{
  "actor": "live-record bridge architect",
  "contract": "research-live-record-bridge",
  "decision": "d-3205df5e8425dc9e1779e673",
  "id": "s-d2c8ec81e980396f2306f8fe",
  "model": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
  "probe": "Astra must compare the stored file with fresh command stdout under the pinned binary/tool identity, decide whether a byte-exact replacement supersedes only capture provenance, and require a fresh hash-bound reserve manifest before the ObservedTech append/growth row is treated as reconciled.",
  "role": "architecture-review",
  "schema": "sots-surprise/1",
  "status": "resolved",
  "summary": "Fresh provenance check falsified the claim that verify/results/research-live-record-bridge/run-ebf85a84ad4247c38792a787/observed-reserve.stdout.txt is byte-exact raw stdout. The stored manually transcribed capture is 2464 bytes/SHA256 5d10954f54a2f8c731ee8d4760414851963ab8dc539ecb66383cf09e176b5c87; rerunning pinned GNU objdump 2.38 against the hash-matched executable with start 0x007b5820 and stop 0x007b5899 produces 2472 bytes/SHA256 2d011ed96329c4c4ff462cbfd65decac9dccf40558765244c769be1dedc92275. First difference is one alignment space at byte 477. SURVIVES: binary/tool/source identities, decoded instructions, append ABI branches, reserve capacity rule, and references to accepted append/reallocator captures. QUALIFIED: the new reserve interpretation is an observation awaiting a byte-exact immutable capture. OVERTURNED: the newly added file cannot be called raw/unfiltered or used as source-bound capture evidence. Affected ABI-row promotion is paused; contract remains proposed. No implementation or lab work occurred.",
  "timestamp": "2026-09-10T02:50:12.833918+00:00"
}