,0 +1,73 @@\n+# Independent ABI verification result (paused)\n+\n+Session `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\n+model claim `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n+\n+## Classification and verdict\n+\n+**Fail / blocked for `independent-cross-check` pending Astra resolution of surprise\n+`s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f`.** This is an independent static reproduction plus archived-save\n+cross-check only. It is not original-assisted runtime execution, a partial or full live compare,\n+an independent replacement, or integrated replay. No live allocator-safety or replacement claim\n+was tested.\n+\n+## Identities\n+\n+* `dumps/sots.exe`: SHA-256\n+  `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, MD5\n+  `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c` (independently recomputed).\n+* Tool reports `GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38`.\n+* Engine worktree: HEAD `7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23`, common Git directory\n+  `/home/alex/sots-engine/.git`, source-binding\n+  `ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd`.\n+* RE worktree: HEAD `3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7`, common Git directory\n+  `/home/alex/sots-re/.git`, source-binding\n+  `6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8`.\n+* Both worktrees had the pre-existing dirty inventories recorded in the checkpoint. This verifier\n+  changed neither worktree and touched no lab resource.\n+\n+## Reproduction results\n+\n+All four handoff commands were executed directly, with no output filter. Each exited zero and\n+emitted nonzero instruction output. Fresh stdout SHA-256 and instruction counts were:\n+\n+| window | instructions | stdout SHA-256 | archive comparison |\n+|---|---:|---|---|\n+| `0x00825d40..0x00825e65` | 120 | `1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8` | **mismatch** |\n+| `0x0046f8c0..0x0046f8f0` | 26 | `373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+| `0x004236a0..0x0042370d` | 51 | `1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+| `0x00422720..0x00422796` | 51 | `4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+\n+The sole semantic-text mismatch is at the first window's terminal instruction. The exact declared\n+command stops at `0x00825e65`, one byte into the three-byte instruction beginning at\n+`0x00825e64`. Fresh objdump stdout reports only byte `c2` while still decoding `ret 0x8`; the\n+archive reports bytes `c2 08 00`. Therefore the archive cannot be unfiltered stdout from the\n+declared command under the recorded effective instrument. The mismatch is not dismissed merely\n+because widening the boundary would likely recover the missing bytes.\n+\n+This failed the predeclared provenance/instrument falsifier. The dedup ABI interpretation is paused;\n+the three matching windows and zero exit statuses are measurements, not a pass.\n+\n+## Independent archived-state check (completed before pause)\n+\n+`python3 verify/save-reader/save_reader.py verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav --dump --json\n+--strict` exited zero. The parser reported 37,847 items, 2,453 frames, zero resyncs, zero hint\n+failures and zero best-effort recoveries (informational positional-tag issues remain). Direct tree\n+inspection, rather than a reported event count, recovered player 1's event storage at inflated\n+offset 120372: `EvNxID=4`; turn-2 bucket with event id 1; turn-3 bucket with event ids 2 and 3.\n+Event 3 is `Research Over Budget`, message `Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.`, image\n+`EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, location 0, action 1, chain id 0, and all three position words are\n+the integer bit pattern `2139095039` (`0x7f7fffff`). Players 2 and 3 each have `EvNxID=0` and an\n+empty event collection. This supports those archived record values only; it is not live execution.\n+\n+## Challenge status, failed predictions, and residuals\n+\n+The planned held-out NaN-position negative control was not promoted to a result after the instrument\n+provenance surprise. Its prediction remains untested in this quantum. Live empty/short/long\n+description fixtures, allocation failure, allocator compatibility, runtime event construction,\n+full-capacity pre/post memory, RNG state and integrated replay also remain residuals. No RNG counter\n+was treated as state evidence; no runtime workload executed, so RNG behavior is outside this result.\n+\n+Reproduction commands are the four exact commands printed in\n+`objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`, followed by the strict save-reader command above. The exact\n+next action belongs to Astra and is recorded in the canonical checkpoint.\n\n","files":[{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md","relativePath":"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md","type":"add","patch":"Index: /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n===================================================================\n--- /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n+++ /home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n@@ -0,0 +1,73 @@\n+# Independent ABI verification result (paused)\n+\n+Session `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\n+model claim `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n+\n+## Classification and verdict\n+\n+**Fail / blocked for `independent-cross-check` pending Astra resolution of surprise\n+`s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f`.** This is an independent static reproduction plus archived-save\n+cross-check only. It is not original-assisted runtime execution, a partial or full live compare,\n+an independent replacement, or integrated replay. No live allocator-safety or replacement claim\n+was tested.\n+\n+## Identities\n+\n+* `dumps/sots.exe`: SHA-256\n+  `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, MD5\n+  `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c` (independently recomputed).\n+* Tool reports `GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38`.\n+* Engine worktree: HEAD `7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23`, common Git directory\n+  `/home/alex/sots-engine/.git`, source-binding\n+  `ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd`.\n+* RE worktree: HEAD `3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7`, common Git directory\n+  `/home/alex/sots-re/.git`, source-binding\n+  `6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8`.\n+* Both worktrees had the pre-existing dirty inventories recorded in the checkpoint. This verifier\n+  changed neither worktree and touched no lab resource.\n+\n+## Reproduction results\n+\n+All four handoff commands were executed directly, with no output filter. Each exited zero and\n+emitted nonzero instruction output. Fresh stdout SHA-256 and instruction counts were:\n+\n+| window | instructions | stdout SHA-256 | archive comparison |\n+|---|---:|---|---|\n+| `0x00825d40..0x00825e65` | 120 | `1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8` | **mismatch** |\n+| `0x0046f8c0..0x0046f8f0` | 26 | `373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+| `0x004236a0..0x0042370d` | 51 | `1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+| `0x00422720..0x00422796` | 51 | `4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n+\n+The sole semantic-text mismatch is at the first window's terminal instruction. The exact declared\n+command stops at `0x00825e65`, one byte into the three-byte instruction beginning at\n+`0x00825e64`. Fresh objdump stdout reports only byte `c2` while still decoding `ret 0x8`; the\n+archive reports bytes `c2 08 00`. Therefore the archive cannot be unfiltered stdout from the\n+declared command under the recorded effective instrument. The mismatch is not dismissed merely\n+because widening the boundary would likely recover the missing bytes.\n+\n+This failed the predeclared provenance/instrument falsifier. The dedup ABI interpretation is paused;\n+the three matching windows and zero exit statuses are measurements, not a pass.\n+\n+## Independent archived-state check (completed before pause)\n+\n+`python3 verify/save-reader/save_reader.py verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav --dump --json\n+--strict` exited zero. The parser reported 37,847 items, 2,453 frames, zero resyncs, zero hint\n+failures and zero best-effort recoveries (informational positional-tag issues remain). Direct tree\n+inspection, rather than a reported event count, recovered player 1's event storage at inflated\n+offset 120372: `EvNxID=4`; turn-2 bucket with event id 1; turn-3 bucket with event ids 2 and 3.\n+Event 3 is `Research Over Budget`, message `Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.`, image\n+`EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, location 0, action 1, chain id 0, and all three position words are\n+the integer bit pattern `2139095039` (`0x7f7fffff`). Players 2 and 3 each have `EvNxID=0` and an\n+empty event collection. This supports those archived record values only; it is not live execution.\n+\n+## Challenge status, failed predictions, and residuals\n+\n+The planned held-out NaN-position negative control was not promoted to a result after the instrument\n+provenance surprise. Its prediction remains untested in this quantum. Live empty/short/long\n+description fixtures, allocation failure, allocator compatibility, runtime event construction,\n+full-capacity pre/post memory, RNG state and integrated replay also remain residuals. No RNG counter\n+was treated as state evidence; no runtime workload executed, so RNG behavior is outside this result.\n+\n+Reproduction commands are the four exact commands printed in\n+`objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`, followed by the strict save-reader command above. The exact\n+next action belongs to Astra and is recorded in the canonical checkpoint.\n","additions":73,"deletions":0}],"diagnostics":{},"truncated":false},"title":"Success. Updated the following files:\nA verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md","time":{"start":1788999616523,"end":1788999616528}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0ea1272d9bd2da73016aa1f79109f487d1871a103c3ca3494b"}},"id":"prt_088af0ec2001nUGNEWhQqwT1NB","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088aeee13001PWkPJsviS0oBPi"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999616684,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088afc8a9001O8yS0DCjgEIQrI","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"270748fee7f01da84f11e03aca44e54f6781c1ee","messageID":"msg_088aeee13001PWkPJsviS0oBPi","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":99444,"input":1122,"output":1503,"reasoning":179,"cache":{"write":0,"read":96640}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999619650,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088afd43f001Zf7LekFNn8kYUk","messageID":"msg_088afc8e40013UENU950Hod0mH","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"ec3ff4147cee4b0edcf0d67f4fd4ddc77aed4c65","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999625632,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"todowrite","callID":"call_gDKE4o99swsUR1lR0gAD9s01","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"todos":[{"content":"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint","status":"in_progress","priority":"high"}]},"output":"[\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities\",\n    \"status\": \"completed\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states\",\n    \"status\": \"completed\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption\",\n    \"status\": \"completed\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint\",\n    \"status\": \"in_progress\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  }\n]","metadata":{"todos":[{"content":"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint","status":"in_progress","priority":"high"}],"truncated":false},"title":"1 todos","time":{"start":1788999625627,"end":1788999625630}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_088132244b7164f5016aa1f7c6316087d1882ebaae4b2b2b2f"}},"id":"prt_088afde57001eCqD4eYRc20HGw","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088afc8e40013UENU950Hod0mH"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999625806,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088afec4b001U0xRsR4ZEmkFrS","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"883dc11aa03cab119e10c9b421e5e81f5e954268","messageID":"msg_088afc8e40013UENU950Hod0mH","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":99646,"input":1810,"output":111,"reasoning":61,"cache":{"write":0,"read":97664}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999628306,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088aff60f0017mOikEqJbidFaV","messageID":"msg_088afec84001tuozr2tEk2wQJT","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"56a904166563d9f36cc2ef18191d5b11a52c56da","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999637434,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_IZlK7eNSabHKxi824m49lT2Q","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"sha256sum verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json verify/save-reader/save_reader.py","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re"},"output":"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008  verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53  verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921  verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\nd6e41b41efa5bf9a155615e08dd4a075ce5c80aa3ad0067370014cd22ebabc86  campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json\n2dcac286b5382b67fe8f2dbce58c80950dd430b726ed0e98f3bcea155df0df35  verify/save-reader/save_reader.py\n","metadata":{"output":"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008  verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\n257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53  verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\n978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921  verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\nd6e41b41efa5bf9a155615e08dd4a075ce5c80aa3ad0067370014cd22ebabc86  campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json\n2dcac286b5382b67fe8f2dbce58c80950dd430b726ed0e98f3bcea155df0df35  verify/save-reader/save_reader.py\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"sha256sum verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json verify/save-reader/save_reader.py","time":{"start":1788999637385,"end":1788999637423}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0179415995dab26b016aa1f7d5144487d1ad71889b2a92f84e"}},"id":"prt_088b01984001T985wv0z8LP6Xo","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088afec84001tuozr2tEk2wQJT"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999637434,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_aEQ1bQXsdCeoiqezcyLSu98c","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"git status --short","workdir":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine"},"output":" M CONTRIBUTING.md\n M README.md\n M docs/S-standalone.md\n M src/app/turn.cpp\n M src/game/sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.cpp\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.h\n M tests/app/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/app/test_command_replay.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn_record.cpp\n M tests/game_config/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_data/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/test_census_saves.cpp\n M tests/game_sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/test_domains.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_rng.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_save.cpp\n M tests/mars_text/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_vfs/CMakeLists.txt\n M tools/clean_room_check.sh\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? docs/architecture.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/clean_room_check.py\n","metadata":{"output":" M CONTRIBUTING.md\n M README.md\n M docs/S-standalone.md\n M src/app/turn.cpp\n M src/game/sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.cpp\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.h\n M tests/app/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/app/test_command_replay.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn_record.cpp\n M tests/game_config/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_data/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/test_census_saves.cpp\n M tests/game_sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/test_domains.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_rng.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_save.cpp\n M tests/mars_text/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_vfs/CMakeLists.txt\n M tools/clean_room_check.sh\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? docs/architecture.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/clean_room_check.py\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"git status --short","time":{"start":1788999637402,"end":1788999637428}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0179415995dab26b016aa1f7d5146887d1ad26cbf34f67fe31"}},"id":"prt_088b01995001A2gnMjHW3I3ncZ","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088afec84001tuozr2tEk2wQJT"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999637434,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_GZ3sW1bnyH3szcUpihNgb8oT","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"git status --short","workdir":"/tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re"},"output":" M README.md\n M campaign/DASHBOARD.md\n M campaign/backlog.md\n M campaign/board.md\n M campaign/open-questions.md\n M findings/00-strategy.md\n M findings/subsystems/nav-classifier-live.md\n M findings/subsystems/research-replace.md\n M guides/method-rules.md\n D scripts/forgejo_campaign.py\n M tools/DASHBOARD_README.md\n M tools/dashboard.py\n D tools/displacement.py\n M tools/gate.sh\n M tools/standalone_report.py\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? campaign/README.md\n?? campaign/agents/\n?? campaign/contract.schema.json\n?? campaign/contracts/\n?? campaign/current.json\n?? campaign/models.json\n?? campaign/pilots/\n?? campaign/research/\n?? campaign/rollout/\n?? guides/multi-agent-workflow.md\n?? guides/windows-lab-housekeeping.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/campaign.py\n?? tools/check_agent_config.py\n?? tools/evidence.py\n?? tools/gate.py\n?? tools/run_agent.py\n?? tools/select_evidence.py\n?? tools/windows-housekeeping/\n?? verify/campaign/\n?? verify/config/\n?? verify/publishing/\n?? verify/results/housekeeping/\n?? verify/tooling/\n","metadata":{"output":" M README.md\n M campaign/DASHBOARD.md\n M campaign/backlog.md\n M campaign/board.md\n M campaign/open-questions.md\n M findings/00-strategy.md\n M findings/subsystems/nav-classifier-live.md\n M findings/subsystems/research-replace.md\n M guides/method-rules.md\n D scripts/forgejo_campaign.py\n M tools/DASHBOARD_README.md\n M tools/dashboard.py\n D tools/displacement.py\n M tools/gate.sh\n M tools/standalone_report.py\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? campaign/README.md\n?? campaign/agents/\n?? campaign/contract.schema.json\n?? campaign/contracts/\n?? campaign/current.json\n?? campaign/models.json\n?? campaign/pilots/\n?? campaign/research/\n?? campaign/rollout/\n?? guides/multi-agent-workflow.md\n?? guides/windows-lab-housekeeping.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/campaign.py\n?? tools/check_agent_config.py\n?? tools/evidence.py\n?? tools/gate.py\n?? tools/run_agent.py\n?? tools/select_evidence.py\n?? tools/windows-housekeeping/\n?? verify/campaign/\n?? verify/config/\n?? verify/publishing/\n?? verify/results/housekeeping/\n?? verify/tooling/\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"git status --short","time":{"start":1788999637411,"end":1788999637432}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0179415995dab26b016aa1f7d5147487d1863fd26054a0121f"}},"id":"prt_088b0199e001W2OWtcuLkpK5IK","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088afec84001tuozr2tEk2wQJT"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999637510,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_SsYMRoDOrYXh1DD7i8h2MTIR","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-completion-abi && python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"[\n  {\n    \"acceptance\": [\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n        \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n      },\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"validation\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n        \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"baseline\": {\n      \"engine\": {\n        \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n      },\n      \"re\": {\n        \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n      }\n    },\n    \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-49350005b48eb04a30cd156f.json\",\n    \"dependencies\": [\n      \"controls-bootstrap\"\n    ],\n    \"effects\": [\n      \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n    ],\n    \"evidence\": [],\n    \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n    \"inputs\": [\n      \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n      \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n      \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n      \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n    ],\n    \"open_surprises\": [\n      {\n        \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n        \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n        \"id\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n        \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n        \"probe\": \"Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.\",\n        \"role\": \"verifier\",\n        \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n        \"status\": \"open\",\n        \"summary\": \"Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.\",\n        \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:19:20.577736+00:00\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"original_dependencies\": [\n      \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n    ],\n    \"owner\": {\n      \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n      \"role\": \"analyst\"\n    },\n    \"predictions\": [\n      \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n      \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n    ],\n    \"scope\": [\n      \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n      \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n      \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n      \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n      \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n    ],\n    \"status\": \"blocked\",\n    \"stop_conditions\": [\n      \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n      \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n      \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n    ],\n    \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n  }\n]\n[\n  \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"launcher-smoke\",\n  \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"research-replacement\"\n]\n","metadata":{"output":"[\n  {\n    \"acceptance\": [\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n        \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n      },\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"validation\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n        \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"baseline\": {\n      \"engine\": {\n        \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n      },\n      \"re\": {\n        \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n      }\n    },\n    \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-49350005b48eb04a30cd156f.json\",\n    \"dependencies\": [\n      \"controls-bootstrap\"\n    ],\n    \"effects\": [\n      \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n    ],\n    \"evidence\": [],\n    \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n    \"inputs\": [\n      \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n      \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n      \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n      \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n    ],\n    \"open_surprises\": [\n      {\n        \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n        \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n        \"id\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n        \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n        \"probe\": \"Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.\",\n        \"role\": \"verifier\",\n        \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n        \"status\": \"open\",\n        \"summary\": \"Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.\",\n        \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:19:20.577736+00:00\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"original_dependencies\": [\n      \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n    ],\n    \"owner\": {\n      \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n      \"role\": \"analyst\"\n    },\n    \"predictions\": [\n      \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n      \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n    ],\n    \"scope\": [\n      \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n      \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n      \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n      \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n      \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n    ],\n    \"status\": \"blocked\",\n    \"stop_conditions\": [\n      \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n      \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n      \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n    ],\n    \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n  }\n]\n[\n  \"controls-bootstrap\",\n  \"launcher-smoke\",\n  \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"research-replacement\"\n]\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-completion-abi && python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate","time":{"start":1788999637393,"end":1788999637508}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0179415995dab26b016aa1f7d5145c87d193fe8e26b69556db"}},"id":"prt_088b0198d0019825jsd0ugpF2V","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088afec84001tuozr2tEk2wQJT"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999638206,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088b01cbb001ygZIL7998KKRQB","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"61fb5daf51fc816ceec53e1f810b732cb8f8f829","messageID":"msg_088afec84001tuozr2tEk2wQJT","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":100081,"input":474,"output":244,"reasoning":35,"cache":{"write":0,"read":99328}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999640386,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088b02538001fkRpi6irVtaSfi","messageID":"msg_088b01cec001bmp24LiTJUI5EZ","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"d376f876f7a6ecc14101fc9285c4582057b0d2a8","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999669549,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_326qvLPl6z5PD335zDU7LTEc","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint research-completion-abi --actor research-abi-independent --role verifier --model openai/gpt-5.6-sol --session run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f --summary 'Mandatory end-of-quantum verifier checkpoint. Observations versus decisions: all required canonical inputs and resolved surprises were read; model registry matches requested openai/gpt-5.6-sol. Assigned source identities remained engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git/binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git/binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Pre-existing dirty inventories remained; this verifier edited no assigned source worktree. Input sots.exe independently matched SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; objdump reports 2.38. Decision before experiment: verifier-owned plan fixed falsifiers, required static branches/distinct states, scope labels and held-out NaN control. Tests: all four exact dedup-helper objdump commands exited zero with 120/26/51/51 instructions. Windows 2-4 matched the archive after line-end whitespace normalization. Window 1 did not: stop 0x00825e65 fresh output contains only byte c2 at 0x00825e64 while the archive claims c2 08 00 and calls itself unfiltered exact-command output. This falsified the provenance/instrument falsifier; surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f was recorded, contract is blocked, and affected ABI interpretation/NaN challenge stopped rather than being scored pass. Independent archived-state check before pause: strict save reader exited zero with 37847 items, 2453 frames, zero resyncs/hint failures/best-effort; direct tree values at inflated offset 120372 recover player 1 EvNxID 4, turn buckets 2/3, IDs 1/2/3 and full overbudget record with FLT_MAX bit words. Scope is independent static reproduction plus archived-save cross-check only, not live original-assisted execution, compare, replacement or integrated replay. No RNG/runtime execution, allocator safety, full-capacity live fixture, allocation failure, or integrated state was tested. No lab leases/resources/actions. Result is fail/blocked for independent-cross-check; no verdict or evidence promotion issued. Campaign validate succeeds with the surprise open.' --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md --artifact campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json --artifact verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav --next-action 'Astra resolve surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f by rerunning and archiving raw stdout for stop-address 0x00825e65 and minimally widened 0x00825e67 against the hashed executable, then decide and record the provenance repair before verifier work resumes.'","workdir":"/home/alex/sots-re","timeout":120000},"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json\",\n      \"sha256\": \"d6e41b41efa5bf9a155615e08dd4a075ce5c80aa3ad0067370014cd22ebabc86\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\n      \"sha256\": \"978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Astra resolve surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f by rerunning and archiving raw stdout for stop-address 0x00825e65 and minimally widened 0x00825e67 against the hashed executable, then decide and record the provenance repair before verifier work resumes.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f\",\n  \"summary\": \"Mandatory end-of-quantum verifier checkpoint. Observations versus decisions: all required canonical inputs and resolved surprises were read; model registry matches requested openai/gpt-5.6-sol. Assigned source identities remained engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git/binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git/binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Pre-existing dirty inventories remained; this verifier edited no assigned source worktree. Input sots.exe independently matched SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; objdump reports 2.38. Decision before experiment: verifier-owned plan fixed falsifiers, required static branches/distinct states, scope labels and held-out NaN control. Tests: all four exact dedup-helper objdump commands exited zero with 120/26/51/51 instructions. Windows 2-4 matched the archive after line-end whitespace normalization. Window 1 did not: stop 0x00825e65 fresh output contains only byte c2 at 0x00825e64 while the archive claims c2 08 00 and calls itself unfiltered exact-command output. This falsified the provenance/instrument falsifier; surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f was recorded, contract is blocked, and affected ABI interpretation/NaN challenge stopped rather than being scored pass. Independent archived-state check before pause: strict save reader exited zero with 37847 items, 2453 frames, zero resyncs/hint failures/best-effort; direct tree values at inflated offset 120372 recover player 1 EvNxID 4, turn buckets 2/3, IDs 1/2/3 and full overbudget record with FLT_MAX bit words. Scope is independent static reproduction plus archived-save cross-check only, not live original-assisted execution, compare, replacement or integrated replay. No RNG/runtime execution, allocator safety, full-capacity live fixture, allocation failure, or integrated state was tested. No lab leases/resources/actions. Result is fail/blocked for independent-cross-check; no verdict or evidence promotion issued. Campaign validate succeeds with the surprise open.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:21:09.525111+00:00\"\n}\n","metadata":{"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json\",\n      \"sha256\": \"d6e41b41efa5bf9a155615e08dd4a075ce5c80aa3ad0067370014cd22ebabc86\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\n      \"sha256\": \"978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Astra resolve surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f by rerunning and archiving raw stdout for stop-address 0x00825e65 and minimally widened 0x00825e67 against the hashed executable, then decide and record the provenance repair before verifier work resumes.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f\",\n  \"summary\": \"Mandatory end-of-quantum verifier checkpoint. Observations versus decisions: all required canonical inputs and resolved surprises were read; model registry matches requested openai/gpt-5.6-sol. Assigned source identities remained engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git/binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git/binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Pre-existing dirty inventories remained; this verifier edited no assigned source worktree. Input sots.exe independently matched SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; objdump reports 2.38. Decision before experiment: verifier-owned plan fixed falsifiers, required static branches/distinct states, scope labels and held-out NaN control. Tests: all four exact dedup-helper objdump commands exited zero with 120/26/51/51 instructions. Windows 2-4 matched the archive after line-end whitespace normalization. Window 1 did not: stop 0x00825e65 fresh output contains only byte c2 at 0x00825e64 while the archive claims c2 08 00 and calls itself unfiltered exact-command output. This falsified the provenance/instrument falsifier; surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f was recorded, contract is blocked, and affected ABI interpretation/NaN challenge stopped rather than being scored pass. Independent archived-state check before pause: strict save reader exited zero with 37847 items, 2453 frames, zero resyncs/hint failures/best-effort; direct tree values at inflated offset 120372 recover player 1 EvNxID 4, turn buckets 2/3, IDs 1/2/3 and full overbudget record with FLT_MAX bit words. Scope is independent static reproduction plus archived-save cross-check only, not live original-assisted execution, compare, replacement or integrated replay. No RNG/runtime execution, allocator safety, full-capacity live fixture, allocation failure, or integrated state was tested. No lab leases/resources/actions. Result is fail/blocked for independent-cross-check; no verdict or evidence promotion issued. Campaign validate succeeds with the surprise open.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:21:09.525111+00:00\"\n}\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint research-completion-abi --actor research-abi-independent --role verifier --model openai/gpt-5.6-sol --session run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f --summary 'Mandatory end-of-quantum verifier checkpoint. Observations versus decisions: all required canonical inputs and resolved surprises were read; model registry matches requested openai/gpt-5.6-sol. Assigned source identities remained engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git/binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git/binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Pre-existing dirty inventories remained; this verifier edited no assigned source worktree. Input sots.exe independently matched SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; objdump reports 2.38. Decision before experiment: verifier-owned plan fixed falsifiers, required static branches/distinct states, scope labels and held-out NaN control. Tests: all four exact dedup-helper objdump commands exited zero with 120/26/51/51 instructions. Windows 2-4 matched the archive after line-end whitespace normalization. Window 1 did not: stop 0x00825e65 fresh output contains only byte c2 at 0x00825e64 while the archive claims c2 08 00 and calls itself unfiltered exact-command output. This falsified the provenance/instrument falsifier; surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f was recorded, contract is blocked, and affected ABI interpretation/NaN challenge stopped rather than being scored pass. Independent archived-state check before pause: strict save reader exited zero with 37847 items, 2453 frames, zero resyncs/hint failures/best-effort; direct tree values at inflated offset 120372 recover player 1 EvNxID 4, turn buckets 2/3, IDs 1/2/3 and full overbudget record with FLT_MAX bit words. Scope is independent static reproduction plus archived-save cross-check only, not live original-assisted execution, compare, replacement or integrated replay. No RNG/runtime execution, allocator safety, full-capacity live fixture, allocation failure, or integrated state was tested. No lab leases/resources/actions. Result is fail/blocked for independent-cross-check; no verdict or evidence promotion issued. Campaign validate succeeds with the surprise open.' --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md --artifact campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json --artifact verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav --next-action 'Astra resolve surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f by rerunning and archiving raw stdout for stop-address 0x00825e65 and minimally widened 0x00825e67 against the hashed executable, then decide and record the provenance repair before verifier work resumes.'","time":{"start":1788999669482,"end":1788999669547}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0fa81dbf560bd2e9016aa1f7dac09087d18c9c1233877d7085"}},"id":"prt_088b02ebf00165gXD1k40MIkee","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088b01cec001bmp24LiTJUI5EZ"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999669652,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088b09791001zuKWQ8ObTdibNC","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"d394e1267a19d4238b41515e546a0feed30da150","messageID":"msg_088b01cec001bmp24LiTJUI5EZ","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":103095,"input":2478,"output":849,"reasoning":56,"cache":{"write":0,"read":99712}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999672307,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088b0a1ef001L4MObnPF9zJDKB","messageID":"msg_088b097c3001uQ2MYtAoFGVKQa","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"30ad0e1e41b18463473b0f1b1452406b9ede9995","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999676903,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"todowrite","callID":"call_IQShJLPX0vspFfAPdSLwHbvl","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"todos":[{"content":"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint","status":"completed","priority":"high"}]},"output":"[\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities\",\n    \"status\": \"completed\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states\",\n    \"status\": \"completed\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption\",\n    \"status\": \"completed\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  },\n  {\n    \"content\": \"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint\",\n    \"status\": \"completed\",\n    \"priority\": \"high\"\n  }\n]","metadata":{"todos":[{"content":"Read canonical instructions, contract, checkpoint, and open surprises; verify identities","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Define verifier falsifiers, required branch exposures, and distinct states","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Reproduce handoff evidence and independently challenge one assumption","status":"completed","priority":"high"},{"content":"Write verifier-owned artifacts and mandatory canonical checkpoint","status":"completed","priority":"high"}],"truncated":false},"title":"0 todos","time":{"start":1788999676899,"end":1788999676902}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_01d07a9c03a519a6016aa1f7f9e25087d1bf356ab005fe95c6"}},"id":"prt_088b0a847001X1YaVp55ARRJq4","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","messageID":"msg_088b097c3001uQ2MYtAoFGVKQa"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999677094,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088b0b4a3001xBUha2EyNlwHfr","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"bc7a395e91adfaa10c491eaee6c4c258c42c8b66","messageID":"msg_088b097c3001uQ2MYtAoFGVKQa","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":104387,"input":2229,"output":110,"reasoning":32,"cache":{"write":0,"read":102016}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999680830,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088b0c3350011oLPLUMsEt0iRC","messageID":"msg_088b0b4d2001ZVrvCBcRQ0eQXb","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","snapshot":"5d7819c1f73b9f941ceeda6271098e31d4a63f19","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"text","timestamp":1788999689353,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088b0c33c0016H9hH2BAxPYiFG","messageID":"msg_088b0b4d2001ZVrvCBcRQ0eQXb","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"text","text":"Quantum completed and checkpointed.\n\n- **Result:** blocked/fail for `independent-cross-check`\n- **Surprise:** `s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f`\n- **Issue:** first archived objdump window is not reproducible as claimed. With stop address `0x00825e65`, fresh objdump emits only byte `c2` at `0x00825e64`; archive records `c2 08 00`.\n- Other three objdump windows reproduced after whitespace normalization.\n- Archived save values were independently recovered successfully.\n- No lab resources, source worktrees, commits, staging, or pushes were touched.\n\nArtifacts:\n\n- `verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md`\n- `verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md`\n- `campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json`\n- Final checkpoint: `campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4.json`\n\nExact next action: Astra resolves the objdump boundary/provenance surprise before verifier work resumes.","time":{"start":1788999680828,"end":1788999689351},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"msg_03057a76548db11e016aa1f800c48c87d1bdfe4018c2b41fd0","phase":"final_answer"}}}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999689807,"sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","part":{"id":"prt_088b0e64700113fo7ikF1m4v97","reason":"stop","snapshot":"8c25d638ddc55bac1605bbc0d5eed723fea2af04","messageID":"msg_088b0b4d2001ZVrvCBcRQ0eQXb","sessionID":"ses_f77566ac0ffeDcaiBW2TUxNMIb","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":104796,"input":478,"output":254,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":104064}},"cost":0}}