{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999717985,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b1545b0011fIHh9ZDFrnFnq","messageID":"msg_088b14aaf001bakKN88yMIwO6b","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"c0e0806dfa57dc2bc8a70bfa7f292564728e9d9d","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999718730,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_Mo7BORMNKtptg5WYX90110PF","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/README.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/README.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Canonical campaign controls\n2: \n3: `sots-re/campaign/` is the state authority. Start with your contract, its checkpoint, open\n4: surprises, and [current policy](../guides/multi-agent-workflow.md). Board/dashboard are generated\n5: projections. Historical evidence is not current acceptance. No automatic commits or lab operations.\n6: \n7: Framework development is complete. The `controls-bootstrap` contract reached scoped acceptance;\n8: see [rollout result](rollout/RESULT.md) and its current contract/verdict for source-bound evidence.\n9: Active work is reverse engineering. Change tooling only to unblock a named RE experiment.\n10: \n11: ## Contract format\n12: \n13: `contract.schema.json` is strict JSON Schema (unknown fields and duplicate JSON keys fail).\n14: The standard-library validator implements the schema's used subset. A populated example is\n15: [contracts/controls-bootstrap.json](contracts/controls-bootstrap.json); its lifecycle is in the record.\n16: \n17: Required fields:\n18: \n19: | Field | Structure |\n20: |---|---|\n21: | `id`, `title`, `status` | Slug, short title, lifecycle state |\n22: | `owner` | `{ \"name\": \"worker-identity\", \"role\": \"implementer\" }` |\n23: | `baseline` | `{ \"engine\": {\"path\":\"/absolute/canonical/engine\",\"commit\":\"full-commit-id\"}, \"re\": {\"path\":\"/absolute/canonical/re\",\"commit\":\"full-commit-id\"} }` |\n24: | `scope`, `inputs`, `effects` | Arrays of explicit nonempty strings; include full write set and runtime inputs |\n25: | `original_dependencies` | String array, including original-assisted portions and unavailable inputs |\n26: | `dependencies` | Array of other contract IDs; all must be accepted before ready/implementing |\n27: | `acceptance` | Array of `{ \"id\": \"unique-criterion\", \"axis\": \"validation-scope\", \"criterion\": \"executable requirement\" }` |\n28: | `predictions`, `stop_conditions` | String arrays of predictions and conditions that halt work |\n29: | `checkpoint` | `null` or `campaign/runtime/checkpoints/<id>.json` |\n30: \n31: Optional `evidence` is an array of\n32: `{id,axis,path,sha256,source,integrated,source_binding,binaries,inputs,outcomes}`.\n33: `path` is an existing canonical RE-relative artifact; `sha256` hashes its actual bytes; `source`\n34: equals the contract's complete baseline object. Store understanding,\n35: implementation, original dependencies, and validation scope as separate acceptance/evidence axes.\n36: There is no generic `verified` scalar. Baseline commit IDs describe starting repositories;\n37: dirty source identity is machine-bound by `source_binding`, never inferred from those commits.\n38: Criteria need distinct states, branch exposure, positive execution, complete writes/elements,\n39: allocations/IDs/events/RNG/runtime inputs, synthetic and original-game differentials as applicable.\n40: The CLI checks package identity and declared axes; the independent reviewer evaluates the actual\n41: criteria, gate outcomes, full manifests and integrated reproduction. A passing measurement alone\n42: does not establish acceptance.\n43: \n44: ### Source-bound evidence interface (R4)\n45: \n46: `source_binding` is `{engine:{path,commit,sha256},re:{path,commit,sha256}}`. Generate it with:\n47: \n48: ```sh\n49: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re source-binding research-replacement --engine-worktree /absolute/candidate-engine --re-worktree /absolute/candidate-re\n50: ```\n51: \n52: Omit both worktree arguments to bind the canonical integrated trees. Paths must be Git worktree\n53: roots in the respective baseline repositories. `commit` is the actual current HEAD; `sha256`\n54: is the deterministic digest of the actual file manifest, including dirty/untracked nonignored\n55: files, deleted tracked paths (`null`), file bytes and Unix modes. Symlinks/submodules fail closed.\n56: The fixed manifest policy uses `git ls-files --cached --others --exclude-standard`; ignored\n57: untracked build/output files are not source. Python cache directories are excluded. In RE only,\n58: `verify/results/` and `campaign/` are excluded **except** `campaign/models.json`,\n59: `campaign/contract.schema.json`, and `campaign/agents/**`. These exclusions prevent mutable\n60: contracts/checkpoints/evidence/projections from hashing themselves. Relevant RE tools, tests,\n61: generated facts and guides remain bound. Any consumed item outside that source inventory must\n62: appear among immutable input/binary artifacts. The independent reviewer checks inventory adequacy.\n63: \n64: `binaries` and `inputs` are nonempty arrays of `{path,sha256}` artifact references; for tooling\n65: contracts, bind the executable scripts/interpreter identity package and fixture input package.\n66: `outcomes` exactly covers the acceptance criterion IDs for that evidence axis, with entries\n67: `{criterion,status,artifact:{path,sha256}}`; promotion requires `status: \"pass\"`. Outcome artifacts\n68: contain positive execution, branch/state exposures, reproduction recipe and required effect/input\n69: accounting. The CLI checks identities, hashes and declared outcomes, **not arbitrary criterion\n70: semantics**. The independent verifier must reproduce and challenge those claims.\n71: \n72: For example, an outcome for the bootstrap contract is:\n73: \n74: ```json\n75: {\"criterion\":\"controls-negative-paths\",\"status\":\"pass\",\"artifact\":{\"path\":\"verify/results/controls/result.json\",\"sha256\":\"<actual 64-hex artifact hash>\"}}\n76: ```\n77: \n78: Capture bindings when producing evidence; do not attach a fresh source hash to old measurements.\n79: Every evidence/verdict/promotion check rehashes referenced sources and artifacts. Same-HEAD byte\n80: changes reject old evidence and verdicts. Integrated records require canonical paths, lead in\n81: integration state, and one identical binding across **all** final integrated evidence. A lead's\n82: `integrated` boolean cannot substitute for this check. Verdicts bind the full evidence array and\n83: the source-binding array; old verdicts lacking these identities must be reproduced.\n84: \n85: This contract wrapper is separate from gate measurement schema **`sots-gate/1`**, whose `source`\n86: still has `engine`/`re`. Reference its immutable manifest/binary/input package; do not rename its\n87: fields to match contract `source`. Reporter output is measured evidence, with `--require-match`\n88: for required equality, and gains acceptance only through independent contract/integration gates.\n89: \n90: ## State and transactions\n91: \n92: Every command requires `--state-root /absolute/canonical/sots-re` (the repository, not `campaign/`).\n93: No sibling inference. Control records stay below canonical `campaign/runtime/`; contracts remain\n94: in `campaign/contracts/`. Immutable hashed artifacts may be referenced anywhere inside canonical\n95: RE, including existing `verify/` corpora, without copying them. Absolute/traversing artifact paths,\n96: outside symlinks, Git internals and named secret/private-key locations are rejected; aliases are\n97: checked after resolution too. Never reference secrets or commit owner-supplied binaries/assets.\n98: JSON writes are atomic and fsynced; a canonical `flock` serializes\n99: CLI mutations, WIP decisions, and resource acquisition. Do not hand-edit active state concurrently\n100: with commands. Interrupted multi-file operations retain blocking records and require inspection.\n101: \n102: Runtime APIs (JSON files; no server):\n103: \n104: - `runtime/checkpoints/*.json`: `sots-checkpoint/1`, contract, actor/role/model/session, timestamp,\n105:   contract `basis` digest, bounded summary (6000 characters), up to 32 `{path,sha256}` artifacts,\n106:   and one `next_action` (2000 characters). Include observations versus decisions, source identities,\n107:   tests, blockers, resources/access/cleanup, exact next action in the summary/artifacts.\n108:   Do not attach the checkpoint's own contract as an artifact: saving the pointer changes that\n109:   file. Its task metadata is already covered by `basis`; the CLI rejects this self-reference.\n110: - `runtime/surprises/*.json`: `sots-surprise/1`, id, contract, `status: open|resolved`, summary,\n111:   discriminating probe, actor/model/session provenance where applicable, optional decision ID.\n112: - `runtime/decisions/*.json`: `sots-decision/1`, Astra resolution, explanation/probe, invalidated\n113:   evidence and checkpoint; prior verdict is marked invalidated. Resolution returns needs-revision\n114:   only when all surprises are closed. Re-probe and rebuild evidence; resolution is not acceptance.\n115: - `runtime/verdicts/<contract>.json`: independent verifier actor/session/model, pass/fail,\n116:   explanation, contract basis, complete evidence digest and source-bindings digest.\n117: - `runtime/transitions/*.json`: actor/model, previous/next lifecycle state, timestamp.\n118: - `runtime/leases/<resource>.json`: owner, random token, held/released, acquisition/release provenance.\n119: - `runtime/runs/run-*.json`, `.jsonl`, `.stderr.log`: requested model/config, command, worktree\n120:   manifests before/after, expanded prompt hash, effective configuration hashes, canonical config\n121:   file hashes, actual events/session/model when emitted, completion/checkpoint status. Effective\n122:   provider config is hashed rather than persisted because it can contain credentials.\n123:   `active-<contract>.json` reserves the contract. Interrupted running reservations never auto-expire.\n124: \n125: Lifecycle: `proposed -> ready -> implementing -> verification -> integration -> accepted`.\n126: Blocked and needs-revision edges support repairs; no skipping stages. Ready requires scope,\n127: inputs, acceptance, stop conditions, valid pinned baseline and accepted dependencies. Implementing\n128: is atomically capped at two concurrent contracts; lead schedules only one pilot before enabling\n129: two independent slices. Verification requires fresh checkpoint/artifacts after implementation start.\n130: Integration requires lead plus independent passing verifier bound to current source/evidence.\n131: Accepted requires every declared axis in integrated evidence, passing independent verdict over\n132: that final package, and no open surprises. Adding integrated evidence changes the evidence digest:\n133: the verifier must attest the integrated package again. Handoff/promotion/end checkpoints must be\n134: within 15 minutes; recovery start has no age limit.\n135: \n136: Role/model registry: lead/architecture-review/analyst/implementer/verifier/lab =\n137: `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`; resolver = `openai/gpt-6-astra`.\n138: CLI identity fields are **claims, not authenticated model authority**. The runner requests the\n139: registry model explicitly and records emitted provenance. Editable JSON, agent permissions and\n140: shell-accessible tooling are not a security boundary. No silent routing fallback.\n141: \n142: ## Commands\n143: \n144: Run from either repository using the canonical tool path when necessary. Examples:\n145: \n146: ```sh\n147: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate\n148: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re list\n149: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-replacement\n150: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint controls-bootstrap --actor controls-architect --role architecture-review --model openai/gpt-6-astra --session rollout-controls --summary 'Source identities, observations, decisions, tests and blockers are in the attached checkpoint.' --artifact campaign/rollout/controls-worker-state.md --next-action 'Run the independent controls review.'\n151: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re transition controls-bootstrap ready --actor controls-architect --role architecture-review --model openai/gpt-6-astra\n152: ```\n153: \n154: `surprise CONTRACT --summary TEXT --probe TEXT` blocks immediately. `resolve SURPRISE_ID\n155: --explanation TEXT --probe TEXT` requires claimed Astra lead/resolver. Both also require\n156: `--actor NAME --role ROLE --model MODEL`. `evidence CONTRACT --record campaign/path.json`\n157: uses the same identity flags; record format is the evidence object above. Integrated records\n158: require lead and integration state. `verdict CONTRACT --session SESSION --verdict pass|fail\n159: --explanation TEXT` requires verifier identity flags and independent actor/session.\n160: \n161: ```sh\n162: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease acquire windows-vm --actor lab-one --role lab --model openai/gpt-5.5\n163: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease show windows-vm\n164: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease release windows-vm --actor lab-one --role lab --model openai/gpt-5.5 --token TOKEN_FROM_ACQUIRE\n165: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease release windows-vm --actor lead --role lead --model openai/gpt-6-astra --lead-release --reason 'Confirmed prior operator stopped; access and cleanup checked.'\n166: ```\n167: \n168: No stale lease stealing. Explicit lead release requires an explanation and lab preconditions,\n169: side effects, cleanup, and access verification in the operator checkpoint. Treat lease tokens\n170: as local owner capabilities, not secrets to put in a board/dashboard.\n171: \n172: ## Fresh bounded launches\n173: \n174: Prepare **two actual linked worktrees**, each distinct from its canonical source repository,\n175: at the contract's full baseline commit. No auto commits/worktree creation. Launch uses explicit\n176: canonical `OPENCODE_CONFIG`, checks matching repo-local agent/model/40 steps, and sets the final\n177: environment overlay to bind requested role/model/steps. Other inherited config overrides are\n178: cleared. `opencode models` must list the exact requested model even for dry runs.\n179: \n180: ```sh\n181: python3 tools/run_agent.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re --role implementer --actor worker-one --contract slice-one --engine-worktree /home/alex/worktrees/slice-one-engine --re-worktree /home/alex/worktrees/slice-one-re --cwd engine --dry-run\n182: ```\n183: \n184: Remove `--dry-run` to execute. Normal worker launch requires a valid durable checkpoint, matching\n185: owner/role/status, no open surprises, baseline HEADs and canonical Git common-directory identity.\n186: Recovery checks checkpoint identity/basis and artifact hashes regardless of age, rechecks any\n187: source-bound evidence, and validates paired Git worktree/baseline identity. Missing ordinary-worker\n188: state still blocks. Bootstrap lead/architecture-review can start without a checkpoint; they still\n189: need paired worktrees. Astra lead/resolver may launch a blocked contract with open surprises and\n190: without a worker checkpoint in **resolution-only** scope: read evidence and write decisions/state,\n191: no implementation. Its prompt and permission overlay carry that limit, and worktree source changes\n192: fail completion. Ordinary affected workers stay blocked. Other Astra architecture actors receive\n193: explicit architecture authority within their owned scope. Each run is a fresh\n194: `opencode run --format json --model ... --agent ...`; no resume/continue option is used. The prompt\n195: supplies the run ID to use as checkpoint `--session`; actual OpenCode session IDs are captured\n196: separately when emitted. On exit, a checkpoint after start matching actor/role/model/run ID is\n197: mandatory or the run is marked incomplete. Completion additionally requires a zero exit, no\n198: `type:error`, a successful `step_finish` with `part.reason: \"stop\"`, one nonempty actual session ID,\n199: and consistent explicitly emitted model IDs. Text/tool-call/length events alone cannot complete a\n200: run. Missing model emission is recorded `observed_model_status: \"unavailable\"`, never invented.\n201: \n202: The runner checks the exact Git baseline again under reservation lock, rejects intervening contract\n203: changes, and checks canonical model/prompt/config files and effective configuration for drift at\n204: completion. Expanded role prompt/model/steps are frozen in the last-layer environment overlay.\n205: `opencode debug config` runs in the actual launch cwd with the actual environment before execution\n206: and again at completion. Permissions explicitly allow read/search, ordinary worker shell commands,\n207: and external-directory access to the assigned paired trees plus canonical RE; role-specific edit\n208: denies survive. Task delegation and interactive questions are denied. No `--auto` is required.\n209: Noninteractive command/environment tests and a live loader check cover this overlay; an actual\n210: normal worker launch smoke is a separate lead integration check. Permissions and before/after\n211: checks are operational guards, not a sandbox or continuous filesystem audit.\n212: Compaction is a backstop; no token threshold or machine-enforced 20-tool-call claim.\n213: \n214: ## Local verification\n215: \n216: ```sh\n217: python3 -m unittest discover -s verify/campaign -p 'test_*.py' -v\n218: python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate\n219: ```\n220: \n221: Tests create commits only in disposable fixture repositories, linked worktrees and fake OpenCode processes; they do\n222: not launch agents or touch the lab. Historical rollout artifacts retain the scope and source identity\n223: of their runs; consult the accepted contract and current evidence, not an old handoff's status prose.\n\n(End of file - total 223 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Canonical campaign controls\n\n`sots-re/campaign/` is the state authority. Start with your contract, its checkpoint, open\nsurprises, and [current policy](../guides/multi-agent-workflow.md). Board/dashboard are generated\nprojections. Historical evidence is not current acceptance. No automatic commits or lab operations.\n\nFramework development is complete. The `controls-bootstrap` contract reached scoped acceptance;\nsee [rollout result](rollout/RESULT.md) and its current contract/verdict for source-bound evidence.\nActive work is reverse engineering. Change tooling only to unblock a named RE experiment.\n\n## Contract format\n\n`contract.schema.json` is strict JSON Schema (unknown fields and duplicate JSON keys fail).\nThe standard-library validator implements the schema's used subset. A populated example is\n[contracts/controls-bootstrap.json](contracts/controls-bootstrap.json); its lifecycle is in the record.\n\nRequired fields:\n\n| Field | Structure |\n|---|---|","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/README.md","text":"# Canonical campaign controls\n\n`sots-re/campaign/` is the state authority. Start with your contract, its checkpoint, open\nsurprises, and [current policy](../guides/multi-agent-workflow.md). Board/dashboard are generated\nprojections. Historical evidence is not current acceptance. No automatic commits or lab operations.\n\nFramework development is complete. The `controls-bootstrap` contract reached scoped acceptance;\nsee [rollout result](rollout/RESULT.md) and its current contract/verdict for source-bound evidence.\nActive work is reverse engineering. Change tooling only to unblock a named RE experiment.\n\n## Contract format\n\n`contract.schema.json` is strict JSON Schema (unknown fields and duplicate JSON keys fail).\nThe standard-library validator implements the schema's used subset. A populated example is\n[contracts/controls-bootstrap.json](contracts/controls-bootstrap.json); its lifecycle is in the record.\n\nRequired fields:\n\n| Field | Structure |\n|---|---|\n| `id`, `title`, `status` | Slug, short title, lifecycle state |\n| `owner` | `{ \"name\": \"worker-identity\", \"role\": \"implementer\" }` |\n| `baseline` | `{ \"engine\": {\"path\":\"/absolute/canonical/engine\",\"commit\":\"full-commit-id\"}, \"re\": {\"path\":\"/absolute/canonical/re\",\"commit\":\"full-commit-id\"} }` |\n| `scope`, `inputs`, `effects` | Arrays of explicit nonempty strings; include full write set and runtime inputs |\n| `original_dependencies` | String array, including original-assisted portions and unavailable inputs |\n| `dependencies` | Array of other contract IDs; all must be accepted before ready/implementing |\n| `acceptance` | Array of `{ \"id\": \"unique-criterion\", \"axis\": \"validation-scope\", \"criterion\": \"executable requirement\" }` |\n| `predictions`, `stop_conditions` | String arrays of predictions and conditions that halt work |\n| `checkpoint` | `null` or `campaign/runtime/checkpoints/<id>.json` |\n\nOptional `evidence` is an array of\n`{id,axis,path,sha256,source,integrated,source_binding,binaries,inputs,outcomes}`.\n`path` is an existing canonical RE-relative artifact; `sha256` hashes its actual bytes; `source`\nequals the contract's complete baseline object. Store understanding,\nimplementation, original dependencies, and validation scope as separate acceptance/evidence axes.\nThere is no generic `verified` scalar. Baseline commit IDs describe starting repositories;\ndirty source identity is machine-bound by `source_binding`, never inferred from those commits.\nCriteria need distinct states, branch exposure, positive execution, complete writes/elements,\nallocations/IDs/events/RNG/runtime inputs, synthetic and original-game differentials as applicable.\nThe CLI checks package identity and declared axes; the independent reviewer evaluates the actual\ncriteria, gate outcomes, full manifests and integrated reproduction. A passing measurement alone\ndoes not establish acceptance.\n\n### Source-bound evidence interface (R4)\n\n`source_binding` is `{engine:{path,commit,sha256},re:{path,commit,sha256}}`. Generate it with:\n\n```sh\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re source-binding research-replacement --engine-worktree /absolute/candidate-engine --re-worktree /absolute/candidate-re\n```\n\nOmit both worktree arguments to bind the canonical integrated trees. Paths must be Git worktree\nroots in the respective baseline repositories. `commit` is the actual current HEAD; `sha256`\nis the deterministic digest of the actual file manifest, including dirty/untracked nonignored\nfiles, deleted tracked paths (`null`), file bytes and Unix modes. Symlinks/submodules fail closed.\nThe fixed manifest policy uses `git ls-files --cached --others --exclude-standard`; ignored\nuntracked build/output files are not source. Python cache directories are excluded. In RE only,\n`verify/results/` and `campaign/` are excluded **except** `campaign/models.json`,\n`campaign/contract.schema.json`, and `campaign/agents/**`. These exclusions prevent mutable\ncontracts/checkpoints/evidence/projections from hashing themselves. Relevant RE tools, tests,\ngenerated facts and guides remain bound. Any consumed item outside that source inventory must\nappear among immutable input/binary artifacts. The independent reviewer checks inventory adequacy.\n\n`binaries` and `inputs` are nonempty arrays of `{path,sha256}` artifact references; for tooling\ncontracts, bind the executable scripts/interpreter identity package and fixture input package.\n`outcomes` exactly covers the acceptance criterion IDs for that evidence axis, with entries\n`{criterion,status,artifact:{path,sha256}}`; promotion requires `status: \"pass\"`. Outcome artifacts\ncontain positive execution, branch/state exposures, reproduction recipe and required effect/input\naccounting. The CLI checks identities, hashes and declared outcomes, **not arbitrary criterion\nsemantics**. The independent verifier must reproduce and challenge those claims.\n\nFor example, an outcome for the bootstrap contract is:\n\n```json\n{\"criterion\":\"controls-negative-paths\",\"status\":\"pass\",\"artifact\":{\"path\":\"verify/results/controls/result.json\",\"sha256\":\"<actual 64-hex artifact hash>\"}}\n```\n\nCapture bindings when producing evidence; do not attach a fresh source hash to old measurements.\nEvery evidence/verdict/promotion check rehashes referenced sources and artifacts. Same-HEAD byte\nchanges reject old evidence and verdicts. Integrated records require canonical paths, lead in\nintegration state, and one identical binding across **all** final integrated evidence. A lead's\n`integrated` boolean cannot substitute for this check. Verdicts bind the full evidence array and\nthe source-binding array; old verdicts lacking these identities must be reproduced.\n\nThis contract wrapper is separate from gate measurement schema **`sots-gate/1`**, whose `source`\nstill has `engine`/`re`. Reference its immutable manifest/binary/input package; do not rename its\nfields to match contract `source`. Reporter output is measured evidence, with `--require-match`\nfor required equality, and gains acceptance only through independent contract/integration gates.\n\n## State and transactions\n\nEvery command requires `--state-root /absolute/canonical/sots-re` (the repository, not `campaign/`).\nNo sibling inference. Control records stay below canonical `campaign/runtime/`; contracts remain\nin `campaign/contracts/`. Immutable hashed artifacts may be referenced anywhere inside canonical\nRE, including existing `verify/` corpora, without copying them. Absolute/traversing artifact paths,\noutside symlinks, Git internals and named secret/private-key locations are rejected; aliases are\nchecked after resolution too. Never reference secrets or commit owner-supplied binaries/assets.\nJSON writes are atomic and fsynced; a canonical `flock` serializes\nCLI mutations, WIP decisions, and resource acquisition. Do not hand-edit active state concurrently\nwith commands. Interrupted multi-file operations retain blocking records and require inspection.\n\nRuntime APIs (JSON files; no server):\n\n- `runtime/checkpoints/*.json`: `sots-checkpoint/1`, contract, actor/role/model/session, timestamp,\n  contract `basis` digest, bounded summary (6000 characters), up to 32 `{path,sha256}` artifacts,\n  and one `next_action` (2000 characters). Include observations versus decisions, source identities,\n  tests, blockers, resources/access/cleanup, exact next action in the summary/artifacts.\n  Do not attach the checkpoint's own contract as an artifact: saving the pointer changes that\n  file. Its task metadata is already covered by `basis`; the CLI rejects this self-reference.\n- `runtime/surprises/*.json`: `sots-surprise/1`, id, contract, `status: open|resolved`, summary,\n  discriminating probe, actor/model/session provenance where applicable, optional decision ID.\n- `runtime/decisions/*.json`: `sots-decision/1`, Astra resolution, explanation/probe, invalidated\n  evidence and checkpoint; prior verdict is marked invalidated. Resolution returns needs-revision\n  only when all surprises are closed. Re-probe and rebuild evidence; resolution is not acceptance.\n- `runtime/verdicts/<contract>.json`: independent verifier actor/session/model, pass/fail,\n  explanation, contract basis, complete evidence digest and source-bindings digest.\n- `runtime/transitions/*.json`: actor/model, previous/next lifecycle state, timestamp.\n- `runtime/leases/<resource>.json`: owner, random token, held/released, acquisition/release provenance.\n- `runtime/runs/run-*.json`, `.jsonl`, `.stderr.log`: requested model/config, command, worktree\n  manifests before/after, expanded prompt hash, effective configuration hashes, canonical config\n  file hashes, actual events/session/model when emitted, completion/checkpoint status. Effective\n  provider config is hashed rather than persisted because it can contain credentials.\n  `active-<contract>.json` reserves the contract. Interrupted running reservations never auto-expire.\n\nLifecycle: `proposed -> ready -> implementing -> verification -> integration -> accepted`.\nBlocked and needs-revision edges support repairs; no skipping stages. Ready requires scope,\ninputs, acceptance, stop conditions, valid pinned baseline and accepted dependencies. Implementing\nis atomically capped at two concurrent contracts; lead schedules only one pilot before enabling\ntwo independent slices. Verification requires fresh checkpoint/artifacts after implementation start.\nIntegration requires lead plus independent passing verifier bound to current source/evidence.\nAccepted requires every declared axis in integrated evidence, passing independent verdict over\nthat final package, and no open surprises. Adding integrated evidence changes the evidence digest:\nthe verifier must attest the integrated package again. Handoff/promotion/end checkpoints must be\nwithin 15 minutes; recovery start has no age limit.\n\nRole/model registry: lead/architecture-review/analyst/implementer/verifier/lab =\n`openai/gpt-5.6-sol`; resolver = `openai/gpt-6-astra`.\nCLI identity fields are **claims, not authenticated model authority**. The runner requests the\nregistry model explicitly and records emitted provenance. Editable JSON, agent permissions and\nshell-accessible tooling are not a security boundary. No silent routing fallback.\n\n## Commands\n\nRun from either repository using the canonical tool path when necessary. Examples:\n\n```sh\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re list\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-replacement\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint controls-bootstrap --actor controls-architect --role architecture-review --model openai/gpt-6-astra --session rollout-controls --summary 'Source identities, observations, decisions, tests and blockers are in the attached checkpoint.' --artifact campaign/rollout/controls-worker-state.md --next-action 'Run the independent controls review.'\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re transition controls-bootstrap ready --actor controls-architect --role architecture-review --model openai/gpt-6-astra\n```\n\n`surprise CONTRACT --summary TEXT --probe TEXT` blocks immediately. `resolve SURPRISE_ID\n--explanation TEXT --probe TEXT` requires claimed Astra lead/resolver. Both also require\n`--actor NAME --role ROLE --model MODEL`. `evidence CONTRACT --record campaign/path.json`\nuses the same identity flags; record format is the evidence object above. Integrated records\nrequire lead and integration state. `verdict CONTRACT --session SESSION --verdict pass|fail\n--explanation TEXT` requires verifier identity flags and independent actor/session.\n\n```sh\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease acquire windows-vm --actor lab-one --role lab --model openai/gpt-5.5\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease show windows-vm\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease release windows-vm --actor lab-one --role lab --model openai/gpt-5.5 --token TOKEN_FROM_ACQUIRE\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re lease release windows-vm --actor lead --role lead --model openai/gpt-6-astra --lead-release --reason 'Confirmed prior operator stopped; access and cleanup checked.'\n```\n\nNo stale lease stealing. Explicit lead release requires an explanation and lab preconditions,\nside effects, cleanup, and access verification in the operator checkpoint. Treat lease tokens\nas local owner capabilities, not secrets to put in a board/dashboard.\n\n## Fresh bounded launches\n\nPrepare **two actual linked worktrees**, each distinct from its canonical source repository,\nat the contract's full baseline commit. No auto commits/worktree creation. Launch uses explicit\ncanonical `OPENCODE_CONFIG`, checks matching repo-local agent/model/40 steps, and sets the final\nenvironment overlay to bind requested role/model/steps. Other inherited config overrides are\ncleared. `opencode models` must list the exact requested model even for dry runs.\n\n```sh\npython3 tools/run_agent.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re --role implementer --actor worker-one --contract slice-one --engine-worktree /home/alex/worktrees/slice-one-engine --re-worktree /home/alex/worktrees/slice-one-re --cwd engine --dry-run\n```\n\nRemove `--dry-run` to execute. Normal worker launch requires a valid durable checkpoint, matching\nowner/role/status, no open surprises, baseline HEADs and canonical Git common-directory identity.\nRecovery checks checkpoint identity/basis and artifact hashes regardless of age, rechecks any\nsource-bound evidence, and validates paired Git worktree/baseline identity. Missing ordinary-worker\nstate still blocks. Bootstrap lead/architecture-review can start without a checkpoint; they still\nneed paired worktrees. Astra lead/resolver may launch a blocked contract with open surprises and\nwithout a worker checkpoint in **resolution-only** scope: read evidence and write decisions/state,\nno implementation. Its prompt and permission overlay carry that limit, and worktree source changes\nfail completion. Ordinary affected workers stay blocked. Other Astra architecture actors receive\nexplicit architecture authority within their owned scope. Each run is a fresh\n`opencode run --format json --model ... --agent ...`; no resume/continue option is used. The prompt\nsupplies the run ID to use as checkpoint `--session`; actual OpenCode session IDs are captured\nseparately when emitted. On exit, a checkpoint after start matching actor/role/model/run ID is\nmandatory or the run is marked incomplete. Completion additionally requires a zero exit, no\n`type:error`, a successful `step_finish` with `part.reason: \"stop\"`, one nonempty actual session ID,\nand consistent explicitly emitted model IDs. Text/tool-call/length events alone cannot complete a\nrun. Missing model emission is recorded `observed_model_status: \"unavailable\"`, never invented.\n\nThe runner checks the exact Git baseline again under reservation lock, rejects intervening contract\nchanges, and checks canonical model/prompt/config files and effective configuration for drift at\ncompletion. Expanded role prompt/model/steps are frozen in the last-layer environment overlay.\n`opencode debug config` runs in the actual launch cwd with the actual environment before execution\nand again at completion. Permissions explicitly allow read/search, ordinary worker shell commands,\nand external-directory access to the assigned paired trees plus canonical RE; role-specific edit\ndenies survive. Task delegation and interactive questions are denied. No `--auto` is required.\nNoninteractive command/environment tests and a live loader check cover this overlay; an actual\nnormal worker launch smoke is a separate lead integration check. Permissions and before/after\nchecks are operational guards, not a sandbox or continuous filesystem audit.\nCompaction is a backstop; no token threshold or machine-enforced 20-tool-call claim.\n\n## Local verification\n\n```sh\npython3 -m unittest discover -s verify/campaign -p 'test_*.py' -v\npython3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate\n```\n\nTests create commits only in disposable fixture repositories, linked worktrees and fake OpenCode processes; they do\nnot launch agents or touch the lab. Historical rollout artifacts retain the scope and source identity\nof their runs; consult the accepted contract and current evidence, not an old handoff's status prose.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":223,"totalLines":223,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/README.md","time":{"start":1788999718704,"end":1788999718726}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0f804f41a9b1702d016aa1f825f72887d1bec6feaedc77da7e"}},"id":"prt_088b1545f001ktuXT1XY7dxvYU","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b14aaf001bakKN88yMIwO6b"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999718778,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b15776001Q4zQ0HZtl0aLxj","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"b78e56c5c0cd87535fd60ceedbdc10e23a7998a8","messageID":"msg_088b14aaf001bakKN88yMIwO6b","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":5821,"input":5792,"output":29,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":0}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999727286,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b178b000114nEWgS2mE5uvv","messageID":"msg_088b157aa001y56yGMfxIgL2KV","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"3eb691219eeb7cdf0d6a2d6349af224da536d539","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999727384,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_XpBFMOJf7oKSIYgCq6N2Z00p","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"acceptance\": [\n3:     {\n4:       \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n5:       \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n6:       \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n7:     },\n8:     {\n9:       \"axis\": \"validation\",\n10:       \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n11:       \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n12:     }\n13:   ],\n14:   \"baseline\": {\n15:     \"engine\": {\n16:       \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n17:       \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n18:     },\n19:     \"re\": {\n20:       \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n21:       \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n22:     }\n23:   },\n24:   \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4.json\",\n25:   \"dependencies\": [\n26:     \"controls-bootstrap\"\n27:   ],\n28:   \"effects\": [\n29:     \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n30:   ],\n31:   \"evidence\": [],\n32:   \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n33:   \"inputs\": [\n34:     \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n35:     \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n36:     \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n37:     \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n38:   ],\n39:   \"original_dependencies\": [\n40:     \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n41:   ],\n42:   \"owner\": {\n43:     \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n44:     \"role\": \"analyst\"\n45:   },\n46:   \"predictions\": [\n47:     \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n48:     \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n49:   ],\n50:   \"scope\": [\n51:     \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n52:     \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n53:     \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n54:     \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n55:     \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n56:   ],\n57:   \"status\": \"blocked\",\n58:   \"stop_conditions\": [\n59:     \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n60:     \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n61:     \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n62:   ],\n63:   \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n64: }\n\n(End of file - total 64 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"acceptance\": [\n    {\n      \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n      \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n      \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"axis\": \"validation\",\n      \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n      \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"baseline\": {\n    \"engine\": {\n      \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n      \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n    },\n    \"re\": {\n      \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json","text":"{\n  \"acceptance\": [\n    {\n      \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n      \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n      \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"axis\": \"validation\",\n      \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n      \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"baseline\": {\n    \"engine\": {\n      \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n      \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n    },\n    \"re\": {\n      \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n      \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n    }\n  },\n  \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4.json\",\n  \"dependencies\": [\n    \"controls-bootstrap\"\n  ],\n  \"effects\": [\n    \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n  ],\n  \"evidence\": [],\n  \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"inputs\": [\n    \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n    \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n    \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n    \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n  ],\n  \"original_dependencies\": [\n    \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n  ],\n  \"owner\": {\n    \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n    \"role\": \"analyst\"\n  },\n  \"predictions\": [\n    \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n    \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n  ],\n  \"scope\": [\n    \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n    \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n    \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n    \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n    \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n  ],\n  \"status\": \"blocked\",\n  \"stop_conditions\": [\n    \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n    \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n    \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n  ],\n  \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":64,"totalLines":64,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json","time":{"start":1788999727373,"end":1788999727381}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b922b919b21af3a016aa1f82f2c8887d18357ab4a7142d70b"}},"id":"prt_088b178b3001lWTNJD6NFk5h0G","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b157aa001y56yGMfxIgL2KV"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999727418,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_9hqqT0auGTbxjKjsxAmEXph8","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n3:   \"artifacts\": [\n4:     {\n5:       \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n6:       \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n7:     },\n8:     {\n9:       \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n10:       \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n11:     },\n12:     {\n13:       \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json\",\n14:       \"sha256\": \"d6e41b41efa5bf9a155615e08dd4a075ce5c80aa3ad0067370014cd22ebabc86\"\n15:     },\n16:     {\n17:       \"path\": \"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\n18:       \"sha256\": \"978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921\"\n19:     }\n20:   ],\n21:   \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n22:   \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n23:   \"id\": \"a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4\",\n24:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n25:   \"next_action\": \"Astra resolve surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f by rerunning and archiving raw stdout for stop-address 0x00825e65 and minimally widened 0x00825e67 against the hashed executable, then decide and record the provenance repair before verifier work resumes.\",\n26:   \"role\": \"verifier\",\n27:   \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n28:   \"session\": \"run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f\",\n29:   \"summary\": \"Mandatory end-of-quantum verifier checkpoint. Observations versus decisions: all required canonical inputs and resolved surprises were read; model registry matches requested openai/gpt-5.6-sol. Assigned source identities remained engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git/binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git/binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Pre-existing dirty inventories remained; this verifier edited no assigned source worktree. Input sots.exe independently matched SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; objdump reports 2.38. Decision before experiment: verifier-owned plan fixed falsifiers, required static branches/distinct states, scope labels and held-out NaN control. Tests: all four exact dedup-helper objdump commands exited zero with 120/26/51/51 instructions. Windows 2-4 matched the archive after line-end whitespace normalization. Window 1 did not: stop 0x00825e65 fresh output contains only byte c2 at 0x00825e64 while the archive claims c2 08 00 and calls itself unfiltered exact-command output. This falsified the provenance/instrument falsifier; surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f was recorded, contract is blocked, and affected ABI interpretation/NaN challenge stopped rather than being scored pass. Independent archived-state check before pause: strict save reader exited zero with 37847 items, 2453 frames, zero resyncs/hint failures/best-effort; direct tree values at inflated offset 120372 recover player 1 EvNxID 4, turn buckets 2/3, IDs 1/2/3 and full overbudget record with FLT_MAX bit words. Scope is independent static reproduction plus archived-save cross-check only, not live original-assisted execution, compare, replacement or integrated replay. No RNG/runtime executio... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n30:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:21:09.525111+00:00\"\n31: }\n\n(End of file - total 31 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json\",\n      \"sha256\": \"d6e41b41efa5bf9a155615e08dd4a075ce5c80aa3ad0067370014cd22ebabc86\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\n      \"sha256\": \"978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921\"\n    }\n  ],","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json\",\n      \"sha256\": \"d6e41b41efa5bf9a155615e08dd4a075ce5c80aa3ad0067370014cd22ebabc86\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav\",\n      \"sha256\": \"978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Astra resolve surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f by rerunning and archiving raw stdout for stop-address 0x00825e65 and minimally widened 0x00825e67 against the hashed executable, then decide and record the provenance repair before verifier work resumes.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f\",\n  \"summary\": \"Mandatory end-of-quantum verifier checkpoint. Observations versus decisions: all required canonical inputs and resolved surprises were read; model registry matches requested openai/gpt-5.6-sol. Assigned source identities remained engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git/binding ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git/binding 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8. Pre-existing dirty inventories remained; this verifier edited no assigned source worktree. Input sots.exe independently matched SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c; objdump reports 2.38. Decision before experiment: verifier-owned plan fixed falsifiers, required static branches/distinct states, scope labels and held-out NaN control. Tests: all four exact dedup-helper objdump commands exited zero with 120/26/51/51 instructions. Windows 2-4 matched the archive after line-end whitespace normalization. Window 1 did not: stop 0x00825e65 fresh output contains only byte c2 at 0x00825e64 while the archive claims c2 08 00 and calls itself unfiltered exact-command output. This falsified the provenance/instrument falsifier; surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f was recorded, contract is blocked, and affected ABI interpretation/NaN challenge stopped rather than being scored pass. Independent archived-state check before pause: strict save reader exited zero with 37847 items, 2453 frames, zero resyncs/hint failures/best-effort; direct tree values at inflated offset 120372 recover player 1 EvNxID 4, turn buckets 2/3, IDs 1/2/3 and full overbudget record with FLT_MAX bit words. Scope is independent static reproduction plus archived-save cross-check only, not live original-assisted execution, compare, replacement or integrated replay. No RNG/runtime executio... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:21:09.525111+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":31,"totalLines":31,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4.json","time":{"start":1788999727408,"end":1788999727416}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b922b919b21af3a016aa1f82f2ca087d1a5a34afc333947c7"}},"id":"prt_088b17921001kOqsm7RG73M8zX","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b157aa001y56yGMfxIgL2KV"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999727465,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_c1fpi8Tb0j1GQxiD8muXsblM","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/AGENTS.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/AGENTS.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # SOTS campaign instructions\n2: \n3: This repository is the state authority for the SOTS reconstruction and its Windows lab.\n4: Start with `campaign/README.md`, your contract, its latest checkpoint, and open surprises.\n5: Current policy: `guides/multi-agent-workflow.md`. Engine architecture: `sots-engine/docs/architecture.md`.\n6: Historical findings are evidence, not current execution instructions or accepted status.\n7: \n8: ## Authority and models\n9: \n10: - The normal lead/RE/implementation/verification/lab loop runs on **GPT-5.6 Sol\n11:   (`openai/gpt-5.6-sol`)**. Reserve **GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`)** for resolving\n12:   falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope.\n13: - `campaign/models.json` is the role/model registry. Launch with `tools/run_agent.py` and an\n14:   explicit role, contract, state root, and paired worktrees. Never silently downgrade or fall back.\n15: - Ordinary implementation/test failures inside the contract may be fixed by its worker.\n16:   Falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope\n17:   require a recorded surprise and an Astra resolution before affected work continues.\n18: - No worker subdelegation. The lead assigns parallelism; max two implementation slices after\n19:   the pilot. Independent workload preparation is scheduled against explicit resource leases.\n20: \n21: ## Durable state and context\n22: \n23: Checkpoint in the canonical RE state root every **20 tool calls or 15 minutes**, whichever is\n24: earlier, and before an experiment, compaction, handoff, or stop. Include model/session, exact\n25: source identities, evidence paths, decisions versus observations, tests, blockers, and ONE exact\n26: next action. Do not store state only in a chat summary or `/tmp`.\n27: The runner uses bounded 40-step quanta. After checkpointing, stop and restart from the repository;\n28: automatic compaction is a backstop, not proof that a checkpoint was written. On recovery read the\n29: contract/checkpoint, verify worktree and resource identities, then continue. Missing state means\n30: blocked, not permission to reconstruct progress from memory.\n31: \n32: ## Ownership\n33: \n34: Use distinct engine and RE worktrees per lane, baseline-pinned. Canonical runtime state is shared\n35: only through the campaign tools. One integrator writes current evidence pointers and projections.\n36: Never stage someone else's changes. No automatic commit, push, pull, or reset. Commands requiring\n37: these actions need explicit user authorization. Source edits use apply_patch.\n38: VM, shared build-host, and Ghidra mutation require leases. A stale lease is not automatically free.\n39: Record preconditions, side effects, cleanup and access verification for any lab operation.\n40: Rollout bootstrap file-ownership exception: `campaign/rollout/architecture-decision.md` only.\n41: \n42: ## Evidence\n43: \n44: No generic `verified` promotion. Separate understanding, implementation, original dependencies,\n45: and validation scope. A count is insufficient without distinct states, branch exposures, and\n46: positive execution evidence. Include all writes, container elements, allocations, IDs, events,\n47: RNG draws, and runtime-only inputs. Original-assisted execution is not independent replacement.\n48: Synthetic boundary tests and original-game differential tests are complementary. Missing required\n49: inputs, zero execution, incomplete coverage, unexpected skips, stale binaries or unbound source\n50: identity fail acceptance. One independent verifier must reproduce the package; integrated-tree\n51: evidence is required for acceptance. Reports are measurements until those gates pass.\n52: \n53: Never commit owner-supplied binaries/assets or secrets. Engine facts cross only documented\n54: generated channels. Never paste disassembly/decompiler output into the engine repository.\n\n(End of file - total 54 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# SOTS campaign instructions\n\nThis repository is the state authority for the SOTS reconstruction and its Windows lab.\nStart with `campaign/README.md`, your contract, its latest checkpoint, and open surprises.\nCurrent policy: `guides/multi-agent-workflow.md`. Engine architecture: `sots-engine/docs/architecture.md`.\nHistorical findings are evidence, not current execution instructions or accepted status.\n\n## Authority and models\n\n- The normal lead/RE/implementation/verification/lab loop runs on **GPT-5.6 Sol\n  (`openai/gpt-5.6-sol`)**. Reserve **GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`)** for resolving\n  falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope.\n- `campaign/models.json` is the role/model registry. Launch with `tools/run_agent.py` and an\n  explicit role, contract, state root, and paired worktrees. Never silently downgrade or fall back.\n- Ordinary implementation/test failures inside the contract may be fixed by its worker.\n  Falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope\n  require a recorded surprise and an Astra resolution before affected work continues.\n- No worker subdelegation. The lead assigns parallelism; max two implementation slices after\n  the pilot. Independent workload preparation is scheduled against explicit resource leases.\n","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/AGENTS.md","text":"# SOTS campaign instructions\n\nThis repository is the state authority for the SOTS reconstruction and its Windows lab.\nStart with `campaign/README.md`, your contract, its latest checkpoint, and open surprises.\nCurrent policy: `guides/multi-agent-workflow.md`. Engine architecture: `sots-engine/docs/architecture.md`.\nHistorical findings are evidence, not current execution instructions or accepted status.\n\n## Authority and models\n\n- The normal lead/RE/implementation/verification/lab loop runs on **GPT-5.6 Sol\n  (`openai/gpt-5.6-sol`)**. Reserve **GPT-6 Astra (`openai/gpt-6-astra`)** for resolving\n  falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope.\n- `campaign/models.json` is the role/model registry. Launch with `tools/run_agent.py` and an\n  explicit role, contract, state root, and paired worktrees. Never silently downgrade or fall back.\n- Ordinary implementation/test failures inside the contract may be fixed by its worker.\n  Falsified assumptions, conflicting evidence, unexpected instrument effects, or changed scope\n  require a recorded surprise and an Astra resolution before affected work continues.\n- No worker subdelegation. The lead assigns parallelism; max two implementation slices after\n  the pilot. Independent workload preparation is scheduled against explicit resource leases.\n\n## Durable state and context\n\nCheckpoint in the canonical RE state root every **20 tool calls or 15 minutes**, whichever is\nearlier, and before an experiment, compaction, handoff, or stop. Include model/session, exact\nsource identities, evidence paths, decisions versus observations, tests, blockers, and ONE exact\nnext action. Do not store state only in a chat summary or `/tmp`.\nThe runner uses bounded 40-step quanta. After checkpointing, stop and restart from the repository;\nautomatic compaction is a backstop, not proof that a checkpoint was written. On recovery read the\ncontract/checkpoint, verify worktree and resource identities, then continue. Missing state means\nblocked, not permission to reconstruct progress from memory.\n\n## Ownership\n\nUse distinct engine and RE worktrees per lane, baseline-pinned. Canonical runtime state is shared\nonly through the campaign tools. One integrator writes current evidence pointers and projections.\nNever stage someone else's changes. No automatic commit, push, pull, or reset. Commands requiring\nthese actions need explicit user authorization. Source edits use apply_patch.\nVM, shared build-host, and Ghidra mutation require leases. A stale lease is not automatically free.\nRecord preconditions, side effects, cleanup and access verification for any lab operation.\nRollout bootstrap file-ownership exception: `campaign/rollout/architecture-decision.md` only.\n\n## Evidence\n\nNo generic `verified` promotion. Separate understanding, implementation, original dependencies,\nand validation scope. A count is insufficient without distinct states, branch exposures, and\npositive execution evidence. Include all writes, container elements, allocations, IDs, events,\nRNG draws, and runtime-only inputs. Original-assisted execution is not independent replacement.\nSynthetic boundary tests and original-game differential tests are complementary. Missing required\ninputs, zero execution, incomplete coverage, unexpected skips, stale binaries or unbound source\nidentity fail acceptance. One independent verifier must reproduce the package; integrated-tree\nevidence is required for acceptance. Reports are measurements until those gates pass.\n\nNever commit owner-supplied binaries/assets or secrets. Engine facts cross only documented\ngenerated channels. Never paste disassembly/decompiler output into the engine repository.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":54,"totalLines":54,"truncated":false}},"title":"AGENTS.md","time":{"start":1788999727448,"end":1788999727463}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b922b919b21af3a016aa1f82f2cac87d1a673b7489c09c207"}},"id":"prt_088b179320013jk8Uc2BVikMxs","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b157aa001y56yGMfxIgL2KV"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999727487,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_NC91rK3qEPiu4fBjFa3vHEwj","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/guides/multi-agent-workflow.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/guides/multi-agent-workflow.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Multi-agent operating architecture\n2: \n3: ## Product and milestone\n4: \n5: Reconstruct a behavior-equivalent engine consuming owner-supplied assets. The next product\n6: milestone is standalone replay given a captured command stream and complete declared runtime\n7: inputs. The first workflow pilot is the complete research write set. A passing host build is a\n8: component baseline, not a playable engine or independent replacement.\n9: \n10: ## Source of truth\n11: \n12: `campaign/contracts/` holds versioned tasks, `campaign/runtime/` holds checkpoints, sessions,\n13: leases and surprises, and evidence packages identify inputs, source and executable artifacts.\n14: `campaign/current.json` selects published evidence by path and digest. Board/dashboard are\n15: generated projections, never alternate writable authorities. Exact tool CLI/schema is documented\n16: in `campaign/README.md`. Historical findings retain their original experiment scope; they are\n17: not promoted by copying an old status into a new contract.\n18: \n19: ## Model authority\n20: \n21: | Responsibility | Model |\n22: |---|---|\n23: | Normal planning, architecture and integration loop | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n24: | Bounded RE analysis, implementation and independent verification | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n25: | Routine lab/workload operations | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n26: | Problem and surprise resolution | GPT-6 Astra |\n27: | Context compaction | GPT-5.5 |\n28: \n29: Exact provider IDs are in `campaign/models.json`. The lead escalates to Astra when a falsified\n30: assumption, conflict, instrument effect, or scope change blocks the loop. No fallback is automatic. Model names in editable JSON are\n31: provenance, not authentication: launcher events and independent review support the record.\n32: Permissions reduce accidental role drift; unrestricted local shell access is not a sandbox.\n33: \n34: ## Behavioral slice\n35: \n36: The lead specifies a bounded input domain, full observable write set, dependencies, acceptance\n37: workloads and stop conditions. The analyst recovers behavior; the verifier specifies discriminating\n38: tests before implementation; the implementer changes engine/adapters; the lab operator captures\n39: controls; the verifier reproduces; the integrator tests the combined source snapshot.\n40: \n41: Include transitive effects: allocations, IDs, container ELEMENTS, event text/records, RNG and\n42: nonserialized state. An address/function name is not a sufficient replacement boundary. If a\n43: neighbor function supplies required effects, extend the approved contract or expose it as an\n44: original dependency. Do not call the original and label the result independent.\n45: \n46: Lifecycle is `proposed → ready → implementing → verification → integration → accepted`, with\n47: blocked/revision states. Lifecycle is distinct from evidence strength. Acceptance is scoped to\n48: the manifest's exact procedure and workloads, never universal correctness.\n49: \n50: ## Independence\n51: \n52: Verifier and implementer are different executions. Verification starts with the contract, raw\n53: evidence and reproduction recipe, not just the author's conclusion. Require one meaningful\n54: challenge: held-out state, boundary, negative control, ablation, or independent state accounting.\n55: Both synthetic tests and original-game experiments matter. Repeat-call volume cannot replace\n56: branch and distinct-state coverage. Null effects and zero executions must be distinguishable.\n57: \n58: ## Sessions and recovery\n59: \n60: At most two implementation slices after a single-slice pilot. No nested worker delegation.\n61: Paired worktrees isolate source changes; unique build directories isolate artifacts. Canonical\n62: RE runtime state remains explicit even when a worker runs in `/tmp` worktrees.\n63: \n64: Checkpoint every 20 calls or 15min; also before experiments, compaction, handoff and stopping.\n65: Record source identities, exact changed paths, commands/results, artifacts and hashes, open\n66: surprises, held leases, requested/observed model, session identity and exact next action. Avoid\n67: large prose histories: raw logs belong in evidence; the checkpoint is a bounded resumption record.\n68: \n69: The launcher caps a quantum at 40 agent steps. A new quantum starts fresh using contract and\n70: checkpoint. Auto-compaction with an ample reserved window and four retained turns is enabled.\n71: This is a best-effort context backstop; regular durable checkpoints and fresh quanta provide the\n72: actual recovery discipline. Never claim a model compacted merely because a setting exists.\n73: \n74: ## Surprises\n75: \n76: On a falsified prediction, contradictory claim, unexplained regression, instrument interference,\n77: or newly necessary dependency: record the observation and evidence; block affected work. Astra\n78: first checks the instrument and source identity, then marks claims surviving/qualified/overturned,\n79: chooses a discriminating experiment, and records the revised plan. Unaffected contracted work\n80: may continue. Updating a paragraph without invalidating affected acceptance is insufficient.\n81: \n82: ## Lab ownership\n83: \n84: Acquire a canonical resource lease before VM, build-host or Ghidra mutation. An expired timestamp\n85: does not authorize stealing a lease. The lead reconciles stale ownership with actual processes.\n86: Use one guest at a time for maintenance, capture before/after inventory, preserve access and\n87: runtime dependencies, and verify unattended console login plus authenticated administration.\n88: Reboots require a free guest and a recorded recovery path. Runtime/Ghidra changes are experiments\n89: with provenance, not undocumented preparatory steps.\n90: \n91: ## Gate and publication\n92: \n93: Run the local gate with explicit engine, corpus, new output directory and profile. It snapshots\n94: source, uses fresh builds, records manifests and runs the expected test inventory once. Host\n95: profile allows a named list of unavailable asset/trace tests and publishes them as limitations.\n96: Full acceptance requires the full profile and the slice-specific original oracle; no blanket\n97: waiver converts a host pass to fidelity. Standalone measurement may diverge; acceptance may not.\n98: \n99: The integrator alone selects current results after verifying their hashes and source binding.\n100: No percentages of LOC, mapped rows or closed leaves purport to measure engine completeness.\n101: Run failure and missing evidence are visible states. Old results remain historical, not current.\n\n(End of file - total 101 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Multi-agent operating architecture\n\n## Product and milestone\n\nReconstruct a behavior-equivalent engine consuming owner-supplied assets. The next product\nmilestone is standalone replay given a captured command stream and complete declared runtime\ninputs. The first workflow pilot is the complete research write set. A passing host build is a\ncomponent baseline, not a playable engine or independent replacement.\n\n## Source of truth\n\n`campaign/contracts/` holds versioned tasks, `campaign/runtime/` holds checkpoints, sessions,\nleases and surprises, and evidence packages identify inputs, source and executable artifacts.\n`campaign/current.json` selects published evidence by path and digest. Board/dashboard are\ngenerated projections, never alternate writable authorities. Exact tool CLI/schema is documented\nin `campaign/README.md`. Historical findings retain their original experiment scope; they are\nnot promoted by copying an old status into a new contract.\n\n## Model authority\n","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/guides/multi-agent-workflow.md","text":"# Multi-agent operating architecture\n\n## Product and milestone\n\nReconstruct a behavior-equivalent engine consuming owner-supplied assets. The next product\nmilestone is standalone replay given a captured command stream and complete declared runtime\ninputs. The first workflow pilot is the complete research write set. A passing host build is a\ncomponent baseline, not a playable engine or independent replacement.\n\n## Source of truth\n\n`campaign/contracts/` holds versioned tasks, `campaign/runtime/` holds checkpoints, sessions,\nleases and surprises, and evidence packages identify inputs, source and executable artifacts.\n`campaign/current.json` selects published evidence by path and digest. Board/dashboard are\ngenerated projections, never alternate writable authorities. Exact tool CLI/schema is documented\nin `campaign/README.md`. Historical findings retain their original experiment scope; they are\nnot promoted by copying an old status into a new contract.\n\n## Model authority\n\n| Responsibility | Model |\n|---|---|\n| Normal planning, architecture and integration loop | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n| Bounded RE analysis, implementation and independent verification | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n| Routine lab/workload operations | GPT-5.6 Sol |\n| Problem and surprise resolution | GPT-6 Astra |\n| Context compaction | GPT-5.5 |\n\nExact provider IDs are in `campaign/models.json`. The lead escalates to Astra when a falsified\nassumption, conflict, instrument effect, or scope change blocks the loop. No fallback is automatic. Model names in editable JSON are\nprovenance, not authentication: launcher events and independent review support the record.\nPermissions reduce accidental role drift; unrestricted local shell access is not a sandbox.\n\n## Behavioral slice\n\nThe lead specifies a bounded input domain, full observable write set, dependencies, acceptance\nworkloads and stop conditions. The analyst recovers behavior; the verifier specifies discriminating\ntests before implementation; the implementer changes engine/adapters; the lab operator captures\ncontrols; the verifier reproduces; the integrator tests the combined source snapshot.\n\nInclude transitive effects: allocations, IDs, container ELEMENTS, event text/records, RNG and\nnonserialized state. An address/function name is not a sufficient replacement boundary. If a\nneighbor function supplies required effects, extend the approved contract or expose it as an\noriginal dependency. Do not call the original and label the result independent.\n\nLifecycle is `proposed → ready → implementing → verification → integration → accepted`, with\nblocked/revision states. Lifecycle is distinct from evidence strength. Acceptance is scoped to\nthe manifest's exact procedure and workloads, never universal correctness.\n\n## Independence\n\nVerifier and implementer are different executions. Verification starts with the contract, raw\nevidence and reproduction recipe, not just the author's conclusion. Require one meaningful\nchallenge: held-out state, boundary, negative control, ablation, or independent state accounting.\nBoth synthetic tests and original-game experiments matter. Repeat-call volume cannot replace\nbranch and distinct-state coverage. Null effects and zero executions must be distinguishable.\n\n## Sessions and recovery\n\nAt most two implementation slices after a single-slice pilot. No nested worker delegation.\nPaired worktrees isolate source changes; unique build directories isolate artifacts. Canonical\nRE runtime state remains explicit even when a worker runs in `/tmp` worktrees.\n\nCheckpoint every 20 calls or 15min; also before experiments, compaction, handoff and stopping.\nRecord source identities, exact changed paths, commands/results, artifacts and hashes, open\nsurprises, held leases, requested/observed model, session identity and exact next action. Avoid\nlarge prose histories: raw logs belong in evidence; the checkpoint is a bounded resumption record.\n\nThe launcher caps a quantum at 40 agent steps. A new quantum starts fresh using contract and\ncheckpoint. Auto-compaction with an ample reserved window and four retained turns is enabled.\nThis is a best-effort context backstop; regular durable checkpoints and fresh quanta provide the\nactual recovery discipline. Never claim a model compacted merely because a setting exists.\n\n## Surprises\n\nOn a falsified prediction, contradictory claim, unexplained regression, instrument interference,\nor newly necessary dependency: record the observation and evidence; block affected work. Astra\nfirst checks the instrument and source identity, then marks claims surviving/qualified/overturned,\nchooses a discriminating experiment, and records the revised plan. Unaffected contracted work\nmay continue. Updating a paragraph without invalidating affected acceptance is insufficient.\n\n## Lab ownership\n\nAcquire a canonical resource lease before VM, build-host or Ghidra mutation. An expired timestamp\ndoes not authorize stealing a lease. The lead reconciles stale ownership with actual processes.\nUse one guest at a time for maintenance, capture before/after inventory, preserve access and\nruntime dependencies, and verify unattended console login plus authenticated administration.\nReboots require a free guest and a recorded recovery path. Runtime/Ghidra changes are experiments\nwith provenance, not undocumented preparatory steps.\n\n## Gate and publication\n\nRun the local gate with explicit engine, corpus, new output directory and profile. It snapshots\nsource, uses fresh builds, records manifests and runs the expected test inventory once. Host\nprofile allows a named list of unavailable asset/trace tests and publishes them as limitations.\nFull acceptance requires the full profile and the slice-specific original oracle; no blanket\nwaiver converts a host pass to fidelity. Standalone measurement may diverge; acceptance may not.\n\nThe integrator alone selects current results after verifying their hashes and source binding.\nNo percentages of LOC, mapped rows or closed leaves purport to measure engine completeness.\nRun failure and missing evidence are visible states. Old results remain historical, not current.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":101,"totalLines":101,"truncated":false}},"title":"guides/multi-agent-workflow.md","time":{"start":1788999727470,"end":1788999727484}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b922b919b21af3a016aa1f82f2cb487d197f3d6085aa2e027"}},"id":"prt_088b179630017A430stZT8N7RO","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b157aa001y56yGMfxIgL2KV"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999727548,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"glob","callID":"call_3vQyyW9x4qp0W9sRjDEaDKDQ","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"pattern":"campaign/runtime/surprises/*.json"},"output":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-410e48d5ae6cc4da0a6ae649.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-4a7d66ebd7d8a8f3ec59f11d.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-abd1c3613c9922cc94c608d5.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-6d1fcc617a20ca2bcbffc0cc.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-f1c41532e618c77d41538902.json","metadata":{"count":7,"truncated":false},"title":"","time":{"start":1788999727497,"end":1788999727546}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b922b919b21af3a016aa1f82f2cc087d1a3147bfd94542b8f"}},"id":"prt_088b17977001VVzBR3cqtWIcd7","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b157aa001y56yGMfxIgL2KV"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999727637,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b17a10001QvF0LAy431dcca","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"64a106da50ff8f3b493651e29efe33c40a86cd18","messageID":"msg_088b157aa001y56yGMfxIgL2KV","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":9941,"input":4139,"output":170,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":5632}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999736184,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b19b74001zm0WWDTOrBlesX","messageID":"msg_088b17a47001te0kKGyOdN2Vxt","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"fdf2cb80d5765788f1d766c612904cc9a2fed51b","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999736333,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_zEdSZInHS8yJPFs3KjZwYSbT","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n4:   \"id\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n5:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n6:   \"probe\": \"Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.\",\n7:   \"role\": \"verifier\",\n8:   \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n9:   \"status\": \"open\",\n10:   \"summary\": \"Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.\",\n11:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:19:20.577736+00:00\"\n12: }\n\n(End of file - total 12 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"probe\": \"Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"open\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:19:20.577736+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-abi-independent\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-5.6-sol\",\n  \"probe\": \"Astra should first rerun both objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and the minimally widened --stop-address=0x00825e67 command against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, archive raw stdout bytes and objdump executable hash/version, and decide whether the existing capture was manually spliced or generated with a different effective boundary. Repair provenance before independent ABI interpretation resumes.\",\n  \"role\": \"verifier\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-surprise/1\",\n  \"status\": \"open\",\n  \"summary\": \"Independent reproduction falsified the handoff claim that objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt is unfiltered output from its exact first command. With the SHA256-matched executable and GNU objdump 2.38, the declared stop-address 0x00825e65 truncates the three-byte instruction beginning at 0x00825e64: current stdout is bytes c2 while the archive records c2 08 00. The other three declared windows reproduce exactly after only line-end whitespace normalization. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction; dedup interpretation is paused rather than converting the otherwise matching instructions into success.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:19:20.577736+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":12,"totalLines":12,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json","time":{"start":1788999736257,"end":1788999736315}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0a0d59d263a4d227016aa1f8381a7087d1a53238f932cdd125"}},"id":"prt_088b19b77001hx9RVH6B37hvtm","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b17a47001te0kKGyOdN2Vxt"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999736334,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_Q0yIN5ghBZfaCfJQ4YMOLfqo","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Completion record ABI recovery\n2: \n3: Static handoff only. The provenance index is\n4: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md`; the regenerated instruction\n5: capture and interpretation are respectively\n6: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` and\n7: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md`. The complete dedup/helper repair is\n8: `verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`. Input identity is `dumps/sots.exe`,\n9: SHA-256 `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n10: `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n11: \n12: ## Implementable machine boundaries recovered\n13: \n14: * `0x008562a0`: ObservedTech default constructor, ECX receiver, EAX return, plain `ret`.\n15: * `0x007b7320`: ObservedTech vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x2c`.\n16:   Its copy helper is `0x0079a150` (cdecl-style allocator/destination/source stack arguments), which copy-constructs the embedded string rather than copying a\n17:   vector element header. Capacity growth is `0x007b5820` -> `0x007b34e0` -> `0x0057e590`.\n18: * `0x0057e590` calls `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x2c`; reallocation destroys every old element via\n19:   virtual slot 0 with zero and frees the array through `0x00924faa`. These are MSVCR100 scalar-new\n20:   and scalar-delete import thunks, not clean-room allocator operations.\n21: * `0x0086c580`: PlayerEvent vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x74`.\n22:   It grows via `0x00869500` and copy-constructs through `0x007693f0` (ECX destination, stack source,\n23:   EAX destination return, ret 4), independently assigning all\n24:   three strings. `0x0061ae90` releases each long string via `0x00924faa` when capacity is `>= 0x10`.\n25: * `0x004249a0` (reached by `0x00425430` assignment) allocates through `0x00924fb6` and releases a\n26:   prior long destination buffer through `0x00924faa`. A temporary long string is therefore not\n27:   transferable by raw header copy.\n28: * `0x00885380`: get-or-create TurnEvents bucket, ECX EventStorage receiver plus stack turn, EAX\n29:   bucket return, `ret 4`. It returns the last existing matching turn. On absence it appends a deep\n30:   copy of a zero/empty stack bucket through `0x00884cb0`, then writes the stored turn.\n31: * `0x00884cb0`: outer TurnEvents vector append, ECX vector receiver plus stack source, `ret 4`,\n32:   stride `0x18`. Full-capacity growth is `0x008841a0` -> `0x00883a60`; allocation is\n33:   `0x006e8f50` -> `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x18`. Existing buckets are copy-constructed by\n34:   `0x0077fed0`, including an independently allocated/copied nested PlayerEvent vector via\n35:   `0x00779850` -> `0x0078af40` (`count * 0x74`) -> `0x007725a0` -> `0x007693f0`.\n36: * TurnEvents virtual slot zero resolves from vtable `0x00a0f07c` to `0x0062e120`. It destroys the\n37:   nested vector through `0x00629580`; that destroys every `0x74` PlayerEvent, frees the nested block,\n38:   and zeros its three pointers. Static unwind edges clean partial PlayerEvent and TurnEvents ranges\n39:   and free the new outer block, but no allocation failure was executed live.\n40: \n41: ## Ordering / visible effects\n42: \n43: RecordObservedTech's append predicate is name absence, not capacity. A matching existing record\n44: keeps first-turn/name and updates last-turn/with mask. `0x00825d40` scans a bucket's events in\n45: `0x74` steps, checking action, location, three floats, message and image before passing both\n46: description strings to `0x0046f8c0`. Fresh complete instructions establish that helper as\n47: caller-cleaned `bool string_not_equal(stored, candidate)`: it returns one for any byte/length\n48: difference and zero for equality, handling each operand's inline/heap representation at capacity\n49: `0x10`. FindDuplicate reaches the match return only on zero, so `EvDsc` equality is required and a\n50: description-only difference does not deduplicate. This statically contradicts the inherited\n51: description-omission claim; decision `d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` required the now-archived complete\n52: branch/helper repair. The wrapper returns the first element equal in all fields and writes nothing.\n53: `0x00879eb0` prunes only a leading\n54: stale run (`EvTurn < turn-50`), deep-shifts from the run's last stale element, and therefore removes\n55: `n-1`: one stale bucket survives, a single stale bucket causes no write, and stale buckets after a\n56: fresh bucket are not inspected. The no-duplicate EventStorage path remains distinct from event-vector\n57: capacity: it is the path that appends a `0x74` PlayerEvent and changes IDs/vector contents. Caller\n58: text/position/action/defaulting and the exact PostEvent write order remain required inputs/effects.\n59: No RNG draw occurs in the recovered bucket, duplicate, prune, copy, allocation, or destruction\n60: boundaries.\n61: \n62: ## Original/runtime dependencies and limits\n63: \n64: Any original-assisted allocation, string assignment or deletion must retain allocator-family\n65: compatibility: the recovered calls target the original MSVCR100 import thunks. A standalone\n66: replacement needs its own coherent allocation/destruction boundary; calling these original helpers\n67: is an original dependency, not independent replacement. Calling `0x0046f8c0` likewise retains an\n68: original string-layout/comparison dependency, though its equality behavior is implementable without\n69: allocation in a standalone boundary. Required unavailable proof inputs are a safe\n70: long-string/full-capacity pre/post fixture (or equivalent archived trace), same-bucket\n71: equal/description-only-different event fixtures covering short and long strings, exact exceptional\n72: cleanup outcomes under a live throw, and independent reproduction of the named static windows and\n73: falsifiers. This handoff makes no live\n74: allocator-safety, runtime event-construction, or replacement-acceptance claim.\n\n(End of file - total 74 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Completion record ABI recovery\n\nStatic handoff only. The provenance index is\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md`; the regenerated instruction\ncapture and interpretation are respectively\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` and\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md`. The complete dedup/helper repair is\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`. Input identity is `dumps/sots.exe`,\nSHA-256 `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n\n## Implementable machine boundaries recovered\n\n* `0x008562a0`: ObservedTech default constructor, ECX receiver, EAX return, plain `ret`.\n* `0x007b7320`: ObservedTech vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x2c`.\n  Its copy helper is `0x0079a150` (cdecl-style allocator/destination/source stack arguments), which copy-constructs the embedded string rather than copying a\n  vector element header. Capacity growth is `0x007b5820` -> `0x007b34e0` -> `0x0057e590`.\n* `0x0057e590` calls `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x2c`; reallocation destroys every old element via\n  virtual slot 0 with zero and frees the array through `0x00924faa`. These are MSVCR100 scalar-new\n  and scalar-delete import thunks, not clean-room allocator operations.","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md","text":"# Completion record ABI recovery\n\nStatic handoff only. The provenance index is\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md`; the regenerated instruction\ncapture and interpretation are respectively\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` and\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/recovered-static.md`. The complete dedup/helper repair is\n`verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`. Input identity is `dumps/sots.exe`,\nSHA-256 `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841` / MD5\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`.\n\n## Implementable machine boundaries recovered\n\n* `0x008562a0`: ObservedTech default constructor, ECX receiver, EAX return, plain `ret`.\n* `0x007b7320`: ObservedTech vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x2c`.\n  Its copy helper is `0x0079a150` (cdecl-style allocator/destination/source stack arguments), which copy-constructs the embedded string rather than copying a\n  vector element header. Capacity growth is `0x007b5820` -> `0x007b34e0` -> `0x0057e590`.\n* `0x0057e590` calls `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x2c`; reallocation destroys every old element via\n  virtual slot 0 with zero and frees the array through `0x00924faa`. These are MSVCR100 scalar-new\n  and scalar-delete import thunks, not clean-room allocator operations.\n* `0x0086c580`: PlayerEvent vector append, ECX receiver plus one stack word, `ret 4`; stride `0x74`.\n  It grows via `0x00869500` and copy-constructs through `0x007693f0` (ECX destination, stack source,\n  EAX destination return, ret 4), independently assigning all\n  three strings. `0x0061ae90` releases each long string via `0x00924faa` when capacity is `>= 0x10`.\n* `0x004249a0` (reached by `0x00425430` assignment) allocates through `0x00924fb6` and releases a\n  prior long destination buffer through `0x00924faa`. A temporary long string is therefore not\n  transferable by raw header copy.\n* `0x00885380`: get-or-create TurnEvents bucket, ECX EventStorage receiver plus stack turn, EAX\n  bucket return, `ret 4`. It returns the last existing matching turn. On absence it appends a deep\n  copy of a zero/empty stack bucket through `0x00884cb0`, then writes the stored turn.\n* `0x00884cb0`: outer TurnEvents vector append, ECX vector receiver plus stack source, `ret 4`,\n  stride `0x18`. Full-capacity growth is `0x008841a0` -> `0x00883a60`; allocation is\n  `0x006e8f50` -> `0x00924fb6` with `count * 0x18`. Existing buckets are copy-constructed by\n  `0x0077fed0`, including an independently allocated/copied nested PlayerEvent vector via\n  `0x00779850` -> `0x0078af40` (`count * 0x74`) -> `0x007725a0` -> `0x007693f0`.\n* TurnEvents virtual slot zero resolves from vtable `0x00a0f07c` to `0x0062e120`. It destroys the\n  nested vector through `0x00629580`; that destroys every `0x74` PlayerEvent, frees the nested block,\n  and zeros its three pointers. Static unwind edges clean partial PlayerEvent and TurnEvents ranges\n  and free the new outer block, but no allocation failure was executed live.\n\n## Ordering / visible effects\n\nRecordObservedTech's append predicate is name absence, not capacity. A matching existing record\nkeeps first-turn/name and updates last-turn/with mask. `0x00825d40` scans a bucket's events in\n`0x74` steps, checking action, location, three floats, message and image before passing both\ndescription strings to `0x0046f8c0`. Fresh complete instructions establish that helper as\ncaller-cleaned `bool string_not_equal(stored, candidate)`: it returns one for any byte/length\ndifference and zero for equality, handling each operand's inline/heap representation at capacity\n`0x10`. FindDuplicate reaches the match return only on zero, so `EvDsc` equality is required and a\ndescription-only difference does not deduplicate. This statically contradicts the inherited\ndescription-omission claim; decision `d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` required the now-archived complete\nbranch/helper repair. The wrapper returns the first element equal in all fields and writes nothing.\n`0x00879eb0` prunes only a leading\nstale run (`EvTurn < turn-50`), deep-shifts from the run's last stale element, and therefore removes\n`n-1`: one stale bucket survives, a single stale bucket causes no write, and stale buckets after a\nfresh bucket are not inspected. The no-duplicate EventStorage path remains distinct from event-vector\ncapacity: it is the path that appends a `0x74` PlayerEvent and changes IDs/vector contents. Caller\ntext/position/action/defaulting and the exact PostEvent write order remain required inputs/effects.\nNo RNG draw occurs in the recovered bucket, duplicate, prune, copy, allocation, or destruction\nboundaries.\n\n## Original/runtime dependencies and limits\n\nAny original-assisted allocation, string assignment or deletion must retain allocator-family\ncompatibility: the recovered calls target the original MSVCR100 import thunks. A standalone\nreplacement needs its own coherent allocation/destruction boundary; calling these original helpers\nis an original dependency, not independent replacement. Calling `0x0046f8c0` likewise retains an\noriginal string-layout/comparison dependency, though its equality behavior is implementable without\nallocation in a standalone boundary. Required unavailable proof inputs are a safe\nlong-string/full-capacity pre/post fixture (or equivalent archived trace), same-bucket\nequal/description-only-different event fixtures covering short and long strings, exact exceptional\ncleanup outcomes under a live throw, and independent reproduction of the named static windows and\nfalsifiers. This handoff makes no live\nallocator-safety, runtime event-construction, or replacement-acceptance claim.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":74,"totalLines":74,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md","time":{"start":1788999736276,"end":1788999736320}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0a0d59d263a4d227016aa1f8381a9087d1a69b553493ac2f03"}},"id":"prt_088b19bd0001OaGj5hSkT1e6fY","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b17a47001te0kKGyOdN2Vxt"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999736334,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_TWDJcaaJ3zoRG3yGRi8lVVVe","state":{"status":"error","input":{"command":"python3 tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re source-binding research-completion-abi --engine-worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine --re-worktree /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re"},"error":"The user has specified a rule which prevents you from using this specific tool call. Here are some of the relevant rules [{\"permission\":\"*\",\"action\":\"allow\",\"pattern\":\"*\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"*\",\"action\":\"deny\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"git -C * status *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"git -C * diff *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"git -C * log *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"git -C * rev-parse *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"git -C * show *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re resolve *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re surprise *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status *\",\"action\":\"allow\"},{\"permission\":\"bash\",\"pattern\":\"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re validate *\",\"action\":\"allow\"}]","time":{"start":1788999736289,"end":1788999736331}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0a0d59d263a4d227016aa1f8381aa887d19e01174ec1dcdfa0"}},"id":"prt_088b19bdd001M3Whor70HL1juQ","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b17a47001te0kKGyOdN2Vxt"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999736350,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"grep","callID":"call_zuITPbYEcUVNktdgdWe3u6Ra","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"pattern":"\"status\": \"open\"","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises"},"output":"Found 1 matches\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/surprises/s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.json:\n  Line 9:   \"status\": \"open\",\n","metadata":{"matches":1,"truncated":false},"title":"\"status\": \"open\"","time":{"start":1788999736283,"end":1788999736336}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0a0d59d263a4d227016aa1f8381a9c87d198f3d4da4c2977df"}},"id":"prt_088b19bd70010OeCJDbmuJRdqA","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b17a47001te0kKGyOdN2Vxt"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999736350,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_VVqLRIctWhaB6uApH7r9ytvy","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Independent ABI verification result (paused)\n2: \n3: Session `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\n4: model claim `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n5: \n6: ## Classification and verdict\n7: \n8: **Fail / blocked for `independent-cross-check` pending Astra resolution of surprise\n9: `s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f`.** This is an independent static reproduction plus archived-save\n10: cross-check only. It is not original-assisted runtime execution, a partial or full live compare,\n11: an independent replacement, or integrated replay. No live allocator-safety or replacement claim\n12: was tested.\n13: \n14: ## Identities\n15: \n16: * `dumps/sots.exe`: SHA-256\n17:   `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, MD5\n18:   `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c` (independently recomputed).\n19: * Tool reports `GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38`.\n20: * Engine worktree: HEAD `7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23`, common Git directory\n21:   `/home/alex/sots-engine/.git`, source-binding\n22:   `ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd`.\n23: * RE worktree: HEAD `3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7`, common Git directory\n24:   `/home/alex/sots-re/.git`, source-binding\n25:   `6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8`.\n26: * Both worktrees had the pre-existing dirty inventories recorded in the checkpoint. This verifier\n27:   changed neither worktree and touched no lab resource.\n28: \n29: ## Reproduction results\n30: \n31: All four handoff commands were executed directly, with no output filter. Each exited zero and\n32: emitted nonzero instruction output. Fresh stdout SHA-256 and instruction counts were:\n33: \n34: | window | instructions | stdout SHA-256 | archive comparison |\n35: |---|---:|---|---|\n36: | `0x00825d40..0x00825e65` | 120 | `1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8` | **mismatch** |\n37: | `0x0046f8c0..0x0046f8f0` | 26 | `373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n38: | `0x004236a0..0x0042370d` | 51 | `1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n39: | `0x00422720..0x00422796` | 51 | `4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n40: \n41: The sole semantic-text mismatch is at the first window's terminal instruction. The exact declared\n42: command stops at `0x00825e65`, one byte into the three-byte instruction beginning at\n43: `0x00825e64`. Fresh objdump stdout reports only byte `c2` while still decoding `ret 0x8`; the\n44: archive reports bytes `c2 08 00`. Therefore the archive cannot be unfiltered stdout from the\n45: declared command under the recorded effective instrument. The mismatch is not dismissed merely\n46: because widening the boundary would likely recover the missing bytes.\n47: \n48: This failed the predeclared provenance/instrument falsifier. The dedup ABI interpretation is paused;\n49: the three matching windows and zero exit statuses are measurements, not a pass.\n50: \n51: ## Independent archived-state check (completed before pause)\n52: \n53: `python3 verify/save-reader/save_reader.py verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav --dump --json\n54: --strict` exited zero. The parser reported 37,847 items, 2,453 frames, zero resyncs, zero hint\n55: failures and zero best-effort recoveries (informational positional-tag issues remain). Direct tree\n56: inspection, rather than a reported event count, recovered player 1's event storage at inflated\n57: offset 120372: `EvNxID=4`; turn-2 bucket with event id 1; turn-3 bucket with event ids 2 and 3.\n58: Event 3 is `Research Over Budget`, message `Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.`, image\n59: `EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, location 0, action 1, chain id 0, and all three position words are\n60: the integer bit pattern `2139095039` (`0x7f7fffff`). Players 2 and 3 each have `EvNxID=0` and an\n61: empty event collection. This supports those archived record values only; it is not live execution.\n62: \n63: ## Challenge status, failed predictions, and residuals\n64: \n65: The planned held-out NaN-position negative control was not promoted to a result after the instrument\n66: provenance surprise. Its prediction remains untested in this quantum. Live empty/short/long\n67: description fixtures, allocation failure, allocator compatibility, runtime event construction,\n68: full-capacity pre/post memory, RNG state and integrated replay also remain residuals. No RNG counter\n69: was treated as state evidence; no runtime workload executed, so RNG behavior is outside this result.\n70: \n71: Reproduction commands are the four exact commands printed in\n72: `objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`, followed by the strict save-reader command above. The exact\n73: next action belongs to Astra and is recorded in the canonical checkpoint.\n\n(End of file - total 73 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Independent ABI verification result (paused)\n\nSession `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\nmodel claim `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n\n## Classification and verdict\n\n**Fail / blocked for `independent-cross-check` pending Astra resolution of surprise\n`s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f`.** This is an independent static reproduction plus archived-save\ncross-check only. It is not original-assisted runtime execution, a partial or full live compare,\nan independent replacement, or integrated replay. No live allocator-safety or replacement claim\nwas tested.\n\n## Identities\n\n* `dumps/sots.exe`: SHA-256\n  `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, MD5\n  `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c` (independently recomputed).\n* Tool reports `GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38`.\n* Engine worktree: HEAD `7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23`, common Git directory","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md","text":"# Independent ABI verification result (paused)\n\nSession `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\nmodel claim `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n\n## Classification and verdict\n\n**Fail / blocked for `independent-cross-check` pending Astra resolution of surprise\n`s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f`.** This is an independent static reproduction plus archived-save\ncross-check only. It is not original-assisted runtime execution, a partial or full live compare,\nan independent replacement, or integrated replay. No live allocator-safety or replacement claim\nwas tested.\n\n## Identities\n\n* `dumps/sots.exe`: SHA-256\n  `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, MD5\n  `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c` (independently recomputed).\n* Tool reports `GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38`.\n* Engine worktree: HEAD `7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23`, common Git directory\n  `/home/alex/sots-engine/.git`, source-binding\n  `ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd`.\n* RE worktree: HEAD `3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7`, common Git directory\n  `/home/alex/sots-re/.git`, source-binding\n  `6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8`.\n* Both worktrees had the pre-existing dirty inventories recorded in the checkpoint. This verifier\n  changed neither worktree and touched no lab resource.\n\n## Reproduction results\n\nAll four handoff commands were executed directly, with no output filter. Each exited zero and\nemitted nonzero instruction output. Fresh stdout SHA-256 and instruction counts were:\n\n| window | instructions | stdout SHA-256 | archive comparison |\n|---|---:|---|---|\n| `0x00825d40..0x00825e65` | 120 | `1c2408cd49cc10383bad9fe06d3287476b103205f4155adf64c8a50ccd5205e8` | **mismatch** |\n| `0x0046f8c0..0x0046f8f0` | 26 | `373b04cbc836e81ee84145796c86766fcbeb363ac3c5be44dc8419ee91a170ed` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n| `0x004236a0..0x0042370d` | 51 | `1debe85f054a442a09cb84c895e1950487abe996051dde0820e5d687022d9a66` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n| `0x00422720..0x00422796` | 51 | `4e2f8375cc0c6f645a09d2ebedb95e40d0414fb8e667b8c01768357397e8c580` | exact after line-end whitespace normalization |\n\nThe sole semantic-text mismatch is at the first window's terminal instruction. The exact declared\ncommand stops at `0x00825e65`, one byte into the three-byte instruction beginning at\n`0x00825e64`. Fresh objdump stdout reports only byte `c2` while still decoding `ret 0x8`; the\narchive reports bytes `c2 08 00`. Therefore the archive cannot be unfiltered stdout from the\ndeclared command under the recorded effective instrument. The mismatch is not dismissed merely\nbecause widening the boundary would likely recover the missing bytes.\n\nThis failed the predeclared provenance/instrument falsifier. The dedup ABI interpretation is paused;\nthe three matching windows and zero exit statuses are measurements, not a pass.\n\n## Independent archived-state check (completed before pause)\n\n`python3 verify/save-reader/save_reader.py verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav --dump --json\n--strict` exited zero. The parser reported 37,847 items, 2,453 frames, zero resyncs, zero hint\nfailures and zero best-effort recoveries (informational positional-tag issues remain). Direct tree\ninspection, rather than a reported event count, recovered player 1's event storage at inflated\noffset 120372: `EvNxID=4`; turn-2 bucket with event id 1; turn-3 bucket with event ids 2 and 3.\nEvent 3 is `Research Over Budget`, message `Research for Waldo Units has gone overbudget.`, image\n`EVENT_RESEARCH_OVERBUDGET`, location 0, action 1, chain id 0, and all three position words are\nthe integer bit pattern `2139095039` (`0x7f7fffff`). Players 2 and 3 each have `EvNxID=0` and an\nempty event collection. This supports those archived record values only; it is not live execution.\n\n## Challenge status, failed predictions, and residuals\n\nThe planned held-out NaN-position negative control was not promoted to a result after the instrument\nprovenance surprise. Its prediction remains untested in this quantum. Live empty/short/long\ndescription fixtures, allocation failure, allocator compatibility, runtime event construction,\nfull-capacity pre/post memory, RNG state and integrated replay also remain residuals. No RNG counter\nwas treated as state evidence; no runtime workload executed, so RNG behavior is outside this result.\n\nReproduction commands are the four exact commands printed in\n`objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt`, followed by the strict save-reader command above. The exact\nnext action belongs to Astra and is recorded in the canonical checkpoint.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":73,"totalLines":73,"truncated":false}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md","time":{"start":1788999736270,"end":1788999736346}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0a0d59d263a4d227016aa1f8381a8487d180d80073ccdbc5e0"}},"id":"prt_088b19bc4001ojXvl4VhwhXSkm","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b17a47001te0kKGyOdN2Vxt"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999736400,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b19c4a001Th4k1gCgLzgeLq","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"d0e301704c19552662005a19ef2abdf89d08c05d","messageID":"msg_088b17a47001te0kKGyOdN2Vxt","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":15021,"input":5194,"output":227,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":9600}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999738758,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b1a582001deZf8VWmV1HBLm","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"edad0fc82c507d99bdb1181a539e05fb38ca7d48","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"text","timestamp":1788999751119,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b1a77c001XTCLAshyds9H6u","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"text","text":"Observation: the independent verifier reports that the archived first dedup disassembly window contains `c2 08 00`, whereas its declared stop boundary reproduces only `c2`; the other three windows matched. Provenance: surprise `s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f` and `verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md`, against the reported SHA-256-matched original executable. This is an archive/instrument-boundary contradiction, not evidence of a game mechanism or stale build.\n\nThe resolver’s execution permissions prohibit source-binding and objdump commands. I will inspect the available identities and raw archive, then record a decision that assigns the permitted provenance-repair probe without claiming to have run it.","time":{"start":1788999739260,"end":1788999751117},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"msg_033341ee6d4f9813016aa1f83b3c5487d1af05316159adb8a7","phase":"commentary"}}}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999751220,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_Ct9puQnOns5vdaZLbKlO4H8s","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/leases"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/leases</path>\n<type>directory</type>\n<entries>\nspicy-autounattend-credential.json\nvm140.json\nvm141.json\nvm144.json\nvm145.json\nvm146.json\n\n(6 entries)\n</entries>","metadata":{"preview":"spicy-autounattend-credential.json\nvm140.json\nvm141.json\nvm144.json\nvm145.json\nvm146.json","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"directory","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/leases","entries":["spicy-autounattend-credential.json","vm140.json","vm141.json","vm144.json","vm145.json","vm146.json"],"offset":1,"totalEntries":6,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/leases","time":{"start":1788999751190,"end":1788999751207}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_033341ee6d4f9813016aa1f847007c87d1951043f0e6273f14"}},"id":"prt_088b1d6130015Se77qm63YL1Yb","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999751220,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_u4lw9udY5Yjk1knaSj6PH3Pb","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n2: # SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n3: # Tool: GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38, Intel syntax.\n4: # Every command below exited 0. Output is unfiltered.\n5: #\n6: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe\n7: \n8: dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n9: \n10: \n11: Disassembly of section .text:\n12: \n13: 00825d40 <.text+0x424d40>:\n14:   825d40:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n15:   825d41:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n16:   825d43:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n17:   825d44:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n18:   825d45:\t8b 5d 08             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n19:   825d48:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n20:   825d49:\t33 f6                \txor    esi,esi\n21:   825d4b:\t3b de                \tcmp    ebx,esi\n22:   825d4d:\t75 0a                \tjne    0x825d59\n23:   825d4f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n24:   825d50:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n25:   825d52:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n26:   825d53:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n27:   825d55:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n28:   825d56:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n29:   825d59:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n30:   825d5c:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n31:   825d5f:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n32:   825d64:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n33:   825d66:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n34:   825d68:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n35:   825d6b:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n36:   825d6d:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n37:   825d70:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n38:   825d72:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n39:   825d73:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n40:   825d76:\t0f 84 d5 00 00 00    \tje     0x825e51\n41:   825d7c:\t8b 7d 0c             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n42:   825d7f:\t89 75 08             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],esi\n43:   825d82:\t8b 73 08             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n44:   825d85:\t03 75 08             \tadd    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n45:   825d88:\t8b 4e 6c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x6c]\n46:   825d8b:\t3b 4f 6c             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x6c]\n47:   825d8e:\t0f 85 91 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n48:   825d94:\t8b 56 40             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x40]\n49:   825d97:\t3b 57 40             \tcmp    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x40]\n50:   825d9a:\t0f 85 85 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n51:   825da0:\td9 46 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x44]\n52:   825da3:\td9 47 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x44]\n53:   825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n54:   825da8:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n55:   825daa:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n56:   825dad:\t7a 76                \tjp     0x825e25\n57:   825daf:\td9 46 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x48]\n58:   825db2:\td9 47 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x48]\n59:   825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n60:   825db7:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n61:   825db9:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n62:   825dbc:\t7a 67                \tjp     0x825e25\n63:   825dbe:\td9 46 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4c]\n64:   825dc1:\td9 47 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4c]\n65:   825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n66:   825dc6:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n67:   825dc8:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n68:   825dcb:\t7a 58                \tjp     0x825e25\n69:   825dcd:\t83 7f 38 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x38],0x10\n70:   825dd1:\t8b 57 34             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x34]\n71:   825dd4:\t8d 47 24             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x24]\n72:   825dd7:\t8d 4e 24             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x24]\n73:   825dda:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825dde\n74:   825ddc:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n75:   825dde:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n76:   825ddf:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n77:   825de0:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n78:   825de3:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n79:   825de4:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n80:   825de6:\te8 b5 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n81:   825deb:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n82:   825ded:\t75 36                \tjne    0x825e25\n83:   825def:\t83 7f 64 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x64],0x10\n84:   825df3:\t8b 57 60             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x60]\n85:   825df6:\t8d 47 50             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x50]\n86:   825df9:\t8d 4e 50             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x50]\n87:   825dfc:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825e00\n88:   825dfe:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n89:   825e00:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n90:   825e01:\t8b 51 10             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n91:   825e04:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n92:   825e05:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n93:   825e06:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n94:   825e08:\te8 93 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n95:   825e0d:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n96:   825e0f:\t75 14                \tjne    0x825e25\n97:   825e11:\t8d 47 08             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x8]\n98:   825e14:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n99:   825e15:\t8d 4e 08             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n100:   825e18:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n101:   825e19:\te8 a2 9a c4 ff       \tcall   0x46f8c0\n102:   825e1e:\t83 c4 08             \tadd    esp,0x8\n103:   825e21:\t84 c0                \ttest   al,al\n104:   825e23:\t74 37                \tje     0x825e5c\n105:   825e25:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n106:   825e28:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n107:   825e2b:\t8b 75 fc             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4]\n108:   825e2e:\t83 45 08 74          \tadd    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],0x74\n109:   825e32:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n110:   825e37:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n111:   825e39:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n112:   825e3b:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n113:   825e3e:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n114:   825e40:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n115:   825e43:\t46                   \tinc    esi\n116:   825e44:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n117:   825e46:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n118:   825e49:\t3b f0                \tcmp    esi,eax\n119:   825e4b:\t0f 82 31 ff ff ff    \tjb     0x825d82\n120:   825e51:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n121:   825e52:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n122:   825e53:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n123:   825e55:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n124:   825e56:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n125:   825e58:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n126:   825e59:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n127:   825e5c:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n128:   825e5d:\t8b c6                \tmov    eax,esi\n129:   825e5f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n130:   825e60:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n131:   825e61:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n132:   825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n133:   825e64:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n134: \n135: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe\n136: \n137: dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n138: \n139: \n140: Disassembly of section .text:\n141: \n142: 0046f8c0 <.text+0x6e8c0>:\n143:   46f8c0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n144:   46f8c1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n145:   46f8c3:\t8b 45 0c             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n146:   46f8c6:\t83 78 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [eax+0x14],0x10\n147:   46f8ca:\t8b 48 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [eax+0x10]\n148:   46f8cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x46f8d1\n149:   46f8cf:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n150:   46f8d1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n151:   46f8d2:\t8b 4d 08             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n152:   46f8d5:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n153:   46f8d6:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n154:   46f8d9:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n155:   46f8da:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n156:   46f8dc:\te8 bf 3d fb ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n157:   46f8e1:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n158:   46f8e3:\t1b c0                \tsbb    eax,eax\n159:   46f8e5:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n160:   46f8e7:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n161:   46f8e8:\tc3                   \tret\n162:   46f8e9:\tcc                   \tint3\n163:   46f8ea:\tcc                   \tint3\n164:   46f8eb:\tcc                   \tint3\n165:   46f8ec:\tcc                   \tint3\n166:   46f8ed:\tcc                   \tint3\n167:   46f8ee:\tcc                   \tint3\n168:   46f8ef:\tcc                   \tint3\n169: \n170: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe\n171: \n172: dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n173: \n174: \n175: Disassembly of section .text:\n176: \n177: 004236a0 <.text+0x226a0>:\n178:   4236a0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n179:   4236a1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n180:   4236a3:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n181:   4236a6:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n182:   4236a7:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n183:   4236a8:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n184:   4236a9:\t8b 7d 08             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n185:   4236ac:\t3b c7                \tcmp    eax,edi\n186:   4236ae:\t73 0b                \tjae    0x4236bb\n187:   4236b0:\t68 60 1f 9e 00       \tpush   0x9e1f60\n188:   4236b5:\tff 15 54 d1 9d 00    \tcall   DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd154\n189:   4236bb:\t8b 75 0c             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n190:   4236be:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n191:   4236c0:\t3b c6                \tcmp    eax,esi\n192:   4236c2:\t73 02                \tjae    0x4236c6\n193:   4236c4:\t8b f0                \tmov    esi,eax\n194:   4236c6:\t8b 5d 14             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x14]\n195:   4236c9:\t8b d6                \tmov    edx,esi\n196:   4236cb:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n197:   4236cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x4236d1\n198:   4236cf:\t8b d3                \tmov    edx,ebx\n199:   4236d1:\t83 79 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0x10\n200:   4236d5:\t72 04                \tjb     0x4236db\n201:   4236d7:\t8b 01                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n202:   4236d9:\teb 02                \tjmp    0x4236dd\n203:   4236db:\t8b c1                \tmov    eax,ecx\n204:   4236dd:\t8b 4d 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n205:   4236e0:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n206:   4236e1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n207:   4236e2:\t03 c7                \tadd    eax,edi\n208:   4236e4:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n209:   4236e5:\te8 36 f0 ff ff       \tcall   0x422720\n210:   4236ea:\t83 c4 0c             \tadd    esp,0xc\n211:   4236ed:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n212:   4236ef:\t75 15                \tjne    0x423706\n213:   4236f1:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n214:   4236f3:\t73 0a                \tjae    0x4236ff\n215:   4236f5:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n216:   4236f6:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n217:   4236f7:\t83 c8 ff             \tor     eax,0xffffffff\n218:   4236fa:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n219:   4236fb:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n220:   4236fc:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n221:   4236ff:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n222:   423701:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n223:   423703:\t0f 95 c0             \tsetne  al\n224:   423706:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n225:   423707:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n226:   423708:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n227:   423709:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n228:   42370a:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n229: \n230: # $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe\n231: \n232: dumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n233: \n234: \n235: Disassembly of section .text:\n236: \n237: 00422720 <.text+0x21720>:\n238:   422720:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n239:   422721:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n240:   422723:\t8b 4d 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n241:   422726:\t8b 55 08             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n242:   422729:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n243:   42272a:\t8b 75 10             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n244:   42272d:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n245:   42272e:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n246:   422731:\t72 14                \tjb     0x422747\n247:   422733:\t8b 02                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n248:   422735:\t3b 01                \tcmp    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n249:   422737:\t75 12                \tjne    0x42274b\n250:   422739:\t83 ee 04             \tsub    esi,0x4\n251:   42273c:\t83 c1 04             \tadd    ecx,0x4\n252:   42273f:\t83 c2 04             \tadd    edx,0x4\n253:   422742:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n254:   422745:\t73 ec                \tjae    0x422733\n255:   422747:\t85 f6                \ttest   esi,esi\n256:   422749:\t74 45                \tje     0x422790\n257:   42274b:\t0f b6 02             \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx]\n258:   42274e:\t0f b6 39             \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx]\n259:   422751:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n260:   422753:\t75 31                \tjne    0x422786\n261:   422755:\t83 fe 01             \tcmp    esi,0x1\n262:   422758:\t76 36                \tjbe    0x422790\n263:   42275a:\t0f b6 42 01          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x1]\n264:   42275e:\t0f b6 79 01          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x1]\n265:   422762:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n266:   422764:\t75 20                \tjne    0x422786\n267:   422766:\t83 fe 02             \tcmp    esi,0x2\n268:   422769:\t76 25                \tjbe    0x422790\n269:   42276b:\t0f b6 42 02          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x2]\n270:   42276f:\t0f b6 79 02          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x2]\n271:   422773:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n272:   422775:\t75 0f                \tjne    0x422786\n273:   422777:\t83 fe 03             \tcmp    esi,0x3\n274:   42277a:\t76 14                \tjbe    0x422790\n275:   42277c:\t0f b6 42 03          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x3]\n276:   422780:\t0f b6 49 03          \tmovzx  ecx,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x3]\n277:   422784:\t2b c1                \tsub    eax,ecx\n278:   422786:\tc1 f8 1f             \tsar    eax,0x1f\n279:   422789:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n280:   42278a:\t83 c8 01             \tor     eax,0x1\n281:   42278d:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n282:   42278e:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n283:   42278f:\tc3                   \tret\n284:   422790:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n285:   422791:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n286:   422793:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n287:   422794:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n288:   422795:\tc3                   \tret\n\n(End of file - total 288 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n# SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n# Tool: GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38, Intel syntax.\n# Every command below exited 0. Output is unfiltered.\n#\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00825d40 <.text+0x424d40>:\n  825d40:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  825d41:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  825d43:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825d44:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  825d45:\t8b 5d 08             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d48:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  825d49:\t33 f6                \txor    esi,esi","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt","text":"# Read-only local capture. Input: dumps/sots.exe\n# SHA-256: 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841\n# Tool: GNU objdump (GNU Binutils for Ubuntu) 2.38, Intel syntax.\n# Every command below exited 0. Output is unfiltered.\n#\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00825d40 <.text+0x424d40>:\n  825d40:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  825d41:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  825d43:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825d44:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  825d45:\t8b 5d 08             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d48:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  825d49:\t33 f6                \txor    esi,esi\n  825d4b:\t3b de                \tcmp    ebx,esi\n  825d4d:\t75 0a                \tjne    0x825d59\n  825d4f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825d50:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  825d52:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825d53:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825d55:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825d56:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n  825d59:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n  825d5c:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825d5f:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n  825d64:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n  825d66:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n  825d68:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n  825d6b:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n  825d6d:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n  825d70:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n  825d72:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  825d73:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n  825d76:\t0f 84 d5 00 00 00    \tje     0x825e51\n  825d7c:\t8b 7d 0c             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  825d7f:\t89 75 08             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],esi\n  825d82:\t8b 73 08             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825d85:\t03 75 08             \tadd    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  825d88:\t8b 4e 6c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x6c]\n  825d8b:\t3b 4f 6c             \tcmp    ecx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x6c]\n  825d8e:\t0f 85 91 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n  825d94:\t8b 56 40             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [esi+0x40]\n  825d97:\t3b 57 40             \tcmp    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x40]\n  825d9a:\t0f 85 85 00 00 00    \tjne    0x825e25\n  825da0:\td9 46 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x44]\n  825da3:\td9 47 44             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x44]\n  825da6:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n  825da8:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825daa:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dad:\t7a 76                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825daf:\td9 46 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x48]\n  825db2:\td9 47 48             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x48]\n  825db5:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n  825db7:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825db9:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dbc:\t7a 67                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825dbe:\td9 46 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [esi+0x4c]\n  825dc1:\td9 47 4c             \tfld    DWORD PTR [edi+0x4c]\n  825dc4:\tda e9                \tfucompp\n  825dc6:\tdf e0                \tfnstsw ax\n  825dc8:\tf6 c4 44             \ttest   ah,0x44\n  825dcb:\t7a 58                \tjp     0x825e25\n  825dcd:\t83 7f 38 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x38],0x10\n  825dd1:\t8b 57 34             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x34]\n  825dd4:\t8d 47 24             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x24]\n  825dd7:\t8d 4e 24             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x24]\n  825dda:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825dde\n  825ddc:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  825dde:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825ddf:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825de0:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  825de3:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825de4:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  825de6:\te8 b5 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  825deb:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  825ded:\t75 36                \tjne    0x825e25\n  825def:\t83 7f 64 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [edi+0x64],0x10\n  825df3:\t8b 57 60             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [edi+0x60]\n  825df6:\t8d 47 50             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x50]\n  825df9:\t8d 4e 50             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x50]\n  825dfc:\t72 02                \tjb     0x825e00\n  825dfe:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  825e00:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825e01:\t8b 51 10             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  825e04:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825e05:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  825e06:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  825e08:\te8 93 d8 bf ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  825e0d:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  825e0f:\t75 14                \tjne    0x825e25\n  825e11:\t8d 47 08             \tlea    eax,[edi+0x8]\n  825e14:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  825e15:\t8d 4e 08             \tlea    ecx,[esi+0x8]\n  825e18:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  825e19:\te8 a2 9a c4 ff       \tcall   0x46f8c0\n  825e1e:\t83 c4 08             \tadd    esp,0x8\n  825e21:\t84 c0                \ttest   al,al\n  825e23:\t74 37                \tje     0x825e5c\n  825e25:\t8b 4b 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0xc]\n  825e28:\t2b 4b 08             \tsub    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebx+0x8]\n  825e2b:\t8b 75 fc             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4]\n  825e2e:\t83 45 08 74          \tadd    DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8],0x74\n  825e32:\tb8 09 cb 3d 8d       \tmov    eax,0x8d3dcb09\n  825e37:\tf7 e9                \timul   ecx\n  825e39:\t03 d1                \tadd    edx,ecx\n  825e3b:\tc1 fa 06             \tsar    edx,0x6\n  825e3e:\t8b c2                \tmov    eax,edx\n  825e40:\tc1 e8 1f             \tshr    eax,0x1f\n  825e43:\t46                   \tinc    esi\n  825e44:\t03 c2                \tadd    eax,edx\n  825e46:\t89 75 fc             \tmov    DWORD PTR [ebp-0x4],esi\n  825e49:\t3b f0                \tcmp    esi,eax\n  825e4b:\t0f 82 31 ff ff ff    \tjb     0x825d82\n  825e51:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  825e52:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825e53:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  825e55:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825e56:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825e58:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825e59:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n  825e5c:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  825e5d:\t8b c6                \tmov    eax,esi\n  825e5f:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  825e60:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  825e61:\t8b e5                \tmov    esp,ebp\n  825e63:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  825e64:\tc2 08 00             \tret    0x8\n\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x0046f8c0 --stop-address=0x0046f8f0 dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n0046f8c0 <.text+0x6e8c0>:\n  46f8c0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  46f8c1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  46f8c3:\t8b 45 0c             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  46f8c6:\t83 78 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [eax+0x14],0x10\n  46f8ca:\t8b 48 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [eax+0x10]\n  46f8cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x46f8d1\n  46f8cf:\t8b 00                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [eax]\n  46f8d1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  46f8d2:\t8b 4d 08             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  46f8d5:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  46f8d6:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  46f8d9:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  46f8da:\t6a 00                \tpush   0x0\n  46f8dc:\te8 bf 3d fb ff       \tcall   0x4236a0\n  46f8e1:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n  46f8e3:\t1b c0                \tsbb    eax,eax\n  46f8e5:\tf7 d8                \tneg    eax\n  46f8e7:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  46f8e8:\tc3                   \tret\n  46f8e9:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ea:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8eb:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ec:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ed:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ee:\tcc                   \tint3\n  46f8ef:\tcc                   \tint3\n\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x004236a0 --stop-address=0x0042370d dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n004236a0 <.text+0x226a0>:\n  4236a0:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  4236a1:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  4236a3:\t8b 41 10             \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx+0x10]\n  4236a6:\t53                   \tpush   ebx\n  4236a7:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  4236a8:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  4236a9:\t8b 7d 08             \tmov    edi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  4236ac:\t3b c7                \tcmp    eax,edi\n  4236ae:\t73 0b                \tjae    0x4236bb\n  4236b0:\t68 60 1f 9e 00       \tpush   0x9e1f60\n  4236b5:\tff 15 54 d1 9d 00    \tcall   DWORD PTR ds:0x9dd154\n  4236bb:\t8b 75 0c             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  4236be:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  4236c0:\t3b c6                \tcmp    eax,esi\n  4236c2:\t73 02                \tjae    0x4236c6\n  4236c4:\t8b f0                \tmov    esi,eax\n  4236c6:\t8b 5d 14             \tmov    ebx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x14]\n  4236c9:\t8b d6                \tmov    edx,esi\n  4236cb:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  4236cd:\t72 02                \tjb     0x4236d1\n  4236cf:\t8b d3                \tmov    edx,ebx\n  4236d1:\t83 79 14 10          \tcmp    DWORD PTR [ecx+0x14],0x10\n  4236d5:\t72 04                \tjb     0x4236db\n  4236d7:\t8b 01                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n  4236d9:\teb 02                \tjmp    0x4236dd\n  4236db:\t8b c1                \tmov    eax,ecx\n  4236dd:\t8b 4d 10             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  4236e0:\t52                   \tpush   edx\n  4236e1:\t51                   \tpush   ecx\n  4236e2:\t03 c7                \tadd    eax,edi\n  4236e4:\t50                   \tpush   eax\n  4236e5:\te8 36 f0 ff ff       \tcall   0x422720\n  4236ea:\t83 c4 0c             \tadd    esp,0xc\n  4236ed:\t85 c0                \ttest   eax,eax\n  4236ef:\t75 15                \tjne    0x423706\n  4236f1:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  4236f3:\t73 0a                \tjae    0x4236ff\n  4236f5:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  4236f6:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  4236f7:\t83 c8 ff             \tor     eax,0xffffffff\n  4236fa:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  4236fb:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  4236fc:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n  4236ff:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  423701:\t3b f3                \tcmp    esi,ebx\n  423703:\t0f 95 c0             \tsetne  al\n  423706:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  423707:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  423708:\t5b                   \tpop    ebx\n  423709:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  42370a:\tc2 10 00             \tret    0x10\n\n# $ objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00422720 --stop-address=0x00422796 dumps/sots.exe\n\ndumps/sots.exe:     file format pei-i386\n\n\nDisassembly of section .text:\n\n00422720 <.text+0x21720>:\n  422720:\t55                   \tpush   ebp\n  422721:\t8b ec                \tmov    ebp,esp\n  422723:\t8b 4d 0c             \tmov    ecx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0xc]\n  422726:\t8b 55 08             \tmov    edx,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x8]\n  422729:\t56                   \tpush   esi\n  42272a:\t8b 75 10             \tmov    esi,DWORD PTR [ebp+0x10]\n  42272d:\t57                   \tpush   edi\n  42272e:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n  422731:\t72 14                \tjb     0x422747\n  422733:\t8b 02                \tmov    eax,DWORD PTR [edx]\n  422735:\t3b 01                \tcmp    eax,DWORD PTR [ecx]\n  422737:\t75 12                \tjne    0x42274b\n  422739:\t83 ee 04             \tsub    esi,0x4\n  42273c:\t83 c1 04             \tadd    ecx,0x4\n  42273f:\t83 c2 04             \tadd    edx,0x4\n  422742:\t83 fe 04             \tcmp    esi,0x4\n  422745:\t73 ec                \tjae    0x422733\n  422747:\t85 f6                \ttest   esi,esi\n  422749:\t74 45                \tje     0x422790\n  42274b:\t0f b6 02             \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx]\n  42274e:\t0f b6 39             \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx]\n  422751:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422753:\t75 31                \tjne    0x422786\n  422755:\t83 fe 01             \tcmp    esi,0x1\n  422758:\t76 36                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42275a:\t0f b6 42 01          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x1]\n  42275e:\t0f b6 79 01          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x1]\n  422762:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422764:\t75 20                \tjne    0x422786\n  422766:\t83 fe 02             \tcmp    esi,0x2\n  422769:\t76 25                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42276b:\t0f b6 42 02          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x2]\n  42276f:\t0f b6 79 02          \tmovzx  edi,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x2]\n  422773:\t2b c7                \tsub    eax,edi\n  422775:\t75 0f                \tjne    0x422786\n  422777:\t83 fe 03             \tcmp    esi,0x3\n  42277a:\t76 14                \tjbe    0x422790\n  42277c:\t0f b6 42 03          \tmovzx  eax,BYTE PTR [edx+0x3]\n  422780:\t0f b6 49 03          \tmovzx  ecx,BYTE PTR [ecx+0x3]\n  422784:\t2b c1                \tsub    eax,ecx\n  422786:\tc1 f8 1f             \tsar    eax,0x1f\n  422789:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  42278a:\t83 c8 01             \tor     eax,0x1\n  42278d:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  42278e:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  42278f:\tc3                   \tret\n  422790:\t5f                   \tpop    edi\n  422791:\t33 c0                \txor    eax,eax\n  422793:\t5e                   \tpop    esi\n  422794:\t5d                   \tpop    ebp\n  422795:\tc3                   \tret","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":288,"totalLines":288,"truncated":false}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt","time":{"start":1788999751185,"end":1788999751215}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_033341ee6d4f9813016aa1f847007487d19beeda8cfb523510"}},"id":"prt_088b1d60d001KoI1oPJIKYoDEK","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999751220,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_K9Ff1o153dtCErXAiadSRFDv","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Independent ABI verification plan\n2: \n3: Session `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\n4: requested model `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n5: \n6: This plan was fixed before running the independent objdump reproductions. The object is the\n7: owner-supplied `dumps/sots.exe` whose required SHA-256 is\n8: `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`.\n9: \n10: ## Falsifiers\n11: \n12: 1. Stop if the executable hash, GNU objdump identity, paired baseline HEAD/common-directory, or\n13:    source-binding differs from the handoff.\n14: 2. Reject the dedup interpretation if complete independent windows do not show: both description\n15:    string addresses passed to `0x0046f8c0`; caller cleanup; helper result tested; zero selecting the\n16:    match return; and the helper/callees implementing byte-and-length inequality with independent\n17:    inline/heap selection at capacity `0x10`.\n18: 3. Reject an ownership claim if append/growth paths use raw element-header transfer, if the\n19:    `0x2c` and `0x74` strides collapse to one shape, if long-string destruction does not call the\n20:    recorded delete thunk, or if old elements are not destroyed/freed after deep copy.\n21: 4. Reject archived record-value claims if an independent parser does not recover the stated event\n22:    IDs, nested turn buckets, strings, action/location, and exact `0x7f7fffff` position words from\n23:    the named save.\n24: 5. Reject acceptance on zero instruction output, nonzero command exit, missing requested address\n25:    ranges, unexpected skips, hash mismatch, or reliance on counters without inspecting bytes/state.\n26: \n27: ## Required branch exposures and distinct states\n28: \n29: Static instruction exposures required in this quantum: dedup null/empty return, scalar mismatch\n30: continuation, description equal match, description unequal continuation, short/long selection for\n31: both operands, byte mismatch, length mismatch, and equal return; ObservedTech spare/full append and\n32: deep copy; PlayerEvent spare/full append, three-string copy, and long cleanup; TurnEvents hit/miss,\n33: outer spare/full growth, nested empty/nonempty copy, and destruction; prune zero/one/two leading\n34: stale plus stale-after-fresh control flow.\n35: \n36: Distinct semantic states to keep separate: empty/short/long descriptions; equal versus\n37: description-only-different events; new versus existing tech name; spare versus full capacity;\n38: empty versus nonempty nested vectors; duplicate versus no duplicate; zero/one/two leading stale\n39: buckets; stale-after-fresh; duplicate turn buckets versus miss. Static branch exposure is not live\n40: execution of these states.\n41: \n42: ## Independent challenge\n43: \n44: Held-out negative control: inspect unordered/NaN position behavior in the dedup comparator, which\n45: the handoff summarizes as finite-position fixtures. Prediction from x87 `fucompp` plus\n46: `test ah,0x44; jp mismatch`: otherwise-identical records containing NaN in any compared coordinate\n47: must not deduplicate, including two records carrying the same NaN payload. This challenges any\n48: implicit whole-bit-equality interpretation without using a live allocator.\n49: \n50: Scope labels will remain separate: this quantum can establish an **independent static\n51: reproduction** and an **archived-save value cross-check**. It is not original-assisted runtime\n52: execution, full live compare, independent replacement, or integrated replay, and makes no live\n53: allocator-safety or replacement-acceptance claim.\n\n(End of file - total 53 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Independent ABI verification plan\n\nSession `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\nrequested model `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n\nThis plan was fixed before running the independent objdump reproductions. The object is the\nowner-supplied `dumps/sots.exe` whose required SHA-256 is\n`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`.\n\n## Falsifiers\n\n1. Stop if the executable hash, GNU objdump identity, paired baseline HEAD/common-directory, or\n   source-binding differs from the handoff.\n2. Reject the dedup interpretation if complete independent windows do not show: both description\n   string addresses passed to `0x0046f8c0`; caller cleanup; helper result tested; zero selecting the\n   match return; and the helper/callees implementing byte-and-length inequality with independent\n   inline/heap selection at capacity `0x10`.\n3. Reject an ownership claim if append/growth paths use raw element-header transfer, if the\n   `0x2c` and `0x74` strides collapse to one shape, if long-string destruction does not call the\n   recorded delete thunk, or if old elements are not destroyed/freed after deep copy.","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md","text":"# Independent ABI verification plan\n\nSession `run-6c7a726f5a2849ef0407876f`; verifier `research-abi-independent`;\nrequested model `openai/gpt-5.6-sol`.\n\nThis plan was fixed before running the independent objdump reproductions. The object is the\nowner-supplied `dumps/sots.exe` whose required SHA-256 is\n`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`.\n\n## Falsifiers\n\n1. Stop if the executable hash, GNU objdump identity, paired baseline HEAD/common-directory, or\n   source-binding differs from the handoff.\n2. Reject the dedup interpretation if complete independent windows do not show: both description\n   string addresses passed to `0x0046f8c0`; caller cleanup; helper result tested; zero selecting the\n   match return; and the helper/callees implementing byte-and-length inequality with independent\n   inline/heap selection at capacity `0x10`.\n3. Reject an ownership claim if append/growth paths use raw element-header transfer, if the\n   `0x2c` and `0x74` strides collapse to one shape, if long-string destruction does not call the\n   recorded delete thunk, or if old elements are not destroyed/freed after deep copy.\n4. Reject archived record-value claims if an independent parser does not recover the stated event\n   IDs, nested turn buckets, strings, action/location, and exact `0x7f7fffff` position words from\n   the named save.\n5. Reject acceptance on zero instruction output, nonzero command exit, missing requested address\n   ranges, unexpected skips, hash mismatch, or reliance on counters without inspecting bytes/state.\n\n## Required branch exposures and distinct states\n\nStatic instruction exposures required in this quantum: dedup null/empty return, scalar mismatch\ncontinuation, description equal match, description unequal continuation, short/long selection for\nboth operands, byte mismatch, length mismatch, and equal return; ObservedTech spare/full append and\ndeep copy; PlayerEvent spare/full append, three-string copy, and long cleanup; TurnEvents hit/miss,\nouter spare/full growth, nested empty/nonempty copy, and destruction; prune zero/one/two leading\nstale plus stale-after-fresh control flow.\n\nDistinct semantic states to keep separate: empty/short/long descriptions; equal versus\ndescription-only-different events; new versus existing tech name; spare versus full capacity;\nempty versus nonempty nested vectors; duplicate versus no duplicate; zero/one/two leading stale\nbuckets; stale-after-fresh; duplicate turn buckets versus miss. Static branch exposure is not live\nexecution of these states.\n\n## Independent challenge\n\nHeld-out negative control: inspect unordered/NaN position behavior in the dedup comparator, which\nthe handoff summarizes as finite-position fixtures. Prediction from x87 `fucompp` plus\n`test ah,0x44; jp mismatch`: otherwise-identical records containing NaN in any compared coordinate\nmust not deduplicate, including two records carrying the same NaN payload. This challenges any\nimplicit whole-bit-equality interpretation without using a live allocator.\n\nScope labels will remain separate: this quantum can establish an **independent static\nreproduction** and an **archived-save value cross-check**. It is not original-assisted runtime\nexecution, full live compare, independent replacement, or integrated replay, and makes no live\nallocator-safety or replacement-acceptance claim.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":53,"totalLines":53,"truncated":false}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md","time":{"start":1788999751202,"end":1788999751218}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_033341ee6d4f9813016aa1f847009087d1a98cc49bebdfb2cc"}},"id":"prt_088b1d61d001tbzV6Xzk6NpGzL","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999751234,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"grep","callID":"call_sZ7DDRs5I3oRUbyeX6NTFBna","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"pattern":"def .*resolve|invalidated|add_parser\\(\"resolve|--explanation","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py"},"output":"Found 8 matches\n/home/alex/sots-re/tools/vtable_map.py:\n  Line 679: def resolve_site(code, fva, ins, kinds, wr, tgts, n, k, carrier=()):\n\n  Line 930: def resolve_all(d, vfts):\n\n\n/home/alex/sots-re/tools/check_agent_config.py:\n  Line 15: def check(root: Path, resolved: bool = False) -> list[str]:\n\n\n/home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py:\n  Line 499:     def resolve(self, sid, actor, role, model, explanation, probe):\n\n  Line 511:                         \"invalidated_evidence\": c.get(\"evidence\", []), \"invalidated_checkpoint\": c[\"checkpoint\"]}\n\n  Line 520:                 verdict[\"verdict\"] = \"invalidated\"\n\n  Line 578:     s = identified(\"resolve\"); s.add_argument(\"surprise\"); s.add_argument(\"--explanation\", required=True); s.add_argument(\"--probe\", required=True)\n\n  Line 581:     s.add_argument(\"--verdict\", required=True, choices=[\"pass\", \"fail\"]); s.add_argument(\"--explanation\", required=True)\n","metadata":{"matches":8,"truncated":false},"title":"def .*resolve|invalidated|add_parser\\(\"resolve|--explanation","time":{"start":1788999751196,"end":1788999751223}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_033341ee6d4f9813016aa1f847008887d1a6e41d9aff02c342"}},"id":"prt_088b1d618001aDkQssHS3FaJaG","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999751250,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_PSlwHoI8UlLYSlQkCOMhsIX7","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"git -C /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine rev-parse HEAD --git-common-dir"},"output":"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\n/home/alex/sots-engine/.git\n","metadata":{"output":"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\n/home/alex/sots-engine/.git\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"git -C /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine rev-parse HEAD --git-common-dir","time":{"start":1788999751152,"end":1788999751238}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_033341ee6d4f9813016aa1f847005487d1b0ba379bf2ac27ad"}},"id":"prt_088b1d5e1001QIdL7dBrkoxbat","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999751250,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_Eqjp3x4uniXOZ20DeWhvEPq5","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"git -C /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re rev-parse HEAD --git-common-dir"},"output":"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\n/home/alex/sots-re/.git\n","metadata":{"output":"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\n/home/alex/sots-re/.git\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"git -C /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re rev-parse HEAD --git-common-dir","time":{"start":1788999751173,"end":1788999751242}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_033341ee6d4f9813016aa1f847006887d1afa57eb409a7d4cc"}},"id":"prt_088b1d5f4001usOrIRk7q19wJW","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999751284,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b1d671001rGaQtUa8YfHKcJ","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"8cbf6c041058f0ee1d7761c2f15f61f15845609c","messageID":"msg_088b19c7e001FYQPLzfVGeo5vR","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":19531,"input":4529,"output":396,"reasoning":14,"cache":{"write":0,"read":14592}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999753474,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b1defe0011DI3yerzptE7Jc","messageID":"msg_088b1d69c001q15HRZsR9xCKJv","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"b4ac02990e926cb8ab726ca3d3b1b269524e7909","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999770370,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_SlLgIjo9Iz0rG7cvZUbvFnic","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint research-completion-abi --actor research-problem-resolver --role resolver --model openai/gpt-6-astra --session run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423 --summary 'Resolution-only recovery. Read canonical AGENTS, README, workflow, contract, latest verifier checkpoint, sole open surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f, verifier plan/result and raw dedup archive. Observation: archive declares stop 0x825e65 yet displays c2 08 00 at 0x825e64; verifier reports exact-command c2 and three other matching windows, positive zero-exit static commands, no runtime execution. Direct git identity checks: engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git; RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git. Historical bindings ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8 not freshly recomputed: source-binding command denied by resolver permission overlay. Binary SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 is verifier-reported, not independently hashed here. No experiment, source edit, delegation or lab access; no lease acquired or cleanup needed. Decision pending: invalidate exact-command provenance, authorize only bounded read-only repair by an authorized subsequent worker, retain affected interpretation/acceptance hold pending raw paired-boundary capture. No stale-build or game-mechanism diagnosis.' --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md --next-action 'Inspect resolve control semantics and dependent claims, then record a durable Astra repair-only decision for s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.'"},"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\",\n      \"sha256\": \"3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"1381c2e77b8c4a68c6809a23\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Inspect resolve control semantics and dependent claims, then record a durable Astra repair-only decision for s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423\",\n  \"summary\": \"Resolution-only recovery. Read canonical AGENTS, README, workflow, contract, latest verifier checkpoint, sole open surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f, verifier plan/result and raw dedup archive. Observation: archive declares stop 0x825e65 yet displays c2 08 00 at 0x825e64; verifier reports exact-command c2 and three other matching windows, positive zero-exit static commands, no runtime execution. Direct git identity checks: engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git; RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git. Historical bindings ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8 not freshly recomputed: source-binding command denied by resolver permission overlay. Binary SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 is verifier-reported, not independently hashed here. No experiment, source edit, delegation or lab access; no lease acquired or cleanup needed. Decision pending: invalidate exact-command provenance, authorize only bounded read-only repair by an authorized subsequent worker, retain affected interpretation/acceptance hold pending raw paired-boundary capture. No stale-build or game-mechanism diagnosis.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:22:50.344764+00:00\"\n}\n","metadata":{"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\",\n      \"sha256\": \"3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"1381c2e77b8c4a68c6809a23\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Inspect resolve control semantics and dependent claims, then record a durable Astra repair-only decision for s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423\",\n  \"summary\": \"Resolution-only recovery. Read canonical AGENTS, README, workflow, contract, latest verifier checkpoint, sole open surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f, verifier plan/result and raw dedup archive. Observation: archive declares stop 0x825e65 yet displays c2 08 00 at 0x825e64; verifier reports exact-command c2 and three other matching windows, positive zero-exit static commands, no runtime execution. Direct git identity checks: engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git; RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git. Historical bindings ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8 not freshly recomputed: source-binding command denied by resolver permission overlay. Binary SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 is verifier-reported, not independently hashed here. No experiment, source edit, delegation or lab access; no lease acquired or cleanup needed. Decision pending: invalidate exact-command provenance, authorize only bounded read-only repair by an authorized subsequent worker, retain affected interpretation/acceptance hold pending raw paired-boundary capture. No stale-build or game-mechanism diagnosis.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:22:50.344764+00:00\"\n}\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint research-completion-abi --actor research-problem-resolver --role resolver --model openai/gpt-6-astra --session run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423 --summary 'Resolution-only recovery. Read canonical AGENTS, README, workflow, contract, latest verifier checkpoint, sole open surprise s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f, verifier plan/result and raw dedup archive. Observation: archive declares stop 0x825e65 yet displays c2 08 00 at 0x825e64; verifier reports exact-command c2 and three other matching windows, positive zero-exit static commands, no runtime execution. Direct git identity checks: engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git; RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git. Historical bindings ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8 not freshly recomputed: source-binding command denied by resolver permission overlay. Binary SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 is verifier-reported, not independently hashed here. No experiment, source edit, delegation or lab access; no lease acquired or cleanup needed. Decision pending: invalidate exact-command provenance, authorize only bounded read-only repair by an authorized subsequent worker, retain affected interpretation/acceptance hold pending raw paired-boundary capture. No stale-build or game-mechanism diagnosis.' --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md --next-action 'Inspect resolve control semantics and dependent claims, then record a durable Astra repair-only decision for s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f.'","time":{"start":1788999770299,"end":1788999770368}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0af1c77f3ae08c00016aa1f849f28887d1a054c7e15648c5c7"}},"id":"prt_088b1e17a0015gojY9aDPWQqde","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b1d69c001q15HRZsR9xCKJv"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999770429,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b22138001Is7U44TOrD8hll","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"a1e89d05b82dfcbc0f78f92eb76283e27dc09510","messageID":"msg_088b1d69c001q15HRZsR9xCKJv","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":27591,"input":8087,"output":551,"reasoning":9,"cache":{"write":0,"read":18944}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999779444,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b2446f001sEexBH7lObhXTD","messageID":"msg_088b22164001hBtLov82169iuv","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"d44fedf06aa00a761403570c182cda22731758d5","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999779552,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_xQA7sDrTIcaRDQRncsgDWc3K","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py","offset":499,"limit":36},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n499:     def resolve(self, sid, actor, role, model, explanation, probe):\n500:         self.identity(actor, role, model)\n501:         if role not in {\"lead\", \"resolver\"} or not explanation.strip() or not probe.strip() or len(explanation) > 6000 or len(probe) > 2000:\n502:             raise ControlError(\"Astra lead/resolver explanation and discriminating probe required\")\n503:         with self.lock():\n504:             path = self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/surprises/{self.identifier(sid)}.json\")\n505:             s = read_json(path)\n506:             if s.get(\"status\") != \"open\":\n507:                 raise ControlError(\"surprise is not open\")\n508:             c = self.load(s[\"contract\"])\n509:             decision = {\"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\", \"id\": \"d-\" + secrets.token_hex(12), \"contract\": c[\"id\"], \"surprise\": sid,\n510:                         \"actor\": actor, \"role\": role, \"model\": model, \"timestamp\": now(), \"explanation\": explanation, \"probe\": probe,\n511:                         \"invalidated_evidence\": c.get(\"evidence\", []), \"invalidated_checkpoint\": c[\"checkpoint\"]}\n512:             atomic_json(self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/decisions/{decision['id']}.json\"), decision)\n513:             c[\"evidence\"] = []\n514:             c[\"checkpoint\"] = None\n515:             c[\"status\"] = \"blocked\"\n516:             self.save(c)\n517:             vpath = self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/verdicts/{c['id']}.json\")\n518:             if vpath.exists():\n519:                 verdict = read_json(vpath)\n520:                 verdict[\"verdict\"] = \"invalidated\"\n521:                 verdict[\"decision\"] = decision[\"id\"]\n522:                 atomic_json(vpath, verdict)\n523:             s.update(status=\"resolved\", decision=decision[\"id\"])\n524:             atomic_json(path, s)\n525:             if not self.open_surprises(c[\"id\"]):\n526:                 c[\"status\"] = \"needs-revision\"\n527:                 self.save(c)\n528:             return decision\n529: \n530:     def lease(self, action, resource, actor=None, token=None, lead_release=False, role=None, model=None, reason=None):\n531:         path = self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/leases/{self.identifier(resource)}.json\")\n532:         with self.lock():\n533:             current = read_json(path) if path.exists() else None\n534:             if current is not None and (not isinstance(current, dict) or current.get(\"schema\") != \"sots-lease/1\" or current.get(\"resource\") != resource or current.get(\"status\") not in {\"held\", \"released\"} or not current.get(\"owner\") or not current.get(\"token\")):\n\n(Showing lines 499-534 of 624. Use offset=535 to continue.)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"    def resolve(self, sid, actor, role, model, explanation, probe):\n        self.identity(actor, role, model)\n        if role not in {\"lead\", \"resolver\"} or not explanation.strip() or not probe.strip() or len(explanation) > 6000 or len(probe) > 2000:\n            raise ControlError(\"Astra lead/resolver explanation and discriminating probe required\")\n        with self.lock():\n            path = self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/surprises/{self.identifier(sid)}.json\")\n            s = read_json(path)\n            if s.get(\"status\") != \"open\":\n                raise ControlError(\"surprise is not open\")\n            c = self.load(s[\"contract\"])\n            decision = {\"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\", \"id\": \"d-\" + secrets.token_hex(12), \"contract\": c[\"id\"], \"surprise\": sid,\n                        \"actor\": actor, \"role\": role, \"model\": model, \"timestamp\": now(), \"explanation\": explanation, \"probe\": probe,\n                        \"invalidated_evidence\": c.get(\"evidence\", []), \"invalidated_checkpoint\": c[\"checkpoint\"]}\n            atomic_json(self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/decisions/{decision['id']}.json\"), decision)\n            c[\"evidence\"] = []\n            c[\"checkpoint\"] = None\n            c[\"status\"] = \"blocked\"\n            self.save(c)\n            vpath = self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/verdicts/{c['id']}.json\")\n            if vpath.exists():","truncated":true,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py","text":"    def resolve(self, sid, actor, role, model, explanation, probe):\n        self.identity(actor, role, model)\n        if role not in {\"lead\", \"resolver\"} or not explanation.strip() or not probe.strip() or len(explanation) > 6000 or len(probe) > 2000:\n            raise ControlError(\"Astra lead/resolver explanation and discriminating probe required\")\n        with self.lock():\n            path = self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/surprises/{self.identifier(sid)}.json\")\n            s = read_json(path)\n            if s.get(\"status\") != \"open\":\n                raise ControlError(\"surprise is not open\")\n            c = self.load(s[\"contract\"])\n            decision = {\"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\", \"id\": \"d-\" + secrets.token_hex(12), \"contract\": c[\"id\"], \"surprise\": sid,\n                        \"actor\": actor, \"role\": role, \"model\": model, \"timestamp\": now(), \"explanation\": explanation, \"probe\": probe,\n                        \"invalidated_evidence\": c.get(\"evidence\", []), \"invalidated_checkpoint\": c[\"checkpoint\"]}\n            atomic_json(self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/decisions/{decision['id']}.json\"), decision)\n            c[\"evidence\"] = []\n            c[\"checkpoint\"] = None\n            c[\"status\"] = \"blocked\"\n            self.save(c)\n            vpath = self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/verdicts/{c['id']}.json\")\n            if vpath.exists():\n                verdict = read_json(vpath)\n                verdict[\"verdict\"] = \"invalidated\"\n                verdict[\"decision\"] = decision[\"id\"]\n                atomic_json(vpath, verdict)\n            s.update(status=\"resolved\", decision=decision[\"id\"])\n            atomic_json(path, s)\n            if not self.open_surprises(c[\"id\"]):\n                c[\"status\"] = \"needs-revision\"\n                self.save(c)\n            return decision\n\n    def lease(self, action, resource, actor=None, token=None, lead_release=False, role=None, model=None, reason=None):\n        path = self.path(f\"campaign/runtime/leases/{self.identifier(resource)}.json\")\n        with self.lock():\n            current = read_json(path) if path.exists() else None\n            if current is not None and (not isinstance(current, dict) or current.get(\"schema\") != \"sots-lease/1\" or current.get(\"resource\") != resource or current.get(\"status\") not in {\"held\", \"released\"} or not current.get(\"owner\") or not current.get(\"token\")):","lineStart":499,"lineEnd":534,"totalLines":624,"truncated":true}},"title":"tools/campaign.py","time":{"start":1788999779499,"end":1788999779549}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_04db0bdfd0e6658b016aa1f863536087d1b750d391b71e4d22"}},"id":"prt_088b244720016kzXWivC6ZoQj4","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b22164001hBtLov82169iuv"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999779560,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"grep","callID":"call_6CyoOMGuWaKfHBaa8eHcdL1q","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"pattern":"research-completion-abi|dedup-helper","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts"},"output":"Found 3 matches\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json:\n  Line 24:   \"checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-1381c2e77b8c4a68c6809a23.json\",\n\n  Line 32:   \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n\n  Line 51:     \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n","metadata":{"matches":3,"truncated":false},"title":"research-completion-abi|dedup-helper","time":{"start":1788999779507,"end":1788999779555}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_04db0bdfd0e6658b016aa1f863537887d1a2c1acdacfd174e1"}},"id":"prt_088b244ad001b4ZK0gm8018C31","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b22164001hBtLov82169iuv"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999779560,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_UkqqWrTrqH8a8QAXLObLP0mi","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n3:   \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n4:   \"explanation\": \"Astra resolution-only decision, session run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5. Observation/provenance: archived verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt SHA256 f95bbd2674aaa074feb70ebb13ec4877b3ceef3d2aafe5810b8b0ec337cfbb8b lines 211-213 contains lea candidate+8, lea stored+8 and call 0x0046f8c0. It jumps directly from 0x00825e19 to 0x00825e2e in the selected excerpt: the disputed test/branch is NOT archived there. No helper body exists in the four-file ABI results package. Surprise says true AL matches; checkpoint 26d1c4fa6bd58b6a442e0241 and handoff say false. Neither polarity is independently established by this archive. This is an evidence-completeness/conflicting-interpretation problem, not measured game behavior or a stale-build mechanism. Identity: assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common dirs independently checked; both dirty inventories observed. Source-before manifests are in runtime/runs/run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5.json; no fresh content binding substituted for old measurements. Input SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and matching ReVa MD5 are recorded provenance only, not freshly rehashed here. Campaign checkpoint rehashed the raw excerpt and index successfully. No live positive execution, runtime binary/input binding, or hooks-off neutrality measurement exists in this review. Read-only archive inspection has no game-side instrument effect; runtime neutrality remains unproved. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS, exact domains: (1) SURVIVES: the archived x86 excerpt loads two +8 addresses and calls the named helper, and shows stride 0x74 and a matched-element return; static excerpt domain only. (2) QUALIFIED: events.md:182-185 claim that EvDsc is not compared; suspended as an implementable dedup rule, not conclusively falsified without helper semantics. (3) QUALIFIED: new handoff/index prediction t... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n5:   \"id\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n6:   \"invalidated_checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-fd414ea958fd39c18cee1964.json\",\n7:   \"invalidated_evidence\": [],\n8:   \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n9:   \"probe\": \"Cheapest discriminating action: lead schedule the ABI analyst to rehash dumps/sots.exe against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, bind paired source manifests, checkpoint, then archive UNFILTERED objdump output for 0x00825d40..0x00825e65 and helper 0x0046f8c0 through all returns (follow any callees), with raw bytes, exact command, tool identity and exit status. Recover push/ECX conventions, test/branch polarity and short/long string semantics; mismatch or missing bytes stops interpretation. This is read-only local static work, not permission to mutate VM/Ghidra. Independent verifier reproduces the complete windows. Only after semantics and ownership are pinned should an explicitly assigned leased lab experiment compare same-bucket events equal in action/location/finite position/message/image, first identical descriptions then description-only difference, including short/long strings. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence, full pre/post records and IDs, exact binary/input/source identities and neutral controls; helper/branch analysis predicts outcomes but is not runtime measurement.\",\n10:   \"role\": \"resolver\",\n11:   \"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\",\n12:   \"surprise\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n13:   \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:52:51.024636+00:00\"\n14: }\n\n(End of file - total 14 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"explanation\": \"Astra resolution-only decision, session run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5. Observation/provenance: archived verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt SHA256 f95bbd2674aaa074feb70ebb13ec4877b3ceef3d2aafe5810b8b0ec337cfbb8b lines 211-213 contains lea candidate+8, lea stored+8 and call 0x0046f8c0. It jumps directly from 0x00825e19 to 0x00825e2e in the selected excerpt: the disputed test/branch is NOT archived there. No helper body exists in the four-file ABI results package. Surprise says true AL matches; checkpoint 26d1c4fa6bd58b6a442e0241 and handoff say false. Neither polarity is independently established by this archive. This is an evidence-completeness/conflicting-interpretation problem, not measured game behavior or a stale-build mechanism. Identity: assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common dirs independently checked; both dirty inventories observed. Source-before manifests are in runtime/runs/run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5.json; no fresh content binding substituted for old measurements. Input SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and matching ReVa MD5 are recorded provenance only, not freshly rehashed here. Campaign checkpoint rehashed the raw excerpt and index successfully. No live positive execution, runtime binary/input binding, or hooks-off neutrality measurement exists in this review. Read-only archive inspection has no game-side instrument effect; runtime neutrality remains unproved. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS, exact domains: (1) SURVIVES: the archived x86 excerpt loads two +8 addresses and calls the named helper, and shows stride 0x74 and a matched-element return; static excerpt domain only. (2) QUALIFIED: events.md:182-185 claim that EvDsc is not compared; suspended as an implementable dedup rule, not conclusively falsified without helper semantics. (3) QUALIFIED: new handoff/index prediction t... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n  \"id\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n  \"invalidated_checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-fd414ea958fd39c18cee1964.json\",\n  \"invalidated_evidence\": [],\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Cheapest discriminating action: lead schedule the ABI analyst to rehash dumps/sots.exe against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, bind paired source manifests, checkpoint, then archive UNFILTERED objdump output for 0x00825d40..0x00825e65 and helper 0x0046f8c0 through all returns (follow any callees), with raw bytes, exact command, tool identity and exit status. Recover push/ECX conventions, test/branch polarity and short/long string semantics; mismatch or missing bytes stops interpretation. This is read-only local static work, not permission to mutate VM/Ghidra. Independent verifier reproduces the complete windows. Only after semantics and ownership are pinned should an explicitly assigned leased lab experiment compare same-bucket events equal in action/location/finite position/message/image, first identical descriptions then description-only difference, including short/long strings. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence, full pre/post records and IDs, exact binary/input/source identities and neutral controls; helper/branch analysis predicts outcomes but is not runtime measurement.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\",\n  \"surprise\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:52:51.024636+00:00\"\n}","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json","text":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"explanation\": \"Astra resolution-only decision, session run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5. Observation/provenance: archived verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt SHA256 f95bbd2674aaa074feb70ebb13ec4877b3ceef3d2aafe5810b8b0ec337cfbb8b lines 211-213 contains lea candidate+8, lea stored+8 and call 0x0046f8c0. It jumps directly from 0x00825e19 to 0x00825e2e in the selected excerpt: the disputed test/branch is NOT archived there. No helper body exists in the four-file ABI results package. Surprise says true AL matches; checkpoint 26d1c4fa6bd58b6a442e0241 and handoff say false. Neither polarity is independently established by this archive. This is an evidence-completeness/conflicting-interpretation problem, not measured game behavior or a stale-build mechanism. Identity: assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common dirs independently checked; both dirty inventories observed. Source-before manifests are in runtime/runs/run-b9c736bb16b1c5ea8f4a96a5.json; no fresh content binding substituted for old measurements. Input SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and matching ReVa MD5 are recorded provenance only, not freshly rehashed here. Campaign checkpoint rehashed the raw excerpt and index successfully. No live positive execution, runtime binary/input binding, or hooks-off neutrality measurement exists in this review. Read-only archive inspection has no game-side instrument effect; runtime neutrality remains unproved. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS, exact domains: (1) SURVIVES: the archived x86 excerpt loads two +8 addresses and calls the named helper, and shows stride 0x74 and a matched-element return; static excerpt domain only. (2) QUALIFIED: events.md:182-185 claim that EvDsc is not compared; suspended as an implementable dedup rule, not conclusively falsified without helper semantics. (3) QUALIFIED: new handoff/index prediction t... (line truncated to 2000 chars)\n  \"id\": \"d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924\",\n  \"invalidated_checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-fd414ea958fd39c18cee1964.json\",\n  \"invalidated_evidence\": [],\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Cheapest discriminating action: lead schedule the ABI analyst to rehash dumps/sots.exe against SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, bind paired source manifests, checkpoint, then archive UNFILTERED objdump output for 0x00825d40..0x00825e65 and helper 0x0046f8c0 through all returns (follow any callees), with raw bytes, exact command, tool identity and exit status. Recover push/ECX conventions, test/branch polarity and short/long string semantics; mismatch or missing bytes stops interpretation. This is read-only local static work, not permission to mutate VM/Ghidra. Independent verifier reproduces the complete windows. Only after semantics and ownership are pinned should an explicitly assigned leased lab experiment compare same-bucket events equal in action/location/finite position/message/image, first identical descriptions then description-only difference, including short/long strings. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence, full pre/post records and IDs, exact binary/input/source identities and neutral controls; helper/branch analysis predicts outcomes but is not runtime measurement.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\",\n  \"surprise\": \"s-8996365dab2cd6dc0e17bb9f\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-09T23:52:51.024636+00:00\"\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":14,"totalLines":14,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/runtime/decisions/d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924.json","time":{"start":1788999779513,"end":1788999779558}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_04db0bdfd0e6658b016aa1f863538487d1baf0cdb7af6f7209"}},"id":"prt_088b244b5001H68ECjQRkY3jhF","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b22164001hBtLov82169iuv"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999779582,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_1lERcc5lnw9yagGpljuX4ufO","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"git -C /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine status --short"},"output":" M CONTRIBUTING.md\n M README.md\n M docs/S-standalone.md\n M src/app/turn.cpp\n M src/game/sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.cpp\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.h\n M tests/app/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/app/test_command_replay.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn_record.cpp\n M tests/game_config/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_data/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/test_census_saves.cpp\n M tests/game_sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/test_domains.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_rng.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_save.cpp\n M tests/mars_text/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_vfs/CMakeLists.txt\n M tools/clean_room_check.sh\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? docs/architecture.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/clean_room_check.py\n","metadata":{"output":" M CONTRIBUTING.md\n M README.md\n M docs/S-standalone.md\n M src/app/turn.cpp\n M src/game/sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.cpp\n M src/mars/rng/mt19937.h\n M tests/app/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/app/test_command_replay.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn.cpp\n M tests/app/test_turn_record.cpp\n M tests/game_config/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_data/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/game_design/test_census_saves.cpp\n M tests/game_sim/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_stream/test_domains.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_rng.cpp\n M tests/mars_stream/test_save.cpp\n M tests/mars_text/CMakeLists.txt\n M tests/mars_vfs/CMakeLists.txt\n M tools/clean_room_check.sh\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? docs/architecture.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/clean_room_check.py\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"git -C /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-engine status --short","time":{"start":1788999779520,"end":1788999779564}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_04db0bdfd0e6658b016aa1f863538c87d19670b1da027a548e"}},"id":"prt_088b244bb001BZzVh9A1FeGKqN","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b22164001hBtLov82169iuv"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999779582,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_QrnbLTrZuClfJjgTlVHZUw6U","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"git -C /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re status --short"},"output":" M README.md\n M campaign/DASHBOARD.md\n M campaign/backlog.md\n M campaign/board.md\n M campaign/open-questions.md\n M findings/00-strategy.md\n M findings/subsystems/nav-classifier-live.md\n M findings/subsystems/research-replace.md\n M guides/method-rules.md\n D scripts/forgejo_campaign.py\n M tools/DASHBOARD_README.md\n M tools/dashboard.py\n D tools/displacement.py\n M tools/gate.sh\n M tools/standalone_report.py\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? campaign/README.md\n?? campaign/agents/\n?? campaign/contract.schema.json\n?? campaign/contracts/\n?? campaign/current.json\n?? campaign/models.json\n?? campaign/pilots/\n?? campaign/research/\n?? campaign/rollout/\n?? guides/multi-agent-workflow.md\n?? guides/windows-lab-housekeeping.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/campaign.py\n?? tools/check_agent_config.py\n?? tools/evidence.py\n?? tools/gate.py\n?? tools/run_agent.py\n?? tools/select_evidence.py\n?? tools/windows-housekeeping/\n?? verify/campaign/\n?? verify/config/\n?? verify/publishing/\n?? verify/results/housekeeping/\n?? verify/tooling/\n","metadata":{"output":" M README.md\n M campaign/DASHBOARD.md\n M campaign/backlog.md\n M campaign/board.md\n M campaign/open-questions.md\n M findings/00-strategy.md\n M findings/subsystems/nav-classifier-live.md\n M findings/subsystems/research-replace.md\n M guides/method-rules.md\n D scripts/forgejo_campaign.py\n M tools/DASHBOARD_README.md\n M tools/dashboard.py\n D tools/displacement.py\n M tools/gate.sh\n M tools/standalone_report.py\n?? AGENTS.md\n?? CLAUDE.md\n?? campaign/README.md\n?? campaign/agents/\n?? campaign/contract.schema.json\n?? campaign/contracts/\n?? campaign/current.json\n?? campaign/models.json\n?? campaign/pilots/\n?? campaign/research/\n?? campaign/rollout/\n?? guides/multi-agent-workflow.md\n?? guides/windows-lab-housekeeping.md\n?? opencode.json\n?? tools/campaign.py\n?? tools/check_agent_config.py\n?? tools/evidence.py\n?? tools/gate.py\n?? tools/run_agent.py\n?? tools/select_evidence.py\n?? tools/windows-housekeeping/\n?? verify/campaign/\n?? verify/config/\n?? verify/publishing/\n?? verify/results/housekeeping/\n?? verify/tooling/\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"git -C /tmp/opencode/sots-final-research-re status --short","time":{"start":1788999779529,"end":1788999779568}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_04db0bdfd0e6658b016aa1f863539487d19fad58fd6ba59863"}},"id":"prt_088b244c5001eX53hadCp7xEcI","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b22164001hBtLov82169iuv"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999779582,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_8RFrqvAj2I2YRPmNxXLbETd1","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: # Read-only capture / provenance index\n2: \n3: Initial ReVa session: `run-1b88df9d169e9517a5e1b0f0`.\n4: \n5: ReVa selected program: `/Sword of the Stars.exe`; reported MD5:\n6: `9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`. The initial ReVa service did not expose a local path or\n7: SHA-256. This limitation is now resolved for the static analysis input only: local\n8: `dumps/sots.exe` has the same MD5 and SHA-256\n9: `970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, as independently recorded\n10: in `campaign/research/record-observation-crosscheck.md`. This binds the local objdump captures to\n11: the ReVa-selected binary fingerprint; it does not bind any live runtime, allocator, asset, or shim.\n12: \n13: | Anchor | Fresh static observation |\n14: |---|---|\n15: | `0x007ba1a0` | `read-memory` returned 256 bytes; decompilation reports 395 bytes, four callers including `OnTechResearched` at `0x008917dc`. |\n16: | `0x008862b0` | `read-memory` returned 435 bytes; decompilation reports 435 bytes and 161 incoming references. |\n17: | `0x0084ee30` | `read-memory` returned 196 bytes; decompilation reports a 196-byte `__fastcall` constructor and six incoming references. |\n18: \n19: Requests used the live schema: `programPath=/Sword of the Stars.exe`,\n20: `addressOrSymbol` for memory, and `functionNameOrAddress` for decompilation. All calls were\n21: read-only; no Ghidra, VM, or source mutation occurred.\n22: \n23: ## Local instruction capture added in this quantum\n24: \n25: `objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` contains selected raw instruction windows plus exact GNU\n26: objdump 2.38 commands. It covers the ObservedTech constructor, append/copy/reallocation/allocation\n27: and destruction path, plus PlayerEvent vector copy and three-string destruction path. The\n28: interpretation is in `recovered-static.md`; raw instructions are the authority where the old\n29: decompiler's false non-return annotation could truncate cleanup.\n30: \n31: `objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt` adds exact local commands and selected raw instructions for\n32: `0x00885380`, `0x00825d40`, `0x00879eb0`, outer TurnEvents append/growth/copy/destruction, nested\n33: PlayerEvent vector construction/copy/destruction, both allocation strides, and static unwind edges.\n34: Its selected excerpt omitted the test/branch at `0x00825e1e`--`0x00825e2d`, so Astra decision\n35: `d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` overturned that excerpt's sufficiency for branch polarity.\n36: \n37: `objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt` repairs that gap with unfiltered, exit-zero GNU objdump 2.38\n38: output for complete `0x00825d40`--`0x00825e64`, helper `0x0046f8c0` through its return, and direct\n39: comparison callees `0x004236a0` and `0x00422720` through every return. After `EvImg`, FindDuplicate\n40: passes both `EvDsc` strings to `0x0046f8c0`; that helper returns one for unequal strings and zero for\n41: equal strings. `0x00825e23` jumps to the matched-element return only on zero. Therefore description\n42: equality is required for dedup. Candidate and stored strings each independently select inline versus\n43: heap bytes at capacity `0x10`; byte equality plus length equality is required, including empty and\n44: mixed short/long cases. This is static instruction evidence, not a live same-bucket fixture.\n45: The raw capture SHA-256 is `3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06`.\n46: \n47: ## Independent-review falsifiers\n48: \n49: The independent verifier should reproduce the local commands against the recorded SHA-256 input\n50: and challenge these distinct-state claims:\n51: \n52: 1. Empty ObservedTech vector and full vector: verify that `0x007b7320` reaches growth only on\n53:    `_Mylast == _Myend`, and that its `0x0079a150` path copy-constructs rather than header-copies.\n54: 2. Long versus short strings: verify `>= 0x10` cleanup and that the temporary cleanup after\n55:    `RecordObservedTech` cannot be interpreted as ownership transfer.\n56: 3. New versus existing observed-tech name and duplicate versus no-duplicate event: verify branch\n57:    ordering before inferring any allocation or ID effect.\n58: 4. Event vector full capacity: verify the `0x74` copy/growth path independently from the `0x2c`\n59:    ObservedTech path; a matching vector header alone is not a falsifier-resistant semantic test.\n60: 5. Duplicate comparator: hold action/location/finite position/message/image fixed; compare equal\n61:    versus description-only-different EvDsc for empty/short and long strings. Raw instructions predict\n62:    dedup only for equal descriptions. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence and full\n63:    pre/post records/IDs in any later live test; static parsing alone does not prove runtime safety.\n64: 6. Prune boundaries: distinguish zero, one, and two leading stale buckets, plus stale-after-fresh;\n65:    only the two-leading-stale case should shorten the outer vector, by one bucket.\n66: 7. Turn buckets: with duplicate `EvTurn` buckets, get-or-create should return the last match; on a\n67:    miss compare spare versus full outer capacity and empty versus nonempty nested vectors.\n68: \n69: No live allocator-safety or replacement claim is offered for independent approval.\n\n(End of file - total 69 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"# Read-only capture / provenance index\n\nInitial ReVa session: `run-1b88df9d169e9517a5e1b0f0`.\n\nReVa selected program: `/Sword of the Stars.exe`; reported MD5:\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`. The initial ReVa service did not expose a local path or\nSHA-256. This limitation is now resolved for the static analysis input only: local\n`dumps/sots.exe` has the same MD5 and SHA-256\n`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, as independently recorded\nin `campaign/research/record-observation-crosscheck.md`. This binds the local objdump captures to\nthe ReVa-selected binary fingerprint; it does not bind any live runtime, allocator, asset, or shim.\n\n| Anchor | Fresh static observation |\n|---|---|\n| `0x007ba1a0` | `read-memory` returned 256 bytes; decompilation reports 395 bytes, four callers including `OnTechResearched` at `0x008917dc`. |\n| `0x008862b0` | `read-memory` returned 435 bytes; decompilation reports 435 bytes and 161 incoming references. |\n| `0x0084ee30` | `read-memory` returned 196 bytes; decompilation reports a 196-byte `__fastcall` constructor and six incoming references. |\n\nRequests used the live schema: `programPath=/Sword of the Stars.exe`,\n`addressOrSymbol` for memory, and `functionNameOrAddress` for decompilation. All calls were","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md","text":"# Read-only capture / provenance index\n\nInitial ReVa session: `run-1b88df9d169e9517a5e1b0f0`.\n\nReVa selected program: `/Sword of the Stars.exe`; reported MD5:\n`9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c`. The initial ReVa service did not expose a local path or\nSHA-256. This limitation is now resolved for the static analysis input only: local\n`dumps/sots.exe` has the same MD5 and SHA-256\n`970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841`, as independently recorded\nin `campaign/research/record-observation-crosscheck.md`. This binds the local objdump captures to\nthe ReVa-selected binary fingerprint; it does not bind any live runtime, allocator, asset, or shim.\n\n| Anchor | Fresh static observation |\n|---|---|\n| `0x007ba1a0` | `read-memory` returned 256 bytes; decompilation reports 395 bytes, four callers including `OnTechResearched` at `0x008917dc`. |\n| `0x008862b0` | `read-memory` returned 435 bytes; decompilation reports 435 bytes and 161 incoming references. |\n| `0x0084ee30` | `read-memory` returned 196 bytes; decompilation reports a 196-byte `__fastcall` constructor and six incoming references. |\n\nRequests used the live schema: `programPath=/Sword of the Stars.exe`,\n`addressOrSymbol` for memory, and `functionNameOrAddress` for decompilation. All calls were\nread-only; no Ghidra, VM, or source mutation occurred.\n\n## Local instruction capture added in this quantum\n\n`objdump-2026-09-09-ownership.txt` contains selected raw instruction windows plus exact GNU\nobjdump 2.38 commands. It covers the ObservedTech constructor, append/copy/reallocation/allocation\nand destruction path, plus PlayerEvent vector copy and three-string destruction path. The\ninterpretation is in `recovered-static.md`; raw instructions are the authority where the old\ndecompiler's false non-return annotation could truncate cleanup.\n\n`objdump-2026-09-09-turnevents.txt` adds exact local commands and selected raw instructions for\n`0x00885380`, `0x00825d40`, `0x00879eb0`, outer TurnEvents append/growth/copy/destruction, nested\nPlayerEvent vector construction/copy/destruction, both allocation strides, and static unwind edges.\nIts selected excerpt omitted the test/branch at `0x00825e1e`--`0x00825e2d`, so Astra decision\n`d-2ff30c9f5355116bea822924` overturned that excerpt's sufficiency for branch polarity.\n\n`objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt` repairs that gap with unfiltered, exit-zero GNU objdump 2.38\noutput for complete `0x00825d40`--`0x00825e64`, helper `0x0046f8c0` through its return, and direct\ncomparison callees `0x004236a0` and `0x00422720` through every return. After `EvImg`, FindDuplicate\npasses both `EvDsc` strings to `0x0046f8c0`; that helper returns one for unequal strings and zero for\nequal strings. `0x00825e23` jumps to the matched-element return only on zero. Therefore description\nequality is required for dedup. Candidate and stored strings each independently select inline versus\nheap bytes at capacity `0x10`; byte equality plus length equality is required, including empty and\nmixed short/long cases. This is static instruction evidence, not a live same-bucket fixture.\nThe raw capture SHA-256 is `3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06`.\n\n## Independent-review falsifiers\n\nThe independent verifier should reproduce the local commands against the recorded SHA-256 input\nand challenge these distinct-state claims:\n\n1. Empty ObservedTech vector and full vector: verify that `0x007b7320` reaches growth only on\n   `_Mylast == _Myend`, and that its `0x0079a150` path copy-constructs rather than header-copies.\n2. Long versus short strings: verify `>= 0x10` cleanup and that the temporary cleanup after\n   `RecordObservedTech` cannot be interpreted as ownership transfer.\n3. New versus existing observed-tech name and duplicate versus no-duplicate event: verify branch\n   ordering before inferring any allocation or ID effect.\n4. Event vector full capacity: verify the `0x74` copy/growth path independently from the `0x2c`\n   ObservedTech path; a matching vector header alone is not a falsifier-resistant semantic test.\n5. Duplicate comparator: hold action/location/finite position/message/image fixed; compare equal\n   versus description-only-different EvDsc for empty/short and long strings. Raw instructions predict\n   dedup only for equal descriptions. Require positive comparator entry/return evidence and full\n   pre/post records/IDs in any later live test; static parsing alone does not prove runtime safety.\n6. Prune boundaries: distinguish zero, one, and two leading stale buckets, plus stale-after-fresh;\n   only the two-leading-stale case should shorten the outer vector, by one bucket.\n7. Turn buckets: with duplicate `EvTurn` buckets, get-or-create should return the last match; on a\n   miss compare spare versus full outer capacity and empty versus nonempty nested vectors.\n\nNo live allocator-safety or replacement claim is offered for independent approval.","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":69,"totalLines":69,"truncated":false}},"title":"verify/results/research-completion-abi/reva-2026-09-09-index.md","time":{"start":1788999779537,"end":1788999779580}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_04db0bdfd0e6658b016aa1f863539c87d1ba417fe392405df0"}},"id":"prt_088b244cd0011DKn0x9kawSh5g","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b22164001hBtLov82169iuv"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999779649,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b2453d001vbrwAr758tuXtO","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"b40d91f731a369a164b34f6a2a92420dee2a63d0","messageID":"msg_088b22164001hBtLov82169iuv","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":28576,"input":1470,"output":226,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":26880}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999782849,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b251ba001oGTNxM1gpfs582","messageID":"msg_088b24570001tSJ2s0KPz1avSj","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"8ce3ad493b21562502b98dcf1ba66b01249811c0","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999784045,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"glob","callID":"call_78CJyJ3WwXDwpj8R5eoTXHnm","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"pattern":"campaign/contracts/*research*.json"},"output":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-replacement.json\n/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-completion-abi.json","metadata":{"count":2,"truncated":false},"title":"","time":{"start":1788999784035,"end":1788999784043}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0b50835587956647016aa1f867781c87d1b042ab44c115acd2"}},"id":"prt_088b2544d0017fZAhO7JSuHIyP","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b24570001tSJ2s0KPz1avSj"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999784157,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b256da0014Y6UOsCD2C1IOO","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"daadcefcdfedeeb765b06629ddcce795157ab1d0","messageID":"msg_088b24570001tSJ2s0KPz1avSj","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":32487,"input":4291,"output":24,"reasoning":12,"cache":{"write":0,"read":28160}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999787620,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b26461001gYMn14nms080Sf","messageID":"msg_088b2570a001f8B1sv6ariHeeh","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"563c490752a1bccd24f601dba62271692ff7489b","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999788440,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"read","callID":"call_xMDqMNrgyBfFW6Hr0Sf1wnM5","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"filePath":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-replacement.json"},"output":"<path>/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-replacement.json</path>\n<type>file</type>\n<content>\n1: {\n2:   \"id\": \"research-replacement\",\n3:   \"title\": \"Completion-bearing research replacement pilot (proposed; acceptance runner and dependencies pending)\",\n4:   \"status\": \"proposed\",\n5:   \"owner\": {\"name\": \"Astra pilot architect\", \"role\": \"architecture-review\"},\n6:   \"baseline\": {\n7:     \"engine\": {\"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\", \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\"},\n8:     \"re\": {\"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\", \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\"}\n9:   },\n10:   \"scope\": [\n11:     \"Planning only until ready: campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md is the detailed input, write-boundary and acceptance specification. No replacement code or lab operations authorized by this proposed contract.\",\n12:     \"Target ProcessResearch plus SetResearched and required OnTechResearched effects for the W1 turn3 LOAD-to-turn4 completion; broad research correctness is not implied.\",\n13:     \"Before implementation assign paired baseline-pinned worktrees, exact owned source paths, supported-input preflight and executable acceptance. Uncommitted bootstrap changes are not bound by these HEAD IDs.\"\n14:   ],\n15:   \"inputs\": [\n16:     \"W1 verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav sha256 978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921; exact fresh-process LOAD route, one End Turn.\",\n17:     \"Historical oracle verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-endturn.sav sha256 e00eed0c03a31d27a81b7470a9dcc9ba08a2ac48c20baeee4f34749164743e3f and cr-oracle-autosave.sav sha256 79df50475a7b83afa927d992b9f030dcf45710f4bda0133b8b1fa4800a72e420; re-certify controls with current candidate inputs.\",\n18:     \"Historical negative saves cr-replace0-autosave.sav sha256 6b51db992b158caa5424d71b2dccf72924af7198b4165bfcfc870e0d438fb6d5 and cr-replace1-autosave.sav sha256 8a4309ee4fe0b3177a2820600b5016c7c256d0f51b065df469ecd0b4f2342235 under verify/results/saves/cr/.\",\n19:     \"Raw historical evidence: verify/traces/cr-{N,R0,R1}.jsonl.gz; verify/results/compare/cr-{compare,replace0,replace1}.json; verify/results/shim/cr/cr-{N,R0,R1}.log. Historical build cr-618ccb1-20260909T131556Z does not identify the current candidate.\",\n20:     \"Required but missing: operator-owned executable/proxy and tech graph/tuning/localized string assets with explicit paths, SHA-256, locale and load order; generated-address provenance; compiler/toolchain; exact candidate source-content and binary manifests.\",\n21:     \"Runtime-only inputs include tree order counter, allocation entries/order, current turn, target and pending-roll flags, preexisting observed-tech and event elements, RNG state/index/left, full FPU CW, installed interception sites and LOAD/continuation route.\",\n22:     \"W0 turn2-state.sav one End Turn is a no-completion regression control; pin hash and re-certify. W2 different-tech positive-RNG/second-completion workload remains to be selected and certified before expanding scope.\"\n23:   ],\n24:   \"effects\": [\n25:     \"All node state/progress/flag/cost/availability/researched-turn/order words; tree order counter; capped spend and refund accumulator; idle-node decay; ordered cascade including conditional recursive zero-cost completions.\",\n26:     \"RNG full state, left and next-index plus actual consumed words, including conditional completion rolls, Zuul second roll and research-event paths; W1 has zero words and proves no positive-draw branch.\",\n27:     \"All applicable callback player floats, boolean/species/design-option masks, target and roll flags, node-bore storage and lifetimes. Existing WritePlayerState is not integration of the full research callback.\",\n28:     \"ObservedTech full record name/first-last turn/detected/with fields, dedup/update, vector elements/header/capacity and compatible allocation/destruction. Scratch span growth is not an append implementation.\",\n29:     \"Complete ordered event turn buckets, records, ids/nextId, text, image/action/location/position/chainId, dedup/pruning and allocation lifetimes; keyless count-only events cannot satisfy the save oracle.\",\n30:     \"Conditional transitive system/ship AI/cap/addiction/plague changes, recursive Zuul grant, rebellion object allocation and cancellation must be implemented or rejected by approved preflight before mutation; TechApplyOutcome alone performs none of them.\",\n31:     \"Observe downstream bankruptcy, repair and checksum consequences through full turn/save validation; never copy original post-state or patch expected derived leaves.\"\n32:   ],\n33:   \"original_dependencies\": [\n34:     \"Existing research adapter calls original TechTree::Cost for effective and cascade costs; independent effective-cost replacement is not established.\",\n35:     \"Separate B2 hook uses original has-researched lookup and node-bore updater. The updater allocates/frees state and is not read-only. Its integration/retention needs an explicit lead decision.\",\n36:     \"Runtime EventText lookup and caller-supplied asset tables already exist. Whether live text/allocator/event adapters use original helpers is unresolved; no PostEvent policy or address is assumed.\",\n37:     \"Shim workload retains original turn driver, budget allocation, remaining simulation, data loading and save serialization. Successful scoped shim replacement would not establish independent standalone turn parity.\"\n38:   ],\n39:   \"dependencies\": [],\n40:   \"acceptance\": [\n41:     {\"id\": \"readiness\", \"axis\": \"planning\", \"criterion\": \"BLOCKED: provide named executable acceptance commands, required assets, approved original-helper decisions, exact implementation ownership and immutable source/binary/input manifests before ready. Dependency contract IDs are unassigned, not satisfied by an empty list.\"},\n42:     {\"id\": \"full-gate\", \"axis\": \"implementation\", \"criterion\": \"Fresh full-profile source-bound host/assets/shim build; expected test identities and explicit positive executed workloads; no required missing input, unexpected skip or stale binary.\"},\n43:     {\"id\": \"control-neutrality\", \"axis\": \"validation\", \"criterion\": \"Two fresh C1/C2 hooks-off processes and candidate compare N on the exact W1 input/route produce identical pre/post save pairs; full installed-site manifests and per-call CW retained. Reject incomplete raw bundles or disagreement.\"},\n44:     {\"id\": \"positive-replace\", \"axis\": \"implementation\", \"criterion\": \"W1 replace executes exactly one tech-144 completion and three unlocks, two actual event records and one full observed-tech record, refund 1166 and primary player effects; original displaced roots bypassed, declared helpers counted; zero unsupported paths, unreadable inputs or failures.\"},\n45:     {\"id\": \"oracle\", \"axis\": \"validation\", \"criterion\": \"Require post-turn file-byte, inflated-byte and exact-bit unmasked state equality plus complete reader coverage and nonserialized order/RNG checks. Pre-turn resave equality, count-only regions and zero-execution passes cannot satisfy this criterion.\"},\n46:     {\"id\": \"negative-controls\", \"axis\": \"validation\", \"criterion\": \"Executable checker rejects archived R0's 27 and R1's 16 leaf differences, absent callback/event/ObservedTech writes, W0 as completion evidence, missing artifacts, wrong hashes, and unknown RNG reported as zero.\"},\n47:     {\"id\": \"independent-reproduction\", \"axis\": \"validation\", \"criterion\": \"Different verifier execution reproduces source/binary/input-bound package and a meaningful negative control; integrated-tree evidence is required before accepted. No author-only verdict or reporter --accept flag grants campaign acceptance.\"},\n48:     {\"id\": \"coverage-and-dependencies\", \"axis\": \"original_dependencies\", \"criterion\": \"Publish retained original helpers and W1-only scope separately. Require certified W2 and branch-specific original experiments plus synthetic boundaries before claiming RNG-consuming, other-effect-family, recursive, dedup, decay, plague or rebellion coverage.\"}\n49:   ],\n50:   \"predictions\": [\n51:     \"W1 owner order 32/496/512 with allocations 144:2898,90:0,9:0; exactly one completion and two null calls.\",\n52:     \"Tech144 progress 5768->7500, state3->4, researched turn4/order22, counter22->23, unchanged flag; capped spend1732/refund1166; no RNG words.\",\n53:     \"Tech132/136/142 become available turn4 at costs10000/16000/8000; observed-tech count10->11 with real element; event nextId5->7 with complete records.\",\n54:     \"Existing R1 still fails by 16 leaves (independently reproduced); merely enabling cascade cannot close callback residuals. Runtime text assets may avoid original PostEvent but live adapter and policy are unresolved.\"\n55:   ],\n56:   \"stop_conditions\": [\n57:     \"Remain proposed while readiness criterion, dependency decisions, input manifests and executable acceptance are missing; do not interpret narrative strings as execution proof.\",\n58:     \"Stop on control disagreement, instrumentation mismatch, source/input drift, missing artifacts/assets, unknown RNG, unmodelled fired branch, unexpected writes, zero required execution or forbidden original fallback.\",\n59:     \"Record any falsified assumption or changed scope as a surprise and obtain Astra resolution before affected work continues; checkpoint at 20 calls/15 minutes and before experiments, handoff or stop.\",\n60:     \"No lab or shared-host mutation without explicit assignment and lease; no commits, staging, push or delegated work under the current pilot-design assignment.\"\n61:   ],\n62:   \"checkpoint\": null\n63: }\n\n(End of file - total 63 lines)\n</content>","metadata":{"preview":"{\n  \"id\": \"research-replacement\",\n  \"title\": \"Completion-bearing research replacement pilot (proposed; acceptance runner and dependencies pending)\",\n  \"status\": \"proposed\",\n  \"owner\": {\"name\": \"Astra pilot architect\", \"role\": \"architecture-review\"},\n  \"baseline\": {\n    \"engine\": {\"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\", \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\"},\n    \"re\": {\"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\", \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\"}\n  },\n  \"scope\": [\n    \"Planning only until ready: campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md is the detailed input, write-boundary and acceptance specification. No replacement code or lab operations authorized by this proposed contract.\",\n    \"Target ProcessResearch plus SetResearched and required OnTechResearched effects for the W1 turn3 LOAD-to-turn4 completion; broad research correctness is not implied.\",\n    \"Before implementation assign paired baseline-pinned worktrees, exact owned source paths, supported-input preflight and executable acceptance. Uncommitted bootstrap changes are not bound by these HEAD IDs.\"\n  ],\n  \"inputs\": [\n    \"W1 verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav sha256 978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921; exact fresh-process LOAD route, one End Turn.\",\n    \"Historical oracle verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-endturn.sav sha256 e00eed0c03a31d27a81b7470a9dcc9ba08a2ac48c20baeee4f34749164743e3f and cr-oracle-autosave.sav sha256 79df50475a7b83afa927d992b9f030dcf45710f4bda0133b8b1fa4800a72e420; re-certify controls with current candidate inputs.\",\n    \"Historical negative saves cr-replace0-autosave.sav sha256 6b51db992b158caa5424d71b2dccf72924af7198b4165bfcfc870e0d438fb6d5 and cr-replace1-autosave.sav sha256 8a4309ee4fe0b3177a2820600b5016c7c256d0f51b065df469ecd0b4f2342235 under verify/results/saves/cr/.\",\n    \"Raw historical evidence: verify/traces/cr-{N,R0,R1}.jsonl.gz; verify/results/compare/cr-{compare,replace0,replace1}.json; verify/results/shim/cr/cr-{N,R0,R1}.log. Historical build cr-618ccb1-20260909T131556Z does not identify the current candidate.\",\n    \"Required but missing: operator-owned executable/proxy and tech graph/tuning/localized string assets with explicit paths, SHA-256, locale and load order; generated-address provenance; compiler/toolchain; exact candidate source-content and binary manifests.\",","truncated":false,"loaded":[],"display":{"type":"file","path":"/home/alex/sots-re/campaign/contracts/research-replacement.json","text":"{\n  \"id\": \"research-replacement\",\n  \"title\": \"Completion-bearing research replacement pilot (proposed; acceptance runner and dependencies pending)\",\n  \"status\": \"proposed\",\n  \"owner\": {\"name\": \"Astra pilot architect\", \"role\": \"architecture-review\"},\n  \"baseline\": {\n    \"engine\": {\"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\", \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\"},\n    \"re\": {\"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\", \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\"}\n  },\n  \"scope\": [\n    \"Planning only until ready: campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md is the detailed input, write-boundary and acceptance specification. No replacement code or lab operations authorized by this proposed contract.\",\n    \"Target ProcessResearch plus SetResearched and required OnTechResearched effects for the W1 turn3 LOAD-to-turn4 completion; broad research correctness is not implied.\",\n    \"Before implementation assign paired baseline-pinned worktrees, exact owned source paths, supported-input preflight and executable acceptance. Uncommitted bootstrap changes are not bound by these HEAD IDs.\"\n  ],\n  \"inputs\": [\n    \"W1 verify/results/saves/turn3-state.sav sha256 978041acd168b56ed8eb3f5e42e78d5e70eae6e6517d75e659a5eb7ca3d60921; exact fresh-process LOAD route, one End Turn.\",\n    \"Historical oracle verify/results/saves/cr/cr-oracle-endturn.sav sha256 e00eed0c03a31d27a81b7470a9dcc9ba08a2ac48c20baeee4f34749164743e3f and cr-oracle-autosave.sav sha256 79df50475a7b83afa927d992b9f030dcf45710f4bda0133b8b1fa4800a72e420; re-certify controls with current candidate inputs.\",\n    \"Historical negative saves cr-replace0-autosave.sav sha256 6b51db992b158caa5424d71b2dccf72924af7198b4165bfcfc870e0d438fb6d5 and cr-replace1-autosave.sav sha256 8a4309ee4fe0b3177a2820600b5016c7c256d0f51b065df469ecd0b4f2342235 under verify/results/saves/cr/.\",\n    \"Raw historical evidence: verify/traces/cr-{N,R0,R1}.jsonl.gz; verify/results/compare/cr-{compare,replace0,replace1}.json; verify/results/shim/cr/cr-{N,R0,R1}.log. Historical build cr-618ccb1-20260909T131556Z does not identify the current candidate.\",\n    \"Required but missing: operator-owned executable/proxy and tech graph/tuning/localized string assets with explicit paths, SHA-256, locale and load order; generated-address provenance; compiler/toolchain; exact candidate source-content and binary manifests.\",\n    \"Runtime-only inputs include tree order counter, allocation entries/order, current turn, target and pending-roll flags, preexisting observed-tech and event elements, RNG state/index/left, full FPU CW, installed interception sites and LOAD/continuation route.\",\n    \"W0 turn2-state.sav one End Turn is a no-completion regression control; pin hash and re-certify. W2 different-tech positive-RNG/second-completion workload remains to be selected and certified before expanding scope.\"\n  ],\n  \"effects\": [\n    \"All node state/progress/flag/cost/availability/researched-turn/order words; tree order counter; capped spend and refund accumulator; idle-node decay; ordered cascade including conditional recursive zero-cost completions.\",\n    \"RNG full state, left and next-index plus actual consumed words, including conditional completion rolls, Zuul second roll and research-event paths; W1 has zero words and proves no positive-draw branch.\",\n    \"All applicable callback player floats, boolean/species/design-option masks, target and roll flags, node-bore storage and lifetimes. Existing WritePlayerState is not integration of the full research callback.\",\n    \"ObservedTech full record name/first-last turn/detected/with fields, dedup/update, vector elements/header/capacity and compatible allocation/destruction. Scratch span growth is not an append implementation.\",\n    \"Complete ordered event turn buckets, records, ids/nextId, text, image/action/location/position/chainId, dedup/pruning and allocation lifetimes; keyless count-only events cannot satisfy the save oracle.\",\n    \"Conditional transitive system/ship AI/cap/addiction/plague changes, recursive Zuul grant, rebellion object allocation and cancellation must be implemented or rejected by approved preflight before mutation; TechApplyOutcome alone performs none of them.\",\n    \"Observe downstream bankruptcy, repair and checksum consequences through full turn/save validation; never copy original post-state or patch expected derived leaves.\"\n  ],\n  \"original_dependencies\": [\n    \"Existing research adapter calls original TechTree::Cost for effective and cascade costs; independent effective-cost replacement is not established.\",\n    \"Separate B2 hook uses original has-researched lookup and node-bore updater. The updater allocates/frees state and is not read-only. Its integration/retention needs an explicit lead decision.\",\n    \"Runtime EventText lookup and caller-supplied asset tables already exist. Whether live text/allocator/event adapters use original helpers is unresolved; no PostEvent policy or address is assumed.\",\n    \"Shim workload retains original turn driver, budget allocation, remaining simulation, data loading and save serialization. Successful scoped shim replacement would not establish independent standalone turn parity.\"\n  ],\n  \"dependencies\": [],\n  \"acceptance\": [\n    {\"id\": \"readiness\", \"axis\": \"planning\", \"criterion\": \"BLOCKED: provide named executable acceptance commands, required assets, approved original-helper decisions, exact implementation ownership and immutable source/binary/input manifests before ready. Dependency contract IDs are unassigned, not satisfied by an empty list.\"},\n    {\"id\": \"full-gate\", \"axis\": \"implementation\", \"criterion\": \"Fresh full-profile source-bound host/assets/shim build; expected test identities and explicit positive executed workloads; no required missing input, unexpected skip or stale binary.\"},\n    {\"id\": \"control-neutrality\", \"axis\": \"validation\", \"criterion\": \"Two fresh C1/C2 hooks-off processes and candidate compare N on the exact W1 input/route produce identical pre/post save pairs; full installed-site manifests and per-call CW retained. Reject incomplete raw bundles or disagreement.\"},\n    {\"id\": \"positive-replace\", \"axis\": \"implementation\", \"criterion\": \"W1 replace executes exactly one tech-144 completion and three unlocks, two actual event records and one full observed-tech record, refund 1166 and primary player effects; original displaced roots bypassed, declared helpers counted; zero unsupported paths, unreadable inputs or failures.\"},\n    {\"id\": \"oracle\", \"axis\": \"validation\", \"criterion\": \"Require post-turn file-byte, inflated-byte and exact-bit unmasked state equality plus complete reader coverage and nonserialized order/RNG checks. Pre-turn resave equality, count-only regions and zero-execution passes cannot satisfy this criterion.\"},\n    {\"id\": \"negative-controls\", \"axis\": \"validation\", \"criterion\": \"Executable checker rejects archived R0's 27 and R1's 16 leaf differences, absent callback/event/ObservedTech writes, W0 as completion evidence, missing artifacts, wrong hashes, and unknown RNG reported as zero.\"},\n    {\"id\": \"independent-reproduction\", \"axis\": \"validation\", \"criterion\": \"Different verifier execution reproduces source/binary/input-bound package and a meaningful negative control; integrated-tree evidence is required before accepted. No author-only verdict or reporter --accept flag grants campaign acceptance.\"},\n    {\"id\": \"coverage-and-dependencies\", \"axis\": \"original_dependencies\", \"criterion\": \"Publish retained original helpers and W1-only scope separately. Require certified W2 and branch-specific original experiments plus synthetic boundaries before claiming RNG-consuming, other-effect-family, recursive, dedup, decay, plague or rebellion coverage.\"}\n  ],\n  \"predictions\": [\n    \"W1 owner order 32/496/512 with allocations 144:2898,90:0,9:0; exactly one completion and two null calls.\",\n    \"Tech144 progress 5768->7500, state3->4, researched turn4/order22, counter22->23, unchanged flag; capped spend1732/refund1166; no RNG words.\",\n    \"Tech132/136/142 become available turn4 at costs10000/16000/8000; observed-tech count10->11 with real element; event nextId5->7 with complete records.\",\n    \"Existing R1 still fails by 16 leaves (independently reproduced); merely enabling cascade cannot close callback residuals. Runtime text assets may avoid original PostEvent but live adapter and policy are unresolved.\"\n  ],\n  \"stop_conditions\": [\n    \"Remain proposed while readiness criterion, dependency decisions, input manifests and executable acceptance are missing; do not interpret narrative strings as execution proof.\",\n    \"Stop on control disagreement, instrumentation mismatch, source/input drift, missing artifacts/assets, unknown RNG, unmodelled fired branch, unexpected writes, zero required execution or forbidden original fallback.\",\n    \"Record any falsified assumption or changed scope as a surprise and obtain Astra resolution before affected work continues; checkpoint at 20 calls/15 minutes and before experiments, handoff or stop.\",\n    \"No lab or shared-host mutation without explicit assignment and lease; no commits, staging, push or delegated work under the current pilot-design assignment.\"\n  ],\n  \"checkpoint\": null\n}","lineStart":1,"lineEnd":63,"totalLines":63,"truncated":false}},"title":"campaign/contracts/research-replacement.json","time":{"start":1788999788427,"end":1788999788438}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_0a3b4905f9df116d016aa1f86b149887d1a73f81d18b9864bf"}},"id":"prt_088b26463001K3ghqrl8FNeGgd","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b2570a001f8B1sv6ariHeeh"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999788668,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b26879001uwz3NAtopOEDab","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"70288d819c0257a1a119f6ba36e6d95423dee28b","messageID":"msg_088b2570a001f8B1sv6ariHeeh","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":32560,"input":272,"output":32,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":32256}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999790683,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b27057001mkt4X0Jk2XlqOK","messageID":"msg_088b2689e001hYh2MpyROORG2V","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"53406b77a3455cf72a95d8b310d9f6b517db1feb","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999830366,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_NqOal7aIrdT0A7qJbY3g6XGg","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re resolve s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f --actor research-problem-resolver --role resolver --model openai/gpt-6-astra --explanation 'Resolution-only Astra decision; session run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423. OBSERVATION/provenance: raw objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt SHA256 3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06 declares unfiltered stop 0x00825e65 but displays c2 08 00 at 0x00825e64. Independent result.md SHA256 257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53 reports exact-command c2, 120 instructions, zero exit; other windows 26/51/51 instructions match after line-end whitespace normalization. Its fresh stdout is reported by hash, not available here as an independently inspected raw capture. Identity: directly checked paired HEADs engine 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common Git directories; dirty inventories observed, not edited. Historical content bindings are not freshly certified; resolver source-binding execution was denied. Original executable SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and objdump 2.38 are verifier-reported; executable/tool hashes must be checked in repair. Positive execution is reported STATIC tool execution only, no live game workload. Archive inspection is game-neutral; no runtime hook-neutrality test exists. No evidence warrants a stale-build or game-mechanism diagnosis. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS: (1) OVERTURNED: this archive is exact unfiltered stdout of its declared first command under the verifier instrument; invalidate that provenance and completeness claim, not all matching instructions. (2) QUALIFIED: stop-boundary truncation is the cheapest explanation of the discrepancy; widened capture is untested here. Manual splicing versus another effective command/tool cannot be diagnosed from present evidence. (3) SURVIVES in inspected archive/reported matching-window static domain: description addresses are passed to 0x0046f8c0, caller cleans stack, zero selects match, helper/callees encode byte-and-length inequality and inline/heap selection. QUALIFIED as implementable dedup rule pending repaired complete provenance and independent challenge; neither runtime description behavior nor NaN handling is measured. Inherited description-omission rule is not reinstated. (4) SURVIVES unaffected, in prior static-evidence domain only: distinct 0x2c/0x74 strides, deep strings/nested vectors, original allocator-family dependency and prior ownership/prune observations; not newly reproduced or accepted here. (5) SURVIVES only as reported independent archived-save values: player1 EvNxID4, bucket2 id1, bucket3 ids2/3, overbudget record/FLT_MAX words; no runtime construction, RNG or allocation conclusion. (6) OVERTURNED: repaired-package sufficiency for independent-cross-check now; verifier fail/paused result remains historical, no pass. QUALIFIED ownership-recovered acceptance remains pending identity-bound fresh captures and independent verification. Live allocator safety, NaN negative control, long-string/full-capacity runtime behavior and integrated replacement remain untested, never waived. INVALIDATION: quarantine the named dedup archive as exact-command evidence, index reva-2026-09-09-index.md lines37-45 and campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md complete-repair/sufficiency claims; preserve bytes/history and link this decision on repair. Prior worker/verifier checkpoints including a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4 are not acceptance evidence. Contract evidence array is empty; control invalidates checkpoint and any verdict. Revised scope: needs-revision permits ONLY lead-scheduled local read-only provenance repair and subsequent independent static verification under existing ABI ownership, not general affected interpretation or implementation. research-replacement remains proposed: its event/dedup/ownership readiness depends on repaired ABI evidence plus its existing runtime manifests, neutral controls and independent/integrated gates; no acceptance change. No source/architecture edits or lab mutations authorized. Integrator must link this actual decision and regenerate projections after integration; no parallel explanatory board history.' --probe 'Cheapest discriminating experiment, NOT executed by this resolver: lead schedule ABI analyst in an authorized bounded worker session; verify paired source-content identities and hash dumps/sots.exe against 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841; pin objdump executable path/hash/version, cwd and argv; checkpoint before experiment. Execute objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and separately objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e67 dumps/sots.exe. Archive each unfiltered stdout/stderr byte stream separately with exit status, hashes and positive nonzero/address coverage. Predict narrow c2 versus wide c2 08 00 at 0x00825e64 with identical preceding instructions; compare existing archive, recording normalization only in a derivative comparison. Never silently edit old capture or infer its production history. If identity or preceding instructions differ, stop and escalate anew. If prediction holds, supersede provenance with fresh wide capture, update owned handoff/index with this decision link, then independent verifier reproduces all four complete windows and resumes its predeclared ABI/NaN challenge. Affected semantic promotion stays blocked until this repair and review; no live execution or acceptance is supplied by the decision.'"},"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"explanation\": \"Resolution-only Astra decision; session run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423. OBSERVATION/provenance: raw objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt SHA256 3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06 declares unfiltered stop 0x00825e65 but displays c2 08 00 at 0x00825e64. Independent result.md SHA256 257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53 reports exact-command c2, 120 instructions, zero exit; other windows 26/51/51 instructions match after line-end whitespace normalization. Its fresh stdout is reported by hash, not available here as an independently inspected raw capture. Identity: directly checked paired HEADs engine 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common Git directories; dirty inventories observed, not edited. Historical content bindings are not freshly certified; resolver source-binding execution was denied. Original executable SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and objdump 2.38 are verifier-reported; executable/tool hashes must be checked in repair. Positive execution is reported STATIC tool execution only, no live game workload. Archive inspection is game-neutral; no runtime hook-neutrality test exists. No evidence warrants a stale-build or game-mechanism diagnosis. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS: (1) OVERTURNED: this archive is exact unfiltered stdout of its declared first command under the verifier instrument; invalidate that provenance and completeness claim, not all matching instructions. (2) QUALIFIED: stop-boundary truncation is the cheapest explanation of the discrepancy; widened capture is untested here. Manual splicing versus another effective command/tool cannot be diagnosed from present evidence. (3) SURVIVES in inspected archive/reported matching-window static domain: description addresses are passed to 0x0046f8c0, caller cleans stack, zero selects match, helper/callees encode byte-and-length inequality and inline/heap selection. QUALIFIED as implementable dedup rule pending repaired complete provenance and independent challenge; neither runtime description behavior nor NaN handling is measured. Inherited description-omission rule is not reinstated. (4) SURVIVES unaffected, in prior static-evidence domain only: distinct 0x2c/0x74 strides, deep strings/nested vectors, original allocator-family dependency and prior ownership/prune observations; not newly reproduced or accepted here. (5) SURVIVES only as reported independent archived-save values: player1 EvNxID4, bucket2 id1, bucket3 ids2/3, overbudget record/FLT_MAX words; no runtime construction, RNG or allocation conclusion. (6) OVERTURNED: repaired-package sufficiency for independent-cross-check now; verifier fail/paused result remains historical, no pass. QUALIFIED ownership-recovered acceptance remains pending identity-bound fresh captures and independent verification. Live allocator safety, NaN negative control, long-string/full-capacity runtime behavior and integrated replacement remain untested, never waived. INVALIDATION: quarantine the named dedup archive as exact-command evidence, index reva-2026-09-09-index.md lines37-45 and campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md complete-repair/sufficiency claims; preserve bytes/history and link this decision on repair. Prior worker/verifier checkpoints including a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4 are not acceptance evidence. Contract evidence array is empty; control invalidates checkpoint and any verdict. Revised scope: needs-revision permits ONLY lead-scheduled local read-only provenance repair and subsequent independent static verification under existing ABI ownership, not general affected interpretation or implementation. research-replacement remains proposed: its event/dedup/ownership readiness depends on repaired ABI evidence plus its existing runtime manifests, neutral controls and independent/integrated gates; no acceptance change. No source/architecture edits or lab mutations authorized. Integrator must link this actual decision and regenerate projections after integration; no parallel explanatory board history.\",\n  \"id\": \"d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5\",\n  \"invalidated_checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-1381c2e77b8c4a68c6809a23.json\",\n  \"invalidated_evidence\": [],\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Cheapest discriminating experiment, NOT executed by this resolver: lead schedule ABI analyst in an authorized bounded worker session; verify paired source-content identities and hash dumps/sots.exe against 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841; pin objdump executable path/hash/version, cwd and argv; checkpoint before experiment. Execute objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and separately objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e67 dumps/sots.exe. Archive each unfiltered stdout/stderr byte stream separately with exit status, hashes and positive nonzero/address coverage. Predict narrow c2 versus wide c2 08 00 at 0x00825e64 with identical preceding instructions; compare existing archive, recording normalization only in a derivative comparison. Never silently edit old capture or infer its production history. If identity or preceding instructions differ, stop and escalate anew. If prediction holds, supersede provenance with fresh wide capture, update owned handoff/index with this decision link, then independent verifier reproduces all four complete windows and resumes its predeclared ABI/NaN challenge. Affected semantic promotion stays blocked until this repair and review; no live execution or acceptance is supplied by the decision.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\",\n  \"surprise\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:23:50.323919+00:00\"\n}\n","metadata":{"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"explanation\": \"Resolution-only Astra decision; session run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423. OBSERVATION/provenance: raw objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt SHA256 3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06 declares unfiltered stop 0x00825e65 but displays c2 08 00 at 0x00825e64. Independent result.md SHA256 257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53 reports exact-command c2, 120 instructions, zero exit; other windows 26/51/51 instructions match after line-end whitespace normalization. Its fresh stdout is reported by hash, not available here as an independently inspected raw capture. Identity: directly checked paired HEADs engine 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common Git directories; dirty inventories observed, not edited. Historical content bindings are not freshly certified; resolver source-binding execution was denied. Original executable SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and objdump 2.38 are verifier-reported; executable/tool hashes must be checked in repair. Positive execution is reported STATIC tool execution only, no live game workload. Archive inspection is game-neutral; no runtime hook-neutrality test exists. No evidence warrants a stale-build or game-mechanism diagnosis. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS: (1) OVERTURNED: this archive is exact unfiltered stdout of its declared first command under the verifier instrument; invalidate that provenance and completeness claim, not all matching instructions. (2) QUALIFIED: stop-boundary truncation is the cheapest explanation of the discrepancy; widened capture is untested here. Manual splicing versus another effective command/tool cannot be diagnosed from present evidence. (3) SURVIVES in inspected archive/reported matching-window static domain: description addresses are passed to 0x0046f8c0, caller cleans stack, zero selects match, helper/callees encode byte-and-length inequality and inline/heap selection. QUALIFIED as implementable dedup rule pending repaired complete provenance and independent challenge; neither runtime description behavior nor NaN handling is measured. Inherited description-omission rule is not reinstated. (4) SURVIVES unaffected, in prior static-evidence domain only: distinct 0x2c/0x74 strides, deep strings/nested vectors, original allocator-family dependency and prior ownership/prune observations; not newly reproduced or accepted here. (5) SURVIVES only as reported independent archived-save values: player1 EvNxID4, bucket2 id1, bucket3 ids2/3, overbudget record/FLT_MAX words; no runtime construction, RNG or allocation conclusion. (6) OVERTURNED: repaired-package sufficiency for independent-cross-check now; verifier fail/paused result remains historical, no pass. QUALIFIED ownership-recovered acceptance remains pending identity-bound fresh captures and independent verification. Live allocator safety, NaN negative control, long-string/full-capacity runtime behavior and integrated replacement remain untested, never waived. INVALIDATION: quarantine the named dedup archive as exact-command evidence, index reva-2026-09-09-index.md lines37-45 and campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md complete-repair/sufficiency claims; preserve bytes/history and link this decision on repair. Prior worker/verifier checkpoints including a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4 are not acceptance evidence. Contract evidence array is empty; control invalidates checkpoint and any verdict. Revised scope: needs-revision permits ONLY lead-scheduled local read-only provenance repair and subsequent independent static verification under existing ABI ownership, not general affected interpretation or implementation. research-replacement remains proposed: its event/dedup/ownership readiness depends on repaired ABI evidence plus its existing runtime manifests, neutral controls and independent/integrated gates; no acceptance change. No source/architecture edits or lab mutations authorized. Integrator must link this actual decision and regenerate projections after integration; no parallel explanatory board history.\",\n  \"id\": \"d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5\",\n  \"invalidated_checkpoint\": \"campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-1381c2e77b8c4a68c6809a23.json\",\n  \"invalidated_evidence\": [],\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"probe\": \"Cheapest discriminating experiment, NOT executed by this resolver: lead schedule ABI analyst in an authorized bounded worker session; verify paired source-content identities and hash dumps/sots.exe against 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841; pin objdump executable path/hash/version, cwd and argv; checkpoint before experiment. Execute objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and separately objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e67 dumps/sots.exe. Archive each unfiltered stdout/stderr byte stream separately with exit status, hashes and positive nonzero/address coverage. Predict narrow c2 versus wide c2 08 00 at 0x00825e64 with identical preceding instructions; compare existing archive, recording normalization only in a derivative comparison. Never silently edit old capture or infer its production history. If identity or preceding instructions differ, stop and escalate anew. If prediction holds, supersede provenance with fresh wide capture, update owned handoff/index with this decision link, then independent verifier reproduces all four complete windows and resumes its predeclared ABI/NaN challenge. Affected semantic promotion stays blocked until this repair and review; no live execution or acceptance is supplied by the decision.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-decision/1\",\n  \"surprise\": \"s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:23:50.323919+00:00\"\n}\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re resolve s-5c58b6a921997731f5b5ae1f --actor research-problem-resolver --role resolver --model openai/gpt-6-astra --explanation 'Resolution-only Astra decision; session run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423. OBSERVATION/provenance: raw objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt SHA256 3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06 declares unfiltered stop 0x00825e65 but displays c2 08 00 at 0x00825e64. Independent result.md SHA256 257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53 reports exact-command c2, 120 instructions, zero exit; other windows 26/51/51 instructions match after line-end whitespace normalization. Its fresh stdout is reported by hash, not available here as an independently inspected raw capture. Identity: directly checked paired HEADs engine 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23 and RE 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7 and canonical common Git directories; dirty inventories observed, not edited. Historical content bindings are not freshly certified; resolver source-binding execution was denied. Original executable SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841 and objdump 2.38 are verifier-reported; executable/tool hashes must be checked in repair. Positive execution is reported STATIC tool execution only, no live game workload. Archive inspection is game-neutral; no runtime hook-neutrality test exists. No evidence warrants a stale-build or game-mechanism diagnosis. CLAIM DISPOSITIONS: (1) OVERTURNED: this archive is exact unfiltered stdout of its declared first command under the verifier instrument; invalidate that provenance and completeness claim, not all matching instructions. (2) QUALIFIED: stop-boundary truncation is the cheapest explanation of the discrepancy; widened capture is untested here. Manual splicing versus another effective command/tool cannot be diagnosed from present evidence. (3) SURVIVES in inspected archive/reported matching-window static domain: description addresses are passed to 0x0046f8c0, caller cleans stack, zero selects match, helper/callees encode byte-and-length inequality and inline/heap selection. QUALIFIED as implementable dedup rule pending repaired complete provenance and independent challenge; neither runtime description behavior nor NaN handling is measured. Inherited description-omission rule is not reinstated. (4) SURVIVES unaffected, in prior static-evidence domain only: distinct 0x2c/0x74 strides, deep strings/nested vectors, original allocator-family dependency and prior ownership/prune observations; not newly reproduced or accepted here. (5) SURVIVES only as reported independent archived-save values: player1 EvNxID4, bucket2 id1, bucket3 ids2/3, overbudget record/FLT_MAX words; no runtime construction, RNG or allocation conclusion. (6) OVERTURNED: repaired-package sufficiency for independent-cross-check now; verifier fail/paused result remains historical, no pass. QUALIFIED ownership-recovered acceptance remains pending identity-bound fresh captures and independent verification. Live allocator safety, NaN negative control, long-string/full-capacity runtime behavior and integrated replacement remain untested, never waived. INVALIDATION: quarantine the named dedup archive as exact-command evidence, index reva-2026-09-09-index.md lines37-45 and campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md complete-repair/sufficiency claims; preserve bytes/history and link this decision on repair. Prior worker/verifier checkpoints including a809b9e3b63f8747063ef4a4 are not acceptance evidence. Contract evidence array is empty; control invalidates checkpoint and any verdict. Revised scope: needs-revision permits ONLY lead-scheduled local read-only provenance repair and subsequent independent static verification under existing ABI ownership, not general affected interpretation or implementation. research-replacement remains proposed: its event/dedup/ownership readiness depends on repaired ABI evidence plus its existing runtime manifests, neutral controls and independent/integrated gates; no acceptance change. No source/architecture edits or lab mutations authorized. Integrator must link this actual decision and regenerate projections after integration; no parallel explanatory board history.' --probe 'Cheapest discriminating experiment, NOT executed by this resolver: lead schedule ABI analyst in an authorized bounded worker session; verify paired source-content identities and hash dumps/sots.exe against 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841; pin objdump executable path/hash/version, cwd and argv; checkpoint before experiment. Execute objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e65 dumps/sots.exe and separately objdump -D -Mintel --start-address=0x00825d40 --stop-address=0x00825e67 dumps/sots.exe. Archive each unfiltered stdout/stderr byte stream separately with exit status, hashes and positive nonzero/address coverage. Predict narrow c2 versus wide c2 08 00 at 0x00825e64 with identical preceding instructions; compare existing archive, recording normalization only in a derivative comparison. Never silently edit old capture or infer its production history. If identity or preceding instructions differ, stop and escalate anew. If prediction holds, supersede provenance with fresh wide capture, update owned handoff/index with this decision link, then independent verifier reproduces all four complete windows and resumes its predeclared ABI/NaN challenge. Affected semantic promotion stays blocked until this repair and review; no live execution or acceptance is supplied by the decision.'","time":{"start":1788999830279,"end":1788999830363}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_093eb156b05a4693016aa1f86ea1a087d18f815625e71281da"}},"id":"prt_088b2705900123731hA3nIRVzT","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b2689e001hYh2MpyROORG2V"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999830438,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b30ba2001GumIXay499c8Ov","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"6c4ee0c727c9a24b1e546242ce0002a64ebfa480","messageID":"msg_088b2689e001hYh2MpyROORG2V","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":36149,"input":2440,"output":1325,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":32384}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999836063,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b3219b001e0AyR3R6AiUXbs","messageID":"msg_088b30bca00101UoqvhTECSudv","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"f307d69a86fb32b06b60f7dd92e500a25539d6b2","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999838013,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_5naT8WgD1GRGcZaIP2ehyafZ","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-completion-abi"},"output":"[\n  {\n    \"acceptance\": [\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n        \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n      },\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"validation\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n        \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"baseline\": {\n      \"engine\": {\n        \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n      },\n      \"re\": {\n        \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n      }\n    },\n    \"checkpoint\": null,\n    \"dependencies\": [\n      \"controls-bootstrap\"\n    ],\n    \"effects\": [\n      \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n    ],\n    \"evidence\": [],\n    \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n    \"inputs\": [\n      \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n      \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n      \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n      \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n    ],\n    \"open_surprises\": [],\n    \"original_dependencies\": [\n      \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n    ],\n    \"owner\": {\n      \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n      \"role\": \"analyst\"\n    },\n    \"predictions\": [\n      \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n      \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n    ],\n    \"scope\": [\n      \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n      \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n      \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n      \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n      \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n    ],\n    \"status\": \"needs-revision\",\n    \"stop_conditions\": [\n      \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n      \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n      \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n    ],\n    \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n  }\n]\n","metadata":{"output":"[\n  {\n    \"acceptance\": [\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"static-recovery\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Addresses/signatures and record/container/string lifetime rules backed by fresh binary/tool captures; distinguish recorded facts, inference and unexercised branches. Name exact callable allocation/copy/destruction operations or precise unresolved blockers.\",\n        \"id\": \"ownership-recovered\"\n      },\n      {\n        \"axis\": \"validation\",\n        \"criterion\": \"Independent verifier checks key instruction/ABI claims and archived record values. No static-only claim of live allocator safety or replacement acceptance.\",\n        \"id\": \"independent-cross-check\"\n      }\n    ],\n    \"baseline\": {\n      \"engine\": {\n        \"commit\": \"7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-engine\"\n      },\n      \"re\": {\n        \"commit\": \"3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7\",\n        \"path\": \"/home/alex/sots-re\"\n      }\n    },\n    \"checkpoint\": null,\n    \"dependencies\": [\n      \"controls-bootstrap\"\n    ],\n    \"effects\": [\n      \"Evidence-backed RE handoff and raw static captures; no game or shared database state changes\"\n    ],\n    \"evidence\": [],\n    \"id\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n    \"inputs\": [\n      \"Existing binary fingerprint/address contract and private RE findings\",\n      \"Owner-supplied binary or live read-only ReVa endpoint\",\n      \"Archived CR traces/saves for observed behavior\",\n      \"Source-identical current engine/RE worktree snapshots\"\n    ],\n    \"open_surprises\": [],\n    \"original_dependencies\": [\n      \"Original binary is the object of analysis, not a replacement dependency decision\"\n    ],\n    \"owner\": {\n      \"name\": \"research-abi-analyst\",\n      \"role\": \"analyst\"\n    },\n    \"predictions\": [\n      \"Count-only scratch updates conceal concrete element construction and original allocator ownership requirements\",\n      \"The observed-tech and nested-event containers use different element strides and nontrivial string lifetimes; raw header copying is insufficient\"\n    ],\n    \"scope\": [\n      \"Reverse engineering only. Own canonical campaign/research/research-completion-abi.md and verify/results/research-completion-abi/ captures. Use assigned source-identical paired worktrees for source inspection; canonical RE for unique evidence/checkpoint outputs.\",\n      \"Recover actual constructors/copy/destructors/vector-growth/allocation/free conventions used by RecordObservedTech and EventStorage/TurnEvents/PlayerEvent. Resolve implementable ABI operations, not another general framework.\",\n      \"Use existing ReVa read-only tools through canonical tools/reva_call.py or the owner-supplied local binary. No Ghidra renames/type writes, VM mutation, new engine code, framework code, agents or delegation. Do not commit/stage/push.\",\n      \"Start with findings/subsystems/{events,observedtech-append,research-replace}.md and campaign/pilots/research-replacement.md; cross-check binary bytes/decompilation rather than merely repeat notes. Anchors: RecordObservedTech 0x007ba1a0, EventStorage::PostEvent 0x008862b0, PlayerEvent constructor 0x0084ee30. Addresses are hypotheses to validate against fingerprint and actual tools.\",\n      \"Produce recovered signatures, ownership/lifetime rules, short/long string and empty/full-capacity container paths, and exact unresolved dependencies with minimum next probe. Store raw tool outputs and a hash/provenance index in your owned RE results directory. Keep code-derived material out of engine repo.\"\n    ],\n    \"status\": \"needs-revision\",\n    \"stop_conditions\": [\n      \"Stop affected interpretation on binary fingerprint mismatch, contradictory ownership/ABI evidence, unavailable original data, or any scope-changing surprise; record and escalate to Astra\",\n      \"Checkpoint every 20 calls/15 minutes and before compaction/stopping; return exact next RE action within 40 steps\",\n      \"Do not expand into framework development or mark pilot replacement ready/accepted\"\n    ],\n    \"title\": \"RE: research completion record construction and allocator ABI\"\n  }\n]\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re status research-completion-abi","time":{"start":1788999837965,"end":1788999838011}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_03566728f677f0f9016aa1f89cb83c87d1baff50a6efe33d05"}},"id":"prt_088b32461001wtM71rEKbC8Lh5","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b30bca00101UoqvhTECSudv"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999838102,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b3299300162rS8x3DpNeRJL","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"5ce50c3e37f84177425b37965c469a8e6fd2fe8f","messageID":"msg_088b30bca00101UoqvhTECSudv","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":37645,"input":2898,"output":48,"reasoning":11,"cache":{"write":0,"read":34688}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999840678,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b3339e001gRrnQ45g217vUt","messageID":"msg_088b329c8001D6U2A1W78c5vxr","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"3611dd1515da847e7aa1276066590b311b3e223e","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"tool_use","timestamp":1788999863675,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"type":"tool","tool":"bash","callID":"call_ksu5bfLon3wQbJUuz4Ff1O8i","state":{"status":"completed","input":{"command":"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint research-completion-abi --actor research-problem-resolver --role resolver --model openai/gpt-6-astra --session run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423 --summary 'Mandatory fresh quantum-end checkpoint. Decision d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5 resolved sole open surprise through campaign controls; status command confirms needs-revision, empty evidence, no open surprises. This is repair-only authorization, not acceptance or permission for general affected interpretation. Observation: inspected raw archive declares stop 0x825e65 but shows three terminal bytes; independent verifier reports narrow c2 and positive static output for all four windows. Boundary explanation is untested here, production history unknown. Decision overturns exact-command/unfiltered provenance and package sufficiency, qualifies dedup semantics pending repair/independent challenge, preserves unaffected prior static ownership and reported archived-save observations in their exact domains. Explicit invalidation and revised pilot dependencies are in attached actual decision. Verified assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git via git; inspected dirty status inventories, no worktree edits. Historical source digests ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8 not freshly bound; source-binding execution denied by resolver overlay. Binary SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c and objdump 2.38 remain reported identities pending authorized rehash. Tests here: read-only git identity/status and campaign post-resolution status; no objdump/save-parser experiment, runtime execution or neutrality measurement. No stale-build/game diagnosis. No lab access, resource lease acquisition, source/architecture edit, delegation, staging or commit; no cleanup required. Remaining blockers: fresh raw paired-boundary capture with executable/tool/input/source identities, repaired provenance and independent full static/challenge verification; runtime allocator/long-string/NaN/integrated claims untested. Integrator alone links actual decision and regenerates projections after integration; board untouched.' --artifact campaign/runtime/decisions/d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5.json --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md --next-action 'Lead schedule an authorized bounded ABI analyst provenance-repair session to execute the identity-bound paired stop-address 0x00825e65/0x00825e67 raw captures specified in decision d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5; do not resume affected semantic promotion before repair and independent review.'"},"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/decisions/d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5.json\",\n      \"sha256\": \"f1cf5d71e9819d80aa128f9eed5e34f8b95658ff661e4e16b46008a0aad6e533\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\",\n      \"sha256\": \"3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"6b33d0aef0a305b7d0eb1a1b\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Lead schedule an authorized bounded ABI analyst provenance-repair session to execute the identity-bound paired stop-address 0x00825e65/0x00825e67 raw captures specified in decision d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5; do not resume affected semantic promotion before repair and independent review.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423\",\n  \"summary\": \"Mandatory fresh quantum-end checkpoint. Decision d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5 resolved sole open surprise through campaign controls; status command confirms needs-revision, empty evidence, no open surprises. This is repair-only authorization, not acceptance or permission for general affected interpretation. Observation: inspected raw archive declares stop 0x825e65 but shows three terminal bytes; independent verifier reports narrow c2 and positive static output for all four windows. Boundary explanation is untested here, production history unknown. Decision overturns exact-command/unfiltered provenance and package sufficiency, qualifies dedup semantics pending repair/independent challenge, preserves unaffected prior static ownership and reported archived-save observations in their exact domains. Explicit invalidation and revised pilot dependencies are in attached actual decision. Verified assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git via git; inspected dirty status inventories, no worktree edits. Historical source digests ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8 not freshly bound; source-binding execution denied by resolver overlay. Binary SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c and objdump 2.38 remain reported identities pending authorized rehash. Tests here: read-only git identity/status and campaign post-resolution status; no objdump/save-parser experiment, runtime execution or neutrality measurement. No stale-build/game diagnosis. No lab access, resource lease acquisition, source/architecture edit, delegation, staging or commit; no cleanup required. Remaining blockers: fresh raw paired-boundary capture with executable/tool/input/source identities, repaired provenance and independent full static/challenge verification; runtime allocator/long-string/NaN/integrated claims untested. Integrator alone links actual decision and regenerates projections after integration; board untouched.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:24:23.648796+00:00\"\n}\n","metadata":{"output":"{\n  \"actor\": \"research-problem-resolver\",\n  \"artifacts\": [\n    {\n      \"path\": \"campaign/runtime/decisions/d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5.json\",\n      \"sha256\": \"f1cf5d71e9819d80aa128f9eed5e34f8b95658ff661e4e16b46008a0aad6e533\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt\",\n      \"sha256\": \"3bc3c368f30f2ef2b0d291acad9c0f898b74f4436393d47bf8c942571793dd06\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"257c48f099c3efd92debbbe66ce5bad8241d0d941ff0d6725b07926e71577b53\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"path\": \"verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md\",\n      \"sha256\": \"a18737d98e6009ea314e9d37b077042e853d886d3ea2cf438b8b4340845aa008\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"basis\": \"aaddeb76f74bbd1a43671f882770ec84a7d690b4060d060ef1a68f918e8edbb0\",\n  \"contract\": \"research-completion-abi\",\n  \"id\": \"6b33d0aef0a305b7d0eb1a1b\",\n  \"model\": \"openai/gpt-6-astra\",\n  \"next_action\": \"Lead schedule an authorized bounded ABI analyst provenance-repair session to execute the identity-bound paired stop-address 0x00825e65/0x00825e67 raw captures specified in decision d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5; do not resume affected semantic promotion before repair and independent review.\",\n  \"role\": \"resolver\",\n  \"schema\": \"sots-checkpoint/1\",\n  \"session\": \"run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423\",\n  \"summary\": \"Mandatory fresh quantum-end checkpoint. Decision d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5 resolved sole open surprise through campaign controls; status command confirms needs-revision, empty evidence, no open surprises. This is repair-only authorization, not acceptance or permission for general affected interpretation. Observation: inspected raw archive declares stop 0x825e65 but shows three terminal bytes; independent verifier reports narrow c2 and positive static output for all four windows. Boundary explanation is untested here, production history unknown. Decision overturns exact-command/unfiltered provenance and package sufficiency, qualifies dedup semantics pending repair/independent challenge, preserves unaffected prior static ownership and reported archived-save observations in their exact domains. Explicit invalidation and revised pilot dependencies are in attached actual decision. Verified assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git via git; inspected dirty status inventories, no worktree edits. Historical source digests ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8 not freshly bound; source-binding execution denied by resolver overlay. Binary SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c and objdump 2.38 remain reported identities pending authorized rehash. Tests here: read-only git identity/status and campaign post-resolution status; no objdump/save-parser experiment, runtime execution or neutrality measurement. No stale-build/game diagnosis. No lab access, resource lease acquisition, source/architecture edit, delegation, staging or commit; no cleanup required. Remaining blockers: fresh raw paired-boundary capture with executable/tool/input/source identities, repaired provenance and independent full static/challenge verification; runtime allocator/long-string/NaN/integrated claims untested. Integrator alone links actual decision and regenerates projections after integration; board untouched.\",\n  \"timestamp\": \"2026-09-10T00:24:23.648796+00:00\"\n}\n","exit":0,"truncated":false},"title":"python3 /home/alex/sots-re/tools/campaign.py --state-root /home/alex/sots-re checkpoint research-completion-abi --actor research-problem-resolver --role resolver --model openai/gpt-6-astra --session run-1334385869fb7d5b940d5423 --summary 'Mandatory fresh quantum-end checkpoint. Decision d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5 resolved sole open surprise through campaign controls; status command confirms needs-revision, empty evidence, no open surprises. This is repair-only authorization, not acceptance or permission for general affected interpretation. Observation: inspected raw archive declares stop 0x825e65 but shows three terminal bytes; independent verifier reports narrow c2 and positive static output for all four windows. Boundary explanation is untested here, production history unknown. Decision overturns exact-command/unfiltered provenance and package sufficiency, qualifies dedup semantics pending repair/independent challenge, preserves unaffected prior static ownership and reported archived-save observations in their exact domains. Explicit invalidation and revised pilot dependencies are in attached actual decision. Verified assigned engine HEAD 7741d42fc5e4e761e6449bdaf0e4a61d00036a23/common /home/alex/sots-engine/.git and RE HEAD 3bfde5a70d874a723e797a695bbd847fd82c0aa7/common /home/alex/sots-re/.git via git; inspected dirty status inventories, no worktree edits. Historical source digests ccd8e02083e8d2e2b3e97976ace2273c8f924dfc02a39e919004eaf3544c50fd and 6696fd5201e144843617cbf6d78b41b5287ad5dcc9fa1e8aaa861d52b64e72e8 not freshly bound; source-binding execution denied by resolver overlay. Binary SHA256 970b7de729956a53094c7eb98aba4270aee98e2fed5daf0d39e290013c90c841, MD5 9969481c39f4b33a8a21c48b62abee4c and objdump 2.38 remain reported identities pending authorized rehash. Tests here: read-only git identity/status and campaign post-resolution status; no objdump/save-parser experiment, runtime execution or neutrality measurement. No stale-build/game diagnosis. No lab access, resource lease acquisition, source/architecture edit, delegation, staging or commit; no cleanup required. Remaining blockers: fresh raw paired-boundary capture with executable/tool/input/source identities, repaired provenance and independent full static/challenge verification; runtime allocator/long-string/NaN/integrated claims untested. Integrator alone links actual decision and regenerates projections after integration; board untouched.' --artifact campaign/runtime/decisions/d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5.json --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi/objdump-2026-09-09-dedup-helper.txt --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/result.md --artifact verify/results/research-completion-abi-independent/verification-plan.md --next-action 'Lead schedule an authorized bounded ABI analyst provenance-repair session to execute the identity-bound paired stop-address 0x00825e65/0x00825e67 raw captures specified in decision d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5; do not resume affected semantic promotion before repair and independent review.'","time":{"start":1788999863602,"end":1788999863673}},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"fc_098b4a824bc85a2b016aa1f8a09f3487d19d0c5ffd23e28da5"}},"id":"prt_088b333a4001BeazraE0OnFo99","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","messageID":"msg_088b329c8001D6U2A1W78c5vxr"}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999863724,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b38da7001NEawWmH1RVhP54","reason":"tool-calls","snapshot":"0d95e14a4958bdbb5e7ad234dd6268921cf1c81a","messageID":"msg_088b329c8001D6U2A1W78c5vxr","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":39312,"input":1037,"output":771,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":37504}},"cost":0}}
{"type":"step_start","timestamp":1788999872965,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b3b1c0001IrIEK2LEOgLHTW","messageID":"msg_088b38de1001aTf5J4AQG2rOSQ","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","snapshot":"5153b065f66bb402358529983e5780232404134a","type":"step-start"}}
{"type":"text","timestamp":1788999884001,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b3b1c2001B1y1sPY1hbXY4y","messageID":"msg_088b38de1001aTf5J4AQG2rOSQ","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"text","text":"Bounded resolution-only quantum completed.\n\n**Observation:** the raw dedup archive declares stop address `0x00825e65` but displays `c2 08 00` at `0x00825e64`; the independent verifier reports that the exact command displays only `c2`. This is a provenance/instrument-boundary contradiction—not measured game behavior or evidence of a stale build.\n\n**Durable decision:** [d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5](campaign/runtime/decisions/d-d2a9b8be6399a6abaa0e05a5.json)\n- **Overturned:** exact-command/unfiltered provenance and the package’s sufficiency for independent acceptance.\n- **Qualified:** dedup semantics, pending repaired provenance and independent challenge.\n- **Survives within prior evidence domains:** unaffected static ownership findings and reported archived-save values; no new runtime claims.\n\nCampaign status is **`needs-revision`**, with the surprise resolved through controls. Only scheduled provenance repair may proceed; affected semantic promotion remains blocked.\n\n**Next action:** lead schedules an authorized ABI analyst to capture both stop boundaries, `0x00825e65` and `0x00825e67`, with fresh source/input/tool identities and separate raw outputs. I did not execute that probe; resolver permissions prohibit it.\n\nPaired HEAD/common-directory identities were checked. No source edits, lab mutations, delegation, staging, or commits occurred.\n\n**Fresh final checkpoint:** [research-completion-abi-6b33d0aef0a305b7d0eb1a1b.json](campaign/runtime/checkpoints/research-completion-abi-6b33d0aef0a305b7d0eb1a1b.json).","time":{"start":1788999872962,"end":1788999883998},"metadata":{"openai":{"itemId":"msg_0139fb78d018ced8016aa1f8c0d12c87d198dda7f97efd05ad","phase":"final_answer"}}}}
{"type":"step_finish","timestamp":1788999884158,"sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","part":{"id":"prt_088b3dd7a0013eU505f9KNj40G","reason":"stop","snapshot":"8ba430bc1d74a8031ec847568a1b9a42d8806e56","messageID":"msg_088b38de1001aTf5J4AQG2rOSQ","sessionID":"ses_f774eb734ffep3hpDERGW22MKw","type":"step-finish","tokens":{"total":40767,"input":1999,"output":368,"reasoning":0,"cache":{"write":0,"read":38400}},"cost":0}}